SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Exercise 1.1 Q1(vi)

Which of the following are sets ? Justify your answer. A collection of novels written by the writer Munshi Prem Chand.

CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a box where you only keep things that follow one clear rule. A 'set' in maths is exactly like that box. The rule must be so clear that anyone can check if something belongs inside or not. Munshi Prem Chand wrote certain novels, and those novels are fixed historical facts. Nobody can argue about which novels he wrote — we can always check and get a definite yes or no answer. That makes it a perfectly clear, well-defined group.

Answer: Yes, the collection of novels written by Munshi Prem Chand is a set, because it is a well-defined collection — for any novel we can definitely decide whether or not it was written by him.

📖 Is a Collection of Munshi Prem Chand's Novels a Set?

Detailed Explanation

In mathematics, a set is a well-defined collection of distinct objects. The key phrase here is 'well-defined'. This means that given any object, we must be able to clearly and unambiguously decide whether that object belongs to the collection or not. There should be no room for personal opinion, taste, or vagueness. For example, 'the collection of tall students' is NOT a set because 'tall' is subjective. But 'the collection of students taller than 170 cm' IS a set because the rule is clear. When the objects are fixed by a definite, checkable rule, the collection is a set.

Formula Used

A collection is a set if and only if it is well-defined, meaning: for any object \( x \), exactly one of \( x \in A \) or \( x \notin A \) is true.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Recall the definition: A collection is a set only when it is well-defined, i.e. we can decide with certainty whether any given object is a member or not.
  2. Step 2: Examine the given collection: 'the novels written by the writer Munshi Prem Chand'. The membership rule is: 'Was this novel written by Munshi Prem Chand?'
  3. Step 3: Check whether this rule is definite. The novels written by Munshi Prem Chand are fixed historical facts. For any given novel, we can clearly say YES it was written by him, or NO it was not. There is no dependence on opinion or personal choice.
  4. Step 4: Since membership is unambiguous, for every object exactly one of \( x \in A \) or \( x \notin A \) holds. Hence the collection is well-defined.
  5. Step 5: By the definition of a set, a well-defined collection qualifies as a set. Therefore this collection IS a set.

Final Answer

Yes, the collection of novels written by Munshi Prem Chand is a set, because it is a well-defined collection — for any novel we can definitely decide whether or not it was written by him.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is thinking that because someone may not personally know all of Prem Chand's novels, the collection is not well-defined. Being well-defined does NOT require us to know all members; it only requires that a definite rule exists to decide membership, which it does here.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Recall the definition of a set: a collection is called a set only when it is well-defined. — Reason: This is the fundamental criterion we must check; without confirming well-definedness, we cannot classify any collection as a set.
  2. Step 2: Understand what 'well-defined' means: for every possible object \( x \), we must be able to say decisively either \( x \in A \) (x belongs) or \( x \notin A \) (x does not belong), with no room for opinion or ambiguity. — Reason: This two-way test is the precise mathematical meaning of well-defined, and it separates valid sets from vague groupings.
  3. Step 3: Identify the collection under examination: the novels written by Munshi Prem Chand. Write the membership rule as a question: 'Was this novel authored by Munshi Prem Chand?' — Reason: Stating the membership rule explicitly makes it easy to test whether the rule is objective or subjective.
  4. Step 4: Check whether the membership rule is objective: the authorship of any novel is a historical, verifiable fact. For any novel presented to us, we can look up the record and answer 'yes' or 'no' with certainty. No personal opinion, taste, or guesswork is involved. — Reason: A rule that depends on personal opinion (like 'interesting novels') would make the collection ill-defined; an objectively verifiable rule guarantees well-definedness.
  5. Step 5: Apply the set-definition test: since for every novel \( x \) exactly one of \( x \in A \) or \( x \notin A \) holds unambiguously, the collection satisfies the condition for being a set. — Reason: Confirming that the two-way membership test works for all objects is the final logical step that justifies calling the collection a set.
  6. Step 6: State the conclusion: the collection of novels written by Munshi Prem Chand is indeed a set, because its membership rule is clear and objective. — Reason: Once well-definedness is established, classification as a set follows directly from the definition.

Final Answer

Yes, the collection of novels written by Munshi Prem Chand is a set, because it is a well-defined collection — for any novel we can definitely decide whether or not it was written by him.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students sometimes confuse 'familiar' or 'famous' with 'well-defined' — for instance, they might think a collection is a set simply because everyone knows the objects involved, rather than checking whether membership can be decided objectively for every possible object.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Membership rule: Was this novel written by Munshi Prem Chand? — a historically verifiable, objective criterion.
  2. Step 2: For any novel \( x \), exactly one of \( x \in A \) or \( x \notin A \) is true — no ambiguity or personal opinion involved.
  3. Step 3: Collection is well-defined. Hence it qualifies as a set.

Answer: Yes, the collection of novels written by Munshi Prem Chand is a set, because it is a well-defined collection — for any novel we can definitely decide whether or not it was written by him.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Is the following collection a set? Justify your answer. 'A collection of all paintings considered beautiful by art critics.'

Solution: To determine whether a given collection is a set, we check whether it is well-defined, i.e., whether we can say with certainty whether any particular object belongs to the collection or not. Here, the collection consists of paintings considered 'beautiful' by art critics. The word 'beautiful' is subjective — different art critics may have different opinions about the same painting. One critic may consider a particular painting beautiful while another may not. Since there is no objective, universally agreed-upon criterion to decide whether a painting belongs to this collection, the collection is NOT well-defined. Therefore, 'A collection of all paintings considered beautiful by art critics' is NOT a set.

Answer: Not a set, because 'beautiful' is subjective and the collection is not well-defined.

Example 2

Question: Is the following collection a set? Justify your answer. 'A collection of all triangles drawn in a given plane whose area is less than 10 square units.'

Solution: To determine whether a given collection is a set, we check whether it is well-defined — that is, whether there is a clear rule to decide if any given object belongs to the collection. Here, the collection consists of all triangles in a given plane whose area is less than 10 square units. For any triangle drawn in the plane, we can calculate its area precisely. If the area is less than 10 square units, the triangle belongs to the collection; otherwise, it does not. The condition 'area less than 10 square units' is a precise, mathematical, and objective criterion. There is no ambiguity involved. For example, a triangle with base 4 units and height 3 units has area \[\text{Area} = \frac{1}{2} \times 4 \times 3 = 6 \text{ square units}\] Since \( 6 < 10 \), this triangle belongs to the collection. Similarly, for any given triangle, we can definitively decide its membership. Therefore, 'A collection of all triangles in a given plane whose area is less than 10 square units' IS a set.

Answer: Yes, it is a set, because the condition (area less than 10 square units) is well-defined and objective.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Which of the following is a set? Justify your answer. 'A collection of all difficult chapters in the Class 11 Mathematics textbook.'

Solution

  1. Step 1: Recall the definition of a set: A set is a well-defined collection of objects. This means there must be a clear, objective rule that allows us to decide, without any ambiguity, whether a given object belongs to the collection or not.
  2. Step 2: Examine the given collection: The collection described is 'all difficult chapters in the Class 11 Mathematics textbook.' We must ask: can we objectively decide whether a given chapter is 'difficult' or not?
  3. Step 3: Check if the collection is well-defined: The word 'difficult' is subjective — it varies from person to person. A chapter that one student finds difficult may be easy for another. For example, a student who is strong in algebra may find 'Sets' easy, while another may find it difficult. There is no universal, objective standard to classify a chapter as 'difficult.'
  4. Step 4: Conclusion: Since membership in this collection depends on personal opinion and cannot be determined objectively, the collection is NOT well-defined. Therefore, 'a collection of all difficult chapters in the Class 11 Mathematics textbook' is NOT a set.

Answer: No, 'a collection of all difficult chapters in the Class 11 Mathematics textbook' is NOT a set, because 'difficult' is a subjective term — different students have different opinions about which chapters are difficult — so the collection is not well-defined.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Sets