In each of the following, determine whether the statement is true or false. If it is true, prove it. If it is false, give an example. If \(A\subset B\) and \(B \in C ,\) then \(A \in C\)
CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets
CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets
Imagine a small bag inside a big bag, and the big bag is placed inside a box. The small bag is inside the big bag — that is like \( A \subset B \). The big bag is inside the box — that is like \( B \in C \). But the small bag is NOT directly inside the box as its own item. Being inside something that is inside something else is not the same as being directly inside. So the claim turns out to be false.
Answer: The statement is FALSE. Counterexample: \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{1, 2\} \), \( C = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \). Here \( A \subset B \) and \( B \in C \), but \( A \notin C \).
This problem tests whether you clearly understand two different ideas in set theory: the subset symbol \( \subset \) and the membership symbol \( \in \). When we write \( A \subset B \), it means every element of the set \( A \) is also an element of the set \( B \). When we write \( B \in C \), it means the set \( B \) is itself one single element of the set \( C \). These are completely different relationships. The statement claims that if \( A \subset B \) and \( B \in C \), then \( A \in C \). To disprove such a general statement, we only need to find ONE specific example (a counterexample) where the given conditions hold but the conclusion fails.
\( A \subset B \) means every element of \( A \) is in \( B \); \( B \in C \) means \( B \) is an element of \( C \).
The statement is FALSE. Counterexample: \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{1, 2\} \), \( C = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \). Here \( A \subset B \) and \( B \in C \), but \( A \notin C \).
A common mistake is to treat \( \subset \) and \( \in \) as the same relation and assume 'containment passes through'. Being a subset of \( B \) does not make \( A \) an element of any set that merely contains \( B \) as a member; membership and the subset relation behave very differently.
The statement is FALSE. Counterexample: \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{1, 2\} \), \( C = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \). Here \( A \subset B \) and \( B \in C \), but \( A \notin C \).
One common mistake: Students assume that because \( A \subset B \) and \( B \in C \), the elements of \( A \) must also appear individually inside \( C \). This confuses membership (\( \in \)) with the subset relation (\( \subset \)) — being a subset of an element of \( C \) does not make you an element of \( C \).
Answer: The statement is FALSE. Counterexample: \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{1, 2\} \), \( C = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \). Here \( A \subset B \) and \( B \in C \), but \( A \notin C \).
Question: Determine whether the following statement is true or false. If true, prove it; if false, give a counterexample. If \( P \subset Q \) and \( Q \in R \), then \( P \in R \).
Solution: The statement is FALSE. We need a counterexample where \( P \subset Q \) and \( Q \in R \), but \( P \notin R \). Let us define the sets as follows: \[ P = \{2\} \] \[ Q = \{2, 4\} \] \[ R = \left\{ \{2, 4\},\ 6,\ 8 \right\} \] Now we verify each condition. Condition 1: Is \( P \subset Q \)? We check whether every element of \( P \) belongs to \( Q \). The only element of \( P \) is \( 2 \), and \( 2 \in Q \). Therefore \( P \subset Q \). This condition holds. Condition 2: Is \( Q \in R \)? The elements of \( R \) are \( \{2, 4\} \), \( 6 \), and \( 8 \). Since \( Q = \{2, 4\} \) is listed as one of the elements of \( R \), we have \( Q \in R \). This condition holds. Condition 3: Is \( P \in R \)? For \( P \in R \), the set \( \{2\} \) must be one of the elements of \( R \). The elements of \( R \) are \( \{2, 4\} \), \( 6 \), and \( 8 \). Since \( \{2\} \) is not among them, we have \( P \notin R \). Thus, even though \( P \subset Q \) and \( Q \in R \), we get \( P \notin R \). This shows the statement is FALSE.
Answer: False. Counterexample: \( P = \{2\} \), \( Q = \{2, 4\} \), \( R = \left\{ \{2, 4\},\ 6,\ 8 \right\} \). Here \( P \subset Q \) and \( Q \in R \), but \( P \notin R \).
Question: Determine whether the following statement is true or false. If true, prove it; if false, give a counterexample. If \( X \subset Y \) and \( Y \in Z \), then \( X \in Z \).
Solution: The statement is FALSE. We construct a specific counterexample. Let the sets be defined as: \[ X = \{a\} \] \[ Y = \{a, b, c\} \] \[ Z = \left\{ \{a, b, c\},\ \{d, e\},\ 10 \right\} \] We verify each condition step by step. Step 1: Verify \( X \subset Y \). The only element of \( X \) is \( a \). Since \( a \in Y \), every element of \( X \) is in \( Y \). Hence \( X \subset Y \). Step 2: Verify \( Y \in Z \). The elements of \( Z \) are \( \{a, b, c\} \), \( \{d, e\} \), and \( 10 \). Since \( Y = \{a, b, c\} \) appears as an element of \( Z \), we have \( Y \in Z \). Step 3: Check whether \( X \in Z \). For \( X \in Z \), the set \( \{a\} \) must be one of the elements of \( Z \). The elements of \( Z \) are \( \{a, b, c\} \), \( \{d, e\} \), and \( 10 \). None of these equals \( \{a\} \), so \( X \notin Z \). The key insight is that \( \subset \) and \( \in \) are different relations. \( X \subset Y \) means the elements of \( X \) are inside \( Y \), but \( X \) itself is not necessarily a member of the collection \( Z \) even though \( Y \) is. Hence the statement is FALSE.
Answer: False. Counterexample: \( X = \{a\} \), \( Y = \{a, b, c\} \), \( Z = \left\{ \{a, b, c\},\ \{d, e\},\ 10 \right\} \). Here \( X \subset Y \) and \( Y \in Z \), but \( X \notin Z \).
Question: Determine whether the following statement is true or false. If it is true, prove it. If it is false, give a counterexample. Statement: If \( A \in B \) and \( B \subset C \), then \( A \in C \).
Answer: The statement is TRUE. Proof: Since \( B \subset C \), every element of \( B \) is also an element of \( C \). Because \( A \in B \), it follows immediately that \( A \in C \).