Example 1
Question: The average marks of 30 students in a class test was found to be 72. After the test papers were rechecked, 3 more students submitted their papers and were included. Determine which of the following statements can be said to be definitely correct, and explain why. (i) The new class average will be 72. (ii) The new class average will be more than 72. (iii) The new class average will be less than 72. (iv) The new class average cannot be determined without knowing the 3 students' marks.
Solution: Let the original number of students be \( n = 30 \) and the original average be \( \bar{x} = 72 \). The original total sum of marks is: \[ \text{Sum} = 30 \times 72 = 2160 \] Now, 3 new students are added. Let their marks be \( m_1, m_2, m_3 \) respectively. These values are not given. The new average will be: \[ \text{New Average} = \frac{2160 + m_1 + m_2 + m_3}{33} \] Case 1: If \( m_1 + m_2 + m_3 = 3 \times 72 = 216 \) (i.e., each student scores exactly 72), then: \[ \text{New Average} = \frac{2160 + 216}{33} = \frac{2376}{33} = 72 \] The average stays the same. Case 2: If each new mark is greater than 72, the sum \( m_1 + m_2 + m_3 > 216 \), so the new average exceeds 72. Case 3: If each new mark is less than 72, the sum \( m_1 + m_2 + m_3 < 216 \), so the new average falls below 72. Since the actual marks of the 3 students are not known, we cannot fix the new average. Statements (i), (ii), and (iii) are each only conditionally true depending on the unknown marks. Only statement (iv) is definitely correct: the new class average cannot be determined without knowing the marks of the 3 newly included students.
Answer: Only statement (iv) is definitely correct. The new average depends on the actual marks of the 3 added students and cannot be determined without that information.
Example 2
Question: The average monthly expenditure of a family over 10 months was recorded as Rs. 18,500. Two more months' data were later added to the record. A friend made the following claims: (A) The yearly average expenditure will definitely remain Rs. 18,500. (B) The yearly average expenditure will definitely increase. (C) The yearly average expenditure could be Rs. 18,500, more than Rs. 18,500, or less than Rs. 18,500 — depending on the expenditure in those 2 months. Which claim is correct? Justify with calculations.
Solution: The average expenditure for the first 10 months is \( \bar{x} = 18500 \). Total expenditure over 10 months: \[ \text{Total}_{10} = 10 \times 18500 = 185000 \text{ rupees} \] Let the expenditures in the 2 additional months be \( e_1 \) and \( e_2 \) (unknown). The new average over 12 months is: \[ \text{New Average} = \frac{185000 + e_1 + e_2}{12} \] For the average to remain Rs. 18,500, we need: \[ 185000 + e_1 + e_2 = 12 \times 18500 = 222000 \] So \( e_1 + e_2 = 37000 \), meaning each month's expenditure averages exactly Rs. 18,500. This is possible but not guaranteed. If \( e_1 + e_2 > 37000 \), for example \( e_1 = 20000, e_2 = 20000 \): \[ \text{New Average} = \frac{185000 + 40000}{12} = \frac{225000}{12} = 18750 \] The average increases. If \( e_1 + e_2 < 37000 \), for example \( e_1 = 15000, e_2 = 17000 \): \[ \text{New Average} = \frac{185000 + 32000}{12} = \frac{217000}{12} \approx 18083 \] The average decreases. Since \( e_1 \) and \( e_2 \) are unknown, none of claims (A) or (B) can be said to be definitely true. Claim (C) is correct: the new average could be equal to, greater than, or less than Rs. 18,500 depending on the expenditure in those 2 months.
Answer: Claim (C) is correct. Without knowing the expenditure for the 2 additional months, we cannot determine whether the average will stay the same, increase, or decrease.