SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 3 Q6(iii)a

There were \(2\) new admissions to Sudhakar’s class just a couple of days after the class average height was found to be \(150.2\ cm.\) Which of the following statements about the new class average height are correct\(?\) Why\(?\) The median will remain the same.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Tales By Dots And Lines

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine lining up students by height from shortest to tallest. The person standing exactly in the middle is called the median. Now picture two new students joining the line. Where they stand depends on how tall they are. If they squeeze into the middle, the middle person changes! We do not know how tall the new students are, so we cannot say the middle person stays the same. The median might stay the same, or it might change — we simply cannot be sure without knowing the new heights.

Answer: The statement 'the median will remain the same' is NOT necessarily correct. Because we do not know the heights of the 2 new students, adding them can shift the middle value of the ordered data. The median stays the same only if the new heights happen to keep the same middle value; otherwise it changes.

📖 Effect of New Admissions on the Median Height

Detailed Explanation

In statistics we describe a group of numbers using measures of central tendency. Two important ones are the mean (average) and the median (middle value). The mean is found by adding all the values and dividing by how many values there are. The median is the middle value when the data is arranged in order. The given information tells us that the class average (mean) height is \( 150.2\ cm \). When 2 new students are admitted, both the total height and the number of students change, so the mean can change depending on how tall the new students are. The median is different: it depends on the position of the middle value(s), not on the actual heights of every student. Whether the median stays the same depends entirely on the heights of the two new students, which we are NOT told. So we cannot be sure the median remains unchanged.

Formula Used

\( \text{Mean} = \dfrac{\text{Sum of all observations}}{\text{Number of observations}} \) and Median = the middle value when data is arranged in increasing order.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what the statement claims. The statement says the median will remain the same after 2 new students are admitted. We must check if this is always true.
  2. Step 2: Recall what the median is. The median is the middle value of the data after arranging all heights in increasing order. When two new values are added, the data set changes and the middle position can also change.
  3. Step 3: Notice what information is missing. We only know the old mean is \( 150.2\ cm \). We are NOT told the heights of the 2 new students. The median depends on those actual heights and where they fall in the ordered list.
  4. Step 4: Test with a simple example. Suppose the old heights are 148, 150, 152 (median is 150). If the 2 new students are 149 and 151, the ordered data is 148, 149, 150, 151, 152 and the median is still 150. But if the 2 new students are 130 and 132, the ordered data is 130, 132, 148, 150, 152 and the median becomes 148. So the median changed.
  5. Step 5: Draw the conclusion. Since we can make the median stay the same OR change depending on the new heights, we cannot say for certain that the median remains the same. The statement is therefore not necessarily correct.

Final Answer

The statement 'the median will remain the same' is NOT necessarily correct. Because we do not know the heights of the 2 new students, adding them can shift the middle value of the ordered data. The median stays the same only if the new heights happen to keep the same middle value; otherwise it changes.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is assuming that the median never changes just because it is the 'middle' value. In fact, adding new observations changes both the size of the data set and the position of the middle, so the median can very well change depending on the new values.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify what the statement is claiming. The statement says: after 2 new students join the class, the median height will remain the same. We need to decide whether this claim must always be true. — Reason: Before accepting or rejecting a statistical statement, we must carefully understand exactly what it is asserting.
  2. Step 2: Recall the meaning of median. The median is found by arranging all heights in increasing order and picking the middle value. If the number of data values is odd, the median is the single middle term; if even, it is the average of the two middle terms. — Reason: Knowing the definition tells us what factors can actually change the median.
  3. Step 3: Think about what changes when 2 new students are added. Suppose the class originally had \( n \) students. After admission, there are \( n + 2 \) students. The ordered list of heights now includes 2 extra values, and the position of the middle term shifts from roughly \( \frac{n+1}{2} \) to roughly \( \frac{n+3}{2} \). — Reason: Adding data points changes both the total count and the index of the middle value, so the median can change.
  4. Step 4: Check what information we actually have. We are told only that the mean height of the current class is \( 150.2 \) cm. We are NOT told the individual heights of the existing students, nor the heights of the 2 new students. — Reason: The median depends on the specific values and their order, not on the mean, so knowing only the mean is insufficient to determine the median's fate.
  5. Step 5: Consider two illustrative scenarios. Scenario A: the 2 new students have heights very close to the current median — in this case the median might stay the same. Scenario B: one or both new students have heights far above or below the current median — in this case the ordered list shifts and the median changes. — Reason: Showing that both outcomes are possible proves the statement is NOT necessarily true.
  6. Step 6: Draw the conclusion. Since we do not know the heights of the 2 new students, we cannot guarantee the median remains unchanged. It may stay the same, or it may change — we simply do not have enough information to be sure. Therefore, the original statement is not necessarily correct. — Reason: A statement in statistics must hold under all possible conditions; since a counter-example exists, the statement fails.

Final Answer

The statement 'the median will remain the same' is NOT necessarily correct. Because we do not know the heights of the 2 new students, adding them can shift the middle value of the ordered data. The median stays the same only if the new heights happen to keep the same middle value; otherwise it changes.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students confuse mean and median, assuming that because the mean is given (150.2 cm), the median is also fixed — but the median depends on the position of the middle value in ordered data, not on the average, so knowing the mean tells us nothing about whether the median changes.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Given: class mean height = \( 150.2 \) cm; 2 new students admitted. Heights of new students: unknown.
  2. Step 2: Median depends on position of middle value(s). Adding 2 unknown heights changes the ordered data set and can shift the middle position.
  3. Step 3: Since new heights are unknown, the new median may or may not equal the old median — the statement is NOT necessarily true.

Answer: The statement 'the median will remain the same' is NOT necessarily correct. Because we do not know the heights of the 2 new students, adding them can shift the middle value of the ordered data. The median stays the same only if the new heights happen to keep the same middle value; otherwise it changes.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: A group of 10 students in Class 8 took a Science test. Their mean score was found to be 72 marks. After the scores were recorded, 2 more students joined and took the same test, scoring 85 and 91 marks respectively. Which of the following is true about the new mean score of all 12 students? (a) The new mean will be greater than 72. (b) The new mean will remain 72. (c) The new mean will be less than 72. Justify your answer with a calculation.

Solution: Step 1: Find the total marks of the original 10 students. We use the formula: Total = Mean × Number of observations. Total marks of 10 students = \[72 \times 10 = 720\] Step 2: Find the total marks after the 2 new students join. The two new students scored 85 and 91. New total = \(720 + 85 + 91\) \[= 720 + 176 = 896\] Step 3: Find the new mean for all 12 students. New number of students = \(10 + 2 = 12\) New Mean = \[\frac{896}{12} = 74.\overline{6}\] Step 4: Compare with the original mean of 72. Since \(74.\overline{6} > 72\), the new mean is greater than 72. Justification: The two new students scored 85 and 91, both of which are above the original mean of 72. Adding values above the mean always pulls the mean upward. Therefore, statement (a) is correct.

Answer: Statement (a) is correct. The new mean is approximately \(74.\overline{6}\), which is greater than 72, because both new scores (85 and 91) are above the original mean of 72.

Example 2

Question: The weights (in kg) of 7 players in a school cricket team are listed in ascending order: 42, 45, 48, 52, 55, 58, 62. The coach records the median weight of the team. Two substitute players, weighing 39 kg and 66 kg, are added to the squad. (a) What was the original median weight? (b) What is the new median weight after the two players are added? (c) Does the median change? Give a reason.

Solution: Part (a): Original Median The original data in ascending order has 7 values: 42, 45, 48, 52, 55, 58, 62. For 7 observations, the median is the \(\left(\frac{7 + 1}{2}\right)\)th value = the 4th value. Original Median = 52 kg. Part (b): New Median after adding 2 players The two new players weigh 39 kg and 66 kg. Inserting them into the ordered list: 39, 42, 45, 48, 52, 55, 58, 62, 66. Now there are \(7 + 2 = 9\) values. For 9 observations, the median is the \(\left(\frac{9 + 1}{2}\right)\)th value = the 5th value. Counting: 39 (1st), 42 (2nd), 45 (3rd), 48 (4th), 52 (5th). New Median = 52 kg. Part (c): Does the median change? The median does NOT change. It remains 52 kg in both cases. Reason: One new value (39 kg) was added below the original median and one new value (66 kg) was added above the original median. Adding one value on each side of the middle keeps the central value in the same position. The original median value of 52 kg is still the middle (5th) observation in the new ordered list of 9 values.

Answer: (a) Original median = 52 kg. (b) New median = 52 kg. (c) The median does not change, because one new value was added on each side of the existing median, keeping 52 kg at the centre of the new ordered dataset.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: The average weight of 30 students in Class 8A was found to be 45.6 kg. A week later, 3 new students joined the class. A classmate claims: 'The new class average weight will definitely remain 45.6 kg.' Is this statement correct? Justify your answer with reasoning and suitable examples.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what the mean represents: The mean (average) of a data set is the total sum of all values divided by the number of values. Here, the original mean is 45.6 kg for 30 students, so the total weight of 30 students is:
  2. Step 2: Calculate the original total weight: Total weight of 30 students = Mean \( \times \) Number of students \[ \text{Total} = 45.6 \times 30 = 1368 \text{ kg} \]
  3. Step 3: Check when the mean stays the same: For the mean to remain exactly 45.6 kg after 3 new students join, the combined weight of the 3 new students must also equal 45.6 kg per student, i.e. their total weight must be:
  4. Step 4: Required weight of new students for mean to stay the same: \[ 45.6 \times 3 = 136.8 \text{ kg} \] So the mean stays at 45.6 kg ONLY IF the 3 new students together weigh exactly 136.8 kg (i.e. each weighs exactly 45.6 kg on average).
  5. Step 5: Example where the mean increases: Suppose the 3 new students weigh 50 kg, 52 kg, and 54 kg. Their total = 156 kg. New mean = \( \dfrac{1368 + 156}{33} = \dfrac{1524}{33} \approx 46.18 \text{ kg} \), which is greater than 45.6 kg.
  6. Step 6: Example where the mean decreases: Suppose the 3 new students weigh 38 kg, 40 kg, and 42 kg. Their total = 120 kg. New mean = \( \dfrac{1368 + 120}{33} = \dfrac{1488}{33} \approx 45.09 \text{ kg} \), which is less than 45.6 kg.
  7. Step 7: Conclusion: Since we do not know the weights of the 3 new students, the new mean could be equal to, greater than, or less than 45.6 kg. Therefore, the classmate's claim that 'the new class average weight will definitely remain 45.6 kg' is NOT necessarily correct.

Answer: The statement 'the new class average weight will definitely remain 45.6 kg' is NOT necessarily correct. The new mean depends on the actual weights of the 3 new students. It stays at 45.6 kg only if their combined weight is exactly \( 45.6 \times 3 = 136.8 \) kg. If they weigh more on average, the mean rises; if they weigh less, the mean falls. Without knowing their weights, we cannot guarantee the mean stays the same.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Tales By Dots And Lines