SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Exercise 1.3 Q3(ix)

Let \(A=\{ 1, 2,\{ 3, 4\}\,5\}.\) Which of the following statements are incorrect and why? \(\phi \in A\)

CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a lunchbox with exactly four items inside: an apple, a banana, a small box, and a sandwich. Now someone asks: is an empty bag inside this lunchbox? No! The empty bag is nowhere in the list. The set \( A = \{1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5\} \) is like that lunchbox. The symbol \( \phi \) is the empty set, like an empty bag. It is not sitting inside \( A \) as one of the four items. So saying \( \phi \in A \) is like claiming the empty bag is in the lunchbox — it simply is not there.

Answer: The statement \( \phi \in A \) is incorrect, because \( \phi \) is not one of the elements of \( A \). The elements of \( A \) are only \( 1 \), \( 2 \), \( \{3, 4\} \), and \( 5 \). (Note that \( \phi \subseteq A \) would be correct, but that is a different statement.)

📖 Is the statement \( \phi \in A \) correct?

Detailed Explanation

The set given is \( A = \{1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5\} \). To answer this question you must carefully list the elements of \( A \). The elements are \( 1 \), \( 2 \), \( \{3, 4\} \) (a set that is itself an element), and \( 5 \). The symbol \( \in \) means 'is an element of'. So the statement \( \phi \in A \) claims that the empty set \( \phi \) is one of the listed members of \( A \). A very common source of confusion is that \( \phi \) is a subset of every set, written \( \phi \subseteq A \), but this does NOT mean \( \phi \) is an element of the set. Being a subset and being an element are two different ideas.

Formula Used

\( x \in A \) means \( x \) is one of the listed elements of \( A \); \( \phi \subseteq A \) is always true for every set \( A \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: List the elements of the set clearly. The set is \( A = \{1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5\} \). Its elements are \( 1 \), \( 2 \), \( \{3, 4\} \), and \( 5 \).
  2. Step 2: Understand what \( \phi \in A \) claims. The symbol \( \in \) means 'belongs to' or 'is an element of'. So \( \phi \in A \) states that the empty set \( \phi \) appears in the list of elements of \( A \).
  3. Step 3: Check the list of elements. The four elements are \( 1 \), \( 2 \), \( \{3, 4\} \), and \( 5 \). None of these is the empty set \( \phi \). Therefore \( \phi \) is not an element of \( A \).
  4. Step 4: Distinguish subset from element. It is true that \( \phi \subseteq A \) because the empty set is a subset of every set. But 'subset' is different from 'element'. The statement uses \( \in \), not \( \subseteq \), so it is asking about membership, which is false here.
  5. Step 5: Conclude. Since \( \phi \) is not among the listed elements of \( A \), the statement \( \phi \in A \) is incorrect.

Final Answer

The statement \( \phi \in A \) is incorrect, because \( \phi \) is not one of the elements of \( A \). The elements of \( A \) are only \( 1 \), \( 2 \), \( \{3, 4\} \), and \( 5 \). (Note that \( \phi \subseteq A \) would be correct, but that is a different statement.)

Common Mistake

Students often confuse \( \in \) with \( \subseteq \). They know \( \phi \) is a subset of every set and wrongly conclude \( \phi \in A \) is true. Being a subset (\( \phi \subseteq A \)) does not make \( \phi \) an element (\( \phi \in A \)).

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Write out the given set and identify each of its elements individually. The set is \( A = \{1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5\} \). Reading carefully, the four elements are: \( 1 \), \( 2 \), \( \{3, 4\} \) (a set counted as a single element), and \( 5 \). — Reason: Listing the elements precisely prevents confusion between what is inside \( A \) and what is merely related to \( A \) in some other way.
  2. Step 2: Decode what the statement \( \phi \in A \) actually claims. The symbol \( \in \) means 'belongs to' or 'is a member of', so \( \phi \in A \) is asserting that the empty set \( \phi \) appears in the list of elements of \( A \). — Reason: Correctly reading the mathematical symbol is essential before we can judge whether the statement is true or false.
  3. Step 3: Check whether \( \phi \) matches any element in the list. The elements are \( 1 \), \( 2 \), \( \{3, 4\} \), and \( 5 \). None of these is \( \phi \). Therefore \( \phi \notin A \), and the statement \( \phi \in A \) is false. — Reason: A direct comparison between \( \phi \) and each listed element shows there is no match.
  4. Step 4: Clarify why the statement might seem tempting but is still wrong. It is a universal fact that the empty set is a subset of every set, so \( \phi \subseteq A \) is true. However, \( \subseteq \) (subset) and \( \in \) (element) are two entirely different relations. \( \phi \subseteq A \) says every member of \( \phi \) (there are none) is also in \( A \); it does NOT say \( \phi \) itself sits inside \( A \) as a listed member. — Reason: Drawing a sharp line between 'subset of' and 'element of' prevents the single most common error in set theory at this level.

Final Answer

The statement \( \phi \in A \) is incorrect, because \( \phi \) is not one of the elements of \( A \). The elements of \( A \) are only \( 1 \), \( 2 \), \( \{3, 4\} \), and \( 5 \). (Note that \( \phi \subseteq A \) would be correct, but that is a different statement.)

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students assume that because \( \phi \subseteq A \) is always true, it must also mean \( \phi \in A \) is true — but 'being a subset of' and 'being an element of' are two completely different relationships, and one does not imply the other.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Given: \( A = \{1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5\} \). Elements of \( A \): \( 1,\ 2,\ \{3,4\},\ 5 \).
  2. Step 2: \( \phi \notin \{1, 2, \{3,4\}, 5\} \), so \( \phi \in A \) is FALSE.
  3. Step 3: \( \phi \subseteq A \) is TRUE (empty set is a subset of every set), but \( \phi \in A \) and \( \phi \subseteq A \) are distinct statements.

Answer: The statement \( \phi \in A \) is incorrect, because \( \phi \) is not one of the elements of \( A \). The elements of \( A \) are only \( 1 \), \( 2 \), \( \{3, 4\} \), and \( 5 \). (Note that \( \phi \subseteq A \) would be correct, but that is a different statement.)

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Let \( B = \{7, 8, \{9, 10\}, 11\} \). State whether the following statement is correct or incorrect, and justify your answer: \( \emptyset \in B \).

Solution: We are asked whether the empty set \( \emptyset \) is an element (member) of the set \( B \). The set \( B \) is given as \( B = \{7, 8, \{9, 10\}, 11\} \). Listing the elements of \( B \) explicitly: the elements are \( 7 \), \( 8 \), \( \{9, 10\} \), and \( 11 \). None of these four elements is the empty set \( \emptyset \). Therefore \( \emptyset \) does NOT appear as a member of \( B \). Hence the statement \( \emptyset \in B \) is INCORRECT. Note: Although \( \emptyset \subseteq B \) is always true (the empty set is a subset of every set), that is a completely different statement from \( \emptyset \in B \). Membership (\( \in \)) requires that \( \emptyset \) itself be one of the listed objects inside \( B \), which it is not.

Answer: The statement \( \emptyset \in B \) is incorrect because \( \emptyset \) is not listed as an element of \( B = \{7, 8, \{9, 10\}, 11\} \). We can only say \( \emptyset \subseteq B \), not \( \emptyset \in B \).

Example 2

Question: Let \( C = \{a, \{b, c\}, d, \emptyset\} \). State whether the following statement is correct or incorrect, and justify your answer: \( \emptyset \in C \).

Solution: We are asked whether the empty set \( \emptyset \) is an element (member) of the set \( C \). The set \( C \) is given as \( C = \{a, \{b, c\}, d, \emptyset\} \). Listing the elements of \( C \) explicitly: the elements are \( a \), \( \{b, c\} \), \( d \), and \( \emptyset \). Here, \( \emptyset \) is clearly and explicitly written as one of the four elements of \( C \). Therefore the statement \( \emptyset \in C \) is CORRECT. This is an important contrast to the previous example: the empty set \( \emptyset \) is always a subset of any set (i.e., \( \emptyset \subseteq C \)), but it is also an element of \( C \) here because it has been explicitly placed inside the braces defining \( C \).

Answer: The statement \( \emptyset \in C \) is correct because \( \emptyset \) is explicitly listed as one of the elements of \( C = \{a, \{b, c\}, d, \emptyset\} \).

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Let \( B = \{7, 8, \{9, 10\}, 11\} \). State whether the following statement is correct or incorrect, and give a reason: \( \{9, 10\} \subseteq B \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the elements of B: Write out all the elements of the set \( B = \{7, 8, \{9, 10\}, 11\} \). The elements of \( B \) are: \( 7 \), \( 8 \), \( \{9, 10\} \), and \( 11 \). Notice that \( \{9, 10\} \) is a single element of \( B \) — it is a set that sits inside \( B \) as one element. The numbers \( 9 \) and \( 10 \) individually are NOT elements of \( B \).
  2. Step 2: Recall the definition of subset: A set \( X \) is a subset of a set \( Y \), written \( X \subseteq Y \), if and only if every element of \( X \) is also an element of \( Y \). That is, for all \( x \), if \( x \in X \) then \( x \in Y \).
  3. Step 3: Check whether {9, 10} ⊆ B: For \( \{9, 10\} \subseteq B \) to be true, every element of \( \{9, 10\} \) must be an element of \( B \). The elements of \( \{9, 10\} \) are \( 9 \) and \( 10 \). Now check: is \( 9 \in B \)? No — \( 9 \) is not listed as an element of \( B \). Similarly, is \( 10 \in B \)? No — \( 10 \) is not listed as an element of \( B \) either. Since neither \( 9 \) nor \( 10 \) belongs to \( B \), the condition for a subset is NOT satisfied.
  4. Step 4: Identify what IS true instead: Although \( \{9, 10\} \not\subseteq B \), notice that \( \{9, 10\} \) is itself one of the listed elements of \( B \). Therefore the correct statement is \( \{9, 10\} \in B \), not \( \{9, 10\} \subseteq B \).
  5. Step 5: State the conclusion: The statement \( \{9, 10\} \subseteq B \) is INCORRECT. The elements \( 9 \) and \( 10 \) do not individually belong to \( B \); only the set \( \{9, 10\} \) as a whole is an element of \( B \). The correct relationship is \( \{9, 10\} \in B \).

Answer: The statement \( \{9, 10\} \subseteq B \) is INCORRECT. For \( \{9, 10\} \) to be a subset of \( B \), the individual elements \( 9 \) and \( 10 \) would each need to belong to \( B \), but they do not. The numbers \( 9 \) and \( 10 \) are not elements of \( B \). The correct statement is \( \{9, 10\} \in B \) (membership, not subset).

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Sets