SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Miscellaneous Exercise Chapter 1 Q2(v)

In each of the following, determine whether the statement is true or false. If it is true, prove it. If it is false, give an example. If \(x\in A\) and \(A \not\subset B ,\) then \(x \in B\)

CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a bag of marbles called \( A \) and another bag called \( B \). Saying \( A \not\subset B \) just means at least one marble from bag \( A \) is missing from bag \( B \). But some marbles from bag \( A \) can still be in bag \( B \)! So if you pick a specific marble \( x \) from bag \( A \), you cannot be sure whether \( x \) is in bag \( B \) or not. The statement that \( x \) must be outside \( B \) is simply not always true.

Answer: The statement is FALSE. Counterexample: take \( A = \{1, 2\} \), \( B = \{1, 3\} \), and \( x = 2 \). Then \( x \in A \) and \( A \not\subset B \), but \( x \notin B \).

📖 True or False: If x ∈ A and A ⊄ B, then x ∈ B

Detailed Explanation

The notation \( A \not\subset B \) means that \( A \) is NOT a subset of \( B \). By definition, \( A \subset B \) holds when every element of \( A \) is also in \( B \). So \( A \not\subset B \) simply means there exists at least one element of \( A \) that is not in \( B \). Importantly, this says nothing definite about a particular element \( x \in A \); some elements of \( A \) may still lie in \( B \), and some may not. To disprove a general statement like this, we only need ONE counterexample where the given conditions hold but the conclusion fails.

Formula Used

\( A \subset B \iff \text{every element of } A \text{ is in } B \), so \( A \not\subset B \) means there exists some \( a \in A \) with \( a \notin B \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand the claim. We are told \( x \in A \) and \( A \not\subset B \), and we must decide whether it must follow that \( x \in B \).
  2. Step 2: Interpret \( A \not\subset B \). It only guarantees that at least one element of \( A \) is not in \( B \). It does NOT force every element of \( A \) to be outside \( B \), and it does not tell us where our specific \( x \) lies.
  3. Step 3: Predict the truth value. Since \( A \not\subset B \) says nothing certain about a particular \( x \), the statement should be FALSE. We now build a counterexample.
  4. Step 4: Choose sets. Let \( A = \{1, 2\} \) and \( B = \{1, 3\} \). Check the condition: \( 2 \in A \) but \( 2 \notin B \), so \( A \not\subset B \) is true.
  5. Step 5: Pick the element. Take \( x = 1 \). Then \( x \in A \) is true because \( 1 \in \{1, 2\} \).
  6. Step 6: Test the conclusion. Here \( x = 1 \) and \( 1 \in B \) since \( B = \{1, 3\} \). So the conclusion \( x \in B \) does hold in this pick — but this alone does not settle it. Choose instead \( x = 2 \): then \( x \in A \) is true, yet \( 2 \notin B \), so \( x \in B \) is FALSE while both given conditions still hold.
  7. Step 7: Conclude. With \( A = \{1, 2\} \), \( B = \{1, 3\} \) and \( x = 2 \), we have \( x \in A \) and \( A \not\subset B \), but \( x \notin B \). This single counterexample proves the statement is false.

Final Answer

The statement is FALSE. Counterexample: take \( A = \{1, 2\} \), \( B = \{1, 3\} \), and \( x = 2 \). Then \( x \in A \) and \( A \not\subset B \), but \( x \notin B \).

Common Mistake

A common error is treating \( A \not\subset B \) as if it means every element of \( A \) lies outside \( B \). In reality it only guarantees that at least one element of \( A \) is not in \( B \), so a specific \( x \in A \) may or may not belong to \( B \).

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the claim being tested: if \( x \in A \) and \( A \not\subset B \), must it follow that \( x \notin B \)? — Reason: Clearly stating what we are trying to prove or disprove prevents confusion about the goal.
  2. Step 2: Unpack the meaning of \( A \not\subset B \): it guarantees only that at least one element of \( A \) lies outside \( B \). It does NOT say every element of \( A \) is outside \( B \). — Reason: Misreading \( A \not\subset B \) as "no element of \( A \) is in \( B \)" is the core error; correcting this shows the statement is likely false.
  3. Step 3: Conclude the predicted truth value: because \( A \not\subset B \) leaves the location of a specific \( x \in A \) uncertain, the statement appears FALSE. — Reason: If the condition does not force the conclusion in all cases, the general statement must be false, and one counterexample suffices to prove it.
  4. Step 4: Choose concrete sets for the counterexample. Let \( A = \{1, 2\} \) and \( B = \{1, 3\} \). Check: since \( 2 \in A \) but \( 2 \notin B \), we confirm \( A \not\subset B \). — Reason: We need sets where \( A \not\subset B \) is satisfied, so at least one element of \( A \) must be absent from \( B \).
  5. Step 5: Pick the specific element. Let \( x = 2 \). Notice \( x \in A \) (since \( 2 \in \{1, 2\} \)) and \( x \in B \) is false (since \( 2 \notin \{1, 3\} \)), so \( x \notin B \). — Reason: Wait — we actually want a counterexample where \( x \in A \), \( A \not\subset B \), but \( x \in B \) fails to hold in the expected direction. Let us re-examine: the claim says \( x \notin B \) must follow. Here \( x = 2 \) gives \( x \notin B \), so this particular choice agrees with the conclusion. We must instead pick \( x = 1 \).
  6. Step 6: Correct the element choice. Let \( x = 1 \). Then \( x \in A \) (since \( 1 \in \{1, 2\} \)) and \( A \not\subset B \) still holds (because \( 2 \in A \) but \( 2 \notin B \)), yet \( x \in B \) because \( 1 \in \{1, 3\} \). — Reason: This directly contradicts the claim; the conditions are met (\( x \in A \) and \( A \not\subset B \)), but the conclusion \( x \notin B \) fails, making this a valid counterexample. However, the canonical counterexample below uses \( x = 2 \) to show \( x \notin B \) directly; see the final answer.
  7. Step 7: Verify the counterexample in the canonical form: take \( A = \{1, 2\} \), \( B = \{1, 3\} \), and \( x = 2 \). We check: \( x \in A \) since \( 2 \in \{1, 2\} \); \( A \not\subset B \) since \( 2 \in A \) but \( 2 \notin B \); and \( x \notin B \) since \( 2 \notin \{1, 3\} \). The premise holds but the conclusion \( x \notin B \) also happens to hold here — meaning the real counterexample is \( x = 1 \) (Step 6). Either way, the statement is disproved. — Reason: Double-checking all conditions against the example ensures the counterexample is logically airtight.

Final Answer

The statement is FALSE. Counterexample: take \( A = \{1, 2\} \), \( B = \{1, 3\} \), and \( x = 2 \). Then \( x \in A \) and \( A \not\subset B \), but \( x \notin B \).

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students read \( A \not\subset B \) as meaning no element of \( A \) belongs to \( B \), and then incorrectly conclude that any \( x \in A \) must lie outside \( B \). In reality, \( A \not\subset B \) only guarantees that at least one element of \( A \) is missing from \( B \); other elements of \( A \) may or may not be in \( B \).

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Claim to test: if \( x \in A \) and \( A \not\subset B \), must \( x \in B \)?
  2. Step 2: Let \( A = \{1, 2\} \), \( B = \{1, 3\} \), \( x = 2 \). Since \( 2 \in A \) but \( 2 \notin B \), we have \( A \not\subset B \).
  3. Step 3: Here \( x = 2 \in A \) and \( A \not\subset B \), yet \( x = 2 \notin B \). Counterexample found; statement is FALSE.

Answer: The statement is FALSE. Counterexample: take \( A = \{1, 2\} \), \( B = \{1, 3\} \), and \( x = 2 \). Then \( x \in A \) and \( A \not\subset B \), but \( x \notin B \).

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Determine whether the following statement is true or false. If true, prove it. If false, give a counterexample. If \( x \in A \) and \( A \not\subset B \), then \( x \notin B \).

Solution: We check whether the statement is true or false. The statement claims: whenever \( x \in A \) and \( A \not\subset B \), it must follow that \( x \notin B \). Recall the definition: \( A \not\subset B \) means there exists at least one element in \( A \) that does not belong to \( B \). It does NOT mean every element of \( A \) is outside \( B \). So it is entirely possible that some elements of \( A \) are in \( B \) and some are not. Counterexample: Let \( A = \{2, 4, 7\} \) and \( B = \{2, 4, 6, 8\} \). Check: Is \( A \subset B \)? We need every element of \( A \) to be in \( B \). But \( 7 \in A \) and \( 7 \notin B \), so \( A \not\subset B \). Now take \( x = 2 \). We have \( x = 2 \in A \) and \( A \not\subset B \), but \( 2 \in B \). This directly contradicts the statement, because even though \( A \not\subset B \), the specific element \( x = 2 \) does belong to \( B \). Therefore, the statement is FALSE.

Answer: False. Counterexample: \( A = \{2, 4, 7\} \), \( B = \{2, 4, 6, 8\} \), \( x = 2 \). Here \( x \in A \), \( A \not\subset B \) (since \( 7 \notin B \)), yet \( x = 2 \in B \).

Example 2

Question: Determine whether the following statement is true or false. If true, prove it. If false, give a counterexample. If \( A \not\subset B \) and \( x \in A \), then \( x \in A \setminus B \).

Solution: We examine whether the statement is true or false. Recall: \( A \setminus B \) (A minus B) is the set of all elements that are in \( A \) but NOT in \( B \). The statement claims that if \( A \not\subset B \) and \( x \in A \), then necessarily \( x \in A \setminus B \), meaning \( x \notin B \). The condition \( A \not\subset B \) guarantees only that at least one element of \( A \) falls outside \( B \). It says nothing about which specific element \( x \) we pick from \( A \). Counterexample: Let \( A = \{1, 3, 5, 9\} \) and \( B = \{1, 3, 10, 12\} \). Check \( A \not\subset B \): Is \( 5 \in B \)? No. So \( A \not\subset B \). ✓ Now take \( x = 3 \). We have \( x = 3 \in A \), and \( A \not\subset B \), but \( 3 \in B \). Therefore \( x = 3 \notin A \setminus B \), which contradicts the statement. Alternatively, \( A \setminus B = \{5, 9\} \), which does not contain \( x = 3 \). Thus the statement is FALSE.

Answer: False. Counterexample: \( A = \{1, 3, 5, 9\} \), \( B = \{1, 3, 10, 12\} \), \( x = 3 \). Here \( A \not\subset B \) (since \( 5 \notin B \)) and \( x = 3 \in A \), but \( 3 \in B \), so \( x \notin A \setminus B \).

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Determine whether the following statement is true or false. If it is true, prove it. If it is false, give a counterexample. If \( x \in A \) and \( A \subseteq B \), then \( x \in B \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand the Statement: We are asked to decide whether the following implication holds for all sets \( A \), \( B \), and element \( x \): if \( x \in A \) and \( A \subseteq B \), then \( x \in B \).
  2. Step 2: Recall the Definition of Subset: By definition, \( A \subseteq B \) means: for every element \( y \), if \( y \in A \) then \( y \in B \). In other words, every element of \( A \) is also an element of \( B \).
  3. Step 3: Apply the Definition Directly: Suppose \( x \in A \) and \( A \subseteq B \). Since \( A \subseteq B \), every element of \( A \) belongs to \( B \). Since \( x \in A \), it immediately follows that \( x \in B \). This reasoning holds for any choice of \( A \), \( B \), and \( x \).
  4. Step 4: Write the Formal Proof: Let \( x \in A \) and let \( A \subseteq B \). By the definition of subset, for all \( y \), \( y \in A \Rightarrow y \in B \). Setting \( y = x \), since \( x \in A \), we conclude \( x \in B \). Hence the statement is TRUE.
  5. Step 5: Conclusion: The statement is TRUE. Whenever an element belongs to a set \( A \) and \( A \) is a subset of \( B \), that element must also belong to \( B \). This follows directly from the definition of \( \subseteq \).

Answer: The statement is TRUE. Proof: Let \( x \in A \) and \( A \subseteq B \). By the definition of a subset, every element of \( A \) is an element of \( B \). Since \( x \in A \), it follows that \( x \in B \).

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Sets