SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Exercise 1.1 Q1(ii)

Which of the following are sets ? Justify your answer. The collection of ten most talented writers of India

CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine your teacher asks everyone to point to the 'most beautiful painting' in the room. Some kids will pick different ones! That is because 'beautiful' means different things to different people. A set in maths must have clear, agreed rules so everyone picks the same members. Words like 'talented' work the same way — your favourite writer may not be mine. Because two people can disagree on who belongs, the group has no fixed boundary and cannot be called a proper set.

Answer: The collection of the ten most talented writers of India is NOT a set, because 'talented' is a subjective term. Membership depends on personal opinion, so the collection is not well-defined.

📖 Is 'Ten Most Talented Writers of India' a Set?

Detailed Explanation

In mathematics, a set is a well-defined collection of objects. 'Well-defined' means that given any object, we can decide with certainty and without personal opinion whether it belongs to the collection or not. If the membership depends on someone's judgement, taste, or opinion, then the collection is NOT well-defined and therefore NOT a set. The word 'talented' is subjective — different people will judge talent differently, so there is no fixed rule to decide which writers qualify.

Formula Used

A collection is a set if and only if it is well-defined, i.e. for every object we can clearly say whether it belongs to the collection \( (\in) \) or not \( (\notin) \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Recall the definition. A collection is a set only if it is well-defined, meaning membership can be decided objectively for every possible object.
  2. Step 2: Examine the given collection: 'the ten most talented writers of India'. The key word here is 'talented'.
  3. Step 3: Ask whether 'talented' has a fixed, agreed meaning. Talent is a matter of opinion — one reader may find a writer talented while another does not. There is no standard rule to rank writers by talent.
  4. Step 4: Since we cannot definitely decide whether a particular writer belongs to this collection or not, the collection is not well-defined.
  5. Step 5: Because the collection fails the well-defined test, it does not satisfy the definition of a set.

Final Answer

The collection of the ten most talented writers of India is NOT a set, because 'talented' is a subjective term. Membership depends on personal opinion, so the collection is not well-defined.

Common Mistake

Students often think that because a number (ten) is mentioned, the collection is automatically a set. But the fixed number does not make it well-defined — the vague, opinion-based word 'talented' is what disqualifies it as a set.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Recall the definition of a set: a collection is called a set only when it is well-defined. — Reason: This is the foundation of set theory in Class 11; without checking this condition, we cannot classify any collection.
  2. Step 2: Identify the given collection: 'the ten most talented writers of India'. Write down the key word that describes membership. — Reason: Pinpointing the descriptive word helps us judge whether the membership rule is objective or subjective.
  3. Step 3: Examine the word 'talented'. Ask: does 'talented' have a single, universally agreed-upon meaning that everyone would apply the same way? — Reason: For a collection to be well-defined, every observer must reach the same yes-or-no decision about each object.
  4. Step 4: Conclude that 'talented' is subjective: one reader may consider a particular writer talented while another reader may not. There is no fixed, standard rule for ranking writers by talent. — Reason: Because different people judge talent differently, there is no single objective criterion to decide \( x \in \text{collection} \) or \( x \notin \text{collection} \).
  5. Step 5: Since membership cannot be decided objectively for every writer, the collection fails the well-defined test. — Reason: A collection that fails the well-defined test cannot be called a set, regardless of how many elements it is said to contain.

Final Answer

The collection of the ten most talented writers of India is NOT a set, because 'talented' is a subjective term. Membership depends on personal opinion, so the collection is not well-defined.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students assume that because a specific number (ten) is mentioned, the collection must be a set. However, having a fixed size does not make a collection well-defined — it is the objectivity of the membership rule, not the count, that matters.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Check the key word: 'talented' — subjective, no fixed rule to decide membership.
  2. Step 2: Since different people judge talent differently, we cannot objectively say a writer belongs \( \in \) or does not belong \( \notin \) to the collection.
  3. Step 3: Collection fails the well-defined test ⟹ NOT a set.

Answer: The collection of the ten most talented writers of India is NOT a set, because 'talented' is a subjective term. Membership depends on personal opinion, so the collection is not well-defined.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Is the following a set? Justify your answer: The collection of five most courageous soldiers of India.

Solution: We need to check whether the collection is well-defined, i.e., whether there is a clear and objective criterion to decide who belongs to the collection. The term 'most courageous' is subjective — different people may rank soldiers differently based on their own opinions, values, or knowledge. There is no universally agreed-upon method to identify exactly the five most courageous soldiers. Since the membership of this collection depends on personal judgment and is not objectively determinable, the collection is NOT well-defined. Hence, the collection of five most courageous soldiers of India is NOT a set.

Answer: Not a set, because 'most courageous' is a subjective criterion and the collection is not well-defined.

Example 2

Question: Is the following a set? Justify your answer: The collection of all months of a year having exactly 30 days.

Solution: We need to check whether the collection is well-defined, i.e., whether there is a clear and objective criterion to decide which months belong to the collection. A month either has exactly 30 days or it does not — this is a fixed, universally agreed-upon fact independent of any personal opinion. The months with exactly 30 days are: April, June, September, and November. Since we can objectively and unambiguously determine which months belong to this collection, the collection IS well-defined. Hence, the collection of all months of a year having exactly 30 days IS a set. We can write it as: \( \{ \text{April, June, September, November} \} \)

Answer: It is a set, because the criterion 'having exactly 30 days' is objective and well-defined. The set is {April, June, September, November}.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Which of the following is a set? Justify your answer. The collection of all students in your class who are good at cricket.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Recall the definition of a set: A set is a well-defined collection of objects. 'Well-defined' means that for any given object, we can say with certainty and without ambiguity whether it belongs to the collection or not.
  2. Step 2: Examine the collection: The collection asks for students who are 'good at cricket.' The word 'good' is a subjective term — different people may have different opinions about what counts as being good at cricket. There is no universally accepted, objective criterion.
  3. Step 3: Check whether the collection is well-defined: Because 'good at cricket' depends on personal judgment, two different people could look at the same student and disagree about whether that student belongs to the collection. There is no clear, objective rule to decide membership.
  4. Step 4: Conclusion: Since the membership of this collection cannot be determined objectively and unambiguously, the collection is NOT well-defined. Therefore, the collection of all students in your class who are good at cricket is NOT a set.

Answer: The collection of all students in your class who are good at cricket is NOT a set. The term 'good at cricket' is subjective and depends on personal opinion, so the collection is not well-defined.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Sets