Which of the following are sets ? Justify your answer. The collection of all boys in your class.
CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets
CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets
Imagine you have a box and you want to know who belongs inside it. A set is just a box where you can always say clearly 'yes, this belongs' or 'no, this does not.' Think of your school class — every student is either a boy in your class or not. There is no guessing or arguing about it. Just like a register has a clear list of names, the boys in your class form a neat, clear group. Nobody has to give an opinion to decide.
Answer: Yes, the collection of all boys in your class IS a set, because it is a well-defined collection: for any given person, we can clearly decide whether or not they are a boy in your class, with no dependence on opinion.
In mathematics, a set is a well-defined collection of objects. The phrase 'well-defined' is the key idea: given any object, we must be able to decide clearly and without any personal opinion whether that object belongs to the collection or not. If the answer is always a definite 'yes' or 'no', the collection is a set. If deciding membership depends on someone's opinion, taste, or judgement, then the collection is NOT a set. Here we examine the collection of all boys in your class using this rule.
A collection is a set if and only if, for every object \( x \), the statement \( x \in A \) is either definitely true or definitely false (well-defined membership).
Yes, the collection of all boys in your class IS a set, because it is a well-defined collection: for any given person, we can clearly decide whether or not they are a boy in your class, with no dependence on opinion.
A common mistake is to confuse this with collections like 'the most intelligent boys' or 'the tallest boys', which are NOT sets because they depend on opinion or lack a clear rule. Simply being 'boys in your class' is factual and well-defined, so it does qualify as a set.
Yes, the collection of all boys in your class IS a set, because it is a well-defined collection: for any given person, we can clearly decide whether or not they are a boy in your class, with no dependence on opinion.
One common mistake: students sometimes confuse 'large or hard-to-list' collections with 'not well-defined' ones. A collection can be perfectly well-defined even if you cannot physically write every member down — what matters is whether the membership rule is objective and unambiguous, not whether the list is short or easy to write.
Answer: Yes, the collection of all boys in your class IS a set, because it is a well-defined collection: for any given person, we can clearly decide whether or not they are a boy in your class, with no dependence on opinion.
Question: Which of the following is a set? Justify your answer. (a) The collection of all difficult problems in your Mathematics textbook. (b) The collection of all prime numbers less than 20.
Solution: We check whether each collection is well-defined. (a) The collection of all difficult problems in your Mathematics textbook: The word 'difficult' is subjective — a problem that seems difficult to one student may be easy to another. Since there is no definite criterion to decide whether a given problem belongs to this collection or not, this collection is NOT a set. (b) The collection of all prime numbers less than 20: A prime number is a number greater than 1 that has no divisors other than 1 and itself. This criterion is precise and unambiguous. We can list the elements exactly: \[\{2,\ 3,\ 5,\ 7,\ 11,\ 13,\ 17,\ 19\}\] Since every number can be tested definitively for primality, this collection IS a set.
Answer: (a) NOT a set — the term 'difficult' is subjective and not well-defined. (b) IS a set — prime numbers less than 20 are precisely determined: \(\{2, 3, 5, 7, 11, 13, 17, 19\}\).
Question: Which of the following is a set? Justify your answer. (a) The collection of all tall students in a school. (b) The collection of all vowels in the English alphabet.
Solution: We check whether each collection is well-defined. (a) The collection of all tall students in a school: The adjective 'tall' is relative and subjective — the height considered 'tall' differs from person to person and context to context. Since membership cannot be decided objectively, this collection is NOT a set. (b) The collection of all vowels in the English alphabet: The English alphabet has exactly five vowels: a, e, i, o, u. Any letter can be checked unambiguously to see whether it is a vowel. The collection can be written precisely as \[\{a,\ e,\ i,\ o,\ u\}\] Since the rule of membership is clear and definite, this collection IS a set.
Answer: (a) NOT a set — 'tall' is a subjective term with no fixed criterion. (b) IS a set — vowels in the English alphabet are well-defined: \(\{a, e, i, o, u\}\).
Question: Which of the following is a set? Justify your answer. (a) The collection of all interesting chapters in your Mathematics textbook. (b) The collection of all prime numbers less than 20.
Answer: (a) The collection of all interesting chapters in the Mathematics textbook is NOT a set, because 'interesting' is subjective and the collection is not well-defined. (b) The collection of all prime numbers less than 20 IS a set, because it is well-defined; the set is \( \{2, 3, 5, 7, 11, 13, 17, 19\} \).