Examine the statements below and justify if the statement is always true, sometimes true, or never true. Removing a value less than the median will decrease the median.
CBSE Class 8 Maths · Tales By Dots And Lines
CBSE Class 8 Maths · Tales By Dots And Lines
Imagine lining up children from shortest to tallest. The one standing exactly in the middle is the 'median.' Now remove one of the shorter children from the left side. The new middle person is either the same or taller — never shorter! Removing a small value never pulls the middle down. So saying 'removing a small number makes the median smaller' is always wrong. The median stays the same or goes up.
Answer: The statement is NEVER true. Removing a value less than the median never decreases the median; it stays the same or increases.
The median is the middle value of a data set after arranging the numbers in increasing order. If there is an odd number of values, the median is the exact middle value. If there is an even number of values, the median is the average of the two middle values. When we remove a value that is less than the median, we take away a number from the lower part of the data. Since the median sits in the middle, removing something small from the left side usually pushes the middle position toward the higher values, which tends to keep the median the same or make it larger. So it does NOT decrease. The correct answer is that the statement is never true.
For \( n \) values arranged in increasing order: if \( n \) is odd, median is the \( \left(\frac{n+1}{2}\right) \)th value; if \( n \) is even, median is the average of the \( \left(\frac{n}{2}\right) \)th and \( \left(\frac{n}{2}+1\right) \)th values.
The statement is NEVER true. Removing a value less than the median never decreases the median; it stays the same or increases.
A common mistake is thinking that removing a small number automatically lowers the middle value. In reality, removing a small (below-median) value pulls the centre of the data toward the larger numbers, so the median goes up or stays the same, never down.
The statement is NEVER true. Removing a value less than the median never decreases the median; it stays the same or increases.
One common mistake: students confuse the effect on the mean with the effect on the median. Removing a small value does lower the mean, but the median depends only on the middle position in the ordered list, not on the actual sizes of all the values.
Answer: The statement is NEVER true. Removing a value less than the median never decreases the median; it stays the same or increases.
Question: Consider the data set: 3, 7, 9, 12, 15, 18, 20. Examine the statement: 'Removing a value that is less than the median will always increase the median.' Is this statement always true, sometimes true, or never true? Justify your answer with at least two cases.
Solution: Step 1: Arrange the data in order (already done): 3, 7, 9, 12, 15, 18, 20. Step 2: Find the original median. There are 7 values, so the median is at position \[ \frac{7+1}{2} = 4 \] The 4th value is 12, so the original median is 12. Step 3 (Case A): Remove 3 (which is less than 12). New data: 7, 9, 12, 15, 18, 20. Now there are 6 values, so the median is the average of the 3rd and 4th values: \[ \text{Median} = \frac{12 + 15}{2} = \frac{27}{2} = 13.5 \] New median (13.5) is greater than the original median (12). The median increased. Step 4 (Case B): Remove 9 (which is less than 12). New data: 3, 7, 12, 15, 18, 20. Now there are 6 values, so the median is the average of the 3rd and 4th values: \[ \text{Median} = \frac{12 + 15}{2} = \frac{27}{2} = 13.5 \] New median (13.5) is greater than the original median (12). The median increased again. Step 5 (Case C): Remove 7 (which is less than 12). New data: 3, 9, 12, 15, 18, 20. Now there are 6 values, so the median is the average of the 3rd and 4th values: \[ \text{Median} = \frac{12 + 15}{2} = 13.5 \] The median again increased to 13.5. Conclusion: In this data set, removing any value less than the median caused the median to increase (not decrease). However, we can construct a different data set where removing a value less than the median keeps the median the same. For example, consider 2, 4, 6, 8, 10. Median = 6. Remove 4 (less than 6): New data: 2, 6, 8, 10. Median = \( \frac{6+8}{2} = 7 \). It increased. Now consider 1, 5, 5, 5, 9. Median = 5. Remove 1 (less than 5): New data: 5, 5, 5, 9. Median = \( \frac{5+5}{2} = 5 \). The median stayed the same! Therefore, the statement 'Removing a value less than the median will always increase the median' is SOMETIMES TRUE — the median can increase or stay the same, but it does not always increase.
Answer: Sometimes True — removing a value less than the median can increase the median or keep it the same; it does not always increase it.
Question: A teacher recorded the marks of 5 students in a test: 14, 22, 30, 38, 46. Without doing any calculation first, a student claims: 'If I remove any mark that is below the median, the median will definitely go down.' Verify this claim by testing at least two removals, and state whether the claim is always true, sometimes true, or never true.
Solution: Step 1: Arrange the marks in order (already in order): 14, 22, 30, 38, 46. Step 2: Find the original median. There are 5 values, so the median is at position \[ \frac{5+1}{2} = 3 \] The 3rd value is 30, so the original median = 30. Step 3: Identify values less than the median (30): these are 14 and 22. Step 4 (Case A): Remove 14. New data: 22, 30, 38, 46. There are now 4 values. The median is the average of the 2nd and 3rd values: \[ \text{Median} = \frac{30 + 38}{2} = \frac{68}{2} = 34 \] New median = 34, which is GREATER than 30. The median went UP, not down. Step 5 (Case B): Remove 22. New data: 14, 30, 38, 46. There are now 4 values. The median is the average of the 2nd and 3rd values: \[ \text{Median} = \frac{30 + 38}{2} = \frac{68}{2} = 34 \] New median = 34, which is again GREATER than 30. The median went UP again. Step 6: In both cases, removing a value below the median caused the median to increase, not decrease. The student's claim that the median 'will definitely go down' is incorrect for this data set. Step 7: Is the claim ever true? Consider the data: 10, 20, 30, 40, 50. Median = 30. Remove 20: New data: 10, 30, 40, 50. Median = \( \frac{30+40}{2} = 35 \). Still increases. Now try: 5, 10, 12, 12, 14. Median = 12. Remove 5: New data: 10, 12, 12, 14. Median = \( \frac{12+12}{2} = 12 \). The median stayed the same. So the median can increase or stay the same when a value below it is removed. Conclusion: The student's claim is NEVER TRUE as stated. Removing a value less than the median never decreases the median — the median either stays the same or increases.
Answer: Never True — removing a value less than the median never decreases the median; the median either stays the same or increases.
Question: Examine the statement below and decide whether it is always true, sometimes true, or never true. Give a reason and an example to support your answer. \nStatement: Removing a value that is greater than the median will increase the median.
Answer: The statement is SOMETIMES TRUE. Removing a value greater than the median does not always increase the median — in many cases, the median stays the same or even decreases. Whether the median increases, decreases, or stays the same depends on the specific data set and its size (odd or even number of values).