SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 3 Q9(v)

The following table shows the retail price (in ₹) of iodised salt in the month of January in a few states over \(10\) years. For your calculations and plotting you may round off values to the nearest counting number. What are you curious to explore further\(?\)

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Tales By Dots And Lines

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine checking the price of a snack in different cities over many years. Some cities always sell it cheap, others always sell it expensive. We round messy prices like 9.47 to neat numbers like 9. Then we spot patterns easily. Assam keeps salt prices low, while Mizoram keeps them high. West Bengal's price jumped the most. Gujarat barely moved for years, then suddenly rose. Noticing these surprises makes us curious to ask why!

Answer: After rounding, we notice: Assam is usually the cheapest and Mizoram usually the costliest; West Bengal shows the largest increase \( (24 - 9 = 15) \); Gujarat stays steady near \( 15 \) and then jumps to about \( 19 \). Curious questions to explore further include: Why is salt cheaper in Assam than in Mizoram? Why did Gujarat's price stay flat for years and then rise sharply? Which state's price increased the fastest? Do states far from salt-producing areas have higher prices? Did prices rise faster after 2020?

📖 Reading a Data Table and Asking Good Questions

Detailed Explanation

This question belongs to data handling. A data table stores many values in rows and columns so we can compare them easily. Here each row is a year and each column is a state. To make sense of such data at Class 8 level, we round each price to the nearest whole number, then look for patterns: which prices are rising, which stay almost the same, which state is cheapest or costliest, and how the values change from year to year. When we plot these rounded values as a line graph (one line per state), rising lines show increasing prices and flat lines show steady prices. Being curious means turning these observations into questions we can investigate.

Formula Used

Rounding rule: round to the nearest whole number \( \text{(if the decimal part} \ge 0.5 \text{ round up, else round down)} \). Change over the years \( = \text{final price} - \text{starting price} \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Round the values to whole numbers: Round each price using the nearest whole number rule. For example, for West Bengal: \( 9.47 \to 9 \), \( 11.65 \to 12 \), \( 23.99 \to 24 \). For Andaman and Nicobar Islands: \( 13.88 \to 14 \), \( 18.22 \to 18 \), \( 20.99 \to 21 \). Do this for every cell so the numbers are easy to compare and plot.
  2. Step 2: Read year by year (rows): Look across a single year. In 2016 the rounded prices are Andaman \( 16 \), Assam \( 6 \), Gujarat \( 17 \), Mizoram \( 20 \), Uttar Pradesh \( 16 \), West Bengal \( 9 \). This tells us that in the same month the price of the same salt was very different in different states.
  3. Step 3: Read state by state (columns): Follow one column down the years. Mizoram goes about \( 20, 20, 22, 22, 20, 22, 25, 28, 29, 30 \), so it keeps rising and is usually the costliest. Gujarat stays close to \( 15 \) for many years and then jumps to about \( 19 \) in 2025, so it was steady for a long time.
  4. Step 4: Find the overall change for each state: Use change \( = \text{2025 price} - \text{2016 price} \) with rounded values. West Bengal: \( 24 - 9 = 15 \). Assam: \( 12 - 6 = 6 \). Uttar Pradesh: \( 25 - 16 = 9 \). Andaman: \( 21 - 16 = 5 \). This shows West Bengal had the biggest rise, while Andaman changed the least.
  5. Step 5: Note special patterns: Assam is the cheapest almost every year (starting at only \( 6 \)). Mizoram is the costliest almost every year. Gujarat is unusually flat and then suddenly rises. West Bengal rises steadily and steeply. Such patterns are exactly what make us curious.
  6. Step 6: Turn observations into questions to explore: From the trends we can ask: Why is salt so much cheaper in Assam than in Mizoram? Why did Gujarat's price stay flat and then suddenly jump in 2025? Which state's price grew the fastest overall? Are the states with higher prices the ones far from where salt is produced (like the Northeast)? Did prices rise more after 2020? These are meaningful things to explore further.

Final Answer

After rounding, we notice: Assam is usually the cheapest and Mizoram usually the costliest; West Bengal shows the largest increase \( (24 - 9 = 15) \); Gujarat stays steady near \( 15 \) and then jumps to about \( 19 \). Curious questions to explore further include: Why is salt cheaper in Assam than in Mizoram? Why did Gujarat's price stay flat for years and then rise sharply? Which state's price increased the fastest? Do states far from salt-producing areas have higher prices? Did prices rise faster after 2020?

Common Mistake

A common mistake is comparing the raw decimal prices carelessly or rounding wrongly, for example writing \( 16.5 \to 16 \) instead of \( 16.5 \to 17 \); remember that a decimal part of exactly \( 0.5 \) rounds up.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Round every price in the table to the nearest whole number using the rounding rule. For West Bengal the values become \( 9.47 \to 9 \), \( 11.65 \to 12 \), and \( 23.99 \to 24 \). For Andaman and Nicobar Islands: \( 13.88 \to 14 \), \( 18.22 \to 18 \), and \( 20.99 \to 21 \). Repeat this for every cell in the table. — Reason: Whole numbers are much easier to compare and to plot on a line graph than decimals with two places.
  2. Step 2: Read across one row at a time to compare all states in the same year. For example, in 2016 the rounded prices are: Andaman \( 16 \), Assam \( 6 \), Gujarat \( 17 \), Mizoram \( 20 \), Uttar Pradesh \( 16 \), West Bengal \( 9 \). — Reason: Looking at a single row tells us which state had the highest or lowest price at that moment in time, which is a fair comparison because it is the same year for all states.
  3. Step 3: Read down one column at a time to see how the price in a single state changed from year to year. For West Bengal the rounded sequence starts at \( 9 \) and ends at \( 24 \). The total increase is \[ 24 - 9 = 15 \] — Reason: Scanning a column reveals whether a state's price was rising steadily, staying flat, or jumping suddenly, which is different information from comparing states in one year.
  4. Step 4: Identify which state is cheapest and which is costliest across most years. Assam consistently has the lowest rounded price while Mizoram consistently has the highest rounded price. — Reason: This shows a geographic or supply-chain pattern — some regions pay much more for the same product — which is worth questioning further.
  5. Step 5: Check Gujarat's column for unusual behaviour. Its rounded prices stay near \( 15 \) for several years and then jump to about \( 19 \). — Reason: A long flat section followed by a sharp rise is called a sudden change; spotting it leads to curious questions about what event caused the jump.
  6. Step 6: Plot the rounded values as a line graph with one line per state, putting years on the horizontal axis and price on the vertical axis. A rising line means prices are increasing; a flat line means prices are barely changing. — Reason: Graphs make trends visible at a glance, much faster than scanning rows and columns of numbers.
  7. Step 7: Frame curious follow-up questions based on the patterns observed: Why is Assam's salt cheaper than Mizoram's? Why did Gujarat's price stay flat and then rise sharply? Which state's price grew the fastest in percentage terms? Do states far from salt-producing regions pay more? Did prices rise faster after 2020? — Reason: In data handling, turning observations into testable questions is just as important as reading the numbers, because it drives deeper investigation.

Final Answer

After rounding, we notice: Assam is usually the cheapest and Mizoram usually the costliest; West Bengal shows the largest increase \( (24 - 9 = 15) \); Gujarat stays steady near \( 15 \) and then jumps to about \( 19 \). Curious questions to explore further include: Why is salt cheaper in Assam than in Mizoram? Why did Gujarat's price stay flat for years and then rise sharply? Which state's price increased the fastest? Do states far from salt-producing areas have higher prices? Did prices rise faster after 2020?

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students forget to round 0.5 upward, writing \( 11.5 \to 11 \) instead of the correct \( 11.5 \to 12 \), which shifts all their comparisons and the calculated change slightly off.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Round all prices to nearest whole number: West Bengal: \( 9.47 \to 9 \), \( 11.65 \to 12 \), \( 23.99 \to 24 \); Andaman & Nicobar: \( 13.88 \to 14 \), \( 18.22 \to 18 \), \( 20.99 \to 21 \). Apply the same rule to every cell in the table.
  2. Step 2: Compare states within a single year: Sample year 2016 rounded values — Andaman: \( 16 \), Assam: \( 6 \), Gujarat: \( 17 \), Mizoram: \( 20 \), Uttar Pradesh: \( 16 \), West Bengal: \( 9 \). Lowest \( = \) Assam; highest \( = \) Mizoram.
  3. Step 3: Compute largest price change: West Bengal increase: \( 24 - 9 = 15 \). Gujarat stays near \( 15 \) for several years, then rises to about \( 19 \).

Answer: After rounding, we notice: Assam is usually the cheapest and Mizoram usually the costliest; West Bengal shows the largest increase \( (24 - 9 = 15) \); Gujarat stays steady near \( 15 \) and then jumps to about \( 19 \). Curious questions to explore further include: Why is salt cheaper in Assam than in Mizoram? Why did Gujarat's price stay flat for years and then rise sharply? Which state's price increased the fastest? Do states far from salt-producing areas have higher prices? Did prices rise faster after 2020?

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: The table below shows the price (in ₹ per litre) of refined sunflower oil in four cities over 6 years. Round all values to the nearest whole number where needed. Year: 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 City A: 95 102 110 118 125 130 City B: 90 98 105 112 120 128 City C: 100 108 115 122 128 135 City D: 88 95 103 110 117 124 (a) Find the mean price across all four cities for each year. (b) Which city had the highest mean price over the 6-year period? (c) By how much did the overall mean (across all cities) rise from 2018 to 2023? (d) Plot a line graph for the yearly mean (across all cities) from 2018 to 2023 and describe the trend.

Solution: Step 1 — Mean price across all four cities for each year. For 2018: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{95 + 90 + 100 + 88}{4} = \frac{373}{4} = 93.25 \approx 93 \] For 2019: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{102 + 98 + 108 + 95}{4} = \frac{403}{4} = 100.75 \approx 101 \] For 2020: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{110 + 105 + 115 + 103}{4} = \frac{433}{4} = 108.25 \approx 108 \] For 2021: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{118 + 112 + 122 + 110}{4} = \frac{462}{4} = 115.5 \approx 116 \] For 2022: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{125 + 120 + 128 + 117}{4} = \frac{490}{4} = 122.5 \approx 123 \] For 2023: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{130 + 128 + 135 + 124}{4} = \frac{517}{4} = 129.25 \approx 129 \] Summary of yearly means (rounded): 93, 101, 108, 116, 123, 129. Step 2 — Mean price for each city over 6 years. City A: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{95 + 102 + 110 + 118 + 125 + 130}{6} = \frac{680}{6} \approx 113 \] City B: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{90 + 98 + 105 + 112 + 120 + 128}{6} = \frac{653}{6} \approx 109 \] City C: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{100 + 108 + 115 + 122 + 128 + 135}{6} = \frac{708}{6} = 118 \] City D: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{88 + 95 + 103 + 110 + 117 + 124}{6} = \frac{637}{6} \approx 106 \] City C has the highest mean price of \( \approx 118 \) over the 6-year period. Step 3 — Rise in overall mean from 2018 to 2023. Overall mean in 2018 \( \approx 93 \), overall mean in 2023 \( \approx 129 \). \[ \text{Rise} = 129 - 93 = 36 \] The overall mean rose by ₹ 36 per litre from 2018 to 2023. Step 4 — Line graph description. Plot the points: (2018, 93), (2019, 101), (2020, 108), (2021, 116), (2022, 123), (2023, 129) on a graph with Year on the x-axis and Mean Price (₹/litre) on the y-axis. Join consecutive points with straight line segments. The graph shows a steady upward (increasing) trend every year, indicating that oil prices have been rising consistently across all four cities.

Answer: (a) Yearly means (rounded): 2018 → ₹93, 2019 → ₹101, 2020 → ₹108, 2021 → ₹116, 2022 → ₹123, 2023 → ₹129. (b) City C had the highest 6-year mean (≈ ₹118/litre). (c) The overall mean rose by ₹36/litre. (d) The line graph shows a steady increasing trend.

Example 2

Question: The table below shows the monthly electricity bill (in ₹) of five households in a colony over 5 months. Round all values to the nearest whole number where needed. Month: Jan Feb Mar Apr May House 1: 820 750 680 720 900 House 2: 960 880 800 840 1020 House 3: 700 640 580 620 780 House 4: 1050 970 890 930 1100 House 5: 880 810 740 780 950 (a) Find the mean bill of all five households for each month. (b) Find the mean monthly bill for each household over the 5 months. (c) Which household spends the most on average? Which spends the least? (d) In which month was the average bill across all households the lowest? By how much was it lower than the highest monthly average?

Solution: Step 1 — Mean bill of all five households for each month. For January: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{820 + 960 + 700 + 1050 + 880}{5} = \frac{4410}{5} = 882 \] For February: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{750 + 880 + 640 + 970 + 810}{5} = \frac{4050}{5} = 810 \] For March: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{680 + 800 + 580 + 890 + 740}{5} = \frac{3690}{5} = 738 \] For April: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{720 + 840 + 620 + 930 + 780}{5} = \frac{3890}{5} = 778 \] For May: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{900 + 1020 + 780 + 1100 + 950}{5} = \frac{4750}{5} = 950 \] Monthly means: Jan → ₹882, Feb → ₹810, Mar → ₹738, Apr → ₹778, May → ₹950. Step 2 — Mean monthly bill for each household over 5 months. House 1: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{820 + 750 + 680 + 720 + 900}{5} = \frac{3870}{5} = 774 \] House 2: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{960 + 880 + 800 + 840 + 1020}{5} = \frac{4500}{5} = 900 \] House 3: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{700 + 640 + 580 + 620 + 780}{5} = \frac{3320}{5} = 664 \] House 4: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{1050 + 970 + 890 + 930 + 1100}{5} = \frac{4940}{5} = 988 \] House 5: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{880 + 810 + 740 + 780 + 950}{5} = \frac{4160}{5} = 832 \] Step 3 — Highest and lowest average spenders. House 4 has the highest average bill at ₹988 per month. House 3 has the lowest average bill at ₹664 per month. Step 4 — Month with the lowest average bill and comparison with the highest. Lowest monthly average: March at ₹738. Highest monthly average: May at ₹950. \[ \text{Difference} = 950 - 738 = 212 \] The average bill in March was ₹212 lower than in May.

Answer: (a) Monthly means: Jan → ₹882, Feb → ₹810, Mar → ₹738, Apr → ₹778, May → ₹950. (b) House 1 → ₹774, House 2 → ₹900, House 3 → ₹664, House 4 → ₹988, House 5 → ₹832. (c) House 4 spends the most (₹988 avg); House 3 spends the least (₹664 avg). (d) March had the lowest average (₹738), which is ₹212 lower than the highest monthly average in May (₹950).

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: The following table shows the retail price (in ₹ per kg) of loose black tea in the month of April across a few states over 8 years. For your calculations and any plotting, round off values to the nearest whole number. Study the table and answer the questions that follow. State | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 Assam | 112.4 | 113.8 | 114.2 | 116.5 | 118.3 | 120.7 | 122.4 | 124.9 Kerala | 135.6 | 137.2 | 139.5 | 141.8 | 143.2 | 144.5 | 146.8 | 149.3 Rajasthan | 148.3 | 150.6 | 152.4 | 154.7 | 157.1 | 160.2 | 164.5 | 169.8 West Bengal | 128.7 | 130.4 | 131.9 | 133.5 | 136.2 | 139.8 | 143.4 | 147.6 Himachal Pradesh | 155.2 | 157.8 | 160.3 | 163.5 | 167.4 | 172.6 | 178.9 | 185.4 (a) Round off all values in the table to the nearest whole number. (b) For each state, find the total increase in price from 2016 to 2023 (using rounded values). (c) Which state shows the largest increase and which shows the smallest increase over these 8 years? (d) Write at least two curious questions you would like to explore further based on this data.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Round off all values to the nearest whole number: Apply the standard rounding rule to each entry. Assam: 112, 114, 114, 117, 118, 121, 122, 125 Kerala: 136, 137, 140, 142, 143, 145, 147, 149 Rajasthan: 148, 151, 152, 155, 157, 160, 165, 170 West Bengal: 129, 130, 132, 134, 136, 140, 143, 148 Himachal Pradesh: 155, 158, 160, 164, 167, 173, 179, 185
  2. Step 2: Find the increase in price from 2016 to 2023 for each state: Using the rounded values, subtract the 2016 value from the 2023 value for each state. Assam: \[ 125 - 112 = 13 \] Kerala: \[ 149 - 136 = 13 \] Rajasthan: \[ 170 - 148 = 22 \] West Bengal: \[ 148 - 129 = 19 \] Himachal Pradesh: \[ 185 - 155 = 30 \]
  3. Step 3: Identify the largest and smallest increase: Comparing the increases: Assam = 13, Kerala = 13, Rajasthan = 22, West Bengal = 19, Himachal Pradesh = 30. The largest increase is for Himachal Pradesh with a rise of \( 30 \) (in ₹ per kg). The smallest increase is shared by Assam and Kerala, each with a rise of \( 13 \) (in ₹ per kg).
  4. Step 4: Observe key patterns in the rounded data: Assam consistently has the lowest price across all years, which makes sense as it is a major tea-producing state. Himachal Pradesh has the highest price throughout and also the steepest rise. Rajasthan and Himachal Pradesh, which are far from the main tea-growing regions, tend to have higher prices. West Bengal shows a steady moderate increase.
  5. Step 5: Formulate curious questions to explore further: Based on the data, some interesting questions to explore are: 1. Why is tea cheapest in Assam — is it because Assam is a major tea-producing state and transport costs are lower? 2. Why does Himachal Pradesh have both the highest prices and the steepest rise — are its transport or storage costs unusually high? 3. Did prices in all states rise faster after 2020, possibly due to the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on supply chains? 4. Are states that are farther from tea-growing regions always more expensive? 5. Will prices in Assam and Kerala continue to rise at the same slow rate in the coming years?

Answer: After rounding, Assam is the cheapest state for black tea in every year, while Himachal Pradesh is the most expensive. Himachal Pradesh shows the largest increase of \( 30 \) (from \( 155 \) in 2016 to \( 185 \) in 2023), and Assam and Kerala both show the smallest increase of \( 13 \). Curious questions to explore further include: Why is tea cheapest in Assam? Why do prices in Himachal Pradesh rise so steeply? Did prices rise faster after 2020 due to supply disruptions? Are states far from tea-growing areas always pricier?

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Tales By Dots And Lines