SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Miscellaneous Exercise Chapter 1 Q2(ii)

In each of the following, determine whether the statement is true or false. If it is true, prove it. If it is false, give an example. If \(A\subset B\) and \(B \in C ,\) then \(A \in C\)

CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a small bag inside a big bag, and the big bag is placed inside a box. The small bag is inside the big bag — that is like \( A \subset B \). The big bag is inside the box — that is like \( B \in C \). But the small bag is NOT directly inside the box as its own item. Being inside something that is inside something else is not the same as being directly inside. So the claim turns out to be false.

Answer: The statement is FALSE. Counterexample: \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{1, 2\} \), \( C = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \). Here \( A \subset B \) and \( B \in C \), but \( A \notin C \).

📖 Is the Statement True or False: A⊂B and B∈C implies A∈C

Detailed Explanation

This problem tests whether you clearly understand two different ideas in set theory: the subset symbol \( \subset \) and the membership symbol \( \in \). When we write \( A \subset B \), it means every element of the set \( A \) is also an element of the set \( B \). When we write \( B \in C \), it means the set \( B \) is itself one single element of the set \( C \). These are completely different relationships. The statement claims that if \( A \subset B \) and \( B \in C \), then \( A \in C \). To disprove such a general statement, we only need to find ONE specific example (a counterexample) where the given conditions hold but the conclusion fails.

Formula Used

\( A \subset B \) means every element of \( A \) is in \( B \); \( B \in C \) means \( B \) is an element of \( C \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand the claim. We are told \( A \subset B \) (so all elements of \( A \) lie in \( B \)) and \( B \in C \) (so \( B \) is one element of \( C \)). The claim says this forces \( A \in C \) (that \( A \) is also an element of \( C \)). We will check if this is always true.
  2. Step 2: Choose simple sets to test the claim. Let \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{1, 2\} \), and \( C = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \). We picked \( C \) so that the set \( B \) appears inside it as an element.
  3. Step 3: Check the first condition. Every element of \( A = \{1\} \) must be in \( B = \{1, 2\} \). Since \( 1 \in B \), it is true that \( A \subset B \).
  4. Step 4: Check the second condition. The set \( C = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \) has two elements: the set \( \{1, 2\} \) and the number \( 3 \). Since \( B = \{1, 2\} \) is one of these elements, it is true that \( B \in C \).
  5. Step 5: Check the conclusion. Is \( A \in C \)? Here \( A = \{1\} \). The elements of \( C \) are \( \{1, 2\} \) and \( 3 \). The set \( \{1\} \) is NOT one of these elements, so \( A \notin C \).
  6. Step 6: Conclude. Both given conditions \( A \subset B \) and \( B \in C \) are satisfied, yet \( A \in C \) is false. This single counterexample proves the statement is false.

Final Answer

The statement is FALSE. Counterexample: \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{1, 2\} \), \( C = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \). Here \( A \subset B \) and \( B \in C \), but \( A \notin C \).

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to treat \( \subset \) and \( \in \) as the same relation and assume 'containment passes through'. Being a subset of \( B \) does not make \( A \) an element of any set that merely contains \( B \) as a member; membership and the subset relation behave very differently.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify what the statement is claiming. The statement says: if \( A \subset B \) and \( B \in C \), then it must follow that \( A \in C \). — Reason: Before accepting or rejecting any general claim, we must clearly state exactly what is being asserted so we know what to test.
  2. Step 2: Recall the precise meaning of each symbol. \( A \subset B \) tells us that every individual member of \( A \) also belongs to \( B \). On the other hand, \( B \in C \) tells us that the entire set \( B \), treated as one object, is a member of \( C \). — Reason: These two relations operate at different levels; mixing them up is the root of the error the statement makes.
  3. Step 3: Decide on a strategy. To show the statement is false, we do NOT need to prove it fails in every case — we only need one specific counterexample where both conditions hold but the conclusion \( A \in C \) fails. — Reason: A single counterexample is logically sufficient to disprove a universal claim.
  4. Step 4: Construct the counterexample. Choose \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{1, 2\} \), and \( C = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \). Notice that \( C \) contains exactly two elements: the set \( \{1, 2\} \) and the number \( 3 \). — Reason: We deliberately make \( B \) an element of \( C \) while keeping \( A \) away from \( C \) to expose the gap in the statement.
  5. Step 5: Verify condition 1: \( A \subset B \). The only element of \( A = \{1\} \) is \( 1 \), and since \( 1 \in \{1, 2\} \), every element of \( A \) is in \( B \). Therefore \( A \subset B \) holds. — Reason: We must confirm the first hypothesis is satisfied before the counterexample is valid.
  6. Step 6: Verify condition 2: \( B \in C \). The set \( C = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \) lists \( \{1, 2\} \) as one of its members, and \( B = \{1, 2\} \), so \( B \in C \) holds. — Reason: Both hypotheses of the original statement are now confirmed to be true for our chosen sets.
  7. Step 7: Check whether the conclusion \( A \in C \) holds. For \( A = \{1\} \) to be an element of \( C \), the set \( \{1\} \) would have to appear as a listed member of \( C = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \). The members of \( C \) are \( \{1, 2\} \) and \( 3 \); neither of these equals \( \{1\} \). Therefore \( A \notin C \). — Reason: This is the critical check — the conclusion of the statement breaks down even though both its conditions are met, proving the statement is false.

Final Answer

The statement is FALSE. Counterexample: \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{1, 2\} \), \( C = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \). Here \( A \subset B \) and \( B \in C \), but \( A \notin C \).

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students assume that because \( A \subset B \) and \( B \in C \), the elements of \( A \) must also appear individually inside \( C \). This confuses membership (\( \in \)) with the subset relation (\( \subset \)) — being a subset of an element of \( C \) does not make you an element of \( C \).

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Let \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{1, 2\} \), \( C = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \).
  2. Step 2: \( 1 \in B \) so \( A \subset B \). \( B = \{1,2\} \) appears directly as an element of \( C \), so \( B \in C \).
  3. Step 3: Elements of \( C \) are \( \{1,2\} \) and \( 3 \). Since \( \{1\} \ne \{1,2\} \) and \( \{1\} \ne 3 \), we have \( A \notin C \).

Answer: The statement is FALSE. Counterexample: \( A = \{1\} \), \( B = \{1, 2\} \), \( C = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \). Here \( A \subset B \) and \( B \in C \), but \( A \notin C \).

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Determine whether the following statement is true or false. If true, prove it; if false, give a counterexample. If \( P \subset Q \) and \( Q \in R \), then \( P \in R \).

Solution: The statement is FALSE. We need a counterexample where \( P \subset Q \) and \( Q \in R \), but \( P \notin R \). Let us define the sets as follows: \[ P = \{2\} \] \[ Q = \{2, 4\} \] \[ R = \left\{ \{2, 4\},\ 6,\ 8 \right\} \] Now we verify each condition. Condition 1: Is \( P \subset Q \)? We check whether every element of \( P \) belongs to \( Q \). The only element of \( P \) is \( 2 \), and \( 2 \in Q \). Therefore \( P \subset Q \). This condition holds. Condition 2: Is \( Q \in R \)? The elements of \( R \) are \( \{2, 4\} \), \( 6 \), and \( 8 \). Since \( Q = \{2, 4\} \) is listed as one of the elements of \( R \), we have \( Q \in R \). This condition holds. Condition 3: Is \( P \in R \)? For \( P \in R \), the set \( \{2\} \) must be one of the elements of \( R \). The elements of \( R \) are \( \{2, 4\} \), \( 6 \), and \( 8 \). Since \( \{2\} \) is not among them, we have \( P \notin R \). Thus, even though \( P \subset Q \) and \( Q \in R \), we get \( P \notin R \). This shows the statement is FALSE.

Answer: False. Counterexample: \( P = \{2\} \), \( Q = \{2, 4\} \), \( R = \left\{ \{2, 4\},\ 6,\ 8 \right\} \). Here \( P \subset Q \) and \( Q \in R \), but \( P \notin R \).

Example 2

Question: Determine whether the following statement is true or false. If true, prove it; if false, give a counterexample. If \( X \subset Y \) and \( Y \in Z \), then \( X \in Z \).

Solution: The statement is FALSE. We construct a specific counterexample. Let the sets be defined as: \[ X = \{a\} \] \[ Y = \{a, b, c\} \] \[ Z = \left\{ \{a, b, c\},\ \{d, e\},\ 10 \right\} \] We verify each condition step by step. Step 1: Verify \( X \subset Y \). The only element of \( X \) is \( a \). Since \( a \in Y \), every element of \( X \) is in \( Y \). Hence \( X \subset Y \). Step 2: Verify \( Y \in Z \). The elements of \( Z \) are \( \{a, b, c\} \), \( \{d, e\} \), and \( 10 \). Since \( Y = \{a, b, c\} \) appears as an element of \( Z \), we have \( Y \in Z \). Step 3: Check whether \( X \in Z \). For \( X \in Z \), the set \( \{a\} \) must be one of the elements of \( Z \). The elements of \( Z \) are \( \{a, b, c\} \), \( \{d, e\} \), and \( 10 \). None of these equals \( \{a\} \), so \( X \notin Z \). The key insight is that \( \subset \) and \( \in \) are different relations. \( X \subset Y \) means the elements of \( X \) are inside \( Y \), but \( X \) itself is not necessarily a member of the collection \( Z \) even though \( Y \) is. Hence the statement is FALSE.

Answer: False. Counterexample: \( X = \{a\} \), \( Y = \{a, b, c\} \), \( Z = \left\{ \{a, b, c\},\ \{d, e\},\ 10 \right\} \). Here \( X \subset Y \) and \( Y \in Z \), but \( X \notin Z \).

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Determine whether the following statement is true or false. If it is true, prove it. If it is false, give a counterexample. Statement: If \( A \in B \) and \( B \subset C \), then \( A \in C \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand the statement: We need to check: if a set \( A \) is an element of set \( B \), and \( B \) is a subset of \( C \), does it necessarily follow that \( A \) is an element of \( C \)?
  2. Step 2: Analyse using definitions: Recall that \( B \subset C \) means every element of \( B \) is also an element of \( C \). Since \( A \in B \), meaning \( A \) is an element of \( B \), and since every element of \( B \) belongs to \( C \), it follows directly that \( A \in C \).
  3. Step 3: Construct a formal proof: Given: \( A \in B \) and \( B \subset C \). By definition of subset, \( B \subset C \) means: for every element \( x \), if \( x \in B \) then \( x \in C \). Since \( A \in B \), applying the subset definition with \( x = A \), we get \( A \in C \). Therefore the statement is TRUE.
  4. Step 4: Verify with an example: Let \( A = \{1, 2\} \), \( B = \left\{ \{1, 2\}, 3 \right\} \), and \( C = \left\{ \{1, 2\}, 3, 4 \right\} \). Here \( A \in B \) since \( \{1,2\} \) is one of the elements listed in \( B \). Also \( B \subset C \) since every element of \( B \) (namely \( \{1,2\} \) and \( 3 \)) is also in \( C \). Checking: \( A = \{1,2\} \in C \)? Yes, \( \{1,2\} \) is listed as an element of \( C \). The conclusion holds.

Answer: The statement is TRUE. Proof: Since \( B \subset C \), every element of \( B \) is also an element of \( C \). Because \( A \in B \), it follows immediately that \( A \in C \).

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Sets