SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 3 Q6(iii)d

There were \(2\) new admissions to Sudhakar’s class just a couple of days after the class average height was found to be \(150.2\ cm.\) Which of the following statements about the new class average height are correct\(?\) Why\(?\) The information is not sufficient to make a claim about median.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Tales By Dots And Lines

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a seesaw balanced perfectly in the middle. The class average height is like that balance point, sitting at \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \). Two new students are joining, but nobody told us how tall they are. A very tall student tips the seesaw up; a very short student tips it down. Without knowing their heights, we simply cannot tell which way the seesaw moves. The median is even trickier — you need everyone's height listed in order to find it, and we do not have that list.

Answer: Without knowing the two new heights, the new class average could increase, decrease, or stay the same at \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \); it goes up if the new students are taller than the average, down if shorter, and unchanged if their heights balance to the average. Also, the given information is not enough to say anything about the median, since finding a median requires the full list of individual heights, not just the mean.

📖 Effect of New Admissions on Class Average Height

Detailed Explanation

The average (mean) height is found by dividing the total height of everyone by the number of people. When new students are admitted, both the total height and the number of students change. Whether the new average goes up, stays the same, or goes down depends entirely on the heights of the new students. If a new student is taller than the current average, the average rises. If a new student is shorter than the current average, the average falls. If a new student's height equals the average, the average stays the same. Since the question does NOT tell us the two new students' heights, we cannot claim exactly what the new average will be. So the correct statement is that the new average could increase, decrease, or stay the same, depending on the two new heights. The mean is affected by every value, while the median (the middle value when data is arranged in order) needs the full ordered list to be found, which we also do not have.

Formula Used

\[ \text{Average height} = \frac{\text{Total height of all students}}{\text{Number of students}} \]

Solution

  1. Step 1: Recall the given information. The old class average height is \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \), and \( 2 \) new students are admitted. We are NOT told the heights of these two new students.
  2. Step 2: Understand how the average changes. The new average depends on how the two new heights compare with \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \). Adding a student taller than the average pulls the average up; adding a shorter student pulls it down.
  3. Step 3: Case 1 (average increases): If both new students are taller than \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \) (for example both are \( 160\ \text{cm} \)), their combined height is more than what two average students would contribute, so the new mean becomes greater than \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \).
  4. Step 4: Case 2 (average decreases): If both new students are shorter than \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \) (for example both are \( 140\ \text{cm} \)), they add less than average, so the new mean becomes less than \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \).
  5. Step 5: Case 3 (average stays the same): If both new students are exactly \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \), or if one is above and one below in a balanced way so their average is \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \), then the class mean stays \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \).
  6. Step 6: Conclusion about the mean. Since all three cases are possible and we do not know the new heights, no single claim (only increases, or only decreases, or only stays same) can be certain. The correct statement is that the new average may increase, decrease, or remain the same.
  7. Step 7: About the median. The median is the middle value of the ordered list of heights. To find how it changes, we need each student's actual height, not just the average. Since we do not have this data, the information is indeed not sufficient to make a claim about the median.

Final Answer

Without knowing the two new heights, the new class average could increase, decrease, or stay the same at \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \); it goes up if the new students are taller than the average, down if shorter, and unchanged if their heights balance to the average. Also, the given information is not enough to say anything about the median, since finding a median requires the full list of individual heights, not just the mean.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to assume the average must definitely increase (or definitely decrease) just because new students are added. The average only changes in a specific direction based on whether the new heights are above or below \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \), so without that data no fixed conclusion can be drawn.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify what is given and what is missing. We know the old class mean height is \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \), and that \( 2 \) new students join the class. However, the heights of these two new students are NOT provided. — Reason: Before analysing any effect on the mean, we must check exactly what information is available and what is unknown.
  2. Step 2: Recall how adding new data points changes the mean. When new students join, both the sum of heights and the count of students change, so the new mean becomes: \[ \text{New mean} = \frac{\text{Old sum of heights} + \text{Sum of new heights}}{\text{Old count} + 2} \] — Reason: Writing out the updated formula makes it clear that the result depends directly on the two new heights, which we do not know.
  3. Step 3: Consider Case 1 — both new students are taller than \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \). Adding values larger than the current mean pulls the mean upward, so the new mean would be greater than \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \). — Reason: A value above the mean always increases the overall average when included.
  4. Step 4: Consider Case 2 — both new students are shorter than \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \). Adding values smaller than the current mean drags the mean downward, so the new mean would be less than \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \). — Reason: A value below the mean always decreases the overall average when included.
  5. Step 5: Consider Case 3 — the two new students' heights together average exactly \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \). In this situation the mean remains unchanged at \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \). — Reason: If the new data points balance out exactly at the existing mean, they contribute proportionally and do not shift the average.
  6. Step 6: Draw the conclusion about the mean. Since all three outcomes (increase, decrease, no change) are possible and we are not given the two new heights, we cannot state a single definite new mean. — Reason: Without the missing data, any one of the three cases could be true; the problem is genuinely underdetermined.
  7. Step 7: Address the median separately. The median is the middle value of the data arranged in order. To find or predict the median, we would need the complete sorted list of every student's height — old and new. Since we have only the mean (\( 150.2\ \text{cm} \)) and not the individual heights, we cannot determine the median at all. — Reason: The mean and the median are different measures; knowing one does not give us the other without the full data set.

Final Answer

Without knowing the two new heights, the new class average could increase, decrease, or stay the same at \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \); it goes up if the new students are taller than the average, down if shorter, and unchanged if their heights balance to the average. Also, the given information is not enough to say anything about the median, since finding a median requires the full list of individual heights, not just the mean.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students assume the average must increase simply because more students are added, forgetting that the direction of change depends entirely on whether the new heights are above or below the current mean — not on the number of students added.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Given: current class average = \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \); 2 new students admitted; heights of new students: unknown.
  2. Step 2: New average depends on new students' heights relative to \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \): taller \( \Rightarrow \) average rises; shorter \( \Rightarrow \) average falls; equal \( \Rightarrow \) average unchanged.
  3. Step 3: Since new heights are not given, the new average cannot be determined; median also cannot be found without the full ordered data set.

Answer: Without knowing the two new heights, the new class average could increase, decrease, or stay the same at \( 150.2\ \text{cm} \); it goes up if the new students are taller than the average, down if shorter, and unchanged if their heights balance to the average. Also, the given information is not enough to say anything about the median, since finding a median requires the full list of individual heights, not just the mean.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: The average weight of 30 students in a class was found to be 42.6 kg. After a few days, 3 new students joined the class with weights 38 kg, 45 kg, and 50 kg. (a) Find the new class average weight. (b) Can we determine the new median weight? Explain why or why not.

Solution: Step 1: Find the total weight of the original 30 students. The original mean is \( 42.6 \) kg with \( 30 \) students. Total weight of original students: \[ \text{Total} = 42.6 \times 30 = 1278 \text{ kg} \] Step 2: Find the total weight of the 3 new students. \[ \text{New total} = 38 + 45 + 50 = 133 \text{ kg} \] Step 3: Find the combined total weight. \[ \text{Combined total} = 1278 + 133 = 1411 \text{ kg} \] Step 4: Find the new number of students. \[ \text{New count} = 30 + 3 = 33 \] Step 5: Calculate the new mean. \[ \text{New Mean} = \frac{1411}{33} \approx 42.76 \text{ kg} \] So the new class average weight is approximately \( 42.76 \) kg. Step 6: Can we find the new median? The median is the middle value when all observations are arranged in order. We know the individual weights of only 3 new students, but we do NOT know the individual weights of the original 30 students or their sorted order. Without the complete sorted list of all 33 students' weights, we cannot identify the 17th value (the new median position). Therefore, the information is NOT sufficient to determine the new median.

Answer: (a) New class average weight is approximately \( 42.76 \) kg. (b) The new median cannot be determined because the individual weights of the original 30 students are unknown, so the full sorted list cannot be constructed.

Example 2

Question: The average score of 25 students in a mathematics test was 68.4 marks. Two students who were absent gave their tests later and scored 72 marks and 55 marks respectively. (a) Find the new average score of all 27 students. (b) A classmate says: 'Since the two new scores are on either side of the original average, the median will not change.' Is this claim correct? Justify your answer.

Solution: Step 1: Find the total score of the original 25 students. Original mean = \( 68.4 \) marks, number of students = \( 25 \). \[ \text{Total score} = 68.4 \times 25 = 1710 \text{ marks} \] Step 2: Add the scores of the two new students. \[ \text{New total} = 1710 + 72 + 55 = 1837 \text{ marks} \] Step 3: Find the new number of students. \[ \text{New count} = 25 + 2 = 27 \] Step 4: Calculate the new mean. \[ \text{New Mean} = \frac{1837}{27} = 68.03... \approx 68.03 \text{ marks} \] So the new class average is approximately \( 68.03 \) marks. Step 5: Evaluate the classmate's claim about the median. For 25 students, the median is the 13th value in the sorted list. For 27 students, the median is the 14th value in the sorted list. The two new scores (55 and 72) will be inserted at specific positions in the sorted list, shifting the positions of several values. Without knowing all 25 individual scores and their sorted order, we cannot say where 55 and 72 will be placed, and therefore we cannot determine what the 14th value will be. The classmate's reasoning is incorrect — the median depends on the actual position of values in the sorted list, not just on whether new values are above or below the mean. The information is NOT sufficient to determine or compare the new median.

Answer: (a) New average score is approximately \( 68.03 \) marks. (b) The classmate's claim is incorrect. The median cannot be determined or compared without knowing all individual scores of the original 25 students in sorted order.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: The average weight of students in Class 8B was calculated to be \( 45.6 \text{ kg} \). A week later, 3 new students joined the class. A classmate, Priya, makes the following statements: (i) The new class average weight must be higher than \( 45.6 \text{ kg} \) since more students joined. (ii) The new class average weight could be exactly \( 45.6 \text{ kg} \) if the right conditions are met. (iii) We can easily find the new median weight from this information. Which of Priya's statements are correct and which are incorrect? Justify your answer.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what information is given: We know the original average (mean) weight of the class is \( 45.6 \text{ kg} \), and 3 new students have joined. We do NOT know the individual weights of the 3 new students, nor the number of students originally in the class.
  2. Step 2: Analyse Statement (i) — the new average must be higher: Statement (i) is INCORRECT. The new mean depends on the weights of the 3 new students. Let the original number of students be \( n \) and the original sum of weights be \( S \), so \( \dfrac{S}{n} = 45.6 \), meaning \( S = 45.6n \). If the 3 new students have weights \( w_1, w_2, w_3 \), the new mean is \[ \text{New Mean} = \frac{S + w_1 + w_2 + w_3}{n + 3} = \frac{45.6n + w_1 + w_2 + w_3}{n + 3}. \] If each new student weighs MORE than \( 45.6 \text{ kg} \), the new mean is greater than \( 45.6 \text{ kg} \). If each weighs LESS than \( 45.6 \text{ kg} \), the new mean is less than \( 45.6 \text{ kg} \). Just adding more students does not automatically raise the mean.
  3. Step 3: Analyse Statement (ii) — the new average could stay at 45.6 kg: Statement (ii) is CORRECT. The new mean equals \( 45.6 \text{ kg} \) when the 3 new students' weights average to exactly \( 45.6 \text{ kg} \). In that case: \[ \frac{45.6n + w_1 + w_2 + w_3}{n + 3} = \frac{45.6n + 3 \times 45.6}{n + 3} = \frac{45.6(n + 3)}{n + 3} = 45.6. \] So, if the 3 new students' combined weight is \( 3 \times 45.6 = 136.8 \text{ kg} \), the class mean remains unchanged at \( 45.6 \text{ kg} \).
  4. Step 4: Summarise how the mean can change: In general: if the average weight of the 3 new students is greater than \( 45.6 \text{ kg} \), the new class mean increases. If their average is less than \( 45.6 \text{ kg} \), the new class mean decreases. If their average equals \( 45.6 \text{ kg} \), the class mean stays the same. Without knowing \( w_1, w_2, w_3 \), we cannot determine what happens to the mean.
  5. Step 5: Analyse Statement (iii) — we can find the new median: Statement (iii) is INCORRECT. The median is the middle value when all data are arranged in order. To find the median, we need the complete list of every student's weight arranged in ascending or descending order. Knowing only the mean (\( 45.6 \text{ kg} \)) and the count of students gives no information about the individual values or their order. Therefore, it is impossible to determine the median from the given information alone.

Answer: Statement (i) is INCORRECT: The new class average weight can increase, decrease, or remain the same at \( 45.6 \text{ kg} \) depending on the weights of the 3 new students — it rises if their average exceeds \( 45.6 \text{ kg} \), falls if it is below, and stays unchanged if it equals \( 45.6 \text{ kg} \). Statement (ii) is CORRECT: The mean remains \( 45.6 \text{ kg} \) if the 3 new students together weigh \( 3 \times 45.6 = 136.8 \text{ kg} \). Statement (iii) is INCORRECT: The median cannot be found without knowing every individual student's weight and arranging them in order; the mean alone is not sufficient.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Tales By Dots And Lines