Examine the statements below and justify if the statement is always true, sometimes true, or never true. Including a value less than the mean will decrease the mean.
CBSE Class 8 Maths · Tales By Dots And Lines
CBSE Class 8 Maths · Tales By Dots And Lines
Think of the mean like the fair share everyone gets. Imagine 3 friends sharing 18 stickers — each gets 6. Now a new friend joins, but brings only 3 stickers instead of 6. The new total is 21 stickers among 4 friends. Each person now gets a little less than 6. Whenever someone brings less than the fair share, the fair share shrinks for everyone. So adding any number smaller than the current mean will always pull the mean down.
Answer: The statement is ALWAYS TRUE. Including any value less than the current mean always decreases the mean.
The mean (average) of a set of values is the total of all the values divided by how many values there are. When we add a new value to the data, both the total and the count change. Whether the mean goes up, down, or stays the same depends on how the new value compares with the current mean. A useful idea: if the new value is smaller than the current mean, it 'pulls' the average down; if it is larger, it pulls the average up; if it equals the mean, the average does not change. Since the statement talks about including a value that is less than the mean, this new value is always below the current average, so it must pull the mean down.
\( \text{Mean} = \dfrac{\text{Sum of all observations}}{\text{Number of observations}} \)
The statement is ALWAYS TRUE. Including any value less than the current mean always decreases the mean.
A common mistake is thinking the mean might stay the same or even rise just because we added 'one more' number. Adding a value equal to the mean keeps it unchanged, and a value greater than the mean raises it — but a value less than the mean always lowers it.
The statement is ALWAYS TRUE. Including any value less than the current mean always decreases the mean.
One common mistake: students think that adding a value below the mean might not change the mean if the value is 'close enough' to the mean — but even a value just slightly below the mean will always pull the mean down by some amount, no matter how small.
Answer: The statement is ALWAYS TRUE. Including any value less than the current mean always decreases the mean.
Question: Examine the following statement and decide whether it is always true, sometimes true, or never true: 'Adding a value that is less than the current mean to a data set will always decrease the mean.' Justify your answer with an example using the data set: 10, 14, 18, 22, 26.
Solution: Step 1: Find the current mean of the data set 10, 14, 18, 22, 26. Sum of values: \[10 + 14 + 18 + 22 + 26 = 90\] Number of values = 5. Current mean: \[\text{Mean} = \frac{90}{5} = 18\] Step 2: Choose a value less than the current mean. Let us add 6 (since \( 6 < 18 \)). New sum: \[90 + 6 = 96\] New number of values = 6. New mean: \[\text{New Mean} = \frac{96}{6} = 16\] Step 3: Compare the means. Original mean = 18, New mean = 16. Since \( 16 < 18 \), the mean decreased. Step 4: Generalise. Suppose the current mean is \( \bar{x} \), the sum is \( S \), and there are \( n \) values, so \( \bar{x} = \frac{S}{n} \). If we add a new value \( v \) where \( v < \bar{x} \), the new mean is \[\text{New Mean} = \frac{S + v}{n + 1}\] We want to check if this is less than \( \bar{x} \). Since \( v < \bar{x} \), we have \( S + v < S + \bar{x} = n\bar{x} + \bar{x} = (n+1)\bar{x} \). Therefore, \[\frac{S + v}{n + 1} < \frac{(n+1)\bar{x}}{n+1} = \bar{x}\] This means the new mean is always less than the original mean whenever the added value is less than the current mean. The statement is ALWAYS TRUE.
Answer: Always True. Adding a value less than the current mean always decreases the mean. (Original mean = 18; after adding 6, new mean = 16.)
Question: A student scored the following marks in five tests: 55, 65, 70, 80, 90. Examine the statement: 'If the student scores less than her current average in the next test, her overall average will go down.' Is this statement always true, sometimes true, or never true? Verify with a specific score.
Solution: Step 1: Find the current mean of 55, 65, 70, 80, 90. Sum: \[55 + 65 + 70 + 80 + 90 = 360\] Number of tests = 5. Current mean: \[\text{Mean} = \frac{360}{5} = 72\] Step 2: The student's next score must be less than 72 for the statement to apply. Let the next score be 48 (since \( 48 < 72 \)). New sum: \[360 + 48 = 408\] New number of tests = 6. New mean: \[\text{New Mean} = \frac{408}{6} = 68\] Step 3: Compare. Original mean = 72, New mean = 68. Since \( 68 < 72 \), the average decreased. Step 4: Let us try another score less than 72 to confirm — say 60 (since \( 60 < 72 \)). New sum: \[360 + 60 = 420\] New mean: \[\frac{420}{6} = 70\] Again, \( 70 < 72 \), so the mean decreased. Step 5: Logical justification. Let the current mean be \( \bar{x} = 72 \) and the new score \( v < 72 \). The difference between the new score and the mean is negative: \( v - \bar{x} < 0 \). The drop in the mean equals \[\text{Change in mean} = \frac{v - \bar{x}}{n + 1}\] Since \( v - \bar{x} < 0 \) and \( n + 1 > 0 \), the change is always negative, meaning the mean always goes down. The statement is ALWAYS TRUE.
Answer: Always True. Scoring below the current average always lowers the overall average. (Current mean = 72; scoring 48 gives new mean = 68; scoring 60 gives new mean = 70 — both lower than 72.)
Question: Examine the statement below and determine whether it is always true, sometimes true, or never true. Give a reason and verify with an example. Statement: Including a value greater than the current mean will increase the mean.
Answer: The statement is SOMETIMES TRUE. Wait — re-examining: since the algebra shows the new mean exceeds the old mean whenever the added value exceeds the old mean, with no exceptions, the statement is actually ALWAYS TRUE. Including any value greater than the current mean always increases the mean.