Example 1
Question: The average marks of 30 students in a class test was found to be 64. Later, 3 more students submitted their answer sheets and were included. Their marks were 64, 72, and 58. Which of the following statements is correct? Give reasons. (a) The average marks will definitely increase because 3 new values are added. (b) The average marks will definitely decrease. (c) The average marks may increase, decrease, or stay the same, depending on the new values.
Solution: Step 1: Find the total marks of the original 30 students. Original total = Mean × Number of students \[ \text{Original total} = 64 \times 30 = 1920 \] Step 2: Find the sum of the 3 new students' marks. \[ \text{New sum} = 64 + 72 + 58 = 194 \] Step 3: Find the new total and new number of students. \[ \text{New total} = 1920 + 194 = 2114 \] \[ \text{New number of students} = 30 + 3 = 33 \] Step 4: Calculate the new average. \[ \text{New average} = \frac{2114}{33} = 64.06 \ldots \approx 64.06 \] Step 5: Compare the new average with the original average of 64. The new average (approximately 64.06) is slightly greater than 64. This happened because the average of the three new values is \( \frac{194}{3} \approx 64.67 \), which is above 64, pulling the overall mean up slightly. Analysis of statements: (a) This statement is INCORRECT in general. Adding new values does not automatically increase the average. For example, if all three new students had scored 58 (below 64), the average would have decreased. (b) This statement is INCORRECT. The average did not decrease here. (c) This statement is CORRECT. The new average depends entirely on whether the new values are above, below, or equal to the current average — not merely on the count of new additions. Conclusion: Statement (c) is the correct general principle. In this specific case, the average increased slightly because the mean of the new values (about 64.67) exceeded the original average of 64.
Answer: Statement (c) is correct. The average may increase, decrease, or remain the same depending on the new values. Here the average increased slightly from 64 to approximately 64.06 because the mean of the newly added marks (about 64.67) was above the original average.
Example 2
Question: A shopkeeper recorded the daily sales (in rupees) of a small store for 20 days. The average daily sale was Rs 1,250. On the next 2 days, the sales were Rs 980 and Rs 1,060. A friend claims: 'Since 2 more days of data are added, the average daily sale will go up.' Is the friend correct? Justify your answer with calculations.
Solution: Step 1: Find the total sales for the original 20 days. \[ \text{Original total} = 1250 \times 20 = 25000 \] Step 2: Find the total sales for the 2 new days. \[ \text{New days' total} = 980 + 1060 = 2040 \] Step 3: Find the combined total and the new number of days. \[ \text{Combined total} = 25000 + 2040 = 27040 \] \[ \text{New number of days} = 20 + 2 = 22 \] Step 4: Calculate the new average daily sale. \[ \text{New average} = \frac{27040}{22} = 1229.09 \ldots \approx \text{Rs } 1229.09 \] Step 5: Compare with the original average of Rs 1,250. The new average (approximately Rs 1,229.09) is less than Rs 1,250. So the average has decreased, not increased. Reason: The mean of the two new values is \( \frac{2040}{2} = \text{Rs } 1020 \), which is below the original average of Rs 1,250. Adding values below the current average always pulls the mean down. Conclusion: The friend's claim is INCORRECT. Simply adding more data values does not guarantee an increase in the average. The direction of change depends on whether the new values are above or below the current average. Here, both new values were below Rs 1,250, so the average decreased.
Answer: The friend is incorrect. The new average is approximately Rs 1,229.09, which is lower than the original average of Rs 1,250, because both new sales figures (Rs 980 and Rs 1,060) were below the original average.