SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 1 Q3(i)

Sudhakar, the class teacher, asks Shreyas to measure the heights of all \(24\) students in his class and calculate the average height. Shreyas informs the teacher that the average height is \(150.2\ cm.\) Sudhakar discovers that the students were wearing uniform shoes when the measurements were taken and the shoes add \(1\ cm\) to the height. Should the teacher get all the heights measured again without the shoes to find the correct average height\(?\) Or is there a simpler way\(?\)

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Tales By Dots And Lines

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine every student wore a hat that made them look exactly 1 cm taller. The class average would also look 1 cm too tall. Remove all the hats, and the average simply drops by 1 cm. Nobody needs to be measured again! That is exactly what happened with shoes here. The measured average was \( 150.2 \) cm. Every student's shoes added \( 1 \) cm. So the real average height without shoes is just \( 150.2 - 1 = 149.2 \) cm.

Answer: The correct average height without shoes is \( 149.2\ cm \). The teacher does not need to re-measure everyone; simply subtracting \( 1\ cm \) from the average \( 150.2\ cm \) gives the right answer.

📖 Correcting an Average Without Re-measuring

Detailed Explanation

The average (mean) of a set of numbers is the total sum of all the values divided by how many values there are. Here, every single student's measured height is too big by the same amount, \( 1\ cm \), because the shoes added \( 1\ cm \) to each height. When the SAME number is added to every value in a data set, that same number is also added to the average. So the teacher does NOT need to measure everyone again. Shreyas can simply subtract \( 1\ cm \) from the average he already found. There is a simple reason for this, which we can see from how the mean is calculated.

Formula Used

\[ \text{Average} = \frac{\text{Sum of all values}}{\text{Number of values}} \]

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what was measured. Each of the \( 24 \) students was measured while wearing shoes that add \( 1\ cm \). So every recorded height is exactly \( 1\ cm \) more than the true height.
  2. Step 2: Recall the average given. The average of the measured (with-shoes) heights is \( 150.2\ cm \). This means the total of all measured heights is \[ 150.2 \times 24 = 3604.8\ cm \]
  3. Step 3: See what happens to the total when shoes are removed. Since each of the \( 24 \) heights loses \( 1\ cm \), the total decreases by \[ 24 \times 1 = 24\ cm \] So the correct total (without shoes) is \[ 3604.8 - 24 = 3580.8\ cm \]
  4. Step 4: Find the correct average. Divide the corrected total by the number of students: \[ \frac{3580.8}{24} = 149.2\ cm \]
  5. Step 5: Notice the shortcut. The corrected average \( 149.2\ cm \) is exactly \( 1\ cm \) less than the measured average \( 150.2\ cm \). So there is no need to re-measure at all: \[ 150.2 - 1 = 149.2\ cm \] Whenever the same amount is added to (or removed from) every value, the average changes by that same amount.
  6. Step 6: Answer the teacher's question. There is a simpler way. The teacher should NOT get all heights measured again; just subtract \( 1\ cm \) from the average already calculated.

Final Answer

The correct average height without shoes is \( 149.2\ cm \). The teacher does not need to re-measure everyone; simply subtracting \( 1\ cm \) from the average \( 150.2\ cm \) gives the right answer.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is thinking that since the total decreases by \( 24\ cm \), the average also decreases by \( 24\ cm \). In fact, the average decreases only by \( 1\ cm \), because that \( 24\ cm \) drop is shared equally among the \( 24 \) students.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the error in the data. Each of the \( 24 \) students was measured while wearing shoes that added exactly \( 1 \) cm to their true height. So every recorded height is \( 1 \) cm more than it should be. — Reason: Pinpointing the source of error tells us exactly how much each data value needs to be corrected.
  2. Step 2: Find the total of all measured heights using the given average. The average with shoes is \( 150.2 \) cm, so the total measured height is \[ 150.2 \times 24 = 3604.8 \text{ cm} \] — Reason: Reversing the mean formula (Sum = Mean \( \times \) Number of values) lets us work with the actual total, which is easier to adjust.
  3. Step 3: Calculate how much the total overestimates true heights. Since every one of the \( 24 \) students contributed an extra \( 1 \) cm, the total excess is \[ 24 \times 1 = 24 \text{ cm} \] — Reason: The total error equals the per-student error multiplied by the number of students.
  4. Step 4: Find the corrected total height (without shoes). Subtract the excess from the measured total: \[ 3604.8 - 24 = 3580.8 \text{ cm} \] — Reason: Removing the shoe contribution from the grand total gives us the sum of true heights.
  5. Step 5: Compute the corrected mean. Divide the corrected total by the number of students: \[ \frac{3580.8}{24} = 149.2 \text{ cm} \] — Reason: Applying the mean formula to the corrected total gives the true average height.
  6. Step 6: Spot the shortcut. Notice that \[ 150.2 - 1 = 149.2 \text{ cm} \] The corrected mean is simply the old mean minus \( 1 \) cm. — Reason: Because the same \( 1 \) cm was added to every student's measurement, the mean shifts by exactly that same \( 1 \) cm. No re-measuring is needed at all.

Final Answer

The correct average height without shoes is \( 149.2\ cm \). The teacher does not need to re-measure everyone; simply subtracting \( 1\ cm \) from the average \( 150.2\ cm \) gives the right answer.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students think they must subtract \( 24 \) cm from the average instead of \( 1 \) cm, confusing the total correction (\( 24 \) cm removed from the sum) with the correction to the mean (only \( 1 \) cm is removed from the average, because that total of \( 24 \) cm is then divided again by the \( 24 \) students).

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Given: measured average (with shoes) \ = \ \( 150.2 \ cm \), number of students \ = \ \( 24 \), extra height per student \ = \ \( 1 \ cm \)
  2. Step 2: Total measured height: \[ 150.2 \times 24 = 3604.8 \ cm \] Corrected total (shoes removed): \[ 3604.8 - (24 \times 1) = 3604.8 - 24 = 3580.8 \ cm \]
  3. Step 3: Correct average: \[ \frac{3580.8}{24} = 149.2 \ cm \] Shortcut: \( 150.2 - 1 = 149.2 \ cm \)

Answer: The correct average height without shoes is \( 149.2\ cm \). The teacher does not need to re-measure everyone; simply subtracting \( 1\ cm \) from the average \( 150.2\ cm \) gives the right answer.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: A sports coach records the weights of all 30 players in a team. The average weight is calculated to be 62.4 kg. Later, the coach realises that the weighing scale was faulty and was showing every reading 2 kg more than the actual weight. Should the coach re-weigh all 30 players, or is there a simpler way to find the correct average weight?

Solution: Let the actual weights of the 30 players be \( w_1, w_2, w_3, \ldots, w_{30} \). Because the faulty scale added 2 kg to every reading, the recorded weights were \( w_1 + 2,\; w_2 + 2,\; \ldots,\; w_{30} + 2 \). The recorded average is given as 62.4 kg, so: \[ \text{Recorded average} = \frac{(w_1 + 2) + (w_2 + 2) + \cdots + (w_{30} + 2)}{30} = 62.4 \] Expanding the numerator: \[ \frac{(w_1 + w_2 + \cdots + w_{30}) + 30 \times 2}{30} = 62.4 \] This gives: \[ \frac{w_1 + w_2 + \cdots + w_{30}}{30} + 2 = 62.4 \] Therefore, the correct average weight is: \[ \text{Correct average} = 62.4 - 2 = 60.4 \text{ kg} \] Since the same error (an extra 2 kg) was present in every reading, the coach simply needs to subtract 2 from the recorded average. There is no need to re-weigh all 30 players.

Answer: The correct average weight is 60.4 kg. The coach does not need to re-weigh all the players.

Example 2

Question: In a school quiz competition, the average score of 18 participants is found to be 47.5 marks. The teacher then realises that every participant received a bonus of 3 marks that was accidentally included in their recorded scores. Should the teacher recalculate each participant's score individually, or is there a quicker way to find the correct average score without the bonus marks?

Solution: Let the actual scores of the 18 participants be \( s_1, s_2, s_3, \ldots, s_{18} \). Since a bonus of 3 marks was added to each recorded score, the recorded scores were \( s_1 + 3,\; s_2 + 3,\; \ldots,\; s_{18} + 3 \). The recorded average is 47.5 marks: \[ \frac{(s_1 + 3) + (s_2 + 3) + \cdots + (s_{18} + 3)}{18} = 47.5 \] Expanding the numerator: \[ \frac{(s_1 + s_2 + \cdots + s_{18}) + 18 \times 3}{18} = 47.5 \] Separating the fraction: \[ \frac{s_1 + s_2 + \cdots + s_{18}}{18} + 3 = 47.5 \] Therefore, the correct average score is: \[ \text{Correct average} = 47.5 - 3 = 44.5 \text{ marks} \] Because the same bonus of 3 marks was added to every participant's score, the correct average is obtained simply by subtracting 3 from the recorded average. The teacher does not need to recalculate each score individually.

Answer: The correct average score is 44.5 marks. The teacher does not need to recalculate each participant's score.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: A physical education teacher asks Priya to record the weights of all 30 students in her class and compute the average weight. Priya reports that the average weight is \( 48.6 \) kg. Later, the teacher realises that the weighing machine used was faulty — it was showing every reading \( 2 \) kg more than the actual weight. Must the teacher collect all 30 weights again to find the correct average, or is there a quicker way? Find the correct average weight.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand the situation: Every student's recorded weight is \( 2 \) kg more than their actual weight because the machine was faulty. So if a student's actual weight is \( w \) kg, the machine showed \( w + 2 \) kg.
  2. Step 2: Express the recorded average in terms of actual weights: Let the actual weights of the 30 students be \( w_1, w_2, \ldots, w_{30} \). The machine recorded \( w_1 + 2,\ w_2 + 2,\ \ldots,\ w_{30} + 2 \). The recorded average is \[ \frac{(w_1 + 2) + (w_2 + 2) + \cdots + (w_{30} + 2)}{30} = 48.6 \]
  3. Step 3: Simplify the numerator: Expanding the numerator: \[ \frac{(w_1 + w_2 + \cdots + w_{30}) + 30 \times 2}{30} = 48.6 \] This gives \[ \frac{w_1 + w_2 + \cdots + w_{30}}{30} + 2 = 48.6 \]
  4. Step 4: Find the correct average: The correct average is \( \frac{w_1 + w_2 + \cdots + w_{30}}{30} \). From Step 3: \[ \text{Correct Average} = 48.6 - 2 = 46.6 \text{ kg} \]
  5. Step 5: Conclusion: The teacher does not need to collect all 30 weights again. Simply subtracting \( 2 \) kg from the recorded average gives the correct average weight of \( 46.6 \) kg.

Answer: The correct average weight of the students is \( 46.6 \) kg. The teacher does not need to re-record all the weights; subtracting \( 2 \) kg from the recorded average \( 48.6 \) kg directly gives the correct answer.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Tales By Dots And Lines