In Fig. 5.10, if \(AC=BD,\) then prove that \(AB=CD.\)
CBSE Class 9 Maths · Introduction To Euclids Geometry
CBSE Class 9 Maths · Introduction To Euclids Geometry
Imagine a long road with four stops: A, B, C, and D in order. The distance from A to C equals the distance from B to D. Both stretches share the middle piece B to C. Remove that shared middle piece from each side. What remains on the left is A to B, and what remains on the right is C to D. Since you removed equal bits from equal totals, the leftovers must match. So A to B and C to D are equal in length.
Answer: Since \( AC = BD \) and \( AC = AB + BC \), \( BD = BC + CD \), subtracting the common part \( BC \) from both gives \( AB = CD \). Hence proved.
In the figure, four points A, B, C and D lie on the same line in the order A, then B, then C, then D. The segment \( AC \) is made up of \( AB \) and \( BC \), while the segment \( BD \) is made up of \( BC \) and \( CD \). Notice that the part \( BC \) is common to both. This kind of proof uses Euclid's axioms about wholes and parts. The key axiom here is: If equals are subtracted from equals, the remainders are equal. So if we start with two equal lengths and remove the same common length from each, the two leftover lengths must also be equal.
Euclid's Axiom 3: If equals are subtracted from equals, the remainders are equal. Also, the whole is equal to the sum of its parts, so \( AC = AB + BC \) and \( BD = BC + CD \).
Since \( AC = BD \) and \( AC = AB + BC \), \( BD = BC + CD \), subtracting the common part \( BC \) from both gives \( AB = CD \). Hence proved.
A common mistake is trying to subtract \( BC \) without first breaking \( AC \) and \( BD \) into their parts, or wrongly assuming the points are equally spaced. Always write \( AC = AB + BC \) and \( BD = BC + CD \) first, then subtract the common segment \( BC \) using Euclid's axiom.
Since \( AC = BD \) and \( AC = AB + BC \), \( BD = BC + CD \), subtracting the common part \( BC \) from both gives \( AB = CD \). Hence proved.
One common mistake: Students sometimes try to subtract or cancel \( BC \) without first writing \( AC \) and \( BD \) as sums of parts, skipping Steps 2 and 3. Without establishing \( AC = AB + BC \) and \( BD = BC + CD \) explicitly, the subtraction step has no valid mathematical foundation.
Answer: Since \( AC = BD \) and \( AC = AB + BC \), \( BD = BC + CD \), subtracting the common part \( BC \) from both gives \( AB = CD \). Hence proved.
Question: Points P, Q, R, and S lie on a straight line in that order. If PR = QS, prove that PQ = RS.
Solution: Given: Points P, Q, R, S lie on a line in that order, and PR = QS. We need to prove: PQ = RS. From the figure, we can write: \[PR = PQ + QR\] and \[QS = QR + RS\] Since it is given that PR = QS, we substitute: \[PQ + QR = QR + RS\] Now, QR is the common segment present on both sides. By Euclid's axiom, if equals are subtracted from equals, the remainders are equal. Subtracting QR from both sides: \[PQ + QR - QR = QR + RS - QR\] Therefore, \[PQ = RS\] Hence proved.
Answer: PQ = RS (proved using Euclid's axiom: equals subtracted from equals give equal remainders)
Question: In a line segment, points A, B, C, and D are marked in that order such that AD = BC. Prove that AB = CD.
Solution: Given: Points A, B, C, D lie on a line in that order, and AD = BC. We need to prove: AB = CD. From the arrangement of the points, we can express: \[AD = AB + BC + CD\] and BC is simply the segment from B to C. We are given: \[AD = BC\] Substituting the expanded form of AD: \[AB + BC + CD = BC\] Wait — let us re-examine. Since A, B, C, D lie in order: \[AD = AB + BD\] Also, \[BD = BC + CD\] So \[AD = AB + BC + CD\] But we are told AD = BC, so: \[AB + BC + CD = BC\] This would imply AB + CD = 0, which is impossible for positive lengths. Let us re-read: the correct given condition must be interpreted differently. Re-reading the question: AD = BC means the entire segment from A to D equals the segment from B to C, but since D is beyond C in our order A, B, C, D, we have AD > BC always. So the intended condition is AD = BC where the order is A, B, D, C instead. Let us take the order as A, B, D, C on the line. Given AD = BC. \[AD = AB + BD\] \[BC = BD + DC\] Since AD = BC: \[AB + BD = BD + DC\] Subtracting BD from both sides (equals subtracted from equals are equal, by Euclid's axiom): \[AB = DC\] That is, AB = CD. Hence proved.
Answer: AB = CD (proved by subtracting the common segment BD from both equal quantities AD and BC, using Euclid's axiom)
Question: Points P, Q, R, and S lie on a straight line in that order. If PR = QS, prove that PQ = RS.
Answer: Since \(PR = QS\) and \(PR = PQ + QR\), \(QS = QR + RS\), subtracting the common part \(QR\) from both sides gives \(PQ = RS\). Hence proved.