SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Exercise 1.1 Q1(iii)

Which of the following are sets ? Justify your answer. A team of eleven best-cricket batsmen of the world.

CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine making a list of your class's 'best' students. Your teacher might pick different names than your parents would. That is the problem here. A set in maths needs a clear, agreed rule so everyone gets the same list. The word 'best' means different things to different people. Your favourite cricket batsman may not be your friend's favourite. Because there is no fixed rule everyone agrees on, we cannot make one definite list. So this collection of eleven best cricket batsmen is not a set at all.

Answer: The given collection is NOT a set, because 'best cricket batsmen' is a subjective term. Membership depends on personal opinion, so the collection is not well-defined.

📖 Is 'A team of eleven best cricket batsmen' a Set?

Detailed Explanation

In mathematics, a set is a well-defined collection of distinct objects. The phrase 'well-defined' is the key idea: given any object, we must be able to decide clearly and without any personal opinion whether that object belongs to the collection or not. If the membership depends on someone's judgement, mood, or taste, then the collection is NOT well-defined, and therefore it is NOT a set. Here the collection is 'eleven best cricket batsmen of the world'. The word 'best' is subjective — different people will choose different batsmen based on their own opinion. There is no fixed, universally agreed rule to decide who is 'best'. Because of this ambiguity, we cannot form a definite, unambiguous collection.

Formula Used

A collection is a set if and only if it is well-defined, i.e. for every object \( x \) we can decide clearly whether \( x \in A \) or \( x \notin A \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Recall the definition of a set. A collection is a set only if it is a well-defined collection of objects, meaning membership must be decidable without any personal opinion.
  2. Step 2: Examine the given collection: 'a team of eleven best cricket batsmen of the world'. Focus on the deciding word 'best'.
  3. Step 3: Check whether 'best' gives a definite rule. The word 'best' is based on opinion and personal judgement. Different cricket experts and fans would list different players. So there is no single agreed list of the eleven best batsmen.
  4. Step 4: Apply the membership test. For a given batsman we cannot definitely say whether he belongs to this collection or not, because that depends on whose opinion we follow. Hence the collection is not well-defined.
  5. Step 5: Conclude using the definition. Since the collection fails the well-defined condition, it does not qualify as a set.
  6. Step 6: Note the contrast: a collection like 'a team of eleven batsmen who scored more than 5000 runs in Test cricket' WOULD be a set, because membership is decided by a fixed, verifiable rule instead of an opinion.

Final Answer

The given collection is NOT a set, because 'best cricket batsmen' is a subjective term. Membership depends on personal opinion, so the collection is not well-defined.

Common Mistake

Students often think that because the number of players is fixed at eleven, the collection must be a set. The count does not matter — what matters is whether the objects can be well-defined. Since 'best' is subjective, it is still not a set.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Recall the definition of a set. A collection of objects is called a set only when it is well-defined, meaning membership must be decidable objectively for every candidate object. — Reason: This is the fundamental criterion we must check before classifying any collection as a set.
  2. Step 2: Identify the collection under examination: 'a team of eleven best cricket batsmen of the world.' Pick out the key word that describes how members are chosen — here it is the word 'best.' — Reason: The deciding word reveals whether an objective rule exists for membership.
  3. Step 3: Ask whether 'best' provides a fixed, universally agreed rule. Consider that one cricket expert might rank Player A among the top eleven while another expert leaves Player A out entirely. There is no single measurable criterion that everyone agrees makes a batsman 'the best.' — Reason: A well-defined collection must give the same answer regardless of who is judging, so we test whether the rule is free from personal opinion.
  4. Step 4: Apply the formal membership test. Take any specific batsman, say Player X. We cannot consistently say \( X \in A \) or \( X \notin A \) because the answer changes from person to person and from era to era. — Reason: If the membership test yields different answers for different people, the collection fails the well-defined requirement.
  5. Step 5: Draw the conclusion. Since the word 'best' is purely subjective and there is no fixed objective rule to determine membership, the collection is not well-defined, and therefore it does not qualify as a set. — Reason: A collection that is not well-defined cannot be treated as a mathematical set, no matter how clearly the description sounds in everyday language.

Final Answer

The given collection is NOT a set, because 'best cricket batsmen' is a subjective term. Membership depends on personal opinion, so the collection is not well-defined.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students sometimes think that any clearly described collection of real-world objects automatically forms a set. They forget that 'well-defined' is a strict mathematical condition — words like 'best', 'beautiful', or 'talented' introduce personal judgement and immediately disqualify a collection from being a set.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Given collection: eleven best cricket batsmen of the world.
  2. Step 2: Key word 'best' is opinion-based — no universal rule exists to decide membership \( x \in A \) or \( x \notin A \).
  3. Step 3: Collection is NOT well-defined, so it is NOT a set.

Answer: The given collection is NOT a set, because 'best cricket batsmen' is a subjective term. Membership depends on personal opinion, so the collection is not well-defined.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Is the following collection a set? Justify your answer: The collection of the five most talented singers in India.

Solution: To decide whether this collection is a set, we must check if it is well-defined — that is, whether we can determine with certainty whether a given person belongs to the collection or not. The word 'talented' is a subjective term. Different people will have different opinions about who the most talented singers in India are. For example, one person may consider a particular singer to be among the top five, while another person may not. Since there is no definite, universally agreed-upon criterion to decide who the five most talented singers are, the collection is NOT well-defined. Therefore, this collection is NOT a set.

Answer: Not a set, because 'most talented' is subjective and the collection is not well-defined.

Example 2

Question: Is the following collection a set? Justify your answer: The collection of all even natural numbers less than 20.

Solution: To decide whether this collection is a set, we must check if it is well-defined — that is, whether we can determine with certainty whether any given object belongs to the collection or not. An even natural number is any natural number divisible by 2. The condition 'less than 20' is also precise and unambiguous. For any natural number, we can definitively say whether it is even and whether it is less than 20. For example, 4 is even and less than 20, so it belongs to the collection. The number 15 is not even, so it does not belong. The number 22 is even but not less than 20, so it does not belong. The collection can be listed as: \{2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12, 14, 16, 18\} Since the rule for membership is clear and objective, this collection is well-defined. Therefore, this collection IS a set.

Answer: Yes, it is a set. The collection is well-defined and can be written as \{2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12, 14, 16, 18\}.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Determine whether the following collection is a set or not. Justify your answer: The collection of all students in your school who are 'very intelligent'.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Recall the definition of a set: A set is a well-defined collection of objects, meaning that it must be possible to determine, clearly and objectively, whether any particular object belongs to the collection or not.
  2. Step 2: Analyse the given collection: The collection is: 'all students in your school who are very intelligent'. We need to ask — is the term 'very intelligent' well-defined? Can we objectively decide whether a given student is 'very intelligent' or not?
  3. Step 3: Identify the nature of the defining property: The term 'very intelligent' is subjective. Different teachers, parents, or students may have different criteria for what counts as 'very intelligent'. One person may consider a student intelligent based on academic marks, another based on problem-solving ability, and yet another based on creative thinking. There is no single universally accepted, objective criterion.
  4. Step 4: State the conclusion: Since the membership of the collection depends on personal opinion and subjective judgment, the collection is NOT well-defined. Therefore, the given collection is NOT a set.

Answer: The given collection IS a set if and only if the collection is well-defined. Here, 'very intelligent' is a subjective and vague term — different people may include or exclude different students based on personal opinion. Since the collection is NOT well-defined, it is NOT a set.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Sets