SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 3 Q10(iii)

Referring to the graph below, which of the following statements are valid\(?\) Why\(?\) In the year \(2000,\ 10\%\) of the urban households used electricity as a primary lighting source.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Tales By Dots And Lines

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine two roads on a map — one going very high and one staying very low. The high road shows how many city families used electricity for light. The low road shows families using kerosene lamps. Someone looked at the low road by mistake and said electricity was only at \( 10\% \) in the year 2000. That was the kerosene road! The electricity road was actually way up at \( 90\% \). The two roads got mixed up, so the statement is wrong.

Answer: The statement is NOT valid. In the year 2000, about \( 90\% \) of urban households (not \( 10\% \)) used electricity as their primary lighting source. The value near \( 10\% \) corresponds to the Kerosene curve, so the reader has confused the two curves.

📖 Reading a Line Graph: Urban Electricity Use in 2000

Detailed Explanation

This is a line graph question from data handling. A line graph shows how a quantity changes over time. To read a value, we find the given year on the horizontal (time) axis, move straight up to the curve, and then move straight across to the vertical axis to read the percentage. In this figure, the right-hand chart is for Urban households. The dark curve represents Electricity and the orange curve represents Kerosene. We simply read the Electricity curve at the year 2000 and compare it with the claimed value of 10%.

Formula Used

Reading rule for a line graph: value \( = \) point where the vertical line at the given year meets the required curve, read off the vertical axis. Also, share of Electricity \( + \) share of Kerosene should be close to \( 100\% \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the correct chart and curve: The statement is about Urban households, so we look at the right-hand line graph. The dark line is labelled Electricity and the orange line is labelled Kerosene. We must read the dark (Electricity) curve.
  2. Step 2: Locate the year 2000 on the time axis: Find \( 2000 \) on the horizontal axis of the Urban chart. Draw an imaginary vertical line upward from this year until it touches the dark Electricity curve.
  3. Step 3: Read the value on the vertical axis: From the meeting point, move straight across to the vertical (percentage) axis. The Electricity curve is high up, at about \( 90\% \) in the year \( 2000 \), not near the bottom.
  4. Step 4: Compare with the claimed 10%: The claim says \( 10\% \), but the graph clearly shows roughly \( 90\% \). In fact, the value near \( 10\% \) belongs to the orange Kerosene curve, not Electricity.
  5. Step 5: Cross-check using the total: The two shares should add up to about \( 100\% \). If Electricity were \( 90\% \), then Kerosene is about \( 10\% \), which matches the graph. If Electricity were only \( 10\% \), Kerosene would be about \( 90\% \), which the graph does not show. So the claim is wrong.

Final Answer

The statement is NOT valid. In the year 2000, about \( 90\% \) of urban households (not \( 10\% \)) used electricity as their primary lighting source. The value near \( 10\% \) corresponds to the Kerosene curve, so the reader has confused the two curves.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is reading the wrong curve, that is, taking the orange Kerosene value (about \( 10\% \)) and wrongly assigning it to Electricity. Always match the curve to its label before reading a value.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Pick the correct chart and identify the curves. The statement mentions Urban households, so focus only on the right-hand line graph. In that graph, the dark curve represents Electricity and the orange curve represents Kerosene. — Reason: Using the wrong chart or mixing up the two curves will give the wrong percentage entirely.
  2. Step 2: Locate the year 2000 on the horizontal (time) axis of the Urban chart. Imagine drawing a vertical line straight upward from the point marked 2000. — Reason: This imaginary vertical line is the key reading tool; it tells us exactly where to look on each curve for that particular year.
  3. Step 3: Find where the vertical line meets the dark Electricity curve. From that meeting point, draw an imaginary horizontal line straight across to the vertical (percentage) axis and read the value. The Electricity curve sits near the top of the graph at this year, giving a reading of about \( 90\% \). — Reason: Moving horizontally from the curve to the axis is the standard way to convert a graph position into an actual number.
  4. Step 4: Now check where the value of approximately \( 10\% \) actually appears. Repeating the same reading process for the orange Kerosene curve at the year 2000 gives a value close to \( 10\% \), not \( 90\% \). — Reason: Comparing both curves at the same year confirms which percentage belongs to which fuel source.
  5. Step 5: Verify using the complement check: \( 90\% + 10\% = 100\% \). This confirms that the two curves together account for nearly all Urban households, and the \( 90\% \) belongs to Electricity while \( 10\% \) belongs to Kerosene. — Reason: When only two categories together make up the whole, their percentages should sum to roughly \( 100\% \), which acts as a built-in check on our readings.
  6. Step 6: Compare the correct reading with the claim. The statement says about \( 10\% \) of Urban households used electricity in 2000, but the graph shows \( 90\% \). The value of \( 10\% \) actually belongs to the Kerosene curve. — Reason: Directly comparing the claim against the graph reading is the final step needed to judge whether the statement is valid or not.

Final Answer

The statement is NOT valid. In the year 2000, about \( 90\% \) of urban households (not \( 10\% \)) used electricity as their primary lighting source. The value near \( 10\% \) corresponds to the Kerosene curve, so the reader has confused the two curves.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students read the Kerosene (orange) curve instead of the Electricity (dark) curve at the year 2000, arriving at roughly \( 10\\% \) and incorrectly treating that as the percentage for Electricity — the two curves must always be identified by their labels before any value is read.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Locate year 2000 on the Urban households line graph; read the Electricity curve (dark line) at that year.
  2. Step 2: Electricity curve at 2000 reads approximately \( 90\% \); the curve near \( 10\% \) at that year is Kerosene.
  3. Step 3: Claimed value \( 10\% \) \( \ne \) actual Electricity value \( 90\% \); curves have been confused.

Answer: The statement is NOT valid. In the year 2000, about \( 90\% \) of urban households (not \( 10\% \)) used electricity as their primary lighting source. The value near \( 10\% \) corresponds to the Kerosene curve, so the reader has confused the two curves.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: A pie chart shows the distribution of fuel types used as the primary cooking source by rural households in a town in the year 2015. The sectors are labelled as follows: Firewood — \ 45\%, LPG — \ 30\%, Kerosene — \ 15\%, Others — \ 10\%. A student reads the chart and makes the following statement: 'In 2015, exactly 30% of the rural households used LPG as their primary cooking source.' Is this statement valid? Give a reason.

Solution: Step 1 — Identify what the pie chart shows. The pie chart displays data for rural households in the year 2015, showing the percentage of households using each fuel type as their primary cooking source. Step 2 — Locate the relevant sector. The sector for LPG is clearly labelled as \ 30\%. Step 3 — Check each part of the statement. (a) Year: The statement says 'In 2015.' The chart is indeed for the year 2015. This part is correct. (b) Category: The statement refers to 'rural households.' The chart is for rural households. This part is correct. (c) Percentage: The statement says \ 30\% used LPG. The LPG sector in the chart is labelled \ 30\%. This part is correct. (d) Description: The statement says 'primary cooking source.' The chart title specifies 'primary cooking source.' This part is correct. Step 4 — Conclusion. Every detail in the statement — the year, the household type, the percentage, and the fuel type — matches the information shown in the pie chart exactly. Therefore, the statement is VALID.

Answer: The statement is VALID, because the pie chart clearly shows that the LPG sector is labelled 30% for rural households in the year 2015, which matches every detail of the statement exactly.

Example 2

Question: A double bar graph compares the number of students (in hundreds) who passed their Class 8 Maths examination in two schools — School A and School B — over the years 2018, 2019, and 2020. The values shown are: 2018: School A — 4 (i.e., 400 students), School B — 6 (i.e., 600 students). 2019: School A — 7, School B — 5. 2020: School A — 9, School B — 8. A student makes the following statement: 'In 2019, School A had more students passing the Maths exam than School B.' Is this statement valid? Give a reason.

Solution: Step 1 — Identify what the bar graph shows. The graph compares the number of students (in hundreds) who passed the Class 8 Maths exam in School A and School B for the years 2018, 2019, and 2020. Step 2 — Read the values for the year 2019. For 2019, the bar for School A shows a height of 7, meaning \ 7 \times 100 = 700 students. For 2019, the bar for School B shows a height of 5, meaning \ 5 \times 100 = 500 students. Step 3 — Compare the two values. Number of students who passed from School A in 2019: \ 700 Number of students who passed from School B in 2019: \ 500 Since \ 700 > 500, School A had more students passing than School B in 2019. Step 4 — Check each part of the statement. (a) Year: The statement specifies 2019. We read the 2019 bars. Correct year used. (b) Comparison: The statement says 'School A had more students passing than School B.' From the graph, School A (700) > School B (500) in 2019. This is true. Step 5 — Conclusion. The data from the bar graph directly supports the statement. Therefore, the statement is VALID. Note: If a student had mistakenly read the 2018 values (School A = 400, School B = 600), they would have concluded School B had more — that would be reading the wrong year, a common error.

Answer: The statement is VALID, because the double bar graph shows that in 2019, School A had 700 students pass (bar height 7) while School B had 500 students pass (bar height 5), so School A did have more students passing than School B in that year.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: A line graph shows the percentage of rural households using two primary cooking fuel sources — Firewood and LPG — over several years. In the year 2010, the graph shows the Firewood curve at approximately 75% and the LPG curve at approximately 20%. A student makes the following statement: 'In the year 2010, about 20% of rural households used Firewood as their primary cooking fuel source.' Is this statement valid? Justify your answer by explaining what the graph actually shows.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify what the graph shows: The line graph has two curves. One curve represents the percentage of rural households using Firewood, and the other represents those using LPG.
  2. Step 2: Read the correct value for Firewood in 2010: For the year 2010, we locate the point on the Firewood curve. The graph shows the Firewood curve at approximately \( 75\% \).
  3. Step 3: Read the correct value for LPG in 2010: For the year 2010, the LPG curve sits at approximately \( 20\% \).
  4. Step 4: Check the student's statement: The student claims that \( 20\% \) of rural households used Firewood in 2010. However, \( 20\% \) is the value on the LPG curve, not the Firewood curve. The student has confused the two curves.
  5. Step 5: Conclude: The correct reading is that approximately \( 75\% \) of rural households used Firewood as their primary cooking fuel in 2010, and approximately \( 20\% \) used LPG. Therefore, the student's statement is NOT valid.

Answer: The statement is NOT valid. In the year 2010, approximately \( 75\% \) of rural households (not \( 20\% \)) used Firewood as their primary cooking fuel source. The value of \( 20\% \) corresponds to the LPG curve, so the student has confused the two curves.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Tales By Dots And Lines