SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Miscellaneous Exercise Chapter 1 Q2(i)

In each of the following, determine whether the statement is true or false. If it is true, prove it. If it is false, give an example.
If \(x\in A\) and \(A\in B,\) then \(x\in B\)

CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a toy box called \( A \) holding a small ball \( x \). Now another big box called \( B \) holds the entire toy box \( A \) inside it. The big box \( B \) sees only one thing: the toy box \( A \) as a whole. The little ball \( x \) is hidden inside \( A \), so \( B \) does not directly see \( x \) at all. Belonging goes only one level deep, not all the way through.

Answer: The statement is FALSE. Counterexample: take \( x = 1 \), \( A = \{1, 2\} \), \( B = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \). Then \( x \in A \) and \( A \in B \), but \( x \notin B \).

📖 Membership vs Transitivity: Is x ∈ A and A ∈ B ⟹ x ∈ B?

Detailed Explanation

In set theory we must carefully distinguish between an element belonging to a set (the symbol \( \in \)) and a set being a subset of another set (the symbol \( \subseteq \)). The statement asks: if \( x \) is an element of \( A \), and \( A \) is an element of \( B \), does it follow that \( x \) is an element of \( B \)? Here \( A \) plays two roles: it contains \( x \) as an element, and \( A \) itself is treated as a single element sitting inside \( B \). When \( A \in B \), it means the whole set \( A \) is one member of \( B \), not that the elements of \( A \) are members of \( B \). So the individual element \( x \) need not appear in \( B \) at all. This is why membership is not transitive, and the statement turns out to be false. To disprove it, one concrete counterexample is enough.

Formula Used

Statement to test: If \( x \in A \) and \( A \in B \), then \( x \in B \). (This is FALSE in general.)

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand what each condition means. The condition \( x \in A \) says \( x \) is an element of set \( A \). The condition \( A \in B \) says the entire set \( A \) is itself an element of set \( B \). We want to check whether these force \( x \in B \).
  2. Step 2: Choose a simple counterexample. Let \( x = 1 \), let \( A = \{1, 2\} \), and let \( B = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \). Notice that \( B \) has two elements: the set \( \{1, 2\} \) and the number \( 3 \).
  3. Step 3: Check the first hypothesis. Since \( A = \{1, 2\} \), the number \( 1 \) is an element of \( A \). So \( 1 \in A \), that is \( x \in A \) holds true.
  4. Step 4: Check the second hypothesis. The set \( A = \{1, 2\} \) is one of the members of \( B \), because \( B = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \). So \( A \in B \) holds true.
  5. Step 5: Check the conclusion. Is \( x \in B \)? The elements of \( B \) are \( \{1, 2\} \) and \( 3 \). The number \( 1 \) is NOT one of these elements. So \( 1 \notin B \), that is \( x \notin B \).
  6. Step 6: Conclude. Both hypotheses \( x \in A \) and \( A \in B \) are satisfied, yet the conclusion \( x \in B \) fails. This single counterexample shows the statement cannot always be true.

Final Answer

The statement is FALSE. Counterexample: take \( x = 1 \), \( A = \{1, 2\} \), \( B = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \). Then \( x \in A \) and \( A \in B \), but \( x \notin B \).

Common Mistake

Confusing \( \in \) with \( \subseteq \). Students often think \( A \in B \) means every element of \( A \) is also in \( B \). That would be \( A \subseteq B \). But \( A \in B \) means the whole set \( A \) is a single member of \( B \), so the elements of \( A \) need not belong to \( B \).

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify what each symbol means. The notation \( x \in A \) says that \( x \) is a direct member of set \( A \). The notation \( A \in B \) says that the entire set \( A \) is itself a single member of \( B \). — Reason: Carefully reading each condition prevents confusing \( \in \) (element-of) with \( \subseteq \) (subset-of); they behave very differently.
  2. Step 2: Recognise the key difference between \( A \in B \) and \( A \subseteq B \). When \( A \in B \), the whole set \( A \) is one object sitting inside \( B \). The individual elements that live inside \( A \) are NOT automatically placed inside \( B \). — Reason: This distinction is exactly why the statement could be false; \( x \) is an element of \( A \), but \( A \) is treated as one indivisible item in \( B \).
  3. Step 3: Construct a counterexample. Choose \( x = 1 \), \( A = \{1, 2\} \), and \( B = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \). The set \( B \) has exactly two elements: the set \( \{1, 2\} \) and the number \( 3 \). — Reason: One concrete example where the hypothesis holds but the conclusion fails is enough to disprove a general statement.
  4. Step 4: Verify the first condition: \( x \in A \). Since \( A = \{1, 2\} \) and \( x = 1 \), we check whether \( 1 \) appears as a listed member of \( A \). It does, so \( x \in A \) is confirmed true. — Reason: Both hypotheses must actually hold in the counterexample, otherwise the example is invalid.
  5. Step 5: Verify the second condition: \( A \in B \). The elements of \( B = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \) are \( \{1, 2\} \) and \( 3 \). Since \( A = \{1, 2\} \) is listed directly as a member, we confirm \( A \in B \) is true. — Reason: Again, this ensures both hypotheses are satisfied simultaneously.
  6. Step 6: Check the conclusion: is \( x \in B \)? The members of \( B \) are \( \{1, 2\} \) and \( 3 \). The number \( 1 \) does not appear anywhere as a direct element of \( B \), so \( x \notin B \). — Reason: The conclusion is false even though both hypotheses are true, which is exactly what a counterexample must demonstrate.
  7. Step 7: State the conclusion. We have found specific values where \( x \in A \) and \( A \in B \) are both true, yet \( x \in B \) is false. Therefore the implication fails, and the original statement is disproved. — Reason: Disproving a universal statement requires only one counterexample, and we have provided exactly that.

Final Answer

The statement is FALSE. Counterexample: take \( x = 1 \), \( A = \{1, 2\} \), \( B = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \). Then \( x \in A \) and \( A \in B \), but \( x \notin B \).

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students confuse \( A \in B \) with \( A \subseteq B \). If \( A \subseteq B \) were given instead, then every element of \( A \) would indeed belong to \( B \), making the conclusion \( x \in B \) true. But \( A \in B \) only places the whole set \( A \) as one item inside \( B \), without spreading \( A \)'s individual members into \( B \).

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Let \( x = 1 \), \( A = \{1, 2\} \), \( B = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \).
  2. Step 2: \( x = 1 \in \{1, 2\} = A \) ✓ and \( A = \{1, 2\} \in \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} = B \) ✓
  3. Step 3: Elements of \( B \) are \( \{1, 2\} \) and \( 3 \); since \( 1 \) is neither, \( x \notin B \). Counterexample established.

Answer: The statement is FALSE. Counterexample: take \( x = 1 \), \( A = \{1, 2\} \), \( B = \{\{1, 2\}, 3\} \). Then \( x \in A \) and \( A \in B \), but \( x \notin B \).

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Determine whether the following statement is true or false. If true, prove it. If false, give a counterexample. If \( p \in C \) and \( C \in D \), then \( p \in D \).

Solution: We claim this statement is FALSE. To disprove it, we construct a specific counterexample. Let \( p = 3 \), let \( C = \{3, 7\} \), and let \( D = \left\{ \{3, 7\}, 10, 15 \right\} \). Step 1: Check whether \( p \in C \). Since \( C = \{3, 7\} \), clearly \( 3 \in \{3, 7\} \), so \( p \in C \) holds. Step 2: Check whether \( C \in D \). Since \( D = \left\{ \{3, 7\}, 10, 15 \right\} \), the set \( \{3, 7\} \) is itself listed as one of the elements of \( D \). Therefore \( C \in D \) holds. Step 3: Check whether \( p \in D \). The elements of \( D \) are \( \{3, 7\} \), \( 10 \), and \( 15 \). The number \( 3 \) is NOT among these elements. Therefore \( p \notin D \). Conclusion: We have \( p \in C \) and \( C \in D \), yet \( p \notin D \). The statement is FALSE. Note: For the conclusion \( p \in D \) to follow, we would need \( C \subseteq D \) (C is a subset of D), not merely \( C \in D \) (C is an element of D).

Answer: False. Counterexample: \( p = 3 \), \( C = \{3, 7\} \), \( D = \left\{ \{3, 7\}, 10, 15 \right\} \). Here \( p \in C \) and \( C \in D \) but \( p \notin D \).

Example 2

Question: Determine whether the following statement is true or false. If true, prove it. If false, give a counterexample. If \( a \in P \) and \( P \in Q \), then \( a \in Q \).

Solution: We claim this statement is FALSE. To disprove it, we need to find sets \( P \) and \( Q \), and an element \( a \), such that \( a \in P \), \( P \in Q \), but \( a \notin Q \). Let \( a = 5 \), let \( P = \{5, 9, 12\} \), and let \( Q = \left\{ \{5, 9, 12\}, 20 \right\} \). Step 1: Verify \( a \in P \). Since \( P = \{5, 9, 12\} \) and \( 5 \) is listed in \( P \), we have \( a \in P \). ✓ Step 2: Verify \( P \in Q \). Since \( Q = \left\{ \{5, 9, 12\}, 20 \right\} \), the set \( \{5, 9, 12\} \) is an element of \( Q \). Therefore \( P \in Q \). ✓ Step 3: Check whether \( a \in Q \). The elements of \( Q \) are \( \{5, 9, 12\} \) and \( 20 \). The number \( 5 \) is not an element of \( Q \); it is only inside the set \( \{5, 9, 12\} \) which is itself an element of \( Q \). Therefore \( a \notin Q \). ✗ The condition \( P \in Q \) means the entire set \( P \) is packed as a single element of \( Q \), so individual members of \( P \) do not automatically become members of \( Q \). Conclusion: The statement is FALSE. Membership (\( \in \)) is not transitive in general.

Answer: False. Counterexample: \( a = 5 \), \( P = \{5, 9, 12\} \), \( Q = \left\{ \{5, 9, 12\}, 20 \right\} \). Here \( a \in P \) and \( P \in Q \) but \( a \notin Q \).

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Determine whether the following statement is true or false. If it is true, prove it. If it is false, give a counterexample. Statement: If \( A \subseteq B \) and \( x \in A \), then \( x \in B \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand the Statement: The statement claims: whenever \( A \subseteq B \) (i.e., \( A \) is a subset of \( B \)) and \( x \in A \), it must follow that \( x \in B \). We need to decide if this is always true or if a counterexample exists.
  2. Step 2: Recall the Definition of Subset: By definition, \( A \subseteq B \) means: for every element \( y \), if \( y \in A \) then \( y \in B \). This is precisely the condition we need to examine.
  3. Step 3: Apply the Definition Directly: Since \( A \subseteq B \), every element of \( A \) is also an element of \( B \). Given that \( x \in A \), the definition of subset directly tells us \( x \in B \). No counterexample is possible because the conclusion follows immediately from the definition.
  4. Step 4: Write the Formal Proof: Assume \( A \subseteq B \) and \( x \in A \). By the definition of the subset relation, \( A \subseteq B \) means: for all \( y \), \( y \in A \Rightarrow y \in B \). Setting \( y = x \), since \( x \in A \), it follows immediately that \( x \in B \). Hence the statement is TRUE.
  5. Step 5: Contrast with the Original Question: Notice the key difference: the original question had \( A \in B \) (set \( A \) is an element of \( B \)), which is NOT the same as \( A \subseteq B \) (set \( A \) is a subset of \( B \)). The relation \( \in \) is membership, while \( \subseteq \) is inclusion. This distinction makes the original statement false but the present statement true.

Answer: The statement is TRUE. Proof: Since \( A \subseteq B \), by the definition of subset, every element of \( A \) belongs to \( B \). Because \( x \in A \), it directly follows that \( x \in B \).

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Sets