SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Chapter 12 Examples Q3

A teacher wanted to analyse the performance of two sections of students in a mathematics test of \(100\) marks. Looking at their performances, she found that a few students got under \(20\) marks and a few got \(70\) marks or above. So she decided to group them into intervals of varying sizes as follows: \(0-20,20-30, . . .,60-70,70-100.\) Then she formed the following table:

CBSE Class 9 Maths · Statistics

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine you are comparing bags of marbles, but some bags are huge and some are tiny. If you just count marbles without thinking about bag size, the big bag always looks more impressive — even if it is not! A histogram works the same way. When the groups have different widths, we must shrink the tall bars of wider groups so the picture stays fair. We do this by making each bar's height smaller when its group is wider. That way, the area of each bar honestly shows how many students belong to that group.

Answer: The histogram must use adjusted (proportional) frequencies, not the raw frequencies, because the class widths are unequal. Using minimum width \( 10 \), the adjusted heights are: 0-20 \( \to 3.5 \), 20-30 \( \to 10 \), 30-40 \( \to 10 \), 40-50 \( \to 20 \), 50-60 \( \to 20 \), 60-70 \( \to 15 \), 70-100 \( \to 2.67 \) (approximately). Draw bars of these heights so that the area of each bar stays proportional to its frequency.

📖 Histogram for Class Intervals of Varying Widths

Detailed Explanation

In a histogram, the AREA of each rectangle (not its height) represents the frequency of that class. When all class widths are equal, the heights can simply be the frequencies. But here the intervals have different widths: the first interval 0-20 has width 20, while most others (20-30, 30-40, etc.) have width 10, and the last interval 70-100 has width 30. If we directly plot the given frequencies as heights, wider bars would look misleadingly large. To make the comparison fair, we adjust the heights so that area stays proportional to frequency. We do this by finding the adjusted (proportional) frequency for each class using a common minimum class width.

Formula Used

Adjusted frequency = \( \frac{\text{Minimum class width}}{\text{Class width of the interval}} \times \text{Frequency} \)

Solution

  1. Step 1: Write down the frequency table clearly. Marks 0-20 has 7 students, 20-30 has 10, 30-40 has 10, 40-50 has 20, 50-60 has 20, 60-70 has 15, and 70-100 has 8 students. The total is \( 7 + 10 + 10 + 20 + 20 + 15 + 8 = 90 \) students.
  2. Step 2: Find the width of each class interval by subtracting the lower limit from the upper limit. For 0-20 the width is \( 20 - 0 = 20 \). For 20-30, 30-40, 40-50, 50-60, 60-70 each width is \( 10 \). For 70-100 the width is \( 100 - 70 = 30 \).
  3. Step 3: Identify the minimum class width. The smallest width among all intervals is \( 10 \). We will use this as the common base to adjust the heights of the bars so that area remains proportional to frequency.
  4. Step 4: Apply the adjusted frequency formula to each class. Adjusted frequency \( = \frac{10}{\text{width}} \times \text{frequency} \). For 0-20: \( \frac{10}{20} \times 7 = 3.5 \). For 20-30: \( \frac{10}{10} \times 10 = 10 \). For 30-40: \( \frac{10}{10} \times 10 = 10 \). For 40-50: \( \frac{10}{10} \times 20 = 20 \). For 50-60: \( \frac{10}{10} \times 20 = 20 \). For 60-70: \( \frac{10}{10} \times 15 = 15 \). For 70-100: \( \frac{10}{30} \times 8 = 2.67 \) (approximately).
  5. Step 5: Note why this adjustment matters. For the wide interval 0-20, we lower the height from 7 to 3.5 so that a wide bar does not appear too tall. For 70-100, we lower the height from 8 to about 2.67. The equal-width intervals keep the same heights as their frequencies because their width equals the minimum width.
  6. Step 6: Draw the histogram. Take Marks on the horizontal axis and Adjusted (proportional) frequency on the vertical axis. Draw rectangles over each interval with the adjusted heights: 0-20 with height 3.5, 20-30 with 10, 30-40 with 10, 40-50 with 20, 50-60 with 20, 60-70 with 15, and 70-100 with height about 2.67. The rectangles touch each other since the data is continuous.

Final Answer

The histogram must use adjusted (proportional) frequencies, not the raw frequencies, because the class widths are unequal. Using minimum width \( 10 \), the adjusted heights are: 0-20 \( \to 3.5 \), 20-30 \( \to 10 \), 30-40 \( \to 10 \), 40-50 \( \to 20 \), 50-60 \( \to 20 \), 60-70 \( \to 15 \), 70-100 \( \to 2.67 \) (approximately). Draw bars of these heights so that the area of each bar stays proportional to its frequency.

Common Mistake

The most common mistake is plotting the given frequencies directly as bar heights. When class widths are unequal, this makes wider intervals (like 0-20 and 70-100) look far more important than they really are. You must first convert to adjusted frequencies using the minimum class width so that area, not height, represents frequency.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Write the complete frequency table. The data given is: marks 0-20 → 7 students, 20-30 → 10 students, 30-40 → 10 students, 40-50 → 20 students, 50-60 → 20 students, 60-70 → 15 students, 70-100 → 8 students. Verify the total: \( 7 + 10 + 10 + 20 + 20 + 15 + 8 = 90 \) students. — Reason: Listing the data clearly prevents errors in later calculations.
  2. Step 2: Calculate the width of each class interval by subtracting its lower limit from its upper limit. For 0-20: width \( = 20 - 0 = 20 \). For each of 20-30, 30-40, 40-50, 50-60, 60-70: width \( = 10 \). For 70-100: width \( = 100 - 70 = 30 \). — Reason: Knowing each class width is essential because unequal widths mean we cannot use raw frequencies directly as bar heights.
  3. Step 3: Identify the minimum class width among all intervals. Looking at the widths 20, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 30, the smallest value is \( 10 \). — Reason: We use the minimum class width as the common reference base so that the adjusted heights are scaled to the narrowest interval, keeping all areas comparable.
  4. Step 4: Apply the adjustment formula to each class. For 0-20: \( \frac{10}{20} \times 7 = 3.5 \). For 20-30: \( \frac{10}{10} \times 10 = 10 \). For 30-40: \( \frac{10}{10} \times 10 = 10 \). For 40-50: \( \frac{10}{10} \times 20 = 20 \). For 50-60: \( \frac{10}{10} \times 20 = 20 \). For 60-70: \( \frac{10}{10} \times 15 = 15 \). For 70-100: \( \frac{10}{30} \times 8 \approx 2.67 \). — Reason: Dividing by the class width and multiplying by the minimum width 'squeezes' or 'stretches' each height so that area (height \( \times \) width) remains proportional to the actual frequency.
  5. Step 5: Verify one example to build confidence. For class 0-20, the adjusted height is \( 3.5 \) and the width is \( 20 \), so area \( = 3.5 \times 20 = 70 \). Compare with a standard interval such as 40-50: adjusted height \( = 20 \) and width \( = 10 \), so area \( = 20 \times 10 = 200 \). The ratio of areas \( 70 : 200 = 7 : 20 \) matches exactly the ratio of their original frequencies \( 7 : 20 \). — Reason: Confirming that area ratios equal frequency ratios proves the adjustment is correct.
  6. Step 6: Draw the histogram using the adjusted heights on the y-axis and the class intervals on the x-axis. Each bar spans its class interval horizontally and rises to its adjusted height vertically. The bars for 0-20 and 70-100 will be noticeably shorter than their raw frequencies would suggest, while the bars for equal-width classes remain unchanged. — Reason: Using adjusted heights ensures that a visually wider bar does not falsely appear to represent more students than it actually does.

Final Answer

The histogram must use adjusted (proportional) frequencies, not the raw frequencies, because the class widths are unequal. Using minimum width \( 10 \), the adjusted heights are: 0-20 \( \to 3.5 \), 20-30 \( \to 10 \), 30-40 \( \to 10 \), 40-50 \( \to 20 \), 50-60 \( \to 20 \), 60-70 \( \to 15 \), 70-100 \( \to 2.67 \) (approximately). Draw bars of these heights so that the area of each bar stays proportional to its frequency.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students plot the raw frequencies (7, 10, 10, 20, 20, 15, 8) directly as bar heights without adjusting for unequal class widths. This makes the bar for 70-100 appear as tall as the bar for 40-50 even though 40-50 has far more students, leading to a completely misleading histogram.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Identify class widths and minimum width: Widths: 0-20 \( \to 20 \), intervals 20-70 \( \to 10 \) each, 70-100 \( \to 30 \). Minimum width \( = 10 \).
  2. Step 2: Compute adjusted heights: 0-20: \( \frac{10}{20} \times 7 = 3.5 \); 20-30: \( \frac{10}{10} \times 10 = 10 \); 30-40: \( \frac{10}{10} \times 10 = 10 \); 40-50: \( \frac{10}{10} \times 20 = 20 \); 50-60: \( \frac{10}{10} \times 20 = 20 \); 60-70: \( \frac{10}{10} \times 15 = 15 \); 70-100: \( \frac{10}{30} \times 8 \approx 2.67 \).
  3. Step 3: Plot histogram using adjusted heights: Draw bars with the adjusted heights above so that area of each bar \( = \text{height} \times \text{width} \) remains proportional to frequency.

Answer: The histogram must use adjusted (proportional) frequencies, not the raw frequencies, because the class widths are unequal. Using minimum width \( 10 \), the adjusted heights are: 0-20 \( \to 3.5 \), 20-30 \( \to 10 \), 30-40 \( \to 10 \), 40-50 \( \to 20 \), 50-60 \( \to 20 \), 60-70 \( \to 15 \), 70-100 \( \to 2.67 \) (approximately). Draw bars of these heights so that the area of each bar stays proportional to its frequency.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: A sports coach recorded the time (in minutes) taken by 50 athletes to complete a long-distance run. A few athletes finished very quickly (under 30 minutes) and a few took very long (90 minutes or above), so the coach grouped the data into intervals of varying sizes: Class Interval (minutes): 0–30, 30–45, 45–60, 60–75, 75–90, 90–120 Number of Athletes: 3, 10, 16, 12, 6, 3 (i) Find the class width of each interval. (ii) Calculate the frequency density for each class interval. (iii) Which class interval has the highest frequency density? (iv) Why is frequency density used instead of frequency for a histogram with unequal class widths?

Solution: Step 1: Find the class width of each interval. Class 0–30: width = \[30 - 0 = 30\] Class 30–45: width = \[45 - 30 = 15\] Class 45–60: width = \[60 - 45 = 15\] Class 60–75: width = \[75 - 60 = 15\] Class 75–90: width = \[90 - 75 = 15\] Class 90–120: width = \[120 - 90 = 30\] Step 2: Calculate frequency density for each class. Frequency Density = Frequency divided by Class Width. For 0–30: Frequency = 3, Width = 30, so Frequency Density = \[\frac{3}{30} = 0.1\] For 30–45: Frequency = 10, Width = 15, so Frequency Density = \[\frac{10}{15} = 0.\overline{6} \approx 0.67\] For 45–60: Frequency = 16, Width = 15, so Frequency Density = \[\frac{16}{15} \approx 1.07\] For 60–75: Frequency = 12, Width = 15, so Frequency Density = \[\frac{12}{15} = 0.8\] For 75–90: Frequency = 6, Width = 15, so Frequency Density = \[\frac{6}{15} = 0.4\] For 90–120: Frequency = 3, Width = 30, so Frequency Density = \[\frac{3}{30} = 0.1\] Step 3: Identify the highest frequency density. Comparing all values: 0.1, 0.67, 1.07, 0.8, 0.4, 0.1 — the highest is approximately 1.07, which belongs to the class 45–60. Step 4: Reason for using frequency density. When class widths are unequal, plotting raw frequency on a histogram makes wider bars appear more significant than they really are. Using frequency density (frequency divided by class width) on the y-axis ensures that the area of each bar equals the frequency of that class, giving a fair visual comparison across all intervals.

Answer: (i) Class widths: 0–30 has width 30; 30–45, 45–60, 60–75, 75–90 each have width 15; 90–120 has width 30. (ii) Frequency densities: 0.1, approximately 0.67, approximately 1.07, 0.8, 0.4, 0.1. (iii) The class 45–60 has the highest frequency density of approximately 1.07. (iv) Frequency density is used so that the area of each bar represents the actual frequency, preventing wider intervals from misleadingly dominating the histogram.

Example 2

Question: A school librarian noted the number of pages in books borrowed by 60 students during a library week. Very short books (under 50 pages) and very long books (250 pages or above) were few, so the data was grouped into intervals of varying widths as follows: Class Interval (pages): 0–50, 50–100, 100–150, 150–200, 200–250, 250–400 Number of Books: 4, 12, 18, 14, 8, 4 (i) Verify that the total frequency is 60. (ii) Calculate the frequency density for each class. (iii) Draw a summary table showing class interval, frequency, class width, and frequency density. (iv) Which two class intervals have the same frequency density?

Solution: Step 1: Verify the total frequency. Total = \[4 + 12 + 18 + 14 + 8 + 4 = 60\] This matches the given total of 60 students. Step 2: Find class widths. Class 0–50: width = \[50 - 0 = 50\] Class 50–100: width = \[100 - 50 = 50\] Class 100–150: width = \[150 - 100 = 50\] Class 150–200: width = \[200 - 150 = 50\] Class 200–250: width = \[250 - 200 = 50\] Class 250–400: width = \[400 - 250 = 150\] Step 3: Calculate frequency density for each class. Frequency Density = Frequency divided by Class Width. For 0–50: \[\frac{4}{50} = 0.08\] For 50–100: \[\frac{12}{50} = 0.24\] For 100–150: \[\frac{18}{50} = 0.36\] For 150–200: \[\frac{14}{50} = 0.28\] For 200–250: \[\frac{8}{50} = 0.16\] For 250–400: \[\frac{4}{150} = 0.02\overline{6} \approx 0.027\] Step 4: Summary table. Class 0–50: Frequency = 4, Width = 50, Frequency Density = 0.08 Class 50–100: Frequency = 12, Width = 50, Frequency Density = 0.24 Class 100–150: Frequency = 18, Width = 50, Frequency Density = 0.36 Class 150–200: Frequency = 14, Width = 50, Frequency Density = 0.28 Class 200–250: Frequency = 8, Width = 50, Frequency Density = 0.16 Class 250–400: Frequency = 4, Width = 150, Frequency Density approximately 0.027 Step 5: Identify two class intervals with the same frequency density. Looking at the frequency densities: 0.08, 0.24, 0.36, 0.28, 0.16, 0.027 — none are exactly equal. However, if we check the classes 0–50 (frequency density = 0.08) and check whether any pair matches: no two are identical. Note: If the question is reconsidered — the classes 0–50 (frequency 4, width 50) and 250–400 (frequency 4, width 150) have the same raw frequency but different frequency densities. The class intervals 0–50 and any other 50-width class do not share a frequency density. Reconsidering the original data, no two intervals share the exact same frequency density. Hence, the answer to part (iv) is that no two class intervals have the same frequency density in this dataset; the closest pair is 0–50 with 0.08 and 200–250 with 0.16, which are related by a factor of 2 but not equal.

Answer: (i) Total frequency = 4 + 12 + 18 + 14 + 8 + 4 = 60. Verified. (ii) Frequency densities: 0–50 gives 0.08; 50–100 gives 0.24; 100–150 gives 0.36; 150–200 gives 0.28; 200–250 gives 0.16; 250–400 gives approximately 0.027. (iii) See the summary table in the solution. (iv) No two class intervals share the exact same frequency density in this dataset. The class 0–50 (frequency density 0.08) and the class 250–400 (frequency density approximately 0.027) both have the same raw frequency of 4, but their different widths lead to different frequency densities, illustrating why frequency density matters for unequal class widths.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: A sports coach recorded the number of hours per week spent practising by players in two squads. The data was grouped into intervals of varying sizes as follows: Class Interval (hours): 0–5, 5–10, 10–15, 15–20, 20–30, 30–50 Number of Players (Frequency): 4, 12, 18, 10, 14, 6 (i) Identify the minimum class width. (ii) Calculate the adjusted frequency (frequency density) for each class interval. (iii) Draw a histogram using the adjusted frequencies. State clearly why adjusted frequencies must be used here instead of raw frequencies.

Solution

  1. Step 1: List the class widths: Compute the width of each class interval: For 0–5: width = 5 For 5–10: width = 5 For 10–15: width = 5 For 15–20: width = 5 For 20–30: width = 10 For 30–50: width = 20 The class widths are NOT all equal, so a standard histogram (using raw frequency as height) would be misleading.
  2. Step 2: Identify the minimum class width: The minimum class width is \( 5 \) (shared by the first four intervals).
  3. Step 3: State the adjusted frequency formula: To keep the area of each bar proportional to its frequency, we use: \[ \text{Adjusted Frequency} = \frac{\text{Frequency}}{\text{Class Width}} \times \text{Minimum Class Width} \] With minimum class width \( = 5 \), this becomes: \[ \text{Adjusted Frequency} = \frac{\text{Frequency}}{\text{Class Width}} \times 5 \]
  4. Step 4: Calculate adjusted frequency for each class: For 0–5 (width = 5, frequency = 4): \[ \frac{4}{5} \times 5 = 4 \] For 5–10 (width = 5, frequency = 12): \[ \frac{12}{5} \times 5 = 12 \] For 10–15 (width = 5, frequency = 18): \[ \frac{18}{5} \times 5 = 18 \] For 15–20 (width = 5, frequency = 10): \[ \frac{10}{5} \times 5 = 10 \] For 20–30 (width = 10, frequency = 14): \[ \frac{14}{10} \times 5 = 7 \] For 30–50 (width = 20, frequency = 6): \[ \frac{6}{20} \times 5 = 1.5 \]
  5. Step 5: Summarise the adjusted frequencies: The adjusted frequencies (bar heights for the histogram) are: 0–5 : \( 4 \) 5–10 : \( 12 \) 10–15 : \( 18 \) 15–20 : \( 10 \) 20–30 : \( 7 \) 30–50 : \( 1.5 \)
  6. Step 6: Draw the histogram: On the horizontal axis, mark the class intervals (0, 5, 10, 15, 20, 30, 50). On the vertical axis, mark the adjusted frequency values. Draw bars of widths equal to each class width and heights equal to the adjusted frequencies listed in Step 5. Note that the bars for 20–30 and 30–50 are wider but shorter, so their areas still correctly represent 14 and 6 players respectively.
  7. Step 7: Justify the use of adjusted frequencies: Because the class widths are unequal, using raw frequencies as bar heights would give a false visual impression — a wide bar would appear to represent more data even if its frequency is low. Adjusted frequencies ensure that the AREA of each bar equals the frequency it represents (since Area = height \( \times \) width = adjusted frequency \( \times \) class width \( = \frac{f}{w} \times 5 \times w = 5f \), which is proportional to \( f \)). This makes the histogram an accurate graphical representation of the data.

Answer: The adjusted frequencies (bar heights) for the histogram are: 0–5 \( \to 4 \), 5–10 \( \to 12 \), 10–15 \( \to 18 \), 15–20 \( \to 10 \), 20–30 \( \to 7 \), 30–50 \( \to 1.5 \). These values are obtained by multiplying each class's frequency density by the minimum class width of 5. Adjusted frequencies must be used (not raw frequencies) because the class widths are unequal; this guarantees that each bar's area is proportional to its frequency, making the histogram an accurate representation of the data.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Statistics