SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 3 Q10(ii)

Referring to the graph below, which of the following statements are valid\(?\) Why\(?\) The use of kerosene as a primary lighting source has decreased over time in both rural and urban areas.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Tales By Dots And Lines

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine drawing a line on paper to track how many people use candles each year. If the line goes down over time, fewer people are using candles. The graph here does exactly that for kerosene lighting. The rural kerosene line drops from about \( 80\% \) all the way to nearly \( 0\% \). The urban kerosene line also falls, starting near \( 35\% \) and reaching almost \( 0\% \). Both lines go downward, which tells us kerosene became less and less popular as a lighting source over the years.

Answer: The statement is VALID. In both the rural and urban line graphs, the kerosene line slopes downward as time moves from 1983 to 2023 (rural: from about \( 80\% \) down to nearly \( 0\% \); urban: from about \( 35\% \) down to nearly \( 0\% \)). A falling line means the share is decreasing, so kerosene use as a primary lighting source has decreased over time in both rural and urban areas.

📖 Reading Line Graphs: Kerosene Usage Over Time

Detailed Explanation

A line graph shows how a quantity changes over time. Here the horizontal axis represents years (from 1983 to 2023) and the vertical axis represents the share (percentage) of households using a particular source for lighting. There are two panels: one for Rural areas and one for Urban areas. Each panel has two lines, one for Electricity and one for Kerosene. To answer the question we only look at the Kerosene line in each panel and check whether it goes up or down as we move from left (older years) to right (recent years). A line that slopes downward as time increases means the value is decreasing.

Formula Used

Change in share \( = \) (Kerosene share in 2023) \( - \) (Kerosene share in 1983). A negative change means a decrease.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what to look at. The statement is only about kerosene, so we ignore the electricity lines. We read the kerosene line in the Rural panel and the kerosene line in the Urban panel.
  2. Step 2: Read the Rural kerosene line. In 1983 it starts high at about \( 80\% \). Moving towards 2023 the line falls steadily and reaches about \( 0\% \). Change \( = 0\% - 80\% = -80\% \), which is a large decrease.
  3. Step 3: Read the Urban kerosene line. In 1983 it starts at about \( 35\% \). Moving towards 2023 the line drops sharply and reaches nearly \( 0\% \). Change \( = 0\% - 35\% = -35\% \), again a decrease.
  4. Step 4: Compare the direction of both lines with time. In both panels the kerosene line slopes downward as the years increase. A downward slope over time means the share of households using kerosene is falling.
  5. Step 5: Conclude. Since the kerosene share drops in the Rural graph and also drops in the Urban graph, the given statement is correct for both areas.

Final Answer

The statement is VALID. In both the rural and urban line graphs, the kerosene line slopes downward as time moves from 1983 to 2023 (rural: from about \( 80\% \) down to nearly \( 0\% \); urban: from about \( 35\% \) down to nearly \( 0\% \)). A falling line means the share is decreasing, so kerosene use as a primary lighting source has decreased over time in both rural and urban areas.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to read the wrong line. The electricity line rises over time, so some students see an upward line and wrongly say kerosene increased. Always match the line to the correct label (Kerosene) before deciding whether it goes up or down.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify what the graph shows. The horizontal axis marks years from 1983 to 2023, and the vertical axis shows the percentage of households using a particular lighting source. There are two panels (Rural and Urban), and each panel has two lines: one for Electricity and one for Kerosene. — Reason: Understanding the axes and panels first prevents confusion about which line to read.
  2. Step 2: Focus only on the Kerosene line; ignore the Electricity line entirely. The statement we are checking is only about kerosene use. — Reason: Selecting the correct line is essential; reading the wrong line would lead to a wrong conclusion.
  3. Step 3: Read the Rural kerosene line. At the starting year 1983, the kerosene share is approximately \( 80\% \). At the ending year 2023, it has dropped to nearly \( 0\% \). Computing the change: \( 0\% - 80\% = -80\% \). — Reason: A negative change of \( 80\% \) confirms a very large decrease in rural kerosene use over these four decades.
  4. Step 4: Read the Urban kerosene line. At 1983, the kerosene share starts at about \( 35\% \). By 2023 it falls to nearly \( 0\% \). Computing the change: \( 0\% - 35\% = -35\% \). — Reason: A negative change of \( 35\% \) confirms a clear decrease in urban kerosene use as well.
  5. Step 5: Check the direction (slope) of both kerosene lines as time moves from left to right. In the Rural panel the line slopes steeply downward. In the Urban panel the line also slopes downward. Both lines show the same trend: a falling share over time. — Reason: A downward slope in a line graph is the visual proof of a decreasing quantity, which directly supports or refutes the given statement.
  6. Step 6: Compare the evidence gathered with the statement being tested. The statement claims that kerosene use as a primary lighting source decreased over time in both rural and urban areas. Both the Rural change (\( -80\% \)) and the Urban change (\( -35\% \)) are negative, and both lines visually fall from left to right. The evidence fully matches the statement. — Reason: Matching graph evidence with the statement lets us declare it valid or invalid with confidence.

Final Answer

The statement is VALID. In both the rural and urban line graphs, the kerosene line slopes downward as time moves from 1983 to 2023 (rural: from about \( 80\% \) down to nearly \( 0\% \); urban: from about \( 35\% \) down to nearly \( 0\% \)). A falling line means the share is decreasing, so kerosene use as a primary lighting source has decreased over time in both rural and urban areas.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students sometimes look at the Electricity line instead of the Kerosene line, or they read only one panel (say, Rural) and forget to check the other (Urban), leading to an incomplete or incorrect conclusion.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Rural kerosene line: 1983 value \( \approx 80\% \), 2023 value \( \approx 0\% \). Change \( = 0\% - 80\% = -80\% \) (decrease).
  2. Step 2: Urban kerosene line: 1983 value \( \approx 35\% \), 2023 value \( \approx 0\% \). Change \( = 0\% - 35\% = -35\% \) (decrease).
  3. Step 3: Both changes are negative \( < 0 \), confirming the kerosene line slopes downward in both panels. Statement is VALID.

Answer: The statement is VALID. In both the rural and urban line graphs, the kerosene line slopes downward as time moves from 1983 to 2023 (rural: from about \( 80\% \) down to nearly \( 0\% \); urban: from about \( 35\% \) down to nearly \( 0\% \)). A falling line means the share is decreasing, so kerosene use as a primary lighting source has decreased over time in both rural and urban areas.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: A line graph shows the percentage of households using wood as a cooking fuel over 5 years (2000 to 2020) in two regions — hilly areas and coastal areas. In hilly areas, the percentages recorded were: 2000: 80%, 2005: 74%, 2010: 65%, 2015: 55%, 2020: 42%. In coastal areas, the percentages recorded were: 2000: 60%, 2005: 52%, 2010: 43%, 2015: 35%, 2020: 25%. A student claims: 'The use of wood as a cooking fuel has decreased over time in both hilly and coastal areas, and coastal areas always had a lower percentage than hilly areas.' Is this statement valid? Justify your answer using the data.

Solution: Step 1: Check whether wood-fuel use decreased in hilly areas over time. The percentages for hilly areas are: 80%, 74%, 65%, 55%, 42%. Each value is less than the previous one, so the trend is strictly decreasing. Decrease from 2000 to 2020 in hilly areas: \[80 - 42 = 38 \text{ percentage points}\] This confirms a consistent decrease in hilly areas. Step 2: Check whether wood-fuel use decreased in coastal areas over time. The percentages for coastal areas are: 60%, 52%, 43%, 35%, 25%. Again, each value is less than the previous one, confirming a strictly decreasing trend. Decrease from 2000 to 2020 in coastal areas: \[60 - 25 = 35 \text{ percentage points}\] This confirms a consistent decrease in coastal areas as well. Step 3: Compare hilly and coastal values at each year. At 2000: Hilly \(= 80\%\), Coastal \(= 60\%\). Since \(80 > 60\), hilly is higher. At 2005: Hilly \(= 74\%\), Coastal \(= 52\%\). Since \(74 > 52\), hilly is higher. At 2010: Hilly \(= 65\%\), Coastal \(= 43\%\). Since \(65 > 43\), hilly is higher. At 2015: Hilly \(= 55\%\), Coastal \(= 35\%\). Since \(55 > 35\), hilly is higher. At 2020: Hilly \(= 42\%\), Coastal \(= 25\%\). Since \(42 > 25\), hilly is higher. At every recorded year, the coastal percentage is lower than the hilly percentage. Step 4: Conclusion. Both parts of the student's statement are supported by the graph data. The statement is valid.

Answer: The statement is VALID. The line graph shows a clear decreasing trend in both regions from 2000 to 2020, and the coastal area percentage is lower than the hilly area percentage at every recorded year.

Example 2

Question: A line graph tracks the number of students (in hundreds) travelling by bicycle to school over four years in two cities — City A and City B. The data is: Year 2018: City A = 12 hundred, City B = 9 hundred. Year 2019: City A = 15 hundred, City B = 11 hundred. Year 2020: City A = 13 hundred, City B = 14 hundred. Year 2021: City A = 18 hundred, City B = 16 hundred. A student makes the following statement: 'The number of students travelling by bicycle increased every year in both cities, and City A always had more students cycling than City B.' Examine whether this statement is valid. Give reasons.

Solution: Step 1: Check whether the number increased every year in City A. City A values (in hundreds): 12, 15, 13, 18. From 2018 to 2019: \(15 - 12 = 3\) (increase — correct). From 2019 to 2020: \(13 - 15 = -2\) (decrease — this is NOT an increase). From 2020 to 2021: \(18 - 13 = 5\) (increase — correct). So City A did NOT show an increase every year. There was a drop from 2019 to 2020. Step 2: Check whether the number increased every year in City B. City B values (in hundreds): 9, 11, 14, 16. From 2018 to 2019: \(11 - 9 = 2\) (increase). From 2019 to 2020: \(14 - 11 = 3\) (increase). From 2020 to 2021: \(16 - 14 = 2\) (increase). City B showed a consistent increase every year — this part is correct for City B. Step 3: Check whether City A always had more students cycling than City B. At 2018: City A \(= 12\), City B \(= 9\). Since \(12 > 9\), City A is higher. At 2019: City A \(= 15\), City B \(= 11\). Since \(15 > 11\), City A is higher. At 2020: City A \(= 13\), City B \(= 14\). Since \(13 < 14\), City B is higher here — City A is NOT higher. At 2021: City A \(= 18\), City B \(= 16\). Since \(18 > 16\), City A is higher. So in 2020, City B actually had more cycling students than City A, which means the second part of the statement is also false for that year. Step 4: Conclusion. The statement has two claims. The first claim (increase every year in both cities) is false because City A decreased from 2019 to 2020. The second claim (City A always higher) is false because in 2020, City B had more cycling students. Therefore, the overall statement is NOT valid.

Answer: The statement is NOT VALID. City A's count dropped from 15 hundred in 2019 to 13 hundred in 2020 (not an increase), and in 2020 City B (14 hundred) had more cycling students than City A (13 hundred), contradicting both claims.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: A line graph shows the percentage of households using solar panels as their primary energy source from 2000 to 2020. In rural areas, the percentage rose from about \( 5\\% \) in 2000 to about \( 45\\% \) in 2020. In urban areas, the percentage rose from about \( 15\\% \) in 2000 to about \( 60\\% \) in 2020. A student makes the following statement: 'The use of solar panels as a primary energy source has increased over time in rural areas but has remained unchanged in urban areas.' Is this statement VALID or INVALID? Justify your answer by referring to the trends shown in the graph.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Examine the rural area trend: According to the graph, the percentage of rural households using solar panels as their primary energy source increased from \( 5\\% \) in 2000 to \( 45\\% \) in 2020. Since the line slopes upward for rural areas, the rural part of the student's statement — that usage has increased over time — is CORRECT.
  2. Step 2: Examine the urban area trend: According to the graph, the percentage of urban households using solar panels increased from \( 15\\% \) in 2000 to \( 60\\% \) in 2020. Since the line also slopes upward for urban areas, the urban part of the student's statement — that usage has remained unchanged — is INCORRECT. Urban usage has clearly increased, not remained the same.
  3. Step 3: Evaluate the overall statement: A statement is VALID only if every part of it is supported by the graph. The rural claim is supported, but the urban claim is not — the urban line rises sharply rather than staying flat. Therefore, the overall statement is INVALID.

Answer: The statement is INVALID. While the rural area line does slope upward (from about \( 5\\% \) to about \( 45\\% \)), confirming an increase in rural solar panel use, the urban area line also slopes upward (from about \( 15\\% \) to about \( 60\\% \)), showing a clear increase — not an unchanged trend. Since the urban portion of the statement contradicts the graph, the entire statement is invalid.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Tales By Dots And Lines