Example 1
Question: A dot plot shows the number of books read by students in a month. The data recorded is: 1, 1, 2, 2, 2, 3, 3, 3, 3, 4, 4, 5. Three students read exactly 4 books. Evaluate whether the following statement is valid: 'Most students read a moderate number of books (2 to 4 books) in that month.' Justify your answer.
Solution: Step 1: Organise the data by listing the frequency of each value. Number of books = 1: frequency = 2 Number of books = 2: frequency = 3 Number of books = 3: frequency = 4 Number of books = 4: frequency = 3 Number of books = 5: frequency = 1 Step 2: Find the total number of students. Total = \( 2 + 3 + 4 + 3 + 1 = 13 \) Step 3: Count the students who read a moderate number of books, that is, between 2 and 4 (inclusive). Students reading 2 to 4 books = \( 3 + 4 + 3 = 10 \) Step 4: Find what fraction of students this represents. \[ \frac{10}{13} \approx 0.77 \] This means approximately \( 77\% \) of students read between 2 and 4 books. Step 5: Evaluate the statement. Since nearly \( 77\% \) (more than three-quarters) of the students read a moderate number of books (2 to 4), the statement is VALID. The data clearly shows that most students are clustered in the 2 to 4 range, with only 2 students reading very few (1 book) and only 1 student reading many (5 books).
Answer: The statement is VALID. 10 out of 13 students (approximately 77%) read between 2 and 4 books, which confirms that most students read a moderate number of books.
Example 2
Question: A dot plot shows the number of hours students spent on outdoor play during the weekend. The recorded data is: 0, 1, 1, 1, 2, 2, 3, 3, 3, 3, 4, 5, 5. Five students spent exactly 3 hours on outdoor play. Evaluate whether the following statement is valid: 'A large number of students spent no time or very little time (0 to 1 hour) on outdoor play.' Justify your answer.
Solution: Step 1: Organise the data by listing the frequency of each value. Hours = 0: frequency = 1 Hours = 1: frequency = 3 Hours = 2: frequency = 2 Hours = 3: frequency = 4 Hours = 4: frequency = 1 Hours = 5: frequency = 2 Note: The problem states five students spent exactly 3 hours, but the listed data gives a frequency of 4 for 3 hours. We verify using the full data list: 0, 1, 1, 1, 2, 2, 3, 3, 3, 3, 4, 5, 5. The frequency of 3 hours is indeed 4. We proceed with the data as listed. Step 2: Find the total number of students. Total = \( 1 + 3 + 2 + 4 + 1 + 2 = 13 \) Step 3: Count students who spent 0 to 1 hour (no time or very little time). Students with 0 or 1 hour = \( 1 + 3 = 4 \) Step 4: Find the fraction this represents. \[ \frac{4}{13} \approx 0.31 \] This is approximately \( 31\% \) of all students. Step 5: Evaluate the statement. Only 4 out of 13 students (about \( 31\% \)) spent 0 to 1 hour on outdoor play. This is less than one-third of the students. The remaining 9 students (about \( 69\% \)) spent 2 or more hours. Therefore, the statement is INVALID. A large number (majority) of students actually spent 2 or more hours on outdoor play, not 0 to 1 hour.
Answer: The statement is INVALID. Only 4 out of 13 students (about 31%) spent 0 to 1 hour on outdoor play. The majority (9 out of 13, about 69%) spent 2 or more hours, so it is incorrect to say a large number spent no time or very little time.