SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Exercise 12.1 Q4(iii)

The length of \(40\) leaves of a plant are measured correct to one millimetre, and the obtained data is represented in the following table: Is it correct to conclude that the maximum number of leaves are \(153\ mm\) long\(?\) Why\(?\)

CBSE Class 9 Maths · Statistics

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine a box of crayons sorted by colour groups, not by exact shade. You know the red group has the most crayons, but you cannot say exactly which red shade there are most of. The leaf data works the same way. The group \( 145-153 \) mm has the most leaves, which is \( 12 \). But that group covers many different lengths. We cannot point to one exact length and say all \( 12 \) leaves are exactly that long. Grouped data hides the exact values inside the group.

Answer: No, it is not correct. The maximum number of leaves, namely \( 12 \), lie in the class interval \( 145-153 \), which covers all lengths from \( 145\ mm \) to \( 153\ mm \). Since the data is grouped, we cannot conclude that the leaves are exactly \( 153\ mm \) long.

📖 Interpreting a Grouped Frequency Distribution

Detailed Explanation

In a grouped frequency distribution, the data is arranged in class intervals, not as single exact values. Looking at the table, the class interval \( 145-153 \) has the highest frequency, which is \( 12 \). This means the largest number of leaves fall inside this interval. But an interval like \( 145-153 \) covers a whole range of lengths from \( 145\ mm \) up to \( 153\ mm \), not just the single value \( 153\ mm \). Since the data has been grouped, we lose the information about the exact length of each individual leaf. So we cannot pick out one exact value and say the maximum leaves have exactly that length.

Formula Used

For a class interval, class size = upper limit - lower limit. Here the interval with maximum frequency is \( 145-153 \) with frequency \( 12 \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Read the frequencies from the table. The number of leaves in each length interval is: \( 118-126 \) has \( 3 \), \( 127-135 \) has \( 5 \), \( 136-144 \) has \( 9 \), \( 145-153 \) has \( 12 \), \( 154-162 \) has \( 5 \), \( 163-171 \) has \( 4 \), \( 172-180 \) has \( 2 \).
  2. Step 2: Find the interval with the largest frequency. Comparing the values, the greatest frequency is \( 12 \), which belongs to the class interval \( 145-153 \). So the maximum number of leaves lie in the interval \( 145-153 \).
  3. Step 3: Understand what this interval means. The interval \( 145-153 \) includes every leaf whose length is anywhere from \( 145\ mm \) to \( 153\ mm \). It does not mean all \( 12 \) leaves are exactly \( 153\ mm \) long. Any of them could be \( 145\ mm \), \( 148\ mm \), \( 150\ mm \), and so on.
  4. Step 4: Reason out the conclusion. Because the data is grouped, the exact length of each leaf is not known. We only know how many leaves fall in each range. Therefore we cannot say the maximum number of leaves are exactly \( 153\ mm \) long.

Final Answer

No, it is not correct. The maximum number of leaves, namely \( 12 \), lie in the class interval \( 145-153 \), which covers all lengths from \( 145\ mm \) to \( 153\ mm \). Since the data is grouped, we cannot conclude that the leaves are exactly \( 153\ mm \) long.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to treat the upper limit of the highest-frequency interval as an exact value and say the maximum leaves are exactly \( 153\ mm \). In grouped data, an interval represents a range, so no single exact length can be claimed.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: List all the class intervals and their corresponding frequencies from the table: • \(118–126\): frequency \(3\) • \(127–135\): frequency \(5\) • \(136–144\): frequency \(9\) • \(145–153\): frequency \(12\) • \(154–162\): frequency \(5\) • \(163–171\): frequency \(4\) • \(172–180\): frequency \(2\) — Reason: Reading all frequencies first gives us a complete picture of the distribution before drawing any conclusion.
  2. Step 2: Compare all the frequencies: \(3,\ 5,\ 9,\ 12,\ 5,\ 4,\ 2\). The largest value among these is \(12\). — Reason: We need to identify the highest frequency in order to locate the class interval that contains the most leaves.
  3. Step 3: The frequency \(12\) belongs to the class interval \(145–153\). So the modal class (the interval with the maximum number of leaves) is \(145–153\). — Reason: Matching the highest frequency back to its interval tells us where most of the data values fall.
  4. Step 4: Examine what the interval \(145–153\) actually represents. Its class size is \(153 - 145 = 8\) mm, meaning it covers every leaf length from \(145\) mm up to \(153\) mm, not just the single value \(153\) mm. — Reason: Understanding the width of the interval shows that it is a range, not a single exact measurement.
  5. Step 5: Since the data is grouped, the exact length of each individual leaf within the interval \(145–153\) is unknown. Any leaf counted in this group could have a length anywhere between \(145\) mm and \(153\) mm. — Reason: Grouping data into class intervals sacrifices information about individual exact values; we only know which interval each leaf belongs to.
  6. Step 6: Therefore, the statement “most leaves are \(153\) mm long” is incorrect. We can only say the maximum number of leaves (\(12\) leaves) have lengths lying somewhere in the range \(145\) mm to \(153\) mm. — Reason: We must not confuse the upper boundary of a class interval with the exact value of all data points inside it.

Final Answer

No, it is not correct. The maximum number of leaves, namely \( 12 \), lie in the class interval \( 145-153 \), which covers all lengths from \( 145\ mm \) to \( 153\ mm \). Since the data is grouped, we cannot conclude that the leaves are exactly \( 153\ mm \) long.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students often read the upper limit of the modal class interval (here, \( 153 \) mm) and incorrectly treat it as the exact length of every leaf in that group, forgetting that the interval spans a full range of values.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Frequencies: \( 118{-}126 \to 3 \), \( 127{-}135 \to 5 \), \( 136{-}144 \to 9 \), \( 145{-}153 \to 12 \), \( 154{-}162 \to 5 \), \( 163{-}171 \to 4 \), \( 172{-}180 \to 2 \).
  2. Step 2: Maximum frequency \( = 12 \), belonging to class interval \( 145{-}153 \).
  3. Step 3: Interval \( 145{-}153 \) covers all lengths from \( 145\ \text{mm} \) to \( 153\ \text{mm} \); exact individual values are not recorded in grouped data.

Answer: No, it is not correct. The maximum number of leaves, namely \( 12 \), lie in the class interval \( 145-153 \), which covers all lengths from \( 145\ mm \) to \( 153\ mm \). Since the data is grouped, we cannot conclude that the leaves are exactly \( 153\ mm \) long.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: The heights (in cm) of 50 students of a class are measured correct to the nearest centimetre and recorded in the following grouped frequency table: Height (in cm): 135–140, 140–145, 145–150, 150–155, 155–160, 160–165 Number of Students: 4, 11, 18, 9, 6, 2 A student looks at the table and concludes: 'The maximum number of students have a height of 145 cm.' Is this conclusion correct? Why?

Solution: Step 1: Identify the class interval with the highest frequency. Looking at the table, the class interval 145–150 has the highest frequency of 18 students. Step 2: Examine the student's claim. The student claims that the maximum number of students have a height of exactly 145 cm. However, the class interval 145–150 includes all heights from 145 cm up to (but not including) 150 cm. Step 3: Determine what the class interval tells us. The interval 145–150 covers heights such as 145 cm, 146 cm, 147 cm, 148 cm, and 149 cm. The frequency 18 is spread across the entire interval, not just at 145 cm. Step 4: Find the class mark (midpoint) of the modal class for reference. Class mark of 145–150 = \( \frac{145 + 150}{2} = \frac{295}{2} = 147.5 \) cm This midpoint 147.5 cm is a better representative of the modal class, but even this is not a definitive single answer. Step 5: Conclusion. No, the conclusion is NOT correct. The class interval 145–150 has the maximum frequency of 18, meaning the maximum number of students have heights lying anywhere between 145 cm and 150 cm. We cannot say that exactly 145 cm (the lower boundary alone) is the most common height.

Answer: No, the conclusion is incorrect. The modal class is 145–150 cm with a frequency of 18. The maximum number of students have heights lying between 145 cm and 150 cm, not specifically at 145 cm.

Example 2

Question: The weights (in kg) of 60 bags of wheat at a warehouse are measured correct to the nearest kilogram and shown in the table below: Weight (in kg): 48–50, 50–52, 52–54, 54–56, 56–58, 58–60 Number of Bags: 5, 14, 22, 12, 5, 2 The warehouse manager says: 'Most bags weigh exactly 52 kg, since the class 52–54 has the highest frequency.' Is the manager's statement correct? Justify your answer.

Solution: Step 1: Find the total number of bags and verify. Total bags = \( 5 + 14 + 22 + 12 + 5 + 2 = 60 \). This matches the given information. Step 2: Identify the modal class. The class interval 52–54 has the highest frequency of 22 bags. Step 3: Analyse the manager's claim. The manager concludes that most bags weigh exactly 52 kg. However, the class interval 52–54 includes all weights from 52 kg up to (but not including) 54 kg. This means any bag in this class could weigh 52 kg, 53 kg, or any value in between (since weights are measured to the nearest kg, values are 52 or 53). Step 4: Find the class mark of the modal class. Class mark of 52–54 = \( \frac{52 + 54}{2} = \frac{106}{2} = 53 \) kg The class mark 53 kg best represents the modal class, not 52 kg. Step 5: Conclusion. The frequency 22 is distributed across the entire interval 52–54 kg. We cannot determine from this table alone how many bags weigh exactly 52 kg versus 53 kg within that class. The manager's statement is NOT correct.

Answer: No, the manager's statement is incorrect. The class 52–54 kg has the highest frequency of 22, but these 22 bags have weights anywhere between 52 kg and 54 kg. We cannot conclude that all or most of them weigh exactly 52 kg.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: The weights (in kg) of 50 students in a school are recorded correct to the nearest kilogram and represented in the following grouped frequency table: \nWeight (in kg): 30–35, 35–40, 40–45, 45–50, 50–55\nNumber of students: 6, 11, 18, 10, 5 \nA student looks at the table and concludes: 'The maximum number of students weigh exactly 40 kg.' Is this conclusion correct? Give a reason for your answer.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify the class with the highest frequency: Looking at the frequency table, the frequencies are 6, 11, 18, 10, and 5 for the respective class intervals. The highest frequency is 18, which belongs to the class interval 40–45.
  2. Step 2: Understand what a class interval represents: The class interval 40–45 covers all weights from 40 kg up to (but not including) 45 kg. This means the 18 students have weights anywhere in the range \( 40 \text{ kg} \le \text{weight} < 45 \text{ kg} \), not necessarily exactly 40 kg.
  3. Step 3: Evaluate the student's conclusion: The student claims the maximum number of students weigh exactly 40 kg. This is incorrect because the data is grouped into class intervals. We only know that 18 students have weights lying somewhere between 40 kg and 45 kg. We cannot determine the exact weight of any individual student from a grouped frequency distribution.
  4. Step 4: State the correct interpretation: The correct interpretation is that the modal class is 40–45 kg, since it has the highest frequency of 18. The maximum number of students, namely 18, lie in the class interval 40–45 kg, which includes all weights from 40 kg to 45 kg. We cannot conclude that these students weigh exactly 40 kg.

Answer: No, the conclusion is not correct. The maximum number of students, namely 18, lie in the class interval 40–45 kg, which covers all weights from 40 kg to 45 kg. Since the data is grouped, we cannot conclude that the students weigh exactly 40 kg.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Statistics