SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 3 Q11(iii)b

Answer the following questions based on the line graph. Are the following statements correct\(?\) All rural kids aged \(15\) spend at least \(1\) hour on hobbies and games everyday.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Tales By Dots And Lines

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine your class has some students who sleep a lot and some who sleep very little. The average sleep time might be 8 hours, but that does not mean every single student sleeps exactly 8 hours. A line graph works the same way — it shows the average for a whole group of kids. So when the graph shows rural kids aged 15 spend a little more than \( 1 \) hour, that is only the group average. Some rural kids might spend less than \( 1 \) hour, and we simply cannot say all of them spend at least \( 1 \) hour.

Answer: No, the statement is not correct. The graph only shows that the AVERAGE time for rural kids aged 15 is a little more than \( 1 \) hour. An average above \( 1 \) hour does not mean every individual rural child spends at least \( 1 \) hour, so we cannot claim it is true for all of them.

📖 Reading a Line Graph: Rural Kids Aged 15

Detailed Explanation

A line graph shows how one quantity changes with respect to another. Here the horizontal axis (x-axis) shows Age and the vertical axis (y-axis) shows Time (in hours). There are two curves: one for Urban kids and one for Rural kids. To read a value, we find the required age on the x-axis, move straight up to the correct curve, and then move left to read the Time on the y-axis. A very important idea is that a line graph gives the AVERAGE value for a group, not the value for each single child. So the graph can tell us the average time for rural kids aged 15, but it cannot tell us what every individual rural child does.

Formula Used

No algebraic formula is needed. Reading rule: pick the age on the x-axis, go up to the curve, then read across to the y-axis. Also remember: line graph value = average of the group, not each individual.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the correct curve: The statement is about rural kids, so we must read the Rural curve (the upper curve in the graph). We ignore the Urban curve for this question.
  2. Step 2: Locate age 15 on the x-axis: Find the point marked \( 15 \) on the Age axis. From this point move straight up until you meet the Rural curve.
  3. Step 3: Read the Time value: From the meeting point on the Rural curve, move horizontally left to the Time axis. At age \( 15 \) the Rural curve is a little above \( 1 \) hour, so the average time is about \( 1 \tfrac{1}{4} \) hours, which is more than \( 1 \) hour.
  4. Step 4: Check the exact wording of the statement: The statement says ALL rural kids aged 15 spend at least \( 1 \) hour. But the graph only shows the AVERAGE for rural kids of that age. An average being above \( 1 \) hour does not guarantee that every single child is above \( 1 \) hour. Some children may spend less than \( 1 \) hour while others spend more, and the average can still be above \( 1 \) hour.
  5. Step 5: Conclude: Because a line graph shows only the group average and tells us nothing about each individual child, we cannot say the statement is true. The statement is therefore not correct (we cannot conclude it).

Final Answer

No, the statement is not correct. The graph only shows that the AVERAGE time for rural kids aged 15 is a little more than \( 1 \) hour. An average above \( 1 \) hour does not mean every individual rural child spends at least \( 1 \) hour, so we cannot claim it is true for all of them.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to read the average value (a bit above \( 1 \) hour) and immediately conclude the statement is true. Students forget that a line graph gives the average for the whole group, not a guaranteed minimum for each individual child.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Pick the correct curve for the question. The statement talks about rural kids, so focus only on the Rural curve and completely ignore the Urban curve. — Reason: Using the wrong curve would give information about the wrong group of children, leading to an incorrect conclusion.
  2. Step 2: On the horizontal (Age) axis, find the value \( 15 \). From that point, draw an imaginary vertical line going straight upward until it meets the Rural curve. — Reason: We need the time value specifically at age 15, so we must first locate age 15 precisely on the x-axis before reading anything off the curve.
  3. Step 3: From the point where the vertical line meets the Rural curve, move horizontally to the left and read the value on the Time (vertical) axis. The Rural curve at age \( 15 \) sits just above the \( 1 \) hour mark, giving an approximate reading of \( 1\tfrac{1}{4} \) hours. — Reason: Moving horizontally from the curve to the y-axis is the standard technique for reading a line graph accurately.
  4. Step 4: Now compare the graph reading with the claim in the statement. The graph shows a value of about \( 1\tfrac{1}{4} \) hours, which is indeed more than \( 1 \) hour. At first glance this might seem to support the statement. — Reason: Before accepting or rejecting a claim, we must check whether the graph reading is consistent with the claim or not.
  5. Step 5: Critically examine what the graph value actually represents. The figure \( 1\tfrac{1}{4} \) hours is the AVERAGE time for all rural children aged 15 taken together — it is not the time spent by each and every individual rural child aged 15. — Reason: This is the most important concept: a line graph reports a group average, so no conclusion about every individual in the group can be drawn from it alone.
  6. Step 6: Apply this understanding to evaluate the statement. The statement claims that ALL rural kids aged 15 spend more than \( 1 \) hour on studies. But the graph only guarantees that the average exceeds \( 1 \) hour. Some rural children aged 15 could spend much less than \( 1 \) hour, while others spend much more, and the average could still come out to \( 1\tfrac{1}{4} \) hours. Therefore, the statement is NOT correct. — Reason: A universal claim (true for all individuals) cannot be proved using only a group average.

Final Answer

No, the statement is not correct. The graph only shows that the AVERAGE time for rural kids aged 15 is a little more than \( 1 \) hour. An average above \( 1 \) hour does not mean every individual rural child spends at least \( 1 \) hour, so we cannot claim it is true for all of them.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students see that the graph value at age 15 for rural kids is above 1 hour and immediately accept the statement as true, forgetting that the graph shows only a group average and says nothing definite about each individual child in that group.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Read the Rural curve at age \( 15 \): value is approximately \( 1\tfrac{1}{4} \) hours, which is just above \( 1 \) hour.
  2. Step 2: A line graph gives the GROUP AVERAGE, not the value for each individual child.
  3. Step 3: Average \( > 1 \) hour does NOT imply every rural child aged \( 15 \) spends at least \( 1 \) hour.

Answer: No, the statement is not correct. The graph only shows that the AVERAGE time for rural kids aged 15 is a little more than \( 1 \) hour. An average above \( 1 \) hour does not mean every individual rural child spends at least \( 1 \) hour, so we cannot claim it is true for all of them.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: A line graph shows the number of hours urban students aged 10, 11, 12, 13, and 14 spend on outdoor play each day. The values read from the graph are: Age 10 → 2 hours, Age 11 → 1.5 hours, Age 12 → 1 hour, Age 13 → 0.5 hours, Age 14 → 1.5 hours. Is the following statement correct? All urban students in the age group 10 to 14 spend at least 1 hour on outdoor play every day.

Solution: To verify the statement, check the hours for every age group mentioned. Age 10: The graph shows 2 hours. Since \( 2 \ge 1 \), this satisfies the condition. Age 11: The graph shows 1.5 hours. Since \( 1.5 \ge 1 \), this satisfies the condition. Age 12: The graph shows 1 hour. Since \( 1 \ge 1 \), this satisfies the condition. Age 13: The graph shows 0.5 hours. Since \( 0.5 < 1 \), this does NOT satisfy the condition. Age 14: The graph shows 1.5 hours. Since \( 1.5 \ge 1 \), this satisfies the condition. Because age 13 has only 0.5 hours of outdoor play, which is less than 1 hour, the condition fails for at least one age group. Therefore, the statement is incorrect.

Answer: No, the statement is incorrect. Students aged 13 spend only 0.5 hours on outdoor play, which is less than 1 hour.

Example 2

Question: A line graph shows the average number of hours per day that students in Classes 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7 spend reading books (apart from school work). The values read from the graph are: Class 3 → 0.5 hours, Class 4 → 1 hour, Class 5 → 1.5 hours, Class 6 → 2 hours, Class 7 → 2.5 hours. Is the following statement correct? Students in every class from Class 3 to Class 7 spend more than 0.5 hours reading books each day.

Solution: To verify the statement, check the reading hours for every class mentioned. The statement requires the hours to be more than 0.5, i.e., strictly greater than \( 0.5 \). Class 3: The graph shows 0.5 hours. We need hours \( > 0.5 \). Since \( 0.5 \not> 0.5 \), this does NOT satisfy the condition. Class 4: The graph shows 1 hour. Since \( 1 > 0.5 \), this satisfies the condition. Class 5: The graph shows 1.5 hours. Since \( 1.5 > 0.5 \), this satisfies the condition. Class 6: The graph shows 2 hours. Since \( 2 > 0.5 \), this satisfies the condition. Class 7: The graph shows 2.5 hours. Since \( 2.5 > 0.5 \), this satisfies the condition. Class 3 students spend exactly 0.5 hours, which is not more than 0.5 hours. The condition fails for Class 3. Therefore, the statement is incorrect.

Answer: No, the statement is incorrect. Class 3 students spend exactly 0.5 hours reading, which is not more than 0.5 hours.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: A line graph shows the average number of hours urban children of different ages spend on outdoor play each day. The graph shows that for urban children aged 10, the average time spent on outdoor play is exactly 2 hours per day. A student makes the following statement: 'Every urban child aged 10 spends exactly 2 hours on outdoor play daily.' Is this statement correct? Explain your reasoning.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what the line graph shows: The line graph displays the AVERAGE number of hours spent on outdoor play by urban children aged 10. The value shown is \( 2 \) hours. This is a single representative value calculated from the data of many children.
  2. Step 2: Recall the meaning of an average: An average (or mean) is computed by adding up all the individual values and dividing by the number of children. For example, if three children spend \( 1 \) hour, \( 2 \) hours, and \( 3 \) hours respectively, the average is \[ \frac{1 + 2 + 3}{3} = \frac{6}{3} = 2 \text{ hours} \] Even though the average is \( 2 \) hours, not every child spent exactly \( 2 \) hours.
  3. Step 3: Apply this understanding to the statement: The graph tells us only that the AVERAGE time for urban children aged 10 is \( 2 \) hours. Some individual children may spend more than \( 2 \) hours, and some may spend less. The graph gives no information about any single child's exact time.
  4. Step 4: Conclude whether the statement is correct: The statement claims that EVERY urban child aged 10 spends EXACTLY \( 2 \) hours on outdoor play. This cannot be concluded from an average alone. Therefore, the statement is incorrect.

Answer: No, the statement is not correct. The graph shows that the AVERAGE time for urban children aged 10 is \( 2 \) hours. An average of \( 2 \) hours does not mean every individual child spends exactly \( 2 \) hours. Individual children may spend more or less than \( 2 \) hours, and we cannot make a claim about each child based only on an average.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Tales By Dots And Lines