SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 3 Q6(i)d

There were \(2\) new admissions to Sudhakar’s class just a couple of days after the class average height was found to be \(150.2\ cm.\) Which of the following statements are correct\(?\) Why\(?\) The heights of everyone in the class has to be measured again to calculate the new average height.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Tales By Dots And Lines

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine you already added up everyone's height and found the average. That total is safely stored — like money in a piggy bank. When two new friends join, only their heights are new and unknown. You just measure those two new friends and drop their heights into the piggy bank. No one else needs to be measured again because their heights did not change at all. The old total is still perfectly usable.

Answer: The statement is INCORRECT. We do NOT need to measure everyone again. We only need to measure the 2 new students, add their heights to the old total \( 150.2 \times n \), and divide by the new number of students \( n + 2 \) to get the new average.

📖 Do We Need to Re-measure Everyone After New Admissions?

Detailed Explanation

The average (mean) height of a class is found by adding all the heights and dividing by the number of students. In symbols, average equals total of all heights divided by number of students. A very useful idea is that if you know the average and the number of students, you can recover the total height without knowing each student's height, because total equals average times number of students. When 2 new students join, the number of students changes and the total height changes (because the two new heights get added). But the heights of the students who were already measured do NOT change. So we do not have to measure everyone again. We only need to measure the 2 new students and reuse the already-known total for the rest.

Formula Used

\[ \text{Average} = \frac{\text{Total of all heights}}{\text{Number of students}} \] which rearranges to \[ \text{Total of all heights} = \text{Average} \times \text{Number of students} \]

Solution

  1. Step 1: Recall what the old average tells us. The old class had some number of students, say \( n \), with average height \( 150.2\ cm \). Using the average, the total height of these \( n \) students is \[ \text{Old total} = 150.2 \times n. \] This total is already known once we know \( n \); we do not need to measure these students again to find it.
  2. Step 2: See what changes when 2 students join. The heights of the original \( n \) students have not changed at all. Only two brand-new heights are added, and these are the only heights we do not yet know.
  3. Step 3: Decide what we actually need. To find the new average, we need the new total and the new number of students. The new number of students is \( n + 2 \). The new total is \[ \text{New total} = (150.2 \times n) + h_1 + h_2, \] where \( h_1 \) and \( h_2 \) are the heights of the two new students. So we only need to measure \( h_1 \) and \( h_2 \).
  4. Step 4: Compute the new average using the two formulas together. \[ \text{New average} = \frac{(150.2 \times n) + h_1 + h_2}{n + 2}. \] Nowhere in this calculation do we need the individual old heights measured again, since \( 150.2 \times n \) already gives their total.
  5. Step 5: Judge the statement. The statement says we must measure everyone again. This is NOT correct, because the old total is already available from the old average, and only the two new students actually need to be measured.

Final Answer

The statement is INCORRECT. We do NOT need to measure everyone again. We only need to measure the 2 new students, add their heights to the old total \( 150.2 \times n \), and divide by the new number of students \( n + 2 \) to get the new average.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is thinking that a new average always requires all original data again. In fact, since total height equals average times number of students, the old data is already summarised in the old average, so only the newly added values need to be measured.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Let the original number of students in the class be \( n \), and note that their average height is \( 150.2 \) cm. — Reason: Naming the unknown count \( n \) lets us write a general formula that works for any class size.
  2. Step 2: Use the rearranged average formula to recover the old total height without measuring anyone individually. The old total is \[ \text{Old total} = 150.2 \times n. \] — Reason: Once the average and the count are known, the total is automatically determined; no re-measurement of the original \( n \) students is needed.
  3. Step 3: Two new students join. Let their individually measured heights be \( h_1 \) and \( h_2 \) (in cm). These are the ONLY two heights we actually need to measure. — Reason: The heights of the original \( n \) students have not changed, so there is nothing new to record for them.
  4. Step 4: Form the new total by adding the two new heights to the old total: \[ \text{New total} = 150.2 \times n + h_1 + h_2. \] — Reason: The overall sum of heights increases only by the heights of the students who actually joined; everyone else's contribution stays the same.
  5. Step 5: The new number of students is \( n + 2 \). Apply the average formula to find the updated mean: \[ \text{New average} = \frac{150.2 \times n + h_1 + h_2}{n + 2}. \] — Reason: Dividing the updated total by the updated count gives the correct new average for the entire class.
  6. Step 6: Evaluate the original claim: the teacher said everyone must be measured again. Compare that with what Step 5 shows — the new average depends only on the old total \( 150.2 \times n \) (already known) and the two new heights \( h_1 \) and \( h_2 \) (measured just once for the new students). — Reason: Since the formula uses no individual height from the original group, re-measuring those students adds no new information and is completely unnecessary.

Final Answer

The statement is INCORRECT. We do NOT need to measure everyone again. We only need to measure the 2 new students, add their heights to the old total \( 150.2 \times n \), and divide by the new number of students \( n + 2 \) to get the new average.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students assume that once new members join, the old average becomes useless and all heights must be re-recorded. In reality, the old total \( 150.2 \times n \) already encodes every original height; only the two new heights are genuinely unknown and need to be measured.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Old total height of \( n \) students: \( \text{Old Total} = 150.2 \times n \)
  2. Step 2: Measure only the 2 new students' heights \( h_1 \) and \( h_2 \); original heights are unchanged.
  3. Step 3: New average \( = \frac{150.2 \times n + h_1 + h_2}{n + 2} \)

Answer: The statement is INCORRECT. We do NOT need to measure everyone again. We only need to measure the 2 new students, add their heights to the old total \( 150.2 \times n \), and divide by the new number of students \( n + 2 \) to get the new average.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: The average score of 30 students in a class test was found to be 72 marks. After the test was graded, 3 students who were absent had their papers evaluated too, and they scored 65, 80, and 55 marks respectively. A classmate says: 'We must re-check every student's marks to find the new average.' Is this statement correct? Find the new average score of all 33 students.

Solution: Step 1 — Find the old total sum of marks. The average of 30 students was 72, so the old sum is: \[\text{Old Sum} = 72 \times 30 = 2160\] Step 2 — Find the sum of the 3 new students' marks. \[\text{New Students' Sum} = 65 + 80 + 55 = 200\] Step 3 — Find the new total sum for all 33 students. \[\text{New Total Sum} = 2160 + 200 = 2360\] Step 4 — Find the new average. \[\text{New Average} = \frac{2360}{33} \approx 71.5 \text{ marks}\] Step 5 — Evaluate the classmate's statement. The classmate's statement is INCORRECT. We do not need to re-check every student's marks. Since we already know the old average and the old count, we can compute the old total sum directly. We only need to add the new students' marks and recalculate the average using the formula above.

Answer: The statement is incorrect. The new average score is approximately 71.5 marks. Re-checking all 30 students' marks is not necessary.

Example 2

Question: The average weight of 25 bags of rice in a warehouse was recorded as 48.4 kg. Later, 5 more bags arrived and were weighed; their individual weights were 50 kg, 46 kg, 52 kg, 49 kg, and 53 kg. A worker claims: 'All 30 bags must be weighed again to get the correct new average.' Decide whether the worker is right or wrong, and calculate the correct new average weight.

Solution: Step 1 — Find the total weight of the original 25 bags. \[\text{Old Total} = 48.4 \times 25 = 1210 \text{ kg}\] Step 2 — Find the total weight of the 5 new bags. \[\text{New Bags Total} = 50 + 46 + 52 + 49 + 53 = 250 \text{ kg}\] Step 3 — Find the combined total weight of all 30 bags. \[\text{Grand Total} = 1210 + 250 = 1460 \text{ kg}\] Step 4 — Calculate the new average weight. \[\text{New Average} = \frac{1460}{30} = 48.\overline{6} \approx 48.67 \text{ kg}\] Step 5 — Evaluate the worker's claim. The worker's claim is INCORRECT. Since the old average and the old count are known, the old total can be calculated without re-weighing those 25 bags. Only the 5 new bags needed to be weighed. The new average is found by adding the new weights to the recovered old total and dividing by the new count.

Answer: The worker's claim is incorrect. The new average weight is approximately 48.67 kg. Re-weighing all 25 original bags is not required.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: The average score of 30 students in a class test was recorded as 72 marks. Later, 3 students who had been absent gave the test. Their scores were 85, 91, and 64. A classmate says: 'We must collect all 30 students' scores again and recalculate the average from scratch.' Is this statement correct? Justify your answer and find the new average score of all 33 students.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what we already know: We know the old average score of 30 students is 72. We do NOT have each individual score, but we can still find the total marks of those 30 students using the relationship: Total = Average \( \times \) Number of students.
  2. Step 2: Find the old total marks: Old total marks of 30 students: \[ 72 \times 30 = 2160 \]
  3. Step 3: Find the sum of the 3 new students' scores: The 3 new students scored 85, 91, and 64. Their combined score is: \[ 85 + 91 + 64 = 240 \]
  4. Step 4: Find the new total marks and new count: New total marks of all 33 students: \[ 2160 + 240 = 2400 \] New number of students: \[ 30 + 3 = 33 \]
  5. Step 5: Calculate the new average: New average score: \[ \frac{2400}{33} = 72.\overline{72} \approx 72.73 \text{ marks} \]
  6. Step 6: Evaluate the classmate's statement: The classmate's statement is INCORRECT. We do not need to collect all 30 students' scores again. We only needed the 3 new students' scores, the old average (72), and the old count (30) to calculate the new average. The old total can always be recovered as Old Average \( \times \) Old Count.

Answer: The classmate's statement is INCORRECT. We only need the 3 new students' scores (85, 91, 64), not all 30 original scores. The new average score of all 33 students is \( \frac{2400}{33} \approx 72.73 \) marks.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Tales By Dots And Lines