SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 3 Q10(i)

Referring to the graph below, which of the following statements are valid\(?\) Why\(?\) In \(1983,\) the majority in rural areas used kerosene as a primary lighting source while the majority in urban areas used electricity.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Tales By Dots And Lines

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine two pictures that show how people cooked their food long ago. One picture is for villages, one for cities. Each picture has lines going up and down to show how popular kerosene or electricity was. We look only at the year 1983. In villages, kerosene was used by about \( 80\% \) of people — way more than half! In cities, electricity was used by about \( 65\% \) of people — also more than half! So both things the statement says are correct.

Answer: The statement is VALID. In 1983 the rural graph shows kerosene at about \( 80\% \) (greater than \( 50\% \)), so kerosene is the majority rural source, and the urban graph shows electricity at about \( 65\% \) (greater than \( 50\% \)), so electricity is the majority urban source. Both claims are true.

📖 Reading Line Graphs: Energy Sources in 1983

Detailed Explanation

This is a data-handling question based on line graphs. A line graph shows how a quantity changes over time. Here, two graphs are given: one for Rural areas and one for Urban areas. Each graph has two lines, one for Electricity and one for Kerosene, and the vertical axis shows the percentage share of households (from 0 percent to 100 percent) while the horizontal axis shows the year (from 1983 to 2023). To check the statement, we only read the values of each line in the year 1983. The word majority means more than half, that is a value greater than \( 50\% \).

Formula Used

Majority means a share greater than \( 50\% \). To read a line graph value: find the year on the horizontal axis, go straight up to the line, then move across to the vertical axis to read the percentage.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what to check: The statement makes two claims about the year 1983. First, that in RURAL areas kerosene was the majority source. Second, that in URBAN areas electricity was the majority source. Both claims must be true for the whole statement to be valid. So we read the graphs only at the year 1983.
  2. Step 2: Read the Rural graph at 1983: In the Rural graph at 1983, the Kerosene line starts high, at about \( 80\% \), and the Electricity line starts low, at about \( 15\% \). Since \( 80\% \) is much greater than \( 50\% \), kerosene is used by the majority in rural areas in 1983. So the first claim is TRUE.
  3. Step 3: Read the Urban graph at 1983: In the Urban graph at 1983, the Electricity line starts at about \( 65\% \) and the Kerosene line starts at about \( 35\% \). Since \( 65\% \) is greater than \( 50\% \), electricity is used by the majority in urban areas in 1983. So the second claim is also TRUE.
  4. Step 4: Combine both claims: Both parts of the statement are supported by the graphs. In rural areas kerosene share \( \approx 80\% \) is the majority, and in urban areas electricity share \( \approx 65\% \) is the majority. Therefore the complete statement is valid.

Final Answer

The statement is VALID. In 1983 the rural graph shows kerosene at about \( 80\% \) (greater than \( 50\% \)), so kerosene is the majority rural source, and the urban graph shows electricity at about \( 65\% \) (greater than \( 50\% \)), so electricity is the majority urban source. Both claims are true.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to read the graphs at the wrong year (for example at 2023, where the lines have crossed over) instead of at 1983. Always locate the exact year first, then go up to the line and across to the percentage axis before deciding.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the two claims inside the statement. The statement says two things about the year 1983: (a) in RURAL areas, kerosene was the majority cooking-fuel source, and (b) in URBAN areas, electricity was the majority source. Both (a) and (b) must be true for the overall statement to be valid. — Reason: Breaking a compound statement into its individual claims makes it easy to verify each one separately before drawing a conclusion.
  2. Step 2: Define what 'majority' means numerically. A source is the majority source when more than half of households use it, i.e. its percentage share is greater than \( 50\% \). — Reason: Having a clear numerical threshold prevents guesswork when reading the graph.
  3. Step 3: Read the Rural graph at the year 1983. Locate 1983 on the horizontal axis, move vertically up to the Kerosene line, then read across to the vertical axis. The Kerosene line sits at approximately \( 80\% \), while the Electricity line sits at approximately \( 15\% \). Since \( 80\% > 50\% \), kerosene is the majority rural source in 1983. Claim (a) is TRUE. — Reason: Directly reading the graph at the required year gives us the evidence needed to judge claim (a).
  4. Step 4: Read the Urban graph at the year 1983. Locate 1983 on the horizontal axis, move vertically up to the Electricity line, then read across to the vertical axis. The Electricity line sits at approximately \( 65\% \), while the Kerosene line sits at a much lower value. Since \( 65\% > 50\% \), electricity is the majority urban source in 1983. Claim (b) is TRUE. — Reason: Repeating the same graph-reading method for the Urban graph lets us judge claim (b) with the same rigour.
  5. Step 5: Combine the results of both checks. Claim (a): Kerosene rural share \( \approx 80\% > 50\% \) — TRUE. Claim (b): Electricity urban share \( \approx 65\% > 50\% \) — TRUE. Since both individual claims are true, the overall statement is VALID. — Reason: A compound statement is valid only when every part of it holds; here, both parts hold, so we confirm validity.

Final Answer

The statement is VALID. In 1983 the rural graph shows kerosene at about \( 80\% \) (greater than \( 50\% \)), so kerosene is the majority rural source, and the urban graph shows electricity at about \( 65\% \) (greater than \( 50\% \)), so electricity is the majority urban source. Both claims are true.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students sometimes read the graph at the wrong year (for example, at 2023 instead of 1983) and conclude the statement is false, because by 2023 the trends have reversed. Always identify the specific year mentioned in the statement before reading any values.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Rural graph at 1983: Kerosene \( \approx 80\% \), and \( 80\% > 50\% \), so kerosene is the majority rural source. Claim 1: TRUE.
  2. Step 2: Urban graph at 1983: Electricity \( \approx 65\% \), and \( 65\% > 50\% \), so electricity is the majority urban source. Claim 2: TRUE.
  3. Step 3: Both claims TRUE, so the statement is VALID.

Answer: The statement is VALID. In 1983 the rural graph shows kerosene at about \( 80\% \) (greater than \( 50\% \)), so kerosene is the majority rural source, and the urban graph shows electricity at about \( 65\% \) (greater than \( 50\% \)), so electricity is the majority urban source. Both claims are true.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: A double bar graph shows the number of students (in hundreds) in a district who prefer different modes of transport to school — cycle, bus, and walking — for two years: 2010 and 2020. The data is as follows: \nCycle: 2010 = 5, 2020 = 3\nBus: 2010 = 2, 2020 = 6\nWalking: 2010 = 3, 2020 = 1 \nTotal students in 2010 = 10 (hundreds). Total students in 2020 = 10 (hundreds). \nState whether the following statement is valid and give a reason: "In 2010, the majority of students preferred cycling to school, while in 2020, the majority preferred the bus."

Solution: Step 1: Find the total number of students in each year. \nTotal in 2010 = \( 5 + 2 + 3 = 10 \) hundreds. \nTotal in 2020 = \( 3 + 6 + 1 = 10 \) hundreds. \nStep 2: Check the majority for 2010. \nFor a majority, a group must account for more than half the total. Half of 10 is \( 5 \). The number preferring cycling in 2010 is exactly 5 hundreds, which equals half but does not strictly exceed half. \nStep 3: Check the majority for 2020. \nThe number preferring bus in 2020 is 6 hundreds. Half of 10 is 5, and since \( 6 > 5 \), the bus group is indeed the majority. \nStep 4: Evaluate the statement. \nThe second part (majority preferred bus in 2020) is VALID because \( 6 > 5 \). The first part (majority preferred cycling in 2010) is NOT strictly valid because the cycle group equals exactly half (\( 5 \) out of \( 10 \)) and a majority requires strictly more than half. So the statement as a whole is only partially valid — the 2020 claim is correct, but the 2010 claim is not precisely correct.

Answer: The statement is partially valid. The claim about 2020 (majority preferred bus) is valid because 6 out of 10 is more than half. The claim about 2010 (majority preferred cycling) is NOT valid because 5 out of 10 is exactly half, not a majority.

Example 2

Question: A pie chart shows how 200 families in a town use their primary source of drinking water. The number of families for each source is: \nTap water: 120 families\nWell: 50 families\nHandpump: 30 families \nState whether the following statement is valid and give a reason: "The majority of families in the town use tap water as their primary source of drinking water."

Solution: Step 1: Find the total number of families. \nTotal = \( 120 + 50 + 30 = 200 \) families. \nStep 2: Determine what constitutes a majority. \nA majority means more than half the total. Half of 200 is \( 100 \). \nStep 3: Check whether tap water users form a majority. \nNumber of families using tap water = 120. \nSince \( 120 > 100 \), the tap water group forms more than half of the total. \nStep 4: Find the percentage of families using tap water as a check. \[ \text{Percentage} = \frac{120}{200} \times 100 = 60\\% \] \nSince \( 60\\% > 50\\% \), this confirms the majority. \nStep 5: Evaluate the statement. \nThe statement is VALID. Out of 200 families, 120 (i.e., 60%) use tap water, which is more than half.

Answer: The statement is valid. 120 out of 200 families use tap water, which is 60% — clearly more than half, so tap water users form the majority.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: A survey conducted in 1995 recorded the primary cooking fuel used by households in rural and urban areas. The data, shown in a double bar graph, gave the following approximate percentages: In rural areas — firewood: \( 72\% \), LPG: \( 18\% \), others: \( 10\% \). In urban areas — firewood: \( 28\% \), LPG: \( 62\% \), others: \( 10\% \). A student makes the following statement: 'In 1995, the majority in rural areas used LPG as a primary cooking fuel, while the majority in urban areas used firewood.' Is this statement VALID or INVALID? Justify your answer with the data given.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what 'majority' means: A majority means more than half, i.e., more than \( 50\% \) of the total households surveyed. So we check whether each claimed fuel exceeds \( 50\% \) in its respective area.
  2. Step 2: Check the rural area claim: The student claims that LPG is the majority fuel in rural areas. From the graph, LPG usage in rural areas is approximately \( 18\% \). Since \( 18\% < 50\% \), LPG is NOT the majority rural fuel. In fact, firewood at \( 72\% \) is the majority rural fuel.
  3. Step 3: Check the urban area claim: The student claims that firewood is the majority fuel in urban areas. From the graph, firewood usage in urban areas is approximately \( 28\% \). Since \( 28\% < 50\% \), firewood is NOT the majority urban fuel. In fact, LPG at \( 62\% \) is the majority urban fuel.
  4. Step 4: Conclude whether the statement is valid or invalid: Both parts of the student's statement are incorrect. The rural majority fuel is firewood (\( 72\% \)), not LPG (\( 18\% \)), and the urban majority fuel is LPG (\( 62\% \)), not firewood (\( 28\% \)). Therefore, the statement is INVALID.

Answer: The statement is INVALID. The rural graph shows firewood at approximately \( 72\% \) (greater than \( 50\% \)), making firewood the majority rural fuel — not LPG at \( 18\% \). The urban graph shows LPG at approximately \( 62\% \) (greater than \( 50\% \)), making LPG the majority urban fuel — not firewood at \( 28\% \). Both claims in the student's statement are false.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Tales By Dots And Lines