SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 3 Q6(i)c

There were \(2\) new admissions to Sudhakar’s class just a couple of days after the class average height was found to be \(150.2\ cm.\) Which of the following statements are correct\(?\) Why\(?\) The heights of the new students have to be measured to find out the new average height.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Tales By Dots And Lines

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine sharing a big bag of apples equally among friends. To find each person's share, you need to know the total number of apples. When two new friends join, you need to add their apples to the bag first. Nobody knows how many apples those new friends bring until you actually count them. Without counting, you cannot find the new equal share. That is exactly why the new average height cannot be found until the two new students are measured.

Answer: Yes, the statement is correct. To find the new average height, we must know the total of all heights, and that total depends on the heights of the two new students. Since those heights are unknown, they have to be measured first before a correct new average can be calculated.

📖 Effect of New Admissions on Class Average Height

Detailed Explanation

The average (or mean) of a set of values is found by adding up all the values and dividing by how many values there are. In symbols, if there are \( n \) values with a total sum \( S \), then the average is \( \frac{S}{n} \). This tells us that the average depends on TWO things: the total sum of all heights, and the number of students. When 2 new students join the class, the number of students increases. But to recompute the average, we also need the new total sum, and that sum changes by exactly the heights of the two new students. Since we do not yet know how tall the new students are, their heights could be short, medium, or tall, and each possibility would change the total sum differently. So the new average could go up, stay the same, or go down depending on those unknown heights. That is why the statement is correct: we genuinely need to measure the heights of the new students first.

Formula Used

\[ \text{Average} = \frac{\text{Sum of all heights}}{\text{Number of students}} \]

Solution

  1. Step 1: Recall what an average needs. To find any average we need both the total sum of the values and the number of values, since \( \text{Average} = \frac{\text{Sum}}{\text{Number}} \).
  2. Step 2: Look at the old average. The class average was \( 150.2 \ cm \). If the old class had \( n \) students, the old total sum of heights was \( n \times 150.2 \ cm \). This total is fixed and known once we know \( n \).
  3. Step 3: See what changes with the new admissions. Two new students join, so the number of students becomes \( n + 2 \). The new total sum becomes the old sum PLUS the two new heights. But those two heights are unknown right now.
  4. Step 4: Write the new average. The new average is \[ \text{New average} = \frac{(n \times 150.2) + h_1 + h_2}{n + 2} \] where \( h_1 \) and \( h_2 \) are the heights of the two new students.
  5. Step 5: Understand why measuring is needed. Since \( h_1 \) and \( h_2 \) appear directly in the numerator, the new average changes with their actual values. If the new students are short, the average drops; if they are tall, it rises. We cannot decide the outcome without knowing \( h_1 \) and \( h_2 \).

Final Answer

Yes, the statement is correct. To find the new average height, we must know the total of all heights, and that total depends on the heights of the two new students. Since those heights are unknown, they have to be measured first before a correct new average can be calculated.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to think the average stays the same because only 2 students joined, or to just average the old mean with a guessed height. In reality the exact heights of the new students directly change the total sum, so they must be measured before recomputing the average.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Recall the formula for average. The average height of a group is given by \[ \text{Average} = \frac{\text{Sum of all heights}}{\text{Number of students}} \] — Reason: This formula shows us that computing the average requires TWO pieces of information: the total sum and the total count. If either piece is missing, the average cannot be found.
  2. Step 2: Identify the known information. The current class average height is \( 150.2 \, \text{cm} \). If the original class had \( n \) students, then the total sum of their heights is \( n \times 150.2 \, \text{cm} \) — Reason: We can work backwards from the known average and the known number of students to find the original total. This total is fixed and fully known.
  3. Step 3: Understand what changes when two new students join. The new number of students becomes \( n + 2 \). The new total sum of heights becomes \( (n \times 150.2) + h_1 + h_2 \), where \( h_1 \) and \( h_2 \) are the heights of the two new students — Reason: Every new student adds their own height to the running total, so the sum changes by exactly the combined heights of the newcomers.
  4. Step 4: Recognise the problem: \( h_1 \) and \( h_2 \) are unknown. Without their values, the new total sum cannot be calculated. The new average would be \[ \text{New Average} = \frac{(n \times 150.2) + h_1 + h_2}{n + 2} \] but this expression cannot be evaluated — Reason: The formula has two unknowns in the numerator. Different heights for the new students would produce completely different averages, so no single answer can be given without measuring them.
  5. Step 5: Consider the range of possible outcomes. If the two new students are shorter than \( 150.2 \, \text{cm} \), the new average goes down. If they are exactly \( 150.2 \, \text{cm} \) each, the average stays the same. If they are taller, the average goes up — Reason: This shows that the result is not fixed; it depends entirely on the actual heights of the new students, confirming that measurement is essential.
  6. Step 6: Conclude whether the statement in the question is correct. Because the new total sum — and therefore the new average — cannot be determined without knowing \( h_1 \) and \( h_2 \), the heights of the two new students must be measured before any recalculation is possible — Reason: The statement is logically sound: skipping the measurement and guessing an average would be mathematically incorrect.

Final Answer

Yes, the statement is correct. To find the new average height, we must know the total of all heights, and that total depends on the heights of the two new students. Since those heights are unknown, they have to be measured first before a correct new average can be calculated.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students sometimes think that adding two students only changes the count (from n to n + 2) and forget that the sum of heights also changes by the heights of those two new students. Both the numerator and the denominator of the average formula are affected, so both must be updated with real measured values.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Given: Old class average = \( 150.2 \) cm, 2 new students admitted.
  2. Step 2: New average requires the new total sum of all heights; new total = Old sum \( + \) heights of 2 new students.
  3. Step 3: Heights of the 2 new students are unknown \( \Rightarrow \) new total sum cannot be determined \( \Rightarrow \) new average cannot be computed without measuring them first.

Answer: Yes, the statement is correct. To find the new average height, we must know the total of all heights, and that total depends on the heights of the two new students. Since those heights are unknown, they have to be measured first before a correct new average can be calculated.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: The average marks scored by 30 students in a Mathematics test was 72. Three new students joined the class and appeared in a re-test. A classmate claimed: 'The new class average must still be 72 because three students do not make a big difference.' Is this claim correct? Explain why or why not, and find the new average if the three new students scored 85, 60, and 90.

Solution: Step 1: Find the total marks of the original 30 students. We know that Mean = (Sum of observations) ÷ (Number of observations), so: Sum of original 30 students' marks = Mean × Number of students \[ \text{Sum}_{\text{original}} = 72 \times 30 = 2160 \] Step 2: Evaluate the classmate's claim. The claim that the average remains 72 is INCORRECT. The new average depends on the actual marks scored by the three new students. Without knowing their marks, we cannot determine the new average — it could be higher, lower, or equal to 72. We must know each new student's marks to calculate the updated average. Step 3: Find the total marks of the three new students. The three new students scored 85, 60, and 90. \[ \text{Sum}_{\text{new}} = 85 + 60 + 90 = 235 \] Step 4: Find the combined sum for all 33 students. \[ \text{Sum}_{\text{total}} = 2160 + 235 = 2395 \] Step 5: Find the new average for 33 students. \[ \text{New Average} = \frac{2395}{33} = 72.57 \text{ (approx.)} \] The classmate's claim is incorrect. The new average is approximately 72.57, which is different from 72. The new average could only be determined after measuring (recording) the marks of the new students.

Answer: The claim is incorrect. The new average is approximately 72.57 marks.

Example 2

Question: The average weight of players in a school football team of 11 players was 58.4 kg. Two substitute players were added to the squad. Another student said: 'We do not need to weigh the new players; the average weight of the squad will automatically increase since they look heavier.' Is this statement correct? Justify your answer. Also find the new average weight if the two new players weigh 65 kg and 70 kg.

Solution: Step 1: Find the total weight of the original 11 players. \[ \text{Sum}_{\text{original}} = 58.4 \times 11 = 642.4 \text{ kg} \] Step 2: Evaluate the student's statement. The statement is INCORRECT on two counts. First, we cannot determine whether the average will increase, decrease, or remain the same merely by appearance — we must actually measure the weights of the new players. Second, even if the new players are heavier than some existing players, the average could change in any direction depending on the exact values. The new weights must be recorded to compute the new average. Step 3: Find the total weight of the two new players. \[ \text{Sum}_{\text{new}} = 65 + 70 = 135 \text{ kg} \] Step 4: Find the combined total weight for all 13 players. \[ \text{Sum}_{\text{total}} = 642.4 + 135 = 777.4 \text{ kg} \] Step 5: Find the new average weight for 13 players. \[ \text{New Average} = \frac{777.4}{13} = 59.8 \text{ kg} \] So the new average weight is 59.8 kg, which is indeed higher than 58.4 kg in this case. However, this conclusion could only be reached after actually weighing the new players — the statement that we 'do not need to weigh them' is wrong.

Answer: The statement is incorrect. The new average weight is 59.8 kg (found only after actually measuring the new players' weights).

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: A sports teacher recorded the average weight of 30 students in a group as \( 42.6 \) kg. Three new students joined the group the following week. A student claims: 'We can find the new average weight of the group without measuring the weights of the three new students, since we already know the old average.' Is this claim correct or incorrect? Give a reason for your answer.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Recall the formula for average: The average (mean) weight is given by: \[ \text{Mean} = \frac{\text{Sum of all weights}}{\text{Total number of students}} \] To find the new average after the three students join, we need both the new total sum of weights and the new total count of students.
  2. Step 2: Find the total weight of the original 30 students: We are told the old average is \( 42.6 \) kg for 30 students. So the total weight of the original group is: \[ \text{Total weight} = 42.6 \times 30 = 1278 \text{ kg} \]
  3. Step 3: Identify what is unknown: After the three new students join, the total number of students becomes \( 30 + 3 = 33 \). However, the individual weights of the three new students are not known. Let the weights of the three new students be \( w_1 \), \( w_2 \), and \( w_3 \) kg. The new total weight would be \( 1278 + w_1 + w_2 + w_3 \), and the new average would be: \[ \text{New Mean} = \frac{1278 + w_1 + w_2 + w_3}{33} \]
  4. Step 4: Decide if the claim is correct: Since \( w_1 \), \( w_2 \), and \( w_3 \) are unknown, the value of \( 1278 + w_1 + w_2 + w_3 \) cannot be determined. Therefore, the new mean cannot be calculated without measuring the weights of the three new students. The student's claim is INCORRECT.
  5. Step 5: Conclusion: The claim is incorrect. Even though we know the old average and can compute the old total weight as \( 42.6 \times 30 = 1278 \) kg, the new average depends on the weights of the three newly joined students, which are unknown. Without measuring those weights, the new average cannot be found.

Answer: The claim is INCORRECT. To find the new average weight of 33 students, we need the total weight of all 33 students. The total weight of the original 30 students is \( 42.6 \times 30 = 1278 \) kg, but the weights of the three new students are unknown. Since the new total sum cannot be determined without their weights, the three new students must be weighed first before the new average can be calculated.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Tales By Dots And Lines