Example 1
Question: The number of books read by students in a month is shown in a dot plot. The dot plot shows dots at the following positions: 1 book — 3 dots, 2 books — 5 dots, 3 books — 4 dots, 4 books — 2 dots, 5 books — 1 dot. A student makes the following statements. Which statements are valid? Give reasons. Statement A: Five students read exactly 2 books in that month. Statement B: The total number of books read by all students is 45. Statement C: Some students read more than one book on certain days.
Solution: First, read the dot plot carefully to find the frequency of each value. Number of students at each value: 1 book: 3 students, 2 books: 5 students, 3 books: 4 students, 4 books: 2 students, 5 books: 1 student. Total number of students: \[3 + 5 + 4 + 2 + 1 = 15\] Checking Statement A: The dot plot shows 5 dots above the value 2. Each dot represents one student, so exactly 5 students read 2 books. Statement A is valid. Checking Statement B: Total books read is calculated as: \[(1 \times 3) + (2 \times 5) + (3 \times 4) + (4 \times 2) + (5 \times 1)\] \[= 3 + 10 + 12 + 8 + 5 = 38\] The total is 38, not 45. Statement B is NOT valid. Checking Statement C: The dot plot only tells us the total number of books read per month by each student. It gives no information about how many books were read on any particular day. We cannot determine whether a student read more than one book on a single day. Statement C is NOT valid — it cannot be concluded from the dot plot.
Answer: Statement A is valid (5 students read exactly 2 books, as shown by 5 dots). Statement B is not valid (the correct total is 38 books, not 45). Statement C is not valid (daily reading habits cannot be determined from the dot plot).
Example 2
Question: The number of hours students spent on homework in a week is recorded in a dot plot as follows: 1 hour — 2 dots, 2 hours — 3 dots, 3 hours — 6 dots, 4 hours — 4 dots, 5 hours — 3 dots, 6 hours — 2 dots. Examine the following statements and decide which are valid and which are not. Give reasons. Statement P: Six students spent exactly 3 hours on homework during the week. Statement Q: More than half the students spent 3 or more hours on homework. Statement R: Some students worked on homework for more than one hour on at least one day of the week.
Solution: First, read the dot plot to record the frequencies. 1 hour: 2 students, 2 hours: 3 students, 3 hours: 6 students, 4 hours: 4 students, 5 hours: 3 students, 6 hours: 2 students. Total students: \[2 + 3 + 6 + 4 + 3 + 2 = 20\] Checking Statement P: There are 6 dots above the value 3. Each dot represents one student. So exactly 6 students spent 3 hours on homework. Statement P is valid. Checking Statement Q: Students who spent 3 or more hours: \[6 + 4 + 3 + 2 = 15\] Half of 20 students is: \[\frac{20}{2} = 10\] Since 15 is greater than 10, more than half the students spent 3 or more hours on homework. Statement Q is valid. Checking Statement R: The dot plot shows the total hours spent in the entire week, not the distribution of hours across individual days. A student recorded as spending 3 hours total might have spent 1 hour on each of 3 different days. We cannot tell from the dot plot alone whether any student spent more than 1 hour on a single day. Statement R is NOT valid — it goes beyond what the dot plot shows.
Answer: Statement P is valid (6 dots appear at 3 hours). Statement Q is valid (15 out of 20 students spent 3 or more hours, and 15 is greater than half of 20, which is 10). Statement R is not valid (daily distribution cannot be determined from a weekly dot plot).