SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Exercise 1.3 Q3(v)

Let \(A=\{ 1, 2,\{ 3, 4\}\,5\}.\) Which of the following statements are incorrect and why? \(1\subset A\)

CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine you have a bag called \( A \) containing some items: the number \( 1 \), the number \( 2 \), a smaller bag \( \{3, 4\} \), and the number \( 5 \). The symbol \( \in \) means "is an item inside the bag." The symbol \( \subset \) means "one whole bag fits inside another bag." Since \( 1 \) is just a single number — not a bag — you cannot use \( \subset \) with it. Saying \( 1 \subset A \) is like asking if a coin is a purse inside a bag. It makes no sense! The right way is \( 1 \in A \).

Answer: The statement \( 1 \subset A \) is INCORRECT, because \( 1 \) is an element (a number), not a set, and \( \subset \) can only relate two sets. The correct statement is \( 1 \in A \), or equivalently \( \{1\} \subset A \).

📖 Is the Statement 1 ⊂ A Correct?

Detailed Explanation

We are given the set \( A = \{1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5\} \). Its elements are \( 1 \), \( 2 \), the set \( \{3, 4\} \), and \( 5 \). There are two different relationships you must never confuse. The symbol \( \in \) (element of) is used between an object and a set, telling us the object is a member of the set. The symbol \( \subset \) (subset of) is used between two sets, telling us every element of the first set is also an element of the second set. So on the left of \( \subset \) there must be a SET, not just a single object. The statement given is \( 1 \subset A \). Here \( 1 \) is a number (an object), not a set, so writing \( \subset \) after it is not valid.

Formula Used

\( x \in A \) means x is an element of A. \( B \subset A \) means every element of B is an element of A (so B must itself be a set).

Solution

  1. Step 1: List the elements of the set. \( A = \{1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5\} \). The members are \( 1 \), \( 2 \), \( \{3, 4\} \) and \( 5 \).
  2. Step 2: Check what type of object \( 1 \) is. Here \( 1 \) is a single number, i.e. an element, not a set.
  3. Step 3: Recall the rule for \( \subset \). The symbol \( \subset \) can only be placed between two sets. Since \( 1 \) is not a set, the expression \( 1 \subset A \) is meaningless and therefore incorrect.
  4. Step 4: State the correct form. Because \( 1 \) is an element of \( A \), the correct statement is \( 1 \in A \). If we wanted to use \( \subset \), we would write \( \{1\} \subset A \), since the set \( \{1\} \) is a subset of \( A \).

Final Answer

The statement \( 1 \subset A \) is INCORRECT, because \( 1 \) is an element (a number), not a set, and \( \subset \) can only relate two sets. The correct statement is \( 1 \in A \), or equivalently \( \{1\} \subset A \).

Common Mistake

A very common mistake is treating \( \in \) and \( \subset \) as the same thing. Writing \( 1 \subset A \) instead of \( 1 \in A \) mixes up an element with a subset. Remember: a single object uses \( \in \), while a set enclosed in braces uses \( \subset \).

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Write out the given set and identify all its members. The set is \( A = \\{1, 2, \\{3, 4\\}, 5\\} \). Its four members are: the number \( 1 \), the number \( 2 \), the set \( \\{3, 4\\} \), and the number \( 5 \). — Reason: Knowing exactly what the elements are helps us judge what type of object \( 1 \) is.
  2. Step 2: Classify the object \( 1 \). Here \( 1 \) is a plain number — a single element, not a collection of elements. — Reason: We need to know whether \( 1 \) is a set or just a member before deciding which symbol is appropriate.
  3. Step 3: Recall the rule governing \( \subset \). The subset symbol \( \subset \) is only defined between two sets: we write \( B \subset A \) only when \( B \) is itself a set. Since \( 1 \) is not a set, the expression \( 1 \subset A \) violates this rule and is therefore incorrect. — Reason: Applying \( \subset \) to a non-set object is like asking whether a single apple is a basket — the question itself is ill-formed.
  4. Step 4: Apply the correct symbol for an element. Because \( 1 \) is an element (member) of \( A \), the proper notation is \( 1 \in A \). — Reason: The symbol \( \in \) is designed exactly for the relationship between an individual object and the set it belongs to.
  5. Step 5: Show how \( \subset \) could be used correctly in this context. If we wrap \( 1 \) in set braces, we get the singleton set \( \\{1\\} \), which is indeed a set. Every element of \( \\{1\\} \) (which is just \( 1 \)) belongs to \( A \), so \( \\{1\\} \subset A \) is a valid and true statement. — Reason: This demonstrates the correct way to involve \( 1 \) in a subset relationship — by first making it into a set.

Final Answer

The statement \( 1 \subset A \) is INCORRECT, because \( 1 \) is an element (a number), not a set, and \( \subset \) can only relate two sets. The correct statement is \( 1 \in A \), or equivalently \( \{1\} \subset A \).

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students see that \( 1 \) is inside \( A \) and automatically write \( 1 \subset A \), forgetting that \( \subset \) requires both sides to be sets — only the singleton \( \\{1\\} \subset A \) is valid, not the bare number \( 1 \subset A \).

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Given: \( A = \{1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5\} \). Check the nature of \( 1 \): it is a number (element), not a set.
  2. Step 2: \( \subset \) requires both sides to be sets, so \( 1 \subset A \) is invalid.
  3. Step 3: Correct forms: \( 1 \in A \) or \( \{1\} \subset A \).

Answer: The statement \( 1 \subset A \) is INCORRECT, because \( 1 \) is an element (a number), not a set, and \( \subset \) can only relate two sets. The correct statement is \( 1 \in A \), or equivalently \( \{1\} \subset A \).

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Let \( B = \{7, 8, \{9, 10\}, 11\} \). State whether the following statement is correct or incorrect, and give a reason: \( 7 \subset B \).

Solution: We first identify the elements of \( B \). The set \( B \) has exactly four elements: \( 7 \), \( 8 \), \( \{9, 10\} \), and \( 11 \). Now, the symbol \( \subset \) (or \( \subseteq \)) is used to describe the relationship between two SETS. We say \( P \subset Q \) only when \( P \) is a set and every element of \( P \) is also an element of \( Q \). Here, \( 7 \) is a number (an element), NOT a set. Therefore, writing \( 7 \subset B \) is meaningless because the subset relation requires both sides to be sets. The correct statement is \( 7 \in B \), meaning 7 is an element (member) of \( B \). Hence, the statement \( 7 \subset B \) is INCORRECT. The correct notation is \( 7 \in B \).

Answer: The statement \( 7 \subset B \) is incorrect because 7 is an element of \( B \), not a set. The correct statement is \( 7 \in B \).

Example 2

Question: Let \( C = \{a, b, \{c, d\}, e\} \). State whether the following statement is correct or incorrect, and give a reason: \( \{c, d\} \subset C \).

Solution: We first list all the elements of \( C \). The set \( C \) contains exactly four elements: \( a \), \( b \), \( \{c, d\} \), and \( e \). Note carefully: \( \{c, d\} \) appears inside \( C \) as a single element (a set-valued element). This means \( \{c, d\} \in C \). Now, for \( \{c, d\} \subset C \) to be true, every element of \( \{c, d\} \) must also be an element of \( C \). The elements of \( \{c, d\} \) are \( c \) and \( d \). We check: Is \( c \in C \)? The elements of \( C \) are \( a \), \( b \), \( \{c, d\} \), and \( e \). The symbol \( c \) alone does NOT appear as an element of \( C \); only the pair \( \{c, d\} \) does. So \( c \notin C \). Since \( c \) is an element of \( \{c, d\} \) but \( c \) is not an element of \( C \), the condition for the subset relation fails. Therefore, \( \{c, d\} \subset C \) is INCORRECT. The correct statement is \( \{c, d\} \in C \) (i.e., \( \{c, d\} \) is a member of \( C \), not a subset of \( C \)).

Answer: The statement \( \{c, d\} \subset C \) is incorrect because \( \{c, d\} \) is an element of \( C \), not a subset. The correct notation is \( \{c, d\} \in C \).

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Let \( B = \{2, 4, \{6, 8\}, 10\} \). State whether the following statement is correct or incorrect, and give a reason: \( \{6, 8\} \in B \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the elements of B: List all members of the set \( B = \{2, 4, \{6, 8\}, 10\} \). The elements are: \( 2 \), \( 4 \), \( \{6, 8\} \), and \( 10 \). Notice that \( \{6, 8\} \) appears as a single element inside \( B \) — it is a set itself, but it is treated as one member of \( B \).
  2. Step 2: Recall the meaning of \( \in \): The symbol \( \in \) means 'is an element of' or 'belongs to'. We write \( x \in B \) when \( x \) is directly listed as a member in \( B \).
  3. Step 3: Check whether \( \{6, 8\} \in B \): Looking at the elements of \( B \), we see that \( \{6, 8\} \) is directly listed as one of its members. Therefore the statement \( \{6, 8\} \in B \) is CORRECT.
  4. Step 4: Distinguish \( \in \) from \( \subset \) for this case: Note carefully: \( \{6, 8\} \in B \) is correct because \( \{6, 8\} \) is an element of \( B \). However, \( \{6, 8\} \subset B \) would be INCORRECT, because for that we would need both \( 6 \in B \) and \( 8 \in B \), which is NOT the case — neither \( 6 \) nor \( 8 \) individually belongs to \( B \).

Answer: The statement \( \{6, 8\} \in B \) is CORRECT, because \( \{6, 8\} \) is explicitly listed as an element (member) of \( B = \{2, 4, \{6, 8\}, 10\} \). The symbol \( \in \) is appropriate here since \( \{6, 8\} \) is a direct member of \( B \). (In contrast, \( \{6, 8\} \subset B \) would be incorrect, because \( 6 \notin B \) and \( 8 \notin B \) individually.)

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Sets