Example 1
Question: The average marks of students in a class were found to be 68 after a unit test. Later, two students who were absent during the test appeared for a re-test and scored 71 marks and 65 marks respectively. Their marks were added to the class data. A student claimed: 'The class average must have gone up because 71 is greater than 68.' Another student said: 'The class average must have gone down because 65 is less than 68.' A third student said: 'We do not have enough information to decide.' Who is correct? Explain with calculations using two possible class sizes.
Solution: Let us first understand what happens when two new marks, 71 and 65, are added to a data set whose mean was 68. The sum of the two new marks is: \[71 + 65 = 136\] The average of the two new marks is: \[\frac{136}{2} = 68\] Since the average of the new marks (68) is exactly equal to the original class average (68), one might expect the mean to stay the same. However, let us verify this with two different original class sizes to confirm. Case 1: Suppose the original class had 25 students. Original sum of marks: \[68 \times 25 = 1700\] New sum after adding 71 and 65: \[1700 + 71 + 65 = 1836\] New number of students: \[25 + 2 = 27\] New mean: \[\frac{1836}{27} = 68\] The mean stays at 68. Case 2: Suppose the original class had 30 students. Original sum of marks: \[68 \times 30 = 2040\] New sum after adding 71 and 65: \[2040 + 71 + 65 = 2176\] New number of students: \[30 + 2 = 32\] New mean: \[\frac{2176}{32} = 68\] The mean stays at 68 in this case too. In fact, whenever the average of the newly added values exactly equals the existing mean, the mean does not change regardless of the original class size. So in this special case, the mean remains 68. The first student (mean goes up) and the second student (mean goes down) are both wrong. The third student's caution is a good general habit, but here we can actually determine the result: the mean stays the same, because the average of the two new scores equals the original mean. Key insight: If the average of the added values equals the existing mean, the overall mean is unchanged, no matter what the original count was. Had the two new scores averaged to something other than 68, we would need the original count to decide.
Answer: The third student's instinct (to check carefully) is admirable, but in this specific case we CAN determine the outcome. Since the average of the two new marks (71 and 65) equals \(\frac{71+65}{2} = 68\), which is the same as the original class average, the class average remains unchanged at 68 marks, regardless of the original class size.
Example 2
Question: The average weight of members in a yoga group was recorded as 62 kg. Three new members joined the group with weights 58 kg, 60 kg, and 64 kg. A trainer said: 'The average weight of the group has definitely decreased, since two of the three new members weigh less than 62 kg.' Is the trainer correct? Analyse the situation. Use two different original group sizes to support your answer.
Solution: Let us first compute the average of the three new members' weights. Sum of new members' weights: \[58 + 60 + 64 = 182\] Average of new members' weights: \[\frac{182}{3} = 60.\overline{6} \text{ kg (approximately 60.67 kg)}\] Since the average of the new members (approximately 60.67 kg) is less than the original group average (62 kg), the new mean will indeed be pulled downward. However, the extent of the change — and precisely whether it falls below a particular value — depends on the original group size. Let us check with two different original sizes. Case 1: Suppose the original group had 10 members. Original total weight: \[62 \times 10 = 620 \text{ kg}\] New total weight after 3 new members: \[620 + 182 = 802 \text{ kg}\] New number of members: \[10 + 3 = 13\] New mean: \[\frac{802}{13} \approx 61.69 \text{ kg}\] The average dropped from 62 kg to approximately 61.69 kg. Case 2: Suppose the original group had 30 members. Original total weight: \[62 \times 30 = 1860 \text{ kg}\] New total weight after 3 new members: \[1860 + 182 = 2042 \text{ kg}\] New number of members: \[30 + 3 = 33\] New mean: \[\frac{2042}{33} \approx 61.88 \text{ kg}\] The average dropped from 62 kg to approximately 61.88 kg. In both cases, the average decreased, which agrees with the direction of the trainer's claim. This is because the average of the new members (approximately 60.67 kg) is less than the original mean (62 kg), so adding them will always pull the mean down, regardless of the original group size. However, the trainer's reasoning — 'two out of three new members weigh less than 62 kg, therefore the average decreases' — is not a reliable rule. What actually matters is whether the mean of the new values is above, below, or equal to the existing mean. In this case, the mean of the three new weights is approximately 60.67 kg, which is below 62 kg, so the overall average does decrease. Important note: The trainer's conclusion (direction of change) is correct here, but the exact new average cannot be found without knowing the original group size.
Answer: The trainer's conclusion that the average weight decreases is correct in direction, because the mean of the three new members' weights is \(\frac{58+60+64}{3} \approx 60.67\) kg, which is less than 62 kg. However, the exact new average depends on the original group size: it is approximately 61.69 kg if there were originally 10 members, and approximately 61.88 kg if there were originally 30 members.