SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 3 Q10(iv)

Referring to the graph below, which of the following statements are valid\(?\) Why\(?\) In \(2023,\) there were no power cuts.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Tales By Dots And Lines

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a chart that only counts how many people in a town own umbrellas. That chart cannot tell you whether it actually rained. This graph works the same way — it only counts how many homes use electricity for lighting. By 2023, nearly \( 100\% \) of homes used electricity. But the graph says nothing about power cuts. Knowing that a home has electricity is very different from knowing the electricity never goes off.

Answer: The statement is NOT valid. The graph only shows the share of households using electricity or kerosene for lighting. It shows that by 2023 nearly \( 100\% \) of households use electricity, but it gives no information at all about power cuts or the reliability of the supply. Therefore we cannot conclude that there were no power cuts in 2023.

📖 Reading a Line Graph: Is the Statement Valid?

Detailed Explanation

This is a data handling question about reading a line graph. A line graph shows how a quantity changes over time. Here, two graphs (Rural and Urban) show the percentage share of households that use Electricity or Kerosene as their main source of lighting from 1983 to 2023. To judge whether a statement is valid, we must check whether the graph actually gives us that information. A graph can only support conclusions about the quantities it plots. Here the y-axis shows the share (percentage) of households using each energy source. It says nothing about the quality or reliability of the electricity supply, such as power cuts. So we must separate what the data shows from what the statement claims.

Formula Used

A conclusion is valid only if it can be read directly from the plotted quantities: here, share of households \( = \dfrac{\text{households using a source}}{\text{total households}} \times 100\% \). The graph plots this share, not supply reliability.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify what the graph actually measures: Look carefully at the axes. The x-axis shows the year (1983 to 2023). The y-axis shows the percentage share of households, from \( 0\% \) to \( 100\% \). Each curve tells us what fraction of households mainly use Electricity or Kerosene for lighting.
  2. Step 2: Read the 2023 values: In 2023, the Electricity curve is near the top. For rural households it is about \( 100\% \) and for urban households also about \( 100\% \). The Kerosene curve has dropped to nearly \( 0\% \). This tells us almost every household uses electricity as its main lighting source.
  3. Step 3: Compare the claim with the data: The statement says there were no power cuts in 2023. A power cut is about the reliability of the electricity supply, that is, whether electricity is available continuously. The graph never measures supply interruptions. It only measures how many households use electricity, not for how many hours it stays on.
  4. Step 4: Judge validity: Since the graph gives no data about power cuts or supply hours, we cannot conclude anything about them. A household can use electricity as its main source and still face power cuts. So the statement is not supported by the graph.

Final Answer

The statement is NOT valid. The graph only shows the share of households using electricity or kerosene for lighting. It shows that by 2023 nearly \( 100\% \) of households use electricity, but it gives no information at all about power cuts or the reliability of the supply. Therefore we cannot conclude that there were no power cuts in 2023.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to assume that a high electricity-usage percentage means uninterrupted supply. Using electricity as the main source is not the same as never having a power cut, so the graph cannot justify that claim.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Read the axes carefully to find out what the graph actually measures. The x-axis records the year, running from 1983 to 2023. The y-axis records the percentage share of households, from \( 0\\% \) to \( 100\\% \). Each curve shows what fraction of households rely on Electricity or Kerosene as their main lighting source. — Reason: Before judging any statement, we must be clear about what the graph is and is not measuring.
  2. Step 2: Note what the graph does NOT measure. There is no axis, no scale, and no curve related to power supply reliability, duration of supply, or frequency of power cuts. — Reason: A graph can only support conclusions about the quantities it plots. Anything outside those quantities is simply not present in the data.
  3. Step 3: Read the 2023 values from the graph. The Electricity curve for both rural and urban households reaches close to \( 100\\% \) by 2023. The Kerosene curve has fallen to nearly \( 0\\% \) by the same year. — Reason: We identify the most recent data point so we know exactly what the graph tells us about 2023.
  4. Step 4: Interpret what the 2023 reading means. Nearly \( 100\\% \) of households use electricity as their source of lighting. This means almost every household has an electricity connection for lighting purposes. — Reason: We must state the correct, limited conclusion that the data actually supports before comparing it with the given statement.
  5. Step 5: Compare the data's conclusion with the statement being evaluated. The statement claims there were no power cuts in 2023. However, having an electricity connection (what the graph shows) is entirely different from having an uninterrupted or reliable electricity supply (what the statement claims). A household can be connected to the electricity grid and still experience frequent power cuts. — Reason: This comparison reveals whether the statement goes beyond what the graph can tell us.
  6. Step 6: Decide on the validity of the statement. Since the graph provides zero information about supply reliability or power cuts, the statement cannot be supported by this graph. The statement is NOT valid. — Reason: A conclusion is valid only when it follows directly from the data plotted; here, the required information is simply absent from the graph.

Final Answer

The statement is NOT valid. The graph only shows the share of households using electricity or kerosene for lighting. It shows that by 2023 nearly \( 100\% \) of households use electricity, but it gives no information at all about power cuts or the reliability of the supply. Therefore we cannot conclude that there were no power cuts in 2023.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students see that nearly \( 100\\% \) of households use electricity and assume this automatically means the electricity supply is perfect and uninterrupted. They confuse having access to an electricity connection with having a reliable, cut-free power supply — these are two very different things, and the graph only tells us about the former.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Graph measures: share of households using Electricity or Kerosene for lighting, plotted as \( \\% \) of total households vs. year (1983–2023).
  2. Step 2: 2023 reading: Electricity share \\ \( \approx 100\\% \) (rural and urban); Kerosene share \\ \( \approx 0\\% \).
  3. Step 3: Graph plots access (who uses electricity), NOT supply reliability (power cuts). Statement about zero power cuts cannot be derived from plotted data.

Answer: The statement is NOT valid. The graph only shows the share of households using electricity or kerosene for lighting. It shows that by 2023 nearly \( 100\% \) of households use electricity, but it gives no information at all about power cuts or the reliability of the supply. Therefore we cannot conclude that there were no power cuts in 2023.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: A line graph shows the number of rainy days in a town for six consecutive years (2016 to 2021). The data recorded is: 2016 — 45 days, 2017 — 38 days, 2018 — 52 days, 2019 — 0 days, 2020 — 29 days, 2021 — 41 days. A student makes the following two statements after looking at the graph: (A) In 2019, there were no rainy days. (B) In 2018, there were no rainy days. Are these statements valid? Give reasons.

Solution: We read the data values from the line graph for each year mentioned. For Statement (A): The year 2019 corresponds to the value 0 on the graph. This means the graph shows zero rainy days for 2019. Therefore, Statement (A) is VALID because the graph clearly supports this claim. For Statement (B): The year 2018 corresponds to the value 52 on the graph. The number of rainy days in 2018 is 52, which is NOT zero. Therefore, Statement (B) is INVALID because the graph directly contradicts this claim — 52 rainy days were recorded in 2018.

Answer: Statement (A) is VALID (the graph shows 0 rainy days in 2019). Statement (B) is INVALID (the graph shows 52 rainy days in 2018, not 0).

Example 2

Question: A bar graph displays the number of books borrowed from a school library in each month from January to June. The figures are: January — 120, February — 95, March — 0, April — 140, May — 0, June — 110. Based on the bar graph, decide whether the following statements are valid. Justify your answers. (A) No books were borrowed in March. (B) No books were borrowed in April. (C) The number of books borrowed was the same in March and May.

Solution: We examine the bar heights for each relevant month from the bar graph. For Statement (A): The bar for March has a height corresponding to the value 0. This means no books were borrowed in March. Statement (A) is VALID because the graph directly supports it. For Statement (B): The bar for April has a height corresponding to the value 140. This means 140 books were borrowed in April, which is clearly not zero. Statement (B) is INVALID because the graph contradicts this claim. For Statement (C): The bar for March corresponds to 0 books and the bar for May also corresponds to 0 books. Since both values are equal (both are 0), Statement (C) is VALID because the graph shows the same number of books borrowed (zero) in both March and May.

Answer: Statement (A) is VALID (graph shows 0 books in March). Statement (B) is INVALID (graph shows 140 books in April). Statement (C) is VALID (graph shows 0 books in both March and May).

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: A line graph shows the percentage of households in a town that own at least one mobile phone, from the years 2010 to 2023. The graph shows a steady rise, reaching nearly 95% by 2023. A student looks at the graph and makes the following statement: 'In 2023, almost every household had good mobile network coverage and fast internet speeds.' Is this statement valid? Give a reason for your answer.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify what the graph actually shows: The line graph displays one specific piece of information: the percentage of households that own at least one mobile phone over the years 2010 to 2023. By 2023, this percentage has reached nearly 95%.
  2. Step 2: Identify what the student's statement claims: The student's statement makes two claims: (a) that households had good mobile network coverage, and (b) that they had fast internet speeds in 2023.
  3. Step 3: Check whether the graph gives information about network coverage or internet speed: Owning a mobile phone and having good network coverage or fast internet are two different things. A household can own a mobile phone even in an area with poor or no network signal. The graph records only ownership, not network quality or internet speed. There is no data in the graph about coverage or connectivity.
  4. Step 4: Conclude whether the statement is valid: Since the graph provides no information about network coverage or internet speed, the student's statement goes well beyond what the data shows. The statement is NOT supported by the graph, but it is also not directly contradicted. The key point is that the graph simply does not have enough information to confirm or deny the claim about coverage and speed.

Answer: The statement is NOT valid. The graph only shows the percentage of households that own a mobile phone. High mobile phone ownership does not tell us anything about the quality of network coverage or internet speed available to those households. Since the graph contains no data about connectivity or network quality, we cannot use it to conclude that households had good coverage or fast internet in 2023.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Tales By Dots And Lines