Example 1
Question: Determine whether the following statement is true or false. If true, prove it. If false, give a counterexample. If \( p \in C \) and \( C \in D \), then \( p \in D \).
Solution: We claim this statement is FALSE. To disprove it, we construct a specific counterexample. Let \( p = 3 \), let \( C = \{3, 7\} \), and let \( D = \left\{ \{3, 7\}, 10, 15 \right\} \). Step 1: Check whether \( p \in C \). Since \( C = \{3, 7\} \), clearly \( 3 \in \{3, 7\} \), so \( p \in C \) holds. Step 2: Check whether \( C \in D \). Since \( D = \left\{ \{3, 7\}, 10, 15 \right\} \), the set \( \{3, 7\} \) is itself listed as one of the elements of \( D \). Therefore \( C \in D \) holds. Step 3: Check whether \( p \in D \). The elements of \( D \) are \( \{3, 7\} \), \( 10 \), and \( 15 \). The number \( 3 \) is NOT among these elements. Therefore \( p \notin D \). Conclusion: We have \( p \in C \) and \( C \in D \), yet \( p \notin D \). The statement is FALSE. Note: For the conclusion \( p \in D \) to follow, we would need \( C \subseteq D \) (C is a subset of D), not merely \( C \in D \) (C is an element of D).
Answer: False. Counterexample: \( p = 3 \), \( C = \{3, 7\} \), \( D = \left\{ \{3, 7\}, 10, 15 \right\} \). Here \( p \in C \) and \( C \in D \) but \( p \notin D \).
Example 2
Question: Determine whether the following statement is true or false. If true, prove it. If false, give a counterexample. If \( a \in P \) and \( P \in Q \), then \( a \in Q \).
Solution: We claim this statement is FALSE. To disprove it, we need to find sets \( P \) and \( Q \), and an element \( a \), such that \( a \in P \), \( P \in Q \), but \( a \notin Q \). Let \( a = 5 \), let \( P = \{5, 9, 12\} \), and let \( Q = \left\{ \{5, 9, 12\}, 20 \right\} \). Step 1: Verify \( a \in P \). Since \( P = \{5, 9, 12\} \) and \( 5 \) is listed in \( P \), we have \( a \in P \). ✓ Step 2: Verify \( P \in Q \). Since \( Q = \left\{ \{5, 9, 12\}, 20 \right\} \), the set \( \{5, 9, 12\} \) is an element of \( Q \). Therefore \( P \in Q \). ✓ Step 3: Check whether \( a \in Q \). The elements of \( Q \) are \( \{5, 9, 12\} \) and \( 20 \). The number \( 5 \) is not an element of \( Q \); it is only inside the set \( \{5, 9, 12\} \) which is itself an element of \( Q \). Therefore \( a \notin Q \). ✗ The condition \( P \in Q \) means the entire set \( P \) is packed as a single element of \( Q \), so individual members of \( P \) do not automatically become members of \( Q \). Conclusion: The statement is FALSE. Membership (\( \in \)) is not transitive in general.
Answer: False. Counterexample: \( a = 5 \), \( P = \{5, 9, 12\} \), \( Q = \left\{ \{5, 9, 12\}, 20 \right\} \). Here \( a \in P \) and \( P \in Q \) but \( a \notin Q \).