Let \(A=\{ 1, 2,\{ 3, 4\}\,5\}.\) Which of the following statements are incorrect and why? \(\phi \in A\)
CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets
CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets
Imagine a lunchbox with exactly four items inside: an apple, a banana, a small box, and a sandwich. Now someone asks: is an empty bag inside this lunchbox? No! The empty bag is nowhere in the list. The set \( A = \{1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5\} \) is like that lunchbox. The symbol \( \phi \) is the empty set, like an empty bag. It is not sitting inside \( A \) as one of the four items. So saying \( \phi \in A \) is like claiming the empty bag is in the lunchbox — it simply is not there.
Answer: The statement \( \phi \in A \) is incorrect, because \( \phi \) is not one of the elements of \( A \). The elements of \( A \) are only \( 1 \), \( 2 \), \( \{3, 4\} \), and \( 5 \). (Note that \( \phi \subseteq A \) would be correct, but that is a different statement.)
The set given is \( A = \{1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5\} \). To answer this question you must carefully list the elements of \( A \). The elements are \( 1 \), \( 2 \), \( \{3, 4\} \) (a set that is itself an element), and \( 5 \). The symbol \( \in \) means 'is an element of'. So the statement \( \phi \in A \) claims that the empty set \( \phi \) is one of the listed members of \( A \). A very common source of confusion is that \( \phi \) is a subset of every set, written \( \phi \subseteq A \), but this does NOT mean \( \phi \) is an element of the set. Being a subset and being an element are two different ideas.
\( x \in A \) means \( x \) is one of the listed elements of \( A \); \( \phi \subseteq A \) is always true for every set \( A \).
The statement \( \phi \in A \) is incorrect, because \( \phi \) is not one of the elements of \( A \). The elements of \( A \) are only \( 1 \), \( 2 \), \( \{3, 4\} \), and \( 5 \). (Note that \( \phi \subseteq A \) would be correct, but that is a different statement.)
Students often confuse \( \in \) with \( \subseteq \). They know \( \phi \) is a subset of every set and wrongly conclude \( \phi \in A \) is true. Being a subset (\( \phi \subseteq A \)) does not make \( \phi \) an element (\( \phi \in A \)).
The statement \( \phi \in A \) is incorrect, because \( \phi \) is not one of the elements of \( A \). The elements of \( A \) are only \( 1 \), \( 2 \), \( \{3, 4\} \), and \( 5 \). (Note that \( \phi \subseteq A \) would be correct, but that is a different statement.)
One common mistake: students assume that because \( \phi \subseteq A \) is always true, it must also mean \( \phi \in A \) is true — but 'being a subset of' and 'being an element of' are two completely different relationships, and one does not imply the other.
Answer: The statement \( \phi \in A \) is incorrect, because \( \phi \) is not one of the elements of \( A \). The elements of \( A \) are only \( 1 \), \( 2 \), \( \{3, 4\} \), and \( 5 \). (Note that \( \phi \subseteq A \) would be correct, but that is a different statement.)
Question: Let \( B = \{7, 8, \{9, 10\}, 11\} \). State whether the following statement is correct or incorrect, and justify your answer: \( \emptyset \in B \).
Solution: We are asked whether the empty set \( \emptyset \) is an element (member) of the set \( B \). The set \( B \) is given as \( B = \{7, 8, \{9, 10\}, 11\} \). Listing the elements of \( B \) explicitly: the elements are \( 7 \), \( 8 \), \( \{9, 10\} \), and \( 11 \). None of these four elements is the empty set \( \emptyset \). Therefore \( \emptyset \) does NOT appear as a member of \( B \). Hence the statement \( \emptyset \in B \) is INCORRECT. Note: Although \( \emptyset \subseteq B \) is always true (the empty set is a subset of every set), that is a completely different statement from \( \emptyset \in B \). Membership (\( \in \)) requires that \( \emptyset \) itself be one of the listed objects inside \( B \), which it is not.
Answer: The statement \( \emptyset \in B \) is incorrect because \( \emptyset \) is not listed as an element of \( B = \{7, 8, \{9, 10\}, 11\} \). We can only say \( \emptyset \subseteq B \), not \( \emptyset \in B \).
Question: Let \( C = \{a, \{b, c\}, d, \emptyset\} \). State whether the following statement is correct or incorrect, and justify your answer: \( \emptyset \in C \).
Solution: We are asked whether the empty set \( \emptyset \) is an element (member) of the set \( C \). The set \( C \) is given as \( C = \{a, \{b, c\}, d, \emptyset\} \). Listing the elements of \( C \) explicitly: the elements are \( a \), \( \{b, c\} \), \( d \), and \( \emptyset \). Here, \( \emptyset \) is clearly and explicitly written as one of the four elements of \( C \). Therefore the statement \( \emptyset \in C \) is CORRECT. This is an important contrast to the previous example: the empty set \( \emptyset \) is always a subset of any set (i.e., \( \emptyset \subseteq C \)), but it is also an element of \( C \) here because it has been explicitly placed inside the braces defining \( C \).
Answer: The statement \( \emptyset \in C \) is correct because \( \emptyset \) is explicitly listed as one of the elements of \( C = \{a, \{b, c\}, d, \emptyset\} \).
Question: Let \( B = \{7, 8, \{9, 10\}, 11\} \). State whether the following statement is correct or incorrect, and give a reason: \( \{9, 10\} \subseteq B \).
Answer: The statement \( \{9, 10\} \subseteq B \) is INCORRECT. For \( \{9, 10\} \) to be a subset of \( B \), the individual elements \( 9 \) and \( 10 \) would each need to belong to \( B \), but they do not. The numbers \( 9 \) and \( 10 \) are not elements of \( B \). The correct statement is \( \{9, 10\} \in B \) (membership, not subset).