Example 1
Question: The number of books read by students in a month is shown in the dot plot below. Dot plot (number line from 0 to 5): - 0 books: 2 dots - 1 book: 5 dots - 2 books: 4 dots - 3 books: 3 dots - 4 books: 1 dot - 5 books: 0 dots Total students surveyed: 15. State whether each of the following statements is valid or invalid. Give a reason for each. (A) More than half the students read at least 2 books. (B) No student read more than 4 books. (C) The most common number of books read was 1.
Solution: First, read the frequency of each value from the dot plot. Frequency table: - 0 books: 2 students - 1 book: 5 students - 2 books: 4 students - 3 books: 3 students - 4 books: 1 student - 5 books: 0 students Total students: We verify: \[ 2 + 5 + 4 + 3 + 1 + 0 = 15 \] Now check each statement. Statement (A): More than half the students read at least 2 books. Half of 15 is \[ \frac{15}{2} = 7.5 \] Students who read at least 2 books (i.e., 2, 3, 4, or 5 books): \[ 4 + 3 + 1 + 0 = 8 \] Since 8 is greater than 7.5, more than half the students did read at least 2 books. Statement (A) is VALID. Statement (B): No student read more than 4 books. From the dot plot, the number of dots above 5 is 0. So no student read 5 books. The maximum number of books read is 4 (by 1 student). Reading more than 4 books means reading 5 or more books, and 0 students did so. Statement (B) is VALID. Statement (C): The most common number of books read was 1. The value with the highest frequency is 1 book, with 5 students. Every other value has a lower frequency (2, 4, 3, 1, 0 for values 0, 2, 3, 4, 5 respectively). So 1 book is indeed the mode. Statement (C) is VALID.
Answer: Statement (A): VALID — 8 out of 15 students read at least 2 books, and 8 > 7.5 (half of 15). Statement (B): VALID — 0 students read 5 books, so no student read more than 4. Statement (C): VALID — 1 book has the highest frequency of 5 students.
Example 2
Question: The number of hours students spent on outdoor play on a Sunday is shown in the dot plot below. Dot plot (number line from 1 to 5): - 1 hour: 3 dots - 2 hours: 6 dots - 3 hours: 4 dots - 4 hours: 2 dots - 5 hours: 1 dot Total students surveyed: 16. State whether each of the following statements is valid or invalid. Give a reason for each. (A) Every student played outdoors for at least 1 hour. (B) Most students played for exactly 3 hours. (C) Fewer than 4 students played for more than 3 hours.
Solution: First, read the frequency of each value from the dot plot. Frequency table: - 1 hour: 3 students - 2 hours: 6 students - 3 hours: 4 students - 4 hours: 2 students - 5 hours: 1 student Verify total: \[ 3 + 6 + 4 + 2 + 1 = 16 \] Now check each statement. Statement (A): Every student played outdoors for at least 1 hour. The dot plot starts at 1 hour and there are no dots at 0 hours. Since all 16 students are accounted for by values 1 through 5, every student played for at least 1 hour. Statement (A) is VALID. Statement (B): Most students played for exactly 3 hours. Students who played for exactly 3 hours: 4. The total number of students is 16. For a value to represent most students, it must account for more than half, i.e., more than \[ \frac{16}{2} = 8 \] students. Since only 4 students played for exactly 3 hours and \[ 4 < 8 \] this is not the majority. Also, the most common (mode) value is 2 hours (6 students), not 3 hours. Statement (B) is INVALID. Statement (C): Fewer than 4 students played for more than 3 hours. Students who played for more than 3 hours (i.e., 4 or 5 hours): \[ 2 + 1 = 3 \] Since \[ 3 < 4 \] fewer than 4 students did indeed play for more than 3 hours. Statement (C) is VALID.
Answer: Statement (A): VALID — the dot plot has no dots at 0 hours, so all 16 students played for at least 1 hour. Statement (B): INVALID — only 4 students played for exactly 3 hours, which is less than half of 16; the mode is 2 hours (6 students). Statement (C): VALID — only 3 students (2 + 1) played for more than 3 hours, and 3 < 4.