Let \(A, B\) and \(C\) be three sets. If \(A\in B\) and \(B\subset C,\) is it true that \(A\subset C?\) If not, give an example.
CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets
CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets
Imagine a box inside a big bag, and the bag is inside a room. The box is inside the bag, but the box is not the same as the bag. Being inside something is very different from being part of something. Here, \( A \in B \) means the whole set \( A \) is like one single toy sitting inside a toy box called \( B \). Even if \( B \) fits inside \( C \), the pieces inside \( A \) are not loose inside \( C \). So \( A \subset C \) is not guaranteed.
Answer: No, it is not true that \( A \subset C \). For example, with \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{\{1\}, 2\} \), \( C = \{\{1\}, 2, 3\} \), we have \( A \in B \) and \( B \subset C \), but \( A \not\subset C \) because \( 1 \notin C \).
In set theory, two very different relationships are often confused. The symbol \( \in \) means 'is an element of', so \( A \in B \) means that the whole set \( A \) is treated as a single element sitting inside \( B \). The symbol \( \subset \) means 'is a subset of', so \( B \subset C \) means every element of \( B \) is also an element of \( C \). The claim \( A \subset C \) would require every element of \( A \) to be an element of \( C \). Since \( A \in B \) only tells us \( A \) is one element of \( B \), and \( B \subset C \) only guarantees that \( A \) as an element belongs to \( C \), we get \( A \in C \), not necessarily \( A \subset C \). Being an element of a set is not the same as being a subset of that set.
\( A \in B \) means A is an element of B. \( B \subset C \) means every element of B is in C. \( A \subset C \) means every element of A is in C.
No, it is not true that \( A \subset C \). For example, with \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{\{1\}, 2\} \), \( C = \{\{1\}, 2, 3\} \), we have \( A \in B \) and \( B \subset C \), but \( A \not\subset C \) because \( 1 \notin C \).
A common mistake is treating \( \in \) and \( \subset \) as the same and writing \( A \subset B \) from \( A \in B \). Membership means \( A \) is a single element inside \( B \), which is very different from \( A \) being a subset of \( B \).
No, it is not true that \( A \subset C \). For example, with \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{\{1\}, 2\} \), \( C = \{\{1\}, 2, 3\} \), we have \( A \in B \) and \( B \subset C \), but \( A \not\subset C \) because \( 1 \notin C \).
One common mistake: students assume that because \( A \in B \) and \( B \subset C \), the set \( A \) must also be a subset of \( C \). In reality, these conditions only guarantee \( A \in C \) (membership), not \( A \subset C \) (every element of \( A \) is in \( C \)), since \( \in \) and \( \subset \) are entirely different relations.
Answer: No, it is not true that \( A \subset C \). For example, with \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{\{1\}, 2\} \), \( C = \{\{1\}, 2, 3\} \), we have \( A \in B \) and \( B \subset C \), but \( A \not\subset C \) because \( 1 \notin C \).
Question: Let \( P \), \( Q \), and \( R \) be three sets such that \( P \in Q \) and \( Q \subseteq R \). Is it necessarily true that \( P \subseteq R \)? Justify your answer with an example.
Solution: We need to check whether \( P \in Q \) and \( Q \subseteq R \) together imply \( P \subseteq R \). Step 1: Understand what \( P \in Q \) means. It means \( P \) is an element (member) of the set \( Q \). So \( P \) itself is an object that belongs to \( Q \). Step 2: Understand what \( Q \subseteq R \) means. It means every element of \( Q \) is also an element of \( R \). Since \( P \in Q \), and every element of \( Q \) is in \( R \), we conclude \( P \in R \). Step 3: Now check whether \( P \subseteq R \) must follow. \( P \subseteq R \) would require that every element of \( P \) is also an element of \( R \). This is NOT guaranteed just because \( P \in R \). Step 4: Provide a counterexample. Let \( P = \{1, 2\} \), \( Q = \{\{1, 2\}, 3, 4\} \), and \( R = \{\{1, 2\}, 3, 4, 5\} \). Check \( P \in Q \): The set \( \{1, 2\} \) is indeed a member of \( Q \), so \( P \in Q \). ✓ Check \( Q \subseteq R \): The elements of \( Q \) are \( \{1, 2\} \), \( 3 \), and \( 4 \). All three are also in \( R \), so \( Q \subseteq R \). ✓ Check whether \( P \subseteq R \): For \( P \subseteq R \), every element of \( P \) must be in \( R \). The elements of \( P = \{1, 2\} \) are \( 1 \) and \( 2 \). Now \( R = \{\{1,2\}, 3, 4, 5\} \). The number \( 1 \notin R \) (only the set \( \{1,2\} \) is in \( R \), not the number \( 1 \) itself). Therefore \( P \not\subseteq R \). ✗ Conclusion: It is NOT necessarily true that \( P \subseteq R \). From \( P \in Q \) and \( Q \subseteq R \), we can only conclude \( P \in R \), not \( P \subseteq R \).
Answer: No, \( P \subseteq R \) is not necessarily true. Counterexample: \( P = \{1,2\} \), \( Q = \{\{1,2\}, 3, 4\} \), \( R = \{\{1,2\}, 3, 4, 5\} \). Here \( P \in Q \), \( Q \subseteq R \), but \( P \not\subseteq R \) since \( 1 \notin R \).
Question: Let \( X \), \( Y \), and \( Z \) be sets defined as \( X = \{a\} \), \( Y = \{\{a\}, b\} \), and \( Z = \{\{a\}, b, c, d\} \). Verify whether \( X \in Y \) and \( Y \subseteq Z \). Using these, determine whether \( X \in Z \) and whether \( X \subseteq Z \) hold.
Solution: We are given \( X = \{a\} \), \( Y = \{\{a\}, b\} \), and \( Z = \{\{a\}, b, c, d\} \). Step 1: Check whether \( X \in Y \). The elements of \( Y \) are \( \{a\} \) and \( b \). Since \( X = \{a\} \), and \( \{a\} \) is an element of \( Y \), we have \( X \in Y \). ✓ Step 2: Check whether \( Y \subseteq Z \). The elements of \( Y \) are \( \{a\} \) and \( b \). The elements of \( Z \) are \( \{a\} \), \( b \), \( c \), and \( d \). Since both \( \{a\} \in Z \) and \( b \in Z \), every element of \( Y \) is in \( Z \), so \( Y \subseteq Z \). ✓ Step 3: Check whether \( X \in Z \). Since \( X = \{a\} \in Y \) and \( Y \subseteq Z \), every element of \( Y \) belongs to \( Z \). Therefore \( X = \{a\} \in Z \). ✓ Step 4: Check whether \( X \subseteq Z \). For \( X \subseteq Z \), every element of \( X \) must belong to \( Z \). The only element of \( X = \{a\} \) is \( a \). The elements of \( Z \) are \( \{a\} \), \( b \), \( c \), \( d \). Note that \( \{a\} \in Z \) but \( a \notin Z \) (the element \( a \) itself is not listed in \( Z \); only the set \( \{a\} \) is). Therefore \( a \notin Z \), which means \( X \not\subseteq Z \). ✗ Conclusion: We have verified \( X \in Y \) and \( Y \subseteq Z \). From these, \( X \in Z \) holds, but \( X \subseteq Z \) does NOT hold. The membership relation \( \in \) is not transitive in the same way the subset relation \( \subseteq \) is.
Answer: \( X \in Z \) is TRUE (since \( X \in Y \) and \( Y \subseteq Z \) imply every element of \( Y \), including \( X \), belongs to \( Z \)). However, \( X \subseteq Z \) is FALSE because \( a \notin Z \) even though \( \{a\} \in Z \).
Question: Let \( P \), \( Q \) and \( R \) be three sets such that \( P \in Q \) and \( Q \in R \). Is it necessarily true that \( P \in R \)? Justify your answer with an example.
Answer: No, it is not necessarily true that \( P \in R \). The membership relation is not transitive. For example, with \( P = \{5\} \), \( Q = \{\{5\}, 6\} \), and \( R = \{\{\{5\}, 6\}, 7\} \), we have \( P \in Q \) and \( Q \in R \), but \( P \notin R \) because \( \{5\} \) is not a direct element of \( R \).