Which of the following are sets ? Justify your answer. A collection of most dangerous animals of the world.
CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets
CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets
Imagine asking your friends to name the 'most dangerous animals.' One friend says sharks, another says mosquitoes, and a third says wolves. Nobody agrees! In maths, a set is like a club with very clear rules for who can join. If the rule is fuzzy or depends on opinion, the club is not a proper maths set. 'Most dangerous animals' means something different to every person. Because we cannot decide for sure which animals belong, this collection fails the clear-rules test and is not a set.
Answer: The given collection is NOT a set, because 'most dangerous' is a subjective term. Membership cannot be decided objectively, so the collection is not well-defined.
In mathematics, a set is a well-defined collection of objects. The words 'well-defined' are the key. A collection is well-defined if, for any given object, we can decide with certainty (without any personal opinion or doubt) whether that object belongs to the collection or not. If deciding membership depends on personal judgement, mood, or opinion, then the collection is NOT a set. Words like 'most dangerous', 'best', 'tallest cities', 'good', 'beautiful' are subjective — different people will give different answers — so such collections fail the well-defined test.
A collection is a set \( \iff \) it is well-defined (membership can be decided objectively).
The given collection is NOT a set, because 'most dangerous' is a subjective term. Membership cannot be decided objectively, so the collection is not well-defined.
Students often think that any group of real objects is a set. But if the describing word is an opinion (like 'most dangerous', 'best', 'beautiful'), the collection is not well-defined and hence not a set.
The given collection is NOT a set, because 'most dangerous' is a subjective term. Membership cannot be decided objectively, so the collection is not well-defined.
One common mistake: students sometimes assume that because the collection sounds specific (it is about animals, and dangerousness seems measurable), it must be well-defined — but 'most dangerous' still depends on personal criteria, so the collection remains subjective and is not a set.
Answer: The given collection is NOT a set, because 'most dangerous' is a subjective term. Membership cannot be decided objectively, so the collection is not well-defined.
Question: Is the following a set? Justify your answer. A collection of the most intelligent students in your school.
Solution: To determine whether a given collection is a set, we check if it is well-defined, i.e., whether we can say with certainty whether any particular student belongs to the collection or not. The term 'most intelligent' is subjective. Different people (teachers, parents, classmates) may have different opinions about who is intelligent and who is not. There is no fixed, universally accepted criterion for measuring intelligence in this context. For example, one teacher might consider a student who excels in Mathematics as most intelligent, while another might consider a student who excels in all subjects. Because of this ambiguity, we cannot determine with certainty whether a specific student belongs to this collection or not. Therefore, this collection is NOT a well-defined collection, and hence it is NOT a set.
Answer: The collection of most intelligent students in a school is NOT a set, because 'most intelligent' is a subjective criterion and the collection is not well-defined.
Question: Is the following a set? Justify your answer. A collection of all prime numbers less than 50.
Solution: To determine whether a given collection is a set, we check if it is well-defined, i.e., whether we can say with certainty whether any particular object belongs to the collection or not. A prime number is a number greater than 1 that has no divisors other than 1 and itself. This is a precise, universally accepted mathematical definition. For any number less than 50, we can definitively decide whether it is prime or not. The prime numbers less than 50 are: 2, 3, 5, 7, 11, 13, 17, 19, 23, 29, 31, 37, 41, 43, and 47. In set notation, this collection can be written as \ \( P = \{2, 3, 5, 7, 11, 13, 17, 19, 23, 29, 31, 37, 41, 43, 47\} \). Since there is no ambiguity — every number less than 50 can be clearly classified as prime or not prime — this collection is well-defined. Therefore, this collection IS a set.
Answer: The collection of all prime numbers less than 50 IS a set, because primality is a well-defined mathematical property and we can clearly list all such numbers: \( \{2, 3, 5, 7, 11, 13, 17, 19, 23, 29, 31, 37, 41, 43, 47\} \).
Question: Determine whether the following collection forms a set. Justify your answer. 'A collection of all talented students in a school.'
Answer: The given collection IS a set — this statement is FALSE. 'A collection of all talented students in a school' is NOT a set, because the term 'talented' is subjective and membership cannot be determined objectively. Hence the collection is not well-defined.