Let \(A=\{ 1, 2,\{ 3, 4\}\,5\}.\) Which of the following statements are incorrect and why? \(1\in A\)
CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets
CBSE Class 11 Maths · Sets
Think of a set like a lunchbox. The lunchbox \( A = \\{ 1, 2, \\{3, 4\\}, 5 \\} \) holds four things inside it: the number \( 1 \), the number \( 2 \), a small bag containing \( 3 \) and \( 4 \), and the number \( 5 \). To check if something belongs, you only peek at what is directly inside the lunchbox. The number \( 1 \) is sitting right there inside, so it definitely belongs. The symbol \( \in \) just means "is inside."
Answer: The statement \( 1 \in A \) is CORRECT (true), because \( 1 \) is one of the top-level elements of \( A = \{ 1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5 \} \).
A set is a well-defined collection of objects called its elements. The symbol \( \in \) means 'is an element of', and \( \notin \) means 'is not an element of'. To test whether \( x \in A \), we look only at the objects listed at the top level inside the braces of \( A \). A tricky point is that a set can itself be an element of another set. Here the set is \( A = \{ 1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5 \} \). Its top-level elements are \( 1 \), \( 2 \), the set \( \{3, 4\} \), and \( 5 \). Note that \( 3 \) and \( 4 \) are NOT elements of \( A \); they are elements of the inner set \( \{3, 4\} \), which as a whole is one element of \( A \).
\( x \in A \) is true precisely when \( x \) appears as one of the top-level elements listed inside the braces of \( A \).
The statement \( 1 \in A \) is CORRECT (true), because \( 1 \) is one of the top-level elements of \( A = \{ 1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5 \} \).
A common error is to confuse the membership symbol \( \in \) with the subset symbol \( \subset \). Writing \( 1 \subset A \) would be wrong, because \( 1 \) is a single element, not a set; the correct relation for a single element is \( 1 \in A \). Also, students sometimes wrongly think \( 3 \in A \) or \( 4 \in A \), but \( 3 \) and \( 4 \) only belong to the inner set \( \{3, 4\} \), not to \( A \) directly.
The statement \( 1 \in A \) is CORRECT (true), because \( 1 \) is one of the top-level elements of \( A = \{ 1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5 \} \).
One common mistake: Students sometimes confuse elements of an inner (nested) set with elements of the outer set — for example, incorrectly thinking that \( 3 \in A \) because \( 3 \) appears inside \( \{3, 4\} \). In reality, only \( \{3, 4\} \) as a whole is an element of \( A \), not the individual numbers \( 3 \) or \( 4 \).
Answer: The statement \( 1 \in A \) is CORRECT (true), because \( 1 \) is one of the top-level elements of \( A = \{ 1, 2, \{3, 4\}, 5 \} \).
Question: Let \( B = \{7, 8, \{9, 10\}, 11\} \). State whether each of the following is correct or incorrect, and give a reason. (i) \( 8 \in B \) (ii) \( \{9, 10\} \subseteq B \) (iii) \( 9 \in B \) (iv) \( \{9, 10\} \in B \)
Solution: The set \( B = \{7, 8, \{9, 10\}, 11\} \) has exactly four elements: \( 7 \), \( 8 \), the set \( \{9, 10\} \) (treated as a single element), and \( 11 \). (i) \( 8 \in B \): This is CORRECT. The number \( 8 \) is directly listed as an element of \( B \). (ii) \( \{9, 10\} \subseteq B \): This is INCORRECT. For \( \{9, 10\} \subseteq B \) to be true, every element of \( \{9, 10\} \) must be an element of \( B \). That would require \( 9 \in B \) and \( 10 \in B \). However, \( 9 \) and \( 10 \) are not individual elements of \( B \); only the set \( \{9, 10\} \) as a whole is an element. So this statement is incorrect. (iii) \( 9 \in B \): This is INCORRECT. The number \( 9 \) is not a direct element of \( B \). It is an element inside the nested set \( \{9, 10\} \), which itself is one element of \( B \). Therefore \( 9 \notin B \). (iv) \( \{9, 10\} \in B \): This is CORRECT. The set \( \{9, 10\} \) appears as one of the four elements listed in \( B \), so it belongs to \( B \).
Answer: (i) Correct — 8 is a direct element of B. (ii) Incorrect — 9 and 10 are not individual elements of B. (iii) Incorrect — 9 is inside the nested set, not a direct element of B. (iv) Correct — the set {9, 10} is itself an element of B.
Question: Let \( C = \{a, b, \{c, d\}, e, \{f\}\} \). Determine whether each statement is correct or incorrect and justify your answer. (i) \( \{c, d\} \in C \) (ii) \( \{f\} \subseteq C \) (iii) \( f \in C \) (iv) \( \{\{c, d\}\} \subseteq C \)
Solution: The set \( C = \{a, b, \{c, d\}, e, \{f\}\} \) has five elements: \( a \), \( b \), the set \( \{c, d\} \), \( e \), and the set \( \{f\} \). Each of these five objects is a direct element of \( C \). (i) \( \{c, d\} \in C \): This is CORRECT. The set \( \{c, d\} \) is explicitly listed as one of the elements of \( C \). (ii) \( \{f\} \subseteq C \): This is INCORRECT. For \( \{f\} \subseteq C \) to hold, every element of \( \{f\} \) must be an element of \( C \). The only element of \( \{f\} \) is \( f \). But \( f \) by itself is not a direct element of \( C \); only the set \( \{f\} \) is. Hence \( f \notin C \), so \( \{f\} \not\subseteq C \). (iii) \( f \in C \): This is INCORRECT. The letter \( f \) alone does not appear as an element of \( C \). It appears only inside the nested set \( \{f\} \), which is an element of \( C \). So \( f \notin C \). (iv) \( \{\{c, d\}\} \subseteq C \): This is CORRECT. The set \( \{\{c, d\}\} \) has exactly one element, namely \( \{c, d\} \). Since \( \{c, d\} \in C \) (as shown in part (i)), every element of \( \{\{c, d\}\} \) is in \( C \). Therefore \( \{\{c, d\}\} \subseteq C \).
Answer: (i) Correct — {c, d} is a direct element of C. (ii) Incorrect — f is not a direct element of C. (iii) Incorrect — f is only inside the nested set {f}, not a direct element of C. (iv) Correct — {c, d} is an element of C, so {{c, d}} is a subset of C.
Question: Let \( B = \{2, 4, \{6, 7\}, 9\} \). State whether the following statement is correct or incorrect, and give a reason: \( 6 \in B \).
Answer: The statement \( 6 \in B \) is INCORRECT. Since \( B = \{2, 4, \{6, 7\}, 9\} \), the element \( 6 \) is not a top-level member of \( B \); it belongs to the inner set \( \{6, 7\} \). The correct statement is \( 6 \notin B \).