Let \(A=\{ 1, 2,\{ 3, 4\}\,5\}.\) Which of the following statements are incorrect and why? \(\{1, 2, 5\}\in A\)
CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets
CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets
Imagine a bag containing four items: a red ball, a blue ball, a small box with two toys inside, and a yellow ball. Now someone asks: is a gift bag containing the red, blue, and yellow balls inside the big bag? No! The big bag holds individual items, not another gift bag. The set \( A = \{1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5\} \) holds four members: \( 1 \), \( 2 \), \( \{3, 4\} \), and \( 5 \). The collection \( \{1, 2, 5\} \) is not one single member sitting inside \( A \). It is a smaller group whose members all belong to \( A \).
Answer: The statement \( \{1, 2, 5\} \in A \) is INCORRECT. The elements of \( A \) are \( 1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5 \), and \( \{1, 2, 5\} \) is not among them. The correct statement is \( \{1, 2, 5\} \subset A \).
The symbol \( \in \) means 'is an element of' (a member listed inside the set), while \( \subset \) or \( \subseteq \) means 'is a subset of' (all its members belong to the set). To check whether \( \{1, 2, 5\} \in A \), we must ask: does the object \( \{1, 2, 5\} \) appear as a single listed element inside \( A \)? Here \( A = \{1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5\} \). The actual elements of \( A \) are \( 1 \), \( 2 \), \( \{3, 4\} \), and \( 5 \). The set \( \{1, 2, 5\} \) is NOT one of these listed elements, so it cannot belong to \( A \) using \( \in \).
\( x \in A \) means \( x \) is one of the objects listed inside \( A \); \( B \subseteq A \) means every element of \( B \) is an element of \( A \).
The statement \( \{1, 2, 5\} \in A \) is INCORRECT. The elements of \( A \) are \( 1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5 \), and \( \{1, 2, 5\} \) is not among them. The correct statement is \( \{1, 2, 5\} \subset A \).
Students often confuse \( \in \) with \( \subset \). Since \( 1, 2, 5 \) all belong to \( A \), they wrongly conclude \( \{1, 2, 5\} \in A \). But those three numbers being members makes \( \{1, 2, 5\} \) a subset, not an element.
The statement \( \{1, 2, 5\} \in A \) is INCORRECT. The elements of \( A \) are \( 1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5 \), and \( \{1, 2, 5\} \) is not among them. The correct statement is \( \{1, 2, 5\} \subset A \).
One common mistake: students see that 1, 2, and 5 are all present inside \( A \) and immediately write \( \{1, 2, 5\} \in A \), forgetting that \( \in \) requires the entire set \( \{1, 2, 5\} \) to appear as a single listed element of \( A \) — which it does not. The correct symbol here is \( \subset \), not \( \in \).
Answer: The statement \( \{1, 2, 5\} \in A \) is INCORRECT. The elements of \( A \) are \( 1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5 \), and \( \{1, 2, 5\} \) is not among them. The correct statement is \( \{1, 2, 5\} \subset A \).
Question: Let \( B = \{7, 8, \{9, 10\}, 11\} \). State whether the statement \( \{7, 8, 11\} \in B \) is correct or incorrect, and give a reason.
Solution: We first identify all the elements of \( B \). The set \( B \) has exactly four elements: \( 7 \), \( 8 \), \( \{9, 10\} \), and \( 11 \). Now we examine \( \{7, 8, 11\} \in B \). The symbol \( \in \) is used when an object is a member (element) of a set. For \( \{7, 8, 11\} \in B \) to be true, the set \( \{7, 8, 11\} \) must itself appear as one of the four listed elements of \( B \). Looking at the elements of \( B \), we see \( 7 \), \( 8 \), \( \{9, 10\} \), and \( 11 \) — the set \( \{7, 8, 11\} \) does NOT appear as a listed element. However, each of \( 7 \), \( 8 \), and \( 11 \) individually belongs to \( B \), which means \( \{7, 8, 11\} \subseteq B \) (subset), not \( \{7, 8, 11\} \in B \) (element of). Therefore, the statement \( \{7, 8, 11\} \in B \) is incorrect. The correct relationship is \( \{7, 8, 11\} \subset B \).
Answer: The statement \( \{7, 8, 11\} \in B \) is incorrect because \( \{7, 8, 11\} \) is not a listed element of \( B \); the correct statement is \( \{7, 8, 11\} \subset B \).
Question: Let \( C = \{a, b, \{c, d\}, e\} \). State whether the statement \( \{c, d\} \in C \) is correct or incorrect, and give a reason.
Solution: We first list all the elements of \( C \). The set \( C \) has exactly four elements: \( a \), \( b \), \( \{c, d\} \), and \( e \). Note carefully that \( \{c, d\} \) is written inside \( C \) with its own braces, making it a single element (a set within a set). Now we check \( \{c, d\} \in C \). The symbol \( \in \) asks: does the object \( \{c, d\} \) appear as a direct member of \( C \)? Yes — \( \{c, d\} \) is explicitly listed as one of the four elements of \( C \). Therefore, the statement \( \{c, d\} \in C \) is correct. Note that \( c \in C \) would be incorrect because \( c \) by itself is not a direct element of \( C \); only the set \( \{c, d\} \) as a whole is an element of \( C \).
Answer: The statement \( \{c, d\} \in C \) is correct because \( \{c, d\} \) appears as a direct (single) element of \( C \).
Question: Let \( B = \{7, 8, \{9, 10\}, 11\} \). State whether the following statement is correct or incorrect and give a reason: \( \{7, 8, 11\} \in B \).
Answer: The statement \( \{7, 8, 11\} \in B \) is INCORRECT. The elements of \( B \) are \( 7 \), \( 8 \), \( \{9, 10\} \), and \( 11 \), and \( \{7, 8, 11\} \) is not among them. The correct statement is \( \{7, 8, 11\} \subset B \).