SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 3 Q9(iii)

The following table shows the retail price (in ₹) of iodised salt in the month of January in a few states over \(10\) years. For your calculations and plotting you may round off values to the nearest counting number. Compare the price variation in Gujarat and Uttar Pradesh.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Tales By Dots And Lines

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine tracking your pocket money over 10 years. If it stays close to the same amount each year, it is very steady. But if it keeps jumping higher and higher, that is big variation. Gujarat's tomato prices stayed close together, like a calm heartbeat. Uttar Pradesh's prices kept climbing up, like stairs going higher each year. We compare the highest and lowest price for each state — the bigger the gap, the more the prices changed.

Answer: Uttar Pradesh shows much greater price variation than Gujarat. The range for Gujarat is about \( 6 \) rupees (staying fairly steady, mostly between \( 13 \) and \( 19 \)), while the range for Uttar Pradesh is about \( 11 \) rupees with a clear rising trend from about \( 16 \) to \( 27 \). Hence prices in Uttar Pradesh varied (increased) far more than in Gujarat over these 10 years.

📖 Comparing Price Variation: Gujarat vs Uttar Pradesh

Detailed Explanation

This question is from data handling. To compare 'price variation' we look at how much the values change over the years for each state. A good way to see this is to find the range, which is the difference between the highest and the lowest value. A large range means the price changed a lot (high variation), and a small range means the price stayed fairly steady (low variation). We can also compare the starting and ending prices and observe the trend (rising, falling or steady). Reading the table carefully for each state is the key skill here.

Formula Used

\[ \text{Range} = \text{Highest value} - \text{Lowest value} \]

Solution

  1. Step 1: Read out the Gujarat prices from the table for each year (rounded to the nearest whole number): 2016 is about \( 17 \) (from 16.5), 2017 is \( 15 \), 2018 is \( 15 \), 2019 is \( 15 \), 2020 is \( 13 \), 2021 is \( 14 \), 2022 is \( 14 \), 2023 is \( 15 \), 2024 is \( 15 \), 2025 is \( 19 \).
  2. Step 2: Read out the Uttar Pradesh prices from the table for each year (rounded): 2016 is \( 16 \), 2017 is \( 17 \), 2018 is \( 16 \), 2019 is \( 18 \), 2020 is \( 19 \), 2021 is \( 21 \), 2022 is \( 21 \), 2023 is \( 25 \), 2024 is \( 27 \), 2025 is \( 25 \).
  3. Step 3: Find the range for Gujarat. The highest price is about \( 19 \) (in 2025) and the lowest is about \( 13 \) (in 2020). \[ \text{Range}_{Gujarat} = 19 - 13 = 6 \] So Gujarat's price stayed within a small band of about \( 6 \) rupees.
  4. Step 4: Find the range for Uttar Pradesh. The highest price is about \( 27 \) (in 2024) and the lowest is about \( 16 \) (in 2016). \[ \text{Range}_{UP} = 27 - 16 = 11 \] So Uttar Pradesh's price spread over a much wider band of about \( 11 \) rupees.
  5. Step 5: Compare the trends. In Gujarat the price first dipped a little, stayed almost steady near \( 14 \) to \( 15 \) for many years, and rose only at the end. In Uttar Pradesh the price kept climbing steadily from \( 16 \) up to around \( 27 \), showing a clear upward trend.

Final Answer

Uttar Pradesh shows much greater price variation than Gujarat. The range for Gujarat is about \( 6 \) rupees (staying fairly steady, mostly between \( 13 \) and \( 19 \)), while the range for Uttar Pradesh is about \( 11 \) rupees with a clear rising trend from about \( 16 \) to \( 27 \). Hence prices in Uttar Pradesh varied (increased) far more than in Gujarat over these 10 years.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to compare only the first year and last year values and ignore the years in between. This can hide the true variation. Always find the highest and lowest values across all years (the range) to correctly judge how much the price varied.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: List the Gujarat prices (rounded to the nearest whole number) year by year from the table: 2016 is \( 17 \), 2017 is \( 15 \), 2018 is \( 15 \), 2019 is \( 15 \), 2020 is \( 13 \), 2021 is \( 14 \), 2022 is \( 14 \), 2023 is \( 15 \), 2024 is \( 15 \), 2025 is \( 19 \). — Reason: Carefully reading each value from the table is the first skill in data handling; rounding makes comparison easier.
  2. Step 2: List the Uttar Pradesh prices (rounded to the nearest whole number) year by year: 2016 is \( 16 \), 2017 is \( 17 \), 2018 is \( 16 \), 2019 is \( 18 \), 2020 is \( 19 \), 2021 is \( 21 \), 2022 is \( 21 \), 2023 is \( 25 \), 2024 is \( 27 \), 2025 is \( 25 \). — Reason: We need both sets of data side by side before we can calculate and compare their ranges.
  3. Step 3: Identify the highest and lowest Gujarat prices. The highest is \( 19 \) (in 2025) and the lowest is \( 13 \) (in 2020). Now calculate the range for Gujarat: \[ \text{Range}_{\text{Gujarat}} = 19 - 13 = 6 \] — Reason: The range tells us the total spread of Gujarat's prices; a small range means prices stayed fairly stable.
  4. Step 4: Identify the highest and lowest Uttar Pradesh prices. The highest is \( 27 \) (in 2024) and the lowest is \( 16 \) (in 2016). Now calculate the range for Uttar Pradesh: \[ \text{Range}_{\text{Uttar Pradesh}} = 27 - 16 = 11 \] — Reason: A range of \( 11 \) is nearly double Gujarat's range of \( 6 \), which immediately signals much greater price variation.
  5. Step 5: Observe the trend for each state. Gujarat's prices moved up and down between roughly \( 13 \) and \( 19 \) with no clear direction — this is a flat or fluctuating trend. Uttar Pradesh's prices climbed almost continuously from \( 16 \) all the way to \( 27 \) — this is a clear rising trend. — Reason: Range alone measures spread, but looking at the trend tells us whether prices moved in one direction (increasing or decreasing) or simply fluctuated randomly.
  6. Step 6: Compare the two ranges directly: Gujarat's range is \( 6 \) rupees and Uttar Pradesh's range is \( 11 \) rupees. Since \( 11 > 6 \), Uttar Pradesh shows greater price variation. Combined with its rising trend, we conclude that prices in Uttar Pradesh changed far more significantly over these 10 years. — Reason: Comparing the two numerical ranges gives us an objective, evidence-based conclusion rather than a guess.

Final Answer

Uttar Pradesh shows much greater price variation than Gujarat. The range for Gujarat is about \( 6 \) rupees (staying fairly steady, mostly between \( 13 \) and \( 19 \)), while the range for Uttar Pradesh is about \( 11 \) rupees with a clear rising trend from about \( 16 \) to \( 27 \). Hence prices in Uttar Pradesh varied (increased) far more than in Gujarat over these 10 years.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students sometimes compare only the highest prices of the two states (or only the lowest) instead of computing the full range for each state separately, which leads to an incomplete and often incorrect comparison.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Gujarat prices (2016–2025): \( 17, 15, 15, 15, 13, 14, 14, 15, 15, 19 \). Range: \( 19 - 13 = 6 \) rupees.
  2. Step 2: Uttar Pradesh prices (2016–2025): \( 16, 17, 16, 18, 19, 21, 21, 25, 27, 25 \). Range: \( 27 - 16 = 11 \) rupees.
  3. Step 3: Comparison: Range of UP \( = 11 \) rupees \( > \) Range of Gujarat \( = 6 \) rupees; UP shows a clear rising trend, Gujarat stays mostly steady.

Answer: Uttar Pradesh shows much greater price variation than Gujarat. The range for Gujarat is about \( 6 \) rupees (staying fairly steady, mostly between \( 13 \) and \( 19 \)), while the range for Uttar Pradesh is about \( 11 \) rupees with a clear rising trend from about \( 16 \) to \( 27 \). Hence prices in Uttar Pradesh varied (increased) far more than in Gujarat over these 10 years.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: The table below shows the retail price (in ₹ per litre) of mustard oil in two states, Maharashtra (MH) and Rajasthan (RJ), recorded in January over 8 years. Round all values to the nearest whole number for calculations and plotting. Year: 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022 Maharashtra (₹): 98, 102, 107, 115, 110, 118, 125, 130 Rajasthan (₹): 95, 98, 100, 105, 112, 116, 120, 128 (a) Find the range of prices for each state over the 8 years. (b) Which state showed a greater overall increase from 2015 to 2022? (c) In which year(s) did Rajasthan's price exceed Maharashtra's price? (d) Compare the price variation in the two states.

Solution: We use the given data directly (all values are already whole numbers). Data summary: Maharashtra: 98, 102, 107, 115, 110, 118, 125, 130 Rajasthan: 95, 98, 100, 105, 112, 116, 120, 128 Part (a): Range of prices For Maharashtra: Maximum price = ₹130 (2022), Minimum price = ₹98 (2015) Range for Maharashtra: \[ \text{Range}_{MH} = 130 - 98 = 32 \] For Rajasthan: Maximum price = ₹128 (2022), Minimum price = ₹95 (2015) Range for Rajasthan: \[ \text{Range}_{RJ} = 128 - 95 = 33 \] Part (b): Overall increase from 2015 to 2022 Increase for Maharashtra: \[ 130 - 98 = 32 \text{ (in ₹)} \] Percentage increase for Maharashtra: \[ \frac{32}{98} \times 100 \approx 32.65\% \] Increase for Rajasthan: \[ 128 - 95 = 33 \text{ (in ₹)} \] Percentage increase for Rajasthan: \[ \frac{33}{95} \times 100 \approx 34.74\% \] So Rajasthan showed a greater overall percentage increase from 2015 to 2022. Part (c): Year(s) when Rajasthan's price exceeded Maharashtra's price Comparing year by year: 2015: MH = 98, RJ = 95. RJ < MH. 2016: MH = 102, RJ = 98. RJ < MH. 2017: MH = 107, RJ = 100. RJ < MH. 2018: MH = 115, RJ = 105. RJ < MH. 2019: MH = 110, RJ = 112. RJ > MH. 2020: MH = 118, RJ = 116. RJ < MH. 2021: MH = 125, RJ = 120. RJ < MH. 2022: MH = 130, RJ = 128. RJ < MH. Rajasthan's price exceeded Maharashtra's price only in the year 2019. Part (d): Comparison of price variation Both states showed an overall upward trend in mustard oil prices from 2015 to 2022. Maharashtra's prices were consistently higher than Rajasthan's in most years, except in 2019. Maharashtra experienced a dip from ₹115 in 2018 to ₹110 in 2019, while Rajasthan's price continued to rise to ₹112 in the same year. The range for Rajasthan (₹33) is slightly higher than for Maharashtra (₹32), meaning Rajasthan had a marginally wider price variation. Overall, Rajasthan recorded a higher percentage increase (~34.74%) compared to Maharashtra (~32.65%), indicating faster price growth in Rajasthan over the 8-year period.

Answer: (a) Range for Maharashtra = ₹32; Range for Rajasthan = ₹33. (b) Rajasthan showed a greater overall increase (~34.74% vs ~32.65%). (c) Rajasthan's price exceeded Maharashtra's only in 2019. (d) Both states show an upward trend; Rajasthan had a slightly wider variation and faster price growth.

Example 2

Question: The table below shows the average monthly electricity bill (in ₹) for households in two cities, City A (Pune) and City B (Lucknow), recorded every year from 2016 to 2023. Round all values to the nearest whole number. Year: 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023 Pune (₹): 850, 870, 900, 920, 880, 950, 1010, 1080 Lucknow (₹): 780, 800, 820, 860, 900, 930, 970, 1020 (a) Find the range of bills for each city. (b) In which year did Lucknow's bill first exceed Pune's bill? (c) Calculate the percentage increase in the electricity bill from 2016 to 2023 for both cities. (d) Compare the variation in electricity bills between the two cities.

Solution: All values are already whole numbers, so no rounding is needed. Data: Pune: 850, 870, 900, 920, 880, 950, 1010, 1080 Lucknow: 780, 800, 820, 860, 900, 930, 970, 1020 Part (a): Range of bills For Pune: Maximum = ₹1080 (2023), Minimum = ₹850 (2016) \[ \text{Range}_{Pune} = 1080 - 850 = 230 \] For Lucknow: Maximum = ₹1020 (2023), Minimum = ₹780 (2016) \[ \text{Range}_{Lucknow} = 1020 - 780 = 240 \] Part (b): Year when Lucknow's bill first exceeds Pune's bill Comparing year by year: 2016: Pune = 850, Lucknow = 780. Lucknow < Pune. 2017: Pune = 870, Lucknow = 800. Lucknow < Pune. 2018: Pune = 900, Lucknow = 820. Lucknow < Pune. 2019: Pune = 920, Lucknow = 860. Lucknow < Pune. 2020: Pune = 880, Lucknow = 900. Lucknow > Pune. So Lucknow's bill first exceeded Pune's bill in the year 2020. Note: Pune's bill dropped from ₹920 in 2019 to ₹880 in 2020, while Lucknow's continued to rise to ₹900, causing the crossover. Part (c): Percentage increase from 2016 to 2023 For Pune: Increase = \( 1080 - 850 = 230 \) \[ \text{Percentage increase for Pune} = \frac{230}{850} \times 100 \approx 27.06\% \] For Lucknow: Increase = \( 1020 - 780 = 240 \) \[ \text{Percentage increase for Lucknow} = \frac{240}{780} \times 100 \approx 30.77\% \] Lucknow showed a higher percentage increase in electricity bills over the 8 years. Part (d): Comparison of price variation Pune's bills started higher (₹850 in 2016) and remained above Lucknow's for the first four years (2016–2019). However, in 2020 Pune experienced a dip to ₹880, allowing Lucknow (which rose steadily to ₹900) to overtake it. After 2020, Pune resumed its rise and ended at ₹1080 in 2023, which is again higher than Lucknow's ₹1020. The range for Lucknow (₹240) is slightly greater than for Pune (₹230), showing Lucknow had a marginally wider spread of values. Lucknow also recorded a higher percentage increase (~30.77%) compared to Pune (~27.06%), indicating faster growth in household electricity bills in Lucknow over this period. Overall, both cities show an upward trend, with Pune generally billing more per month but Lucknow growing at a faster rate.

Answer: (a) Range for Pune = ₹230; Range for Lucknow = ₹240. (b) Lucknow's bill first exceeded Pune's in 2020. (c) Pune: ~27.06% increase; Lucknow: ~30.77% increase. (d) Both show an upward trend; Lucknow has a slightly wider range and faster percentage growth, while Pune had higher absolute bills in most years.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: The table below shows the retail price (in ₹ per kg) of refined cooking oil in the month of June over 8 years in two states — Maharashtra and Rajasthan. (Round values to the nearest rupee for calculations.) Year: 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022 Maharashtra (₹): 82, 84, 83, 85, 86, 84, 85, 87 Rajasthan (₹): 78, 82, 86, 90, 95, 100, 105, 110 (a) Find the range of prices for each state over the 8 years. (b) Plot a double line graph for the data. (c) Compare the price variation in Maharashtra and Rajasthan. Which state shows a greater increase in price?

Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the maximum and minimum prices for Maharashtra: From the table, the prices for Maharashtra (in ₹) are: 82, 84, 83, 85, 86, 84, 85, 87. Maximum price = ₹87 (in 2022) Minimum price = ₹82 (in 2015) Range for Maharashtra: \[ \text{Range} = 87 - 82 = 5 \text{ rupees} \]
  2. Step 2: Identify the maximum and minimum prices for Rajasthan: From the table, the prices for Rajasthan (in ₹) are: 78, 82, 86, 90, 95, 100, 105, 110. Maximum price = ₹110 (in 2022) Minimum price = ₹78 (in 2015) Range for Rajasthan: \[ \text{Range} = 110 - 78 = 32 \text{ rupees} \]
  3. Step 3: Plot the double line graph: On the x-axis, mark the years from 2015 to 2022. On the y-axis, mark the price in ₹ (starting from about 70 to 115 to accommodate both states). Plot the Maharashtra prices as one line (e.g., using filled circles) and the Rajasthan prices as a second line (e.g., using filled triangles). Connect the points for each state separately. Label both lines clearly in a legend.
  4. Step 4: Compare the price variation: Maharashtra: The prices fluctuate between ₹82 and ₹87, giving a small range of ₹5. The line is nearly flat, showing very little change over the 8 years. Rajasthan: The prices rise steadily from ₹78 in 2015 to ₹110 in 2022, giving a large range of ₹32. The line shows a clear and consistent upward trend. Hence, Rajasthan shows a far greater price variation (increase) compared to Maharashtra over these 8 years.

Answer: Range for Maharashtra = ₹5 (prices stayed nearly steady, between ₹82 and ₹87). Range for Rajasthan = ₹32 (prices rose sharply from ₹78 to ₹110 with a clear upward trend). Therefore, Rajasthan shows a much greater price variation (increase) in refined cooking oil compared to Maharashtra over the 8 years.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Tales By Dots And Lines