SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 3 Q6(i)b

There were \(2\) new admissions to Sudhakar’s class just a couple of days after the class average height was found to be \(150.2\ cm.\) Which of the following statements are correct\(?\) Why\(?\) The average height of the class will remain the same.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Tales By Dots And Lines

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine you and your friends each weigh some amount, and the average weight is found by sharing the total equally. Now two new friends join your group. Unless the new friends weigh exactly the same as the current average, the shared amount will shift up or down. The same idea applies to heights in a class. Adding two new students changes both the total height and the count of students. So the average almost certainly becomes a different number.

Answer: The statement is not correct in general. The average will remain \( 150.2\ cm \) only if both new students are exactly \( 150.2\ cm \) tall. Since their heights are unknown, the average will most likely change.

📖 Effect of New Admissions on Class Average Height

Detailed Explanation

The average (mean) of a set of values is found by adding all the values and dividing by the number of values. Here the average height is \( 150.2\ cm \). When 2 new students join the class, both the total height (the sum of all heights) and the number of students change. The average stays the same ONLY if the total height increases in exactly the right proportion — that is, only if each new student is exactly \( 150.2\ cm \) tall, so the two new students together add exactly what is needed to keep the mean unchanged. In real life the new students can be taller or shorter, so the average will almost certainly change. Therefore the statement 'the average height will remain the same' is not generally correct.

Formula Used

\[ \text{Average} = \frac{\text{Sum of all heights}}{\text{Number of students}} \]

Solution

  1. Step 1: Recall the meaning of average. If there are \( n \) students with total height \( S \), then the average is \( \frac{S}{n} = 150.2\ cm \). This means \( S = 150.2 \times n \).
  2. Step 2: Now 2 new students join. The number of students becomes \( n + 2 \), and their two heights, say \( a \) and \( b \), get added to the total. The new total height is \( S + a + b \).
  3. Step 3: The new average is \[ \text{New average} = \frac{S + a + b}{n + 2}. \] This is generally not equal to the old average \( 150.2\ cm \), because both the numerator and denominator have changed by different amounts.
  4. Step 4: The average stays the same only in a special case. It remains \( 150.2\ cm \) exactly when each new student's height equals the old average, that is when \( a = 150.2 \) and \( b = 150.2 \). In that case \( a + b = 2 \times 150.2 = 300.4\ cm \), which is exactly \( 150.2 \) per extra student, so the mean does not move.
  5. Step 5: Since we are not told that both new students are exactly \( 150.2\ cm \) tall, we cannot assume the average is unchanged. If either new student is taller than \( 150.2\ cm \), the average rises; if shorter, it falls.

Final Answer

The statement is not correct in general. The average will remain \( 150.2\ cm \) only if both new students are exactly \( 150.2\ cm \) tall. Since their heights are unknown, the average will most likely change.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is thinking that adding more students never changes the average. In fact the average stays the same only when the new values equal the existing average; otherwise it goes up or down.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Write down what the current average tells us. Let there be \( n \) students with a total height of \( S \) cm. We are given that the mean is \( 150.2 \) cm, so \[ \frac{S}{n} = 150.2 \] which means \( S = 150.2 \times n \). — Reason: Expressing the sum in terms of \( n \) makes it easier to see how the mean changes when new students join.
  2. Step 2: Introduce the two new students. Let their individual heights be \( a \) cm and \( b \) cm respectively. After they join, the new number of students is \( n + 2 \) and the new total height becomes \( S + a + b \). — Reason: Both the count and the sum must be updated before we can compute the new mean.
  3. Step 3: Write the expression for the new mean. \[ \text{New mean} = \frac{S + a + b}{n + 2} \] — Reason: This is simply the definition of the mean applied to the updated data set.
  4. Step 4: Substitute \( S = 150.2 \times n \) into the new mean expression. \[ \text{New mean} = \frac{150.2n + a + b}{n + 2} \] — Reason: Replacing \( S \) lets us see exactly how the heights \( a \) and \( b \) of the new students affect the result.
  5. Step 5: Find the special condition under which the new mean equals \( 150.2 \) cm. Set \[ \frac{150.2n + a + b}{n + 2} = 150.2 \] Multiply both sides by \( n + 2 \): \[ 150.2n + a + b = 150.2(n + 2) \] Expand the right side: \[ 150.2n + a + b = 150.2n + 300.4 \] Subtract \( 150.2n \) from both sides: \[ a + b = 300.4 \] So \( a + b = 300.4 \), meaning each new student must be exactly \( 150.2 \) cm tall on average. — Reason: This algebra reveals that the mean stays unchanged only in one very specific situation, not in general.
  6. Step 6: Interpret the result. Unless both new students happen to be exactly \( 150.2 \) cm tall, the value of \( a + b \) will not equal \( 300.4 \), and therefore the new mean will differ from \( 150.2 \) cm. Since we have no information about their heights, we cannot assume this special condition holds. — Reason: A conclusion must always be based on the actual data; assuming the average stays the same without checking is a logical error.

Final Answer

The statement is not correct in general. The average will remain \( 150.2\ cm \) only if both new students are exactly \( 150.2\ cm \) tall. Since their heights are unknown, the average will most likely change.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students assume that adding more students to a group never changes the mean. In reality, only new values that are exactly equal to the current mean leave the mean unchanged; any other values will shift it up or down.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Let \\ n \\ students have total height \\ S, \\ so \\ \( \frac{S}{n} = 150.2 \) cm, giving \( S = 150.2 \times n \).
  2. Step 2: Two new students with heights \( a \) and \( b \) join; new average \( = \frac{S + a + b}{n + 2} \), which equals \( 150.2 \) cm only when \( a = b = 150.2 \) cm.
  3. Step 3: Since \( a \) and \( b \) are unknown and generally \( \ne 150.2 \) cm, the new average \( \ne 150.2 \) cm.

Answer: The statement is not correct in general. The average will remain \( 150.2\ cm \) only if both new students are exactly \( 150.2\ cm \) tall. Since their heights are unknown, the average will most likely change.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: The average marks of 30 students in a class test was found to be 72. After the test papers were rechecked, 3 more students submitted their papers and were included. Determine which of the following statements can be said to be definitely correct, and explain why. (i) The new class average will be 72. (ii) The new class average will be more than 72. (iii) The new class average will be less than 72. (iv) The new class average cannot be determined without knowing the 3 students' marks.

Solution: Let the original number of students be \( n = 30 \) and the original average be \( \bar{x} = 72 \). The original total sum of marks is: \[ \text{Sum} = 30 \times 72 = 2160 \] Now, 3 new students are added. Let their marks be \( m_1, m_2, m_3 \) respectively. These values are not given. The new average will be: \[ \text{New Average} = \frac{2160 + m_1 + m_2 + m_3}{33} \] Case 1: If \( m_1 + m_2 + m_3 = 3 \times 72 = 216 \) (i.e., each student scores exactly 72), then: \[ \text{New Average} = \frac{2160 + 216}{33} = \frac{2376}{33} = 72 \] The average stays the same. Case 2: If each new mark is greater than 72, the sum \( m_1 + m_2 + m_3 > 216 \), so the new average exceeds 72. Case 3: If each new mark is less than 72, the sum \( m_1 + m_2 + m_3 < 216 \), so the new average falls below 72. Since the actual marks of the 3 students are not known, we cannot fix the new average. Statements (i), (ii), and (iii) are each only conditionally true depending on the unknown marks. Only statement (iv) is definitely correct: the new class average cannot be determined without knowing the marks of the 3 newly included students.

Answer: Only statement (iv) is definitely correct. The new average depends on the actual marks of the 3 added students and cannot be determined without that information.

Example 2

Question: The average monthly expenditure of a family over 10 months was recorded as Rs. 18,500. Two more months' data were later added to the record. A friend made the following claims: (A) The yearly average expenditure will definitely remain Rs. 18,500. (B) The yearly average expenditure will definitely increase. (C) The yearly average expenditure could be Rs. 18,500, more than Rs. 18,500, or less than Rs. 18,500 — depending on the expenditure in those 2 months. Which claim is correct? Justify with calculations.

Solution: The average expenditure for the first 10 months is \( \bar{x} = 18500 \). Total expenditure over 10 months: \[ \text{Total}_{10} = 10 \times 18500 = 185000 \text{ rupees} \] Let the expenditures in the 2 additional months be \( e_1 \) and \( e_2 \) (unknown). The new average over 12 months is: \[ \text{New Average} = \frac{185000 + e_1 + e_2}{12} \] For the average to remain Rs. 18,500, we need: \[ 185000 + e_1 + e_2 = 12 \times 18500 = 222000 \] So \( e_1 + e_2 = 37000 \), meaning each month's expenditure averages exactly Rs. 18,500. This is possible but not guaranteed. If \( e_1 + e_2 > 37000 \), for example \( e_1 = 20000, e_2 = 20000 \): \[ \text{New Average} = \frac{185000 + 40000}{12} = \frac{225000}{12} = 18750 \] The average increases. If \( e_1 + e_2 < 37000 \), for example \( e_1 = 15000, e_2 = 17000 \): \[ \text{New Average} = \frac{185000 + 32000}{12} = \frac{217000}{12} \approx 18083 \] The average decreases. Since \( e_1 \) and \( e_2 \) are unknown, none of claims (A) or (B) can be said to be definitely true. Claim (C) is correct: the new average could be equal to, greater than, or less than Rs. 18,500 depending on the expenditure in those 2 months.

Answer: Claim (C) is correct. Without knowing the expenditure for the 2 additional months, we cannot determine whether the average will stay the same, increase, or decrease.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: The average score of 30 students in a class test was found to be 72.5 marks. Three more students took the test later and their scores were added to the data. A student claims: 'Adding more students will not change the class average.' Is this statement always correct? Justify your answer with an example where the average changes and one where it stays the same.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what the current average means: The average score of 30 students is 72.5 marks. This means the total marks of all 30 students is: Total = \( 30 \times 72.5 = 2175 \) marks.
  2. Step 2: Case where the average STAYS the same: If each of the 3 new students also scores exactly 72.5 marks, the new total becomes \( 2175 + 3 \times 72.5 = 2175 + 217.5 = 2392.5 \) marks, for 33 students. New average = \( \frac{2392.5}{33} = 72.5 \) marks. So the average remains unchanged only in this special case.
  3. Step 3: Case where the average CHANGES: Suppose the 3 new students score 80, 85, and 90 marks. Their total = \( 80 + 85 + 90 = 255 \) marks. New total = \( 2175 + 255 = 2430 \) marks, for 33 students. New average = \( \frac{2430}{33} \approx 73.6 \) marks, which is greater than 72.5.
  4. Step 4: Another case where the average changes (decreases): Suppose the 3 new students score 50, 55, and 60 marks. Their total = \( 50 + 55 + 60 = 165 \) marks. New total = \( 2175 + 165 = 2340 \) marks, for 33 students. New average = \( \frac{2340}{33} \approx 70.9 \) marks, which is less than 72.5.
  5. Step 5: Conclusion: The student's claim is NOT always correct. The average changes when the new scores differ from 72.5. The average stays at 72.5 only if every new student scores exactly 72.5 marks. Since the new scores are generally unknown and can be higher or lower, the average will most likely change.

Answer: The statement is NOT always correct. The class average will remain 72.5 marks only if each of the 3 new students scores exactly 72.5 marks. If any new score is higher than 72.5, the average rises; if any new score is lower, the average falls. Since the new scores are unknown, the average will most likely change.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Tales By Dots And Lines