SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Exercise 1.1 Q1(i)

Which of the following are sets ? Justify your answer. The collection of all the months of a year beginning with the letter \(J.\)

CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine sorting your crayons by color into a box. You can always tell which crayons belong — no guessing needed! A set in math works the same way. Here, we are grouping months whose names start with the letter J. Every month either starts with J or it does not — there is no confusion. January, June, and July all start with J, so they go in. December and March clearly do not, so they stay out. Because the rule is perfectly clear, this group is called a well-defined set.

Answer: Yes, it is a set, because the collection of months beginning with J is well-defined. It has exactly three members: \( \{ \text{January}, \text{June}, \text{July} \} \).

📖 Is the Collection of Months Beginning with J a Set?

Detailed Explanation

In mathematics, a set is a well-defined collection of distinct objects. The words 'well-defined' are the key idea. A collection is well-defined if, given any object, we can decide with certainty whether that object belongs to the collection or not. There should be no confusion, personal opinion, or vagueness involved. For example, 'the collection of all vowels in the English alphabet' is a set, because for any letter we can clearly say whether it is a vowel. On the other hand, 'the collection of good students' is NOT a set, because 'good' is subjective and cannot be decided definitely. To test the given collection, we simply check whether the membership rule is clear enough that every object either definitely belongs or definitely does not.

Formula Used

A collection is a set \( \iff \) it is well-defined (for every object, membership is decidable). Notation: \( x \in A \) means \( x \) belongs to set \( A \), and \( x \notin A \) means it does not.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand the rule. The collection is 'all the months of a year beginning with the letter J'. The membership condition is: a month qualifies only if its name starts with the letter J.
  2. Step 2: Check if the condition is well-defined. Take any month of the year and ask: does its name begin with J? This can be answered with a definite yes or no. There is no room for opinion or ambiguity, so the collection is well-defined.
  3. Step 3: List the members to confirm. The months beginning with J are January, June and July. So the collection can be written as \( \{ \text{January}, \text{June}, \text{July} \} \).
  4. Step 4: Verify membership clearly. For example, \( \text{January} \in A \) since it begins with J, while \( \text{March} \notin A \) since it does not. Every month can be classified without doubt.
  5. Step 5: Conclude. Since membership can always be decided definitely, the collection is a well-defined collection and therefore forms a set.

Final Answer

Yes, it is a set, because the collection of months beginning with J is well-defined. It has exactly three members: \( \{ \text{January}, \text{June}, \text{July} \} \).

Common Mistake

A common mistake is thinking a collection is 'too small' or 'too specific' to be a set. The number of members does not matter — even a collection with three members (or none) is a set as long as membership is well-defined.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the membership rule of the given collection. The collection is described as: all months of a year whose names begin with the letter J. — Reason: Before testing whether something is a set, we must clearly state what condition an object must satisfy to be included.
  2. Step 2: Check whether the membership rule is well-defined. Ask: given any month, can we say with certainty whether its name starts with J? The answer is always a clear yes or no — there is no room for personal judgment or ambiguity. — Reason: A collection is a valid set only when the inclusion rule is objective and unambiguous for every possible object.
  3. Step 3: Go through all 12 months of the year and apply the rule. Test each month: does its name begin with J? January — Yes. February — No. March — No. April — No. May — No. June — Yes. July — Yes. August — No. September — No. October — No. November — No. December — No. — Reason: Listing all candidates and checking each one confirms the rule works without any doubt for every month.
  4. Step 4: Collect the months that satisfy the condition. The qualifying months are January, June, and July, so the set is \( \{\text{January},\ \text{June},\ \text{July}\} \). — Reason: After confirming well-definedness, we state the exact members of the set to complete the answer.
  5. Step 5: State the conclusion. Since the membership condition (name starts with J) can be verified definitively for every month, the collection is well-defined. Therefore, it is indeed a set containing exactly three members. — Reason: We must explicitly confirm both parts: that the collection qualifies as a set and what its elements are.

Final Answer

Yes, it is a set, because the collection of months beginning with J is well-defined. It has exactly three members: \( \{ \text{January}, \text{June}, \text{July} \} \).

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students sometimes confuse 'being able to list the members' with 'being well-defined' — a collection is well-defined when the rule of membership is clear and objective, not merely when we happen to know the elements. Always test the rule itself, not just the resulting list.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Rule: a month qualifies if and only if its name starts with the letter J.
  2. Step 2: For every month, the question "does it start with J?" has a definite yes or no — no ambiguity, so the collection is well-defined.
  3. Step 3: Members: \( \{\text{January},\ \text{June},\ \text{July}\} \). All other months do not start with J and are excluded.

Answer: Yes, it is a set, because the collection of months beginning with J is well-defined. It has exactly three members: \( \{ \text{January}, \text{June}, \text{July} \} \).

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Is the following collection a set? Justify your answer. The collection of all days of the week whose names contain the letter 'S'.

Solution: We need to check whether the given collection is well-defined, i.e., whether we can clearly and objectively decide which days belong to it. The days of the week are: Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday. Now we check each day for the letter 'S' (upper or lower case): Monday — does NOT contain 'S'. Tuesday — contains 's' (Tue-s-day). Yes. Wednesday — contains 's' (Wedne-s-day). Yes. Thursday — contains 's' (Thur-s-day). Yes. Friday — does NOT contain 'S'. Saturday — contains 'S' (Saturday). Yes. Sunday — contains 'S' (Sunday). Yes. So the collection is: Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Saturday, Sunday. In set notation: \[ C = \{ \text{Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Saturday, Sunday} \} \] Since it is completely clear and objective which days belong to this collection, every person applying the rule will arrive at exactly the same set of elements. There is no ambiguity. Therefore, this collection IS a set.

Answer: Yes, it is a set. The collection is well-defined because the rule 'name contains the letter S' is objective and unambiguous. The set is \( \{ \text{Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Saturday, Sunday} \} \).

Example 2

Question: Is the following collection a set? Justify your answer. The collection of all letters in the word 'MATHEMATICS' that appear more than once.

Solution: We need to check whether this collection is well-defined. First, write out all the letters of the word 'MATHEMATICS' and count each letter's frequency: M — appears at positions 1 and 6, so frequency = 2. A — appears at positions 2 and 7, so frequency = 2. T — appears at positions 3 and 8, so frequency = 2. H — appears at position 4, frequency = 1. E — appears at position 5, frequency = 1. I — appears at position 9, frequency = 1. C — appears at position 10, frequency = 1. S — appears at position 11, frequency = 1. Letters that appear more than once are: M, A, T. In set notation: \[ D = \{ M, A, T \} \] The rule 'appears more than once in the word MATHEMATICS' is completely objective and unambiguous — every person who applies this rule will identify exactly the same three letters. There is no room for personal opinion or subjective judgment. Therefore, this collection IS a set.

Answer: Yes, it is a set. The rule 'appears more than once' is well-defined and objective. The set is \( \{ M, A, T \} \).

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Which of the following is a set? Justify your answer. The collection of all days of the week whose names begin with the letter 'T'.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Recall the definition of a set: A collection is called a set if and only if it is well-defined, meaning for any object, we can clearly and objectively decide whether it belongs to the collection or not.
  2. Step 2: Examine the given collection: We consider the collection of all days of the week whose names begin with the letter 'T'. The seven days of the week are: Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday.
  3. Step 3: Check which days begin with 'T': Going through each day: Sunday — begins with 'S', does not qualify. Monday — begins with 'M', does not qualify. Tuesday — begins with 'T', qualifies. Wednesday — begins with 'W', does not qualify. Thursday — begins with 'T', qualifies. Friday — begins with 'F', does not qualify. Saturday — begins with 'S', does not qualify.
  4. Step 4: Verify well-definedness: For every day of the week, we can unambiguously decide whether its name starts with 'T'. There is no ambiguity or subjectivity involved. Therefore, this collection is well-defined.
  5. Step 5: Write the conclusion: Since the collection is well-defined, it is a set. The set can be written as \( \{\text{Tuesday},\ \text{Thursday}\} \), which has exactly two elements.

Answer: Yes, it is a set, because we can objectively determine which days of the week begin with 'T'. The set has exactly two members: \( \{\text{Tuesday},\ \text{Thursday}\} \).

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Sets