SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 3 Q6(iii)b

There were \(2\) new admissions to Sudhakar’s class just a couple of days after the class average height was found to be \(150.2\ cm.\) Which of the following statements about the new class average height are correct\(?\) Why\(?\) The median will increase.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Tales By Dots And Lines

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine your class lines up by height, shortest to tallest. The middle person is the median. Now two new students join. We only know the old average height was 150.2 cm. But we do NOT know how tall the new students are. They could be very short or very tall. Depending on where they stand in the line, the middle person could change, stay the same, or shift. So we simply cannot say the median will definitely go up.

Answer: The statement is NOT necessarily correct. Since the heights of the 2 new students are unknown, the median may increase, decrease, or remain the same. It will increase only if the new heights raise the middle value, which we cannot be sure of.

📖 Effect of 2 New Admissions on the Class Median Height

Detailed Explanation

The mean (average) is found by adding all the heights and dividing by the number of students. The median is the middle value when all heights are arranged in order (if there is an even number of values, the median is the average of the two middle values). The key idea here is that the average being \( 150.2\ cm \) tells us nothing about what the two NEW students' heights are. New students could be taller than average, shorter than average, or right around the middle. The median depends only on the middle position after arranging the data, so whether it goes up, down, or stays the same depends entirely on the actual heights of the 2 new students, which we do not know.

Formula Used

Mean \( = \dfrac{\text{sum of all heights}}{\text{number of students}} \). Median = middle value of the ordered data (for an even count, the average of the two middle values).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what is given. We only know the old class average height was \( 150.2\ cm \). We are NOT told the heights of the 2 new students, and we are not told how many students were in the class before.
  2. Step 2: Recall what the median means. Arrange all heights from smallest to largest; the median is the middle value. Adding 2 new values can shift this middle position up, down, or leave it unchanged, depending on where the new values fall in the ordered list.
  3. Step 3: Test with a taller pair. Suppose the new students are much taller than the middle of the class. Then most new values sit at the top end, and the middle of the ordered list may move to a higher value, so the median could increase.
  4. Step 4: Test with a shorter pair. Now suppose the new students are much shorter than the middle of the class. The extra low values push the middle position toward smaller heights, so the median could actually decrease instead.
  5. Step 5: Draw the conclusion. Because the two new heights are unknown, the median might increase, decrease, or stay the same. So the statement 'the median will increase' cannot be said to be always correct.

Final Answer

The statement is NOT necessarily correct. Since the heights of the 2 new students are unknown, the median may increase, decrease, or remain the same. It will increase only if the new heights raise the middle value, which we cannot be sure of.

Common Mistake

Assuming that adding new students, or knowing the average, automatically tells us how the median changes. The average alone gives no information about the new students' actual heights, so we cannot conclude the median must increase.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify exactly what information is given. We are told the old class average (mean) height was \( 150.2 \text{ cm} \), and that 2 new students joined. — Reason: Before analysing any claim, it is essential to separate what we actually know from what we are merely assuming.
  2. Step 2: Recognise what is NOT given. The heights of the 2 new students are not mentioned anywhere, and neither is the total number of students in the original class. — Reason: The claim is about the median increasing, so we need to check whether we have enough information to determine that; missing data is a red flag.
  3. Step 3: Recall how the median works. Arrange all heights from smallest to largest; the median is the value sitting exactly in the middle. When 2 new values are added, the middle position shifts, and where those new values land in the ordered list determines whether the median goes up, down, or stays the same. — Reason: Understanding the definition of median clarifies why the new students' actual heights matter so much.
  4. Step 4: Test Case 1 — new students are very tall. Suppose the original ordered heights (in cm) are \( 140, 145, 148, 152, 155 \) (median \( = 148 \)). If the 2 new students are \( 160 \) cm and \( 165 \) cm, the new ordered list is \( 140, 145, 148, 152, 155, 160, 165 \), giving median \( = 152 \). The median increased. — Reason: A concrete example shows one possible outcome.
  5. Step 5: Test Case 2 — new students are very short. Using the same original list \( 140, 145, 148, 152, 155 \) (median \( = 148 \)), if the 2 new students are \( 130 \) cm and \( 135 \) cm, the new ordered list is \( 130, 135, 140, 145, 148, 152, 155 \), giving median \( = 145 \). The median decreased. — Reason: A second example with different new heights produces the opposite outcome, showing the result is not fixed.
  6. Step 6: Connect this back to the mean. The mean being \( 150.2 \text{ cm} \) tells us the sum of heights divided by the count equals \( 150.2 \). This is a single arithmetic fact about totals, not about the position of values in an ordered list. Knowing the mean gives zero information about what the 2 new heights are individually. — Reason: Mean and median measure different things; confusing them is the core error the question tests.
  7. Step 7: Draw the conclusion. Because the heights of the 2 new students are completely unknown, the median after they join could increase, decrease, or remain unchanged. The statement that the median will definitely increase cannot be confirmed from the given data alone. — Reason: A mathematical claim must hold in every possible case; since we found cases where the median does not increase, the statement is not necessarily correct.

Final Answer

The statement is NOT necessarily correct. Since the heights of the 2 new students are unknown, the median may increase, decrease, or remain the same. It will increase only if the new heights raise the middle value, which we cannot be sure of.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students assume that because the mean is high (150.2 cm), the new students must also be tall, and therefore the median must rise — but the mean tells us nothing about the individual heights of the new students or where they fall in the ordered list.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Given: Old class mean height = \( 150.2 \text{ cm} \); heights of 2 new students are unknown.
  2. Step 2: Median = middle value of ordered data; adding 2 unknown values may shift the middle up, down, or leave it unchanged.
  3. Step 3: Mean = \( 150.2 \text{ cm} \) gives no information about the new students' individual heights, so the effect on the median cannot be determined.

Answer: The statement is NOT necessarily correct. Since the heights of the 2 new students are unknown, the median may increase, decrease, or remain the same. It will increase only if the new heights raise the middle value, which we cannot be sure of.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: The average score of 30 students in a class test was 72 marks. After the results were announced, 3 more students (who had missed the test) appeared for a re-test and their scores were 85, 90, and 95 marks. A classmate claims: 'The new class average will definitely be more than 72.' Is this claim correct? Justify your answer. Also state whether the median will necessarily increase.

Solution: Step 1: Find the original total sum of scores. Original number of students = 30, Original mean = 72. \[\text{Original total sum} = 30 \times 72 = 2160\] Step 2: Find the sum of the 3 new students' scores. \[\text{New scores sum} = 85 + 90 + 95 = 270\] Step 3: Find the new total sum and new number of students. \[\text{New total sum} = 2160 + 270 = 2430\] New number of students = \(30 + 3 = 33\). Step 4: Calculate the new mean. \[\text{New mean} = \frac{2430}{33} = 73.636...\] Since \(73.636... > 72\), the new mean is greater than the original mean. Why? Because each of the three new scores (85, 90, 95) is greater than the original mean of 72. Adding values above the current mean always pulls the mean upward. So the claim is CORRECT. Step 5: Comment on the median. The median depends on the position of the middle value after arranging all scores in order. With 33 students, the median is the 17th value. With 30 students, the median was the average of the 15th and 16th values. The three new scores (85, 90, 95) are all very high — they would be placed near or at the top of the ordered list. This means the lower-ranked students' positions shift, and the 17th value (new median) may be very close to or the same as the old median. The median does NOT necessarily increase — it depends on how the existing 30 scores are distributed. The claim about the median increasing is NOT guaranteed.

Answer: The claim about the new mean being more than 72 is CORRECT (new mean is approximately 73.6). The median will NOT necessarily increase.

Example 2

Question: The average mass of 25 athletes in a sports club was 68 kg. After two new athletes joined the club, the coach noted their masses as 60 kg and 62 kg. A reporter wrote: 'The new average mass of the club's athletes will be less than 68 kg.' Is the reporter correct? Also, will the median mass necessarily decrease? Justify both answers.

Solution: Step 1: Find the original total mass of all 25 athletes. Original number of athletes = 25, Original mean = 68 kg. \[\text{Original total mass} = 25 \times 68 = 1700 \text{ kg}\] Step 2: Find the sum of the two new athletes' masses. \[\text{New athletes' total mass} = 60 + 62 = 122 \text{ kg}\] Step 3: Find the new total mass and new number of athletes. \[\text{New total mass} = 1700 + 122 = 1822 \text{ kg}\] New number of athletes = \(25 + 2 = 27\). Step 4: Calculate the new mean. \[\text{New mean} = \frac{1822}{27} = 67.48... \text{ kg}\] Since \(67.48... < 68\), the new mean is less than the original mean. The reporter is CORRECT. Why? Both new athletes (60 kg and 62 kg) have masses below the original mean of 68 kg. Adding values below the current mean always pulls the mean downward. Step 5: Comment on the median. With 25 athletes, the median was the 13th value in the ordered list. With 27 athletes, the median is the 14th value. The two new athletes (60 kg and 62 kg) are below the original mean. Depending on where exactly 60 kg and 62 kg fall in the ordered list of 25 values, the 14th value may be the same as or close to the old 13th value. The median does NOT necessarily decrease — it could remain the same or even shift slightly, depending on the actual distribution of the 25 original masses. The claim about the median necessarily decreasing is NOT guaranteed.

Answer: The reporter is CORRECT about the mean (new mean is approximately 67.48 kg, which is less than 68 kg). However, the median will NOT necessarily decrease.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: After a science test, the average (mean) score of 30 students in Priya's class was found to be 72 marks. Three students who were absent gave their test the next day and their scores were added to the class record. A classmate claimed: 'The mean score of the class will definitely increase now.' Is this statement correct? Justify your answer with examples.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what information is given: The original class has 30 students with a mean score of 72. So the total marks scored by all 30 students is: Total = 30 \times 72 = 2160 marks. Three new students' scores are being added, but their actual scores are NOT given.
  2. Step 2: Write the formula for the new mean: After adding 3 new students, the new mean is \[ \text{New Mean} = \frac{2160 + (s_1 + s_2 + s_3)}{33} \] where \( s_1, s_2, s_3 \) are the scores of the three absent students.
  3. Step 3: Case 1 — New scores are above 72: Suppose the three students scored 80, 85, and 90. Their total is \( 80 + 85 + 90 = 255 \). New mean \[ = \frac{2160 + 255}{33} = \frac{2415}{33} \approx 73.2 \] This is greater than 72, so the mean increases in this case.
  4. Step 4: Case 2 — New scores equal 72: Suppose each of the three students also scored exactly 72. Their total is \( 72 \times 3 = 216 \). New mean \[ = \frac{2160 + 216}{33} = \frac{2376}{33} = 72 \] The mean stays the same in this case.
  5. Step 5: Case 3 — New scores are below 72: Suppose the three students scored 50, 60, and 55. Their total is \( 50 + 60 + 55 = 165 \). New mean \[ = \frac{2160 + 165}{33} = \frac{2325}{33} \approx 70.5 \] This is less than 72, so the mean decreases in this case.
  6. Step 6: Conclusion: Since we do not know the actual scores of the three absent students, the new mean could be greater than, equal to, or less than 72. The classmate's claim that the mean will definitely increase is NOT necessarily correct.

Answer: The statement is NOT necessarily correct. The new mean will increase only if the three absent students scored above 72, stay the same if they scored exactly 72, and decrease if they scored below 72. Since their actual scores are unknown, we cannot conclude that the mean will definitely increase.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Tales By Dots And Lines