SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Chapter 1 Examples Q11

Let \(A, B\) and \(C\) be three sets. If \(A\in B\) and \(B\subset C,\) is it true that \(A\subset C?\) If not, give an example.

CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a box inside a big bag, and the bag is inside a room. The box is inside the bag, but the box is not the same as the bag. Being inside something is very different from being part of something. Here, \( A \in B \) means the whole set \( A \) is like one single toy sitting inside a toy box called \( B \). Even if \( B \) fits inside \( C \), the pieces inside \( A \) are not loose inside \( C \). So \( A \subset C \) is not guaranteed.

Answer: No, it is not true that \( A \subset C \). For example, with \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{\{1\}, 2\} \), \( C = \{\{1\}, 2, 3\} \), we have \( A \in B \) and \( B \subset C \), but \( A \not\subset C \) because \( 1 \notin C \).

📖 Does A ∈ B and B ⊂ C imply A ⊂ C?

Detailed Explanation

In set theory, two very different relationships are often confused. The symbol \( \in \) means 'is an element of', so \( A \in B \) means that the whole set \( A \) is treated as a single element sitting inside \( B \). The symbol \( \subset \) means 'is a subset of', so \( B \subset C \) means every element of \( B \) is also an element of \( C \). The claim \( A \subset C \) would require every element of \( A \) to be an element of \( C \). Since \( A \in B \) only tells us \( A \) is one element of \( B \), and \( B \subset C \) only guarantees that \( A \) as an element belongs to \( C \), we get \( A \in C \), not necessarily \( A \subset C \). Being an element of a set is not the same as being a subset of that set.

Formula Used

\( A \in B \) means A is an element of B. \( B \subset C \) means every element of B is in C. \( A \subset C \) means every element of A is in C.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what is given. We are told \( A \in B \), meaning the set \( A \) is an element of \( B \). We are also told \( B \subset C \), meaning every element of \( B \) also lies in \( C \).
  2. Step 2: Understand what we must check. The statement to verify is \( A \subset C \), which would require every element of \( A \) to be an element of \( C \). This is a completely different condition from \( A \in C \).
  3. Step 3: Combine the given facts. Since \( A \in B \) and \( B \subset C \), the element \( A \) of \( B \) must also lie in \( C \). Hence we can only conclude \( A \in C \), not \( A \subset C \).
  4. Step 4: Construct a counterexample. Let \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{\{1\}, 2\} \), and \( C = \{\{1\}, 2, 3\} \). Here \( A = \{1\} \) is an element of \( B \), so \( A \in B \) holds.
  5. Step 5: Check the subset condition. Every element of \( B \), namely \( \{1\} \) and \( 2 \), is also in \( C \). So \( B \subset C \) holds.
  6. Step 6: Test the claim. Is \( A \subset C \)? The element of \( A \) is \( 1 \). But \( 1 \notin C \), since \( C \) contains \( \{1\} \) (a set) not \( 1 \) itself. Therefore \( A \not\subset C \), and the statement is false.

Final Answer

No, it is not true that \( A \subset C \). For example, with \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{\{1\}, 2\} \), \( C = \{\{1\}, 2, 3\} \), we have \( A \in B \) and \( B \subset C \), but \( A \not\subset C \) because \( 1 \notin C \).

Common Mistake

A common mistake is treating \( \in \) and \( \subset \) as the same and writing \( A \subset B \) from \( A \in B \). Membership means \( A \) is a single element inside \( B \), which is very different from \( A \) being a subset of \( B \).

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Unpack the first given condition: \( A \in B \). This tells us that the entire set \( A \) is treated as one single object and placed inside \( B \) as one of its elements. — Reason: Distinguishing \( \in \) from \( \subset \) right at the start prevents the most common confusion in this type of problem.
  2. Step 2: Unpack the second given condition: \( B \subset C \). This means every element listed in \( B \) is also an element of \( C \). Since \( A \) is one such element of \( B \), combining both conditions gives us \( A \in C \). — Reason: This is the only conclusion that is logically guaranteed; we must not jump to a stronger claim.
  3. Step 3: Identify the claim to verify: \( A \subset C \). For this to hold, every individual element inside \( A \) must itself belong to \( C \). This is a completely different requirement from simply saying \( A \in C \). — Reason: Recognising the gap between \( A \in C \) and \( A \subset C \) is the heart of the argument.
  4. Step 4: Construct a counterexample. Let \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{\{1\}, 2\} \), and \( C = \{\{1\}, 2, 3\} \). Check \( A \in B \): the set \( \{1\} \) appears as an element of \( B \), so \( A \in B \) holds. — Reason: A single concrete counterexample is enough to disprove a general claim.
  5. Step 5: Verify \( B \subset C \) for the chosen sets. The elements of \( B \) are \( \{1\} \) and \( 2 \). Both \( \{1\} \in C \) and \( 2 \in C \), so every element of \( B \) is in \( C \), confirming \( B \subset C \). — Reason: Both given conditions must genuinely hold in the counterexample, otherwise the example is invalid.
  6. Step 6: Check whether \( A \subset C \) holds. For \( A = \{1\} \) to be a subset of \( C = \{\{1\}, 2, 3\} \), the element \( 1 \) (a number) must belong to \( C \). But \( C \) contains \( \{1\} \) (the set), not the bare number \( 1 \). Hence \( 1 \notin C \), so \( A \not\subset C \). — Reason: This is the crucial distinction: \( \{1\} \) and \( 1 \) are different objects in set theory.
  7. Step 7: State the conclusion. The counterexample shows that even when \( A \in B \) and \( B \subset C \) are both true, \( A \subset C \) need not be true. What we can always deduce is only \( A \in C \), not \( A \subset C \). — Reason: One valid counterexample is sufficient to prove that a universally claimed statement is false.

Final Answer

No, it is not true that \( A \subset C \). For example, with \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{\{1\}, 2\} \), \( C = \{\{1\}, 2, 3\} \), we have \( A \in B \) and \( B \subset C \), but \( A \not\subset C \) because \( 1 \notin C \).

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students assume that because \( A \in B \) and \( B \subset C \), the set \( A \) must also be a subset of \( C \). In reality, these conditions only guarantee \( A \in C \) (membership), not \( A \subset C \) (every element of \( A \) is in \( C \)), since \( \in \) and \( \subset \) are entirely different relations.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Given: \( A \in B \) (A is an element of B) and \( B \subset C \) (every element of B is in C).
  2. Step 2: From \( A \in B \) and \( B \subset C \), we conclude \( A \in C \) — not \( A \subset C \).
  3. Step 3: Counterexample: \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{\{1\}, 2\} \), \( C = \{\{1\}, 2, 3\} \). Then \( A \in B \), \( B \subset C \), but \( 1 \notin C \), so \( A \not\subset C \).

Answer: No, it is not true that \( A \subset C \). For example, with \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{\{1\}, 2\} \), \( C = \{\{1\}, 2, 3\} \), we have \( A \in B \) and \( B \subset C \), but \( A \not\subset C \) because \( 1 \notin C \).

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Let \( P \), \( Q \), and \( R \) be three sets such that \( P \in Q \) and \( Q \subseteq R \). Is it necessarily true that \( P \subseteq R \)? Justify your answer with an example.

Solution: We need to check whether \( P \in Q \) and \( Q \subseteq R \) together imply \( P \subseteq R \). Step 1: Understand what \( P \in Q \) means. It means \( P \) is an element (member) of the set \( Q \). So \( P \) itself is an object that belongs to \( Q \). Step 2: Understand what \( Q \subseteq R \) means. It means every element of \( Q \) is also an element of \( R \). Since \( P \in Q \), and every element of \( Q \) is in \( R \), we conclude \( P \in R \). Step 3: Now check whether \( P \subseteq R \) must follow. \( P \subseteq R \) would require that every element of \( P \) is also an element of \( R \). This is NOT guaranteed just because \( P \in R \). Step 4: Provide a counterexample. Let \( P = \{1, 2\} \), \( Q = \{\{1, 2\}, 3, 4\} \), and \( R = \{\{1, 2\}, 3, 4, 5\} \). Check \( P \in Q \): The set \( \{1, 2\} \) is indeed a member of \( Q \), so \( P \in Q \). ✓ Check \( Q \subseteq R \): The elements of \( Q \) are \( \{1, 2\} \), \( 3 \), and \( 4 \). All three are also in \( R \), so \( Q \subseteq R \). ✓ Check whether \( P \subseteq R \): For \( P \subseteq R \), every element of \( P \) must be in \( R \). The elements of \( P = \{1, 2\} \) are \( 1 \) and \( 2 \). Now \( R = \{\{1,2\}, 3, 4, 5\} \). The number \( 1 \notin R \) (only the set \( \{1,2\} \) is in \( R \), not the number \( 1 \) itself). Therefore \( P \not\subseteq R \). ✗ Conclusion: It is NOT necessarily true that \( P \subseteq R \). From \( P \in Q \) and \( Q \subseteq R \), we can only conclude \( P \in R \), not \( P \subseteq R \).

Answer: No, \( P \subseteq R \) is not necessarily true. Counterexample: \( P = \{1,2\} \), \( Q = \{\{1,2\}, 3, 4\} \), \( R = \{\{1,2\}, 3, 4, 5\} \). Here \( P \in Q \), \( Q \subseteq R \), but \( P \not\subseteq R \) since \( 1 \notin R \).

Example 2

Question: Let \( X \), \( Y \), and \( Z \) be sets defined as \( X = \{a\} \), \( Y = \{\{a\}, b\} \), and \( Z = \{\{a\}, b, c, d\} \). Verify whether \( X \in Y \) and \( Y \subseteq Z \). Using these, determine whether \( X \in Z \) and whether \( X \subseteq Z \) hold.

Solution: We are given \( X = \{a\} \), \( Y = \{\{a\}, b\} \), and \( Z = \{\{a\}, b, c, d\} \). Step 1: Check whether \( X \in Y \). The elements of \( Y \) are \( \{a\} \) and \( b \). Since \( X = \{a\} \), and \( \{a\} \) is an element of \( Y \), we have \( X \in Y \). ✓ Step 2: Check whether \( Y \subseteq Z \). The elements of \( Y \) are \( \{a\} \) and \( b \). The elements of \( Z \) are \( \{a\} \), \( b \), \( c \), and \( d \). Since both \( \{a\} \in Z \) and \( b \in Z \), every element of \( Y \) is in \( Z \), so \( Y \subseteq Z \). ✓ Step 3: Check whether \( X \in Z \). Since \( X = \{a\} \in Y \) and \( Y \subseteq Z \), every element of \( Y \) belongs to \( Z \). Therefore \( X = \{a\} \in Z \). ✓ Step 4: Check whether \( X \subseteq Z \). For \( X \subseteq Z \), every element of \( X \) must belong to \( Z \). The only element of \( X = \{a\} \) is \( a \). The elements of \( Z \) are \( \{a\} \), \( b \), \( c \), \( d \). Note that \( \{a\} \in Z \) but \( a \notin Z \) (the element \( a \) itself is not listed in \( Z \); only the set \( \{a\} \) is). Therefore \( a \notin Z \), which means \( X \not\subseteq Z \). ✗ Conclusion: We have verified \( X \in Y \) and \( Y \subseteq Z \). From these, \( X \in Z \) holds, but \( X \subseteq Z \) does NOT hold. The membership relation \( \in \) is not transitive in the same way the subset relation \( \subseteq \) is.

Answer: \( X \in Z \) is TRUE (since \( X \in Y \) and \( Y \subseteq Z \) imply every element of \( Y \), including \( X \), belongs to \( Z \)). However, \( X \subseteq Z \) is FALSE because \( a \notin Z \) even though \( \{a\} \in Z \).

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Let \( P \), \( Q \) and \( R \) be three sets such that \( P \in Q \) and \( Q \in R \). Is it necessarily true that \( P \in R \)? Justify your answer with an example.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand the given conditions: We are given that \( P \in Q \) (P is an element of Q) and \( Q \in R \) (Q is an element of R). We need to check whether \( P \in R \) must follow.
  2. Step 2: Construct a concrete example: Let \( P = \{5\} \), \( Q = \{\{5\}, 6\} \), and \( R = \{\{\{5\}, 6\}, 7\} \).
  3. Step 3: Verify P ∈ Q: The elements of \( Q \) are \( \{5\} \) and \( 6 \). Since \( P = \{5\} \) is listed as an element of \( Q \), we have \( P \in Q \). ✓
  4. Step 4: Verify Q ∈ R: The elements of \( R \) are \( \{\{5\}, 6\} \) and \( 7 \). Since \( Q = \{\{5\}, 6\} \) is listed as an element of \( R \), we have \( Q \in R \). ✓
  5. Step 5: Check whether P ∈ R: The elements of \( R \) are \( \{\{5\}, 6\} \) and \( 7 \). We check whether \( P = \{5\} \) is among the elements of \( R \). It is NOT — \( \{5\} \) does not appear directly as an element of \( R \). Therefore \( P \notin R \).
  6. Step 6: Conclusion: The example shows that even though \( P \in Q \) and \( Q \in R \), it is NOT necessarily true that \( P \in R \). The membership relation (\( \in \)) is not transitive in general.

Answer: No, it is not necessarily true that \( P \in R \). The membership relation is not transitive. For example, with \( P = \{5\} \), \( Q = \{\{5\}, 6\} \), and \( R = \{\{\{5\}, 6\}, 7\} \), we have \( P \in Q \) and \( Q \in R \), but \( P \notin R \) because \( \{5\} \) is not a direct element of \( R \).

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Sets