SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 1 Q10(iii)c

The number of times students rode their cycles in a week is shown in the dot plot below. Four students rode their cycles twice in that week. Which of the following statements are valid\(?\) Why\(?\) There are some students who cycled more than once on some days.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Tales By Dots And Lines

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a chart that shows how many stickers each friend collected in a whole week. It tells you the total, but not which day they got each sticker. A dot plot works the same way. It only shows the weekly total number of bike rides. So if someone rode 5 times in a week, we have no idea if those rides were spread across days or all on one day. We cannot say someone rode more than once on a single day just from this chart.

Answer: The statement is NOT valid. The dot plot only shows the total number of rides in a week, not how many rides happened on each day. So we cannot conclude that any student cycled more than once on some day.

📖 Reading a Dot Plot About Cycling

Detailed Explanation

A dot plot is a simple way of showing data. Along the horizontal line we have the number of times a student rode a cycle in the whole week, and each dot above a number stands for one student. So if there are 4 dots above the number 2, it means 4 students rode their cycles 2 times during the week. The key idea is to read what the numbers on the axis actually mean. Here the axis tells us the total number of rides in a week, not the number of rides on a single day. To decide whether a statement is valid, we must check whether the data can actually prove it. If the data does not tell us anything about single days, we cannot conclude something about single days.

Formula Used

Number of students for a value \( = \) number of dots above that value. Total rides in a week is read from the horizontal axis (not per day).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what the axis shows. The numbers \( 0, 1, 2, \dots, 10 \) along the bottom tell us how many times a student rode the cycle in the whole week. Each dot above a number represents one student.
  2. Step 2: Confirm the given clue. Above the number 2 there are 4 dots, which matches the statement that 4 students rode their cycles twice in the week. This shows we are reading the plot correctly.
  3. Step 3: Read the statement carefully. The statement says some students cycled more than once on some days. The word day is important. The dot plot only gives the weekly total, for example 5 rides in a week.
  4. Step 4: Check if the data supports it. A student with, say, 7 rides in a week could have ridden once on each of 7 different days, or many times on fewer days. The dot plot does not tell us how the rides are spread across the days of the week.
  5. Step 5: Draw the conclusion. Since the dot plot gives only weekly totals and no day-by-day information, we cannot be sure that any student rode more than once on a single day. So the statement cannot be proved from this data.

Final Answer

The statement is NOT valid. The dot plot only shows the total number of rides in a week, not how many rides happened on each day. So we cannot conclude that any student cycled more than once on some day.

Common Mistake

Assuming that a large weekly total (like 8 or 10 rides) must mean more than one ride on some day. This is not certain, because those rides could be spread as one ride per day over many days, and the plot never shows daily counts.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify what the horizontal axis represents. The numbers along the bottom of the dot plot — such as 0, 1, 2, up to 10 — stand for how many times a student rode a cycle during the entire week. Each dot above a number represents exactly one student. — Reason: Before drawing any conclusions from a graph, you must know what the axis is actually measuring, because the same number can mean very different things depending on the label.
  2. Step 2: Verify that we are reading the plot correctly using the given clue. There are 4 dots above the value 2, which confirms that 4 students rode their cycles a total of 2 times during the week. This matches the information provided in the question. — Reason: Cross-checking one known fact against the graph before answering is a good habit; it tells us our interpretation of the plot is correct.
  3. Step 3: Read the statement under review very carefully. The statement claims that some students cycled more than once on a single day. The key word here is day — the statement is making a claim about what happened within one particular day, not across the whole week. — Reason: Spotting the exact claim being made helps us decide what kind of data is needed to prove or disprove it.
  4. Step 4: Check whether the dot plot contains daily information. The horizontal axis records a weekly total, for example 5 rides in the full week. It gives us no information about which days those 5 rides took place. A student with 5 weekly rides could have ridden once on each of 5 different days, or could have ridden multiple times on fewer days — the dot plot cannot tell us which. — Reason: A graph can only support conclusions that are directly shown by the data it displays. Data about weekly totals cannot be used to make conclusions about individual days.
  5. Step 5: Decide whether the statement is valid or not. Because the dot plot records only the total number of rides per week and gives absolutely no breakdown by day, there is no way to determine from this graph alone whether any student cycled more than once on a particular day. The statement goes beyond what the data can show. — Reason: A statement is valid only if the available data is sufficient to prove it; if the data is silent on the matter, the statement cannot be accepted as a conclusion.

Final Answer

The statement is NOT valid. The dot plot only shows the total number of rides in a week, not how many rides happened on each day. So we cannot conclude that any student cycled more than once on some day.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students often assume that a high weekly total (for example, 6 rides in a week) automatically means the student must have cycled more than once on at least one day. This is a logical leap — it is possible, but the dot plot does not confirm it, so no such conclusion can be drawn from this graph.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Dot plot axis: total rides per week (values 0, 1, 2, ... , 10). Each dot = 1 student. No information about rides per day is recorded.
  2. Step 2: Check: 4 dots above value 2 means 4 students rode exactly 2 times in the whole week — weekly total only, not daily breakdown.
  3. Step 3: Statement claims students cycled more than once on some day. Since daily data is absent from the plot, this claim cannot be supported.

Answer: The statement is NOT valid. The dot plot only shows the total number of rides in a week, not how many rides happened on each day. So we cannot conclude that any student cycled more than once on some day.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: The number of books read by students in a month is shown in a dot plot. The dot plot shows dots at the following positions: 1 book — 3 dots, 2 books — 5 dots, 3 books — 4 dots, 4 books — 2 dots, 5 books — 1 dot. A student makes the following statements. Which statements are valid? Give reasons. Statement A: Five students read exactly 2 books in that month. Statement B: The total number of books read by all students is 45. Statement C: Some students read more than one book on certain days.

Solution: First, read the dot plot carefully to find the frequency of each value. Number of students at each value: 1 book: 3 students, 2 books: 5 students, 3 books: 4 students, 4 books: 2 students, 5 books: 1 student. Total number of students: \[3 + 5 + 4 + 2 + 1 = 15\] Checking Statement A: The dot plot shows 5 dots above the value 2. Each dot represents one student, so exactly 5 students read 2 books. Statement A is valid. Checking Statement B: Total books read is calculated as: \[(1 \times 3) + (2 \times 5) + (3 \times 4) + (4 \times 2) + (5 \times 1)\] \[= 3 + 10 + 12 + 8 + 5 = 38\] The total is 38, not 45. Statement B is NOT valid. Checking Statement C: The dot plot only tells us the total number of books read per month by each student. It gives no information about how many books were read on any particular day. We cannot determine whether a student read more than one book on a single day. Statement C is NOT valid — it cannot be concluded from the dot plot.

Answer: Statement A is valid (5 students read exactly 2 books, as shown by 5 dots). Statement B is not valid (the correct total is 38 books, not 45). Statement C is not valid (daily reading habits cannot be determined from the dot plot).

Example 2

Question: The number of hours students spent on homework in a week is recorded in a dot plot as follows: 1 hour — 2 dots, 2 hours — 3 dots, 3 hours — 6 dots, 4 hours — 4 dots, 5 hours — 3 dots, 6 hours — 2 dots. Examine the following statements and decide which are valid and which are not. Give reasons. Statement P: Six students spent exactly 3 hours on homework during the week. Statement Q: More than half the students spent 3 or more hours on homework. Statement R: Some students worked on homework for more than one hour on at least one day of the week.

Solution: First, read the dot plot to record the frequencies. 1 hour: 2 students, 2 hours: 3 students, 3 hours: 6 students, 4 hours: 4 students, 5 hours: 3 students, 6 hours: 2 students. Total students: \[2 + 3 + 6 + 4 + 3 + 2 = 20\] Checking Statement P: There are 6 dots above the value 3. Each dot represents one student. So exactly 6 students spent 3 hours on homework. Statement P is valid. Checking Statement Q: Students who spent 3 or more hours: \[6 + 4 + 3 + 2 = 15\] Half of 20 students is: \[\frac{20}{2} = 10\] Since 15 is greater than 10, more than half the students spent 3 or more hours on homework. Statement Q is valid. Checking Statement R: The dot plot shows the total hours spent in the entire week, not the distribution of hours across individual days. A student recorded as spending 3 hours total might have spent 1 hour on each of 3 different days. We cannot tell from the dot plot alone whether any student spent more than 1 hour on a single day. Statement R is NOT valid — it goes beyond what the dot plot shows.

Answer: Statement P is valid (6 dots appear at 3 hours). Statement Q is valid (15 out of 20 students spent 3 or more hours, and 15 is greater than half of 20, which is 10). Statement R is not valid (daily distribution cannot be determined from a weekly dot plot).

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: The number of books read by students during a month is shown in a dot plot. Three students read exactly 4 books that month. A classmate looks at the dot plot and says: 'Some students must have read more than one book on certain days.' Is this statement valid? Justify your answer.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what the dot plot shows: The dot plot records the total number of books each student read during the entire month. Each dot above a number on the number line represents one student who read that many books in the month.
  2. Step 2: Identify what the dot plot does NOT show: The dot plot does not tell us on which specific days the students read, or how many books they read on any particular day. It only gives the total count for the whole month.
  3. Step 3: Analyse the claim: The classmate claims that some students must have read more than one book on certain days. For example, a student who read 4 books in a month could have read exactly one book on 4 different days — so there is no necessity to read more than one book on any single day.
  4. Step 4: Conclusion: Since the dot plot only shows the monthly total and gives no information about daily reading habits, we cannot conclude anything about how many books were read on any given day. The classmate's statement is NOT valid based on the given data.

Answer: The statement is VALID in possibility but NOT provably valid from the dot plot. The dot plot only shows the total number of books read in a month, not how many were read on each day. Therefore, we cannot conclude that any student read more than one book on a particular day — a student who read 4 books could have read one book on each of 4 different days. The classmate's statement is NOT a valid conclusion from the dot plot.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Tales By Dots And Lines