Which of the following statements are true and which are false? Give reasons for your answers. In Fig. 5.9, if \(AB=PQ\) and \(PQ= XY,\) then \(AB=XY.\)
CBSE Class 9 Maths · Introduction To Euclids Geometry
CBSE Class 9 Maths · Introduction To Euclids Geometry
Imagine three friends — Alex, Pat, and Sam — all have the same number of marbles. Alex and Pat have the same count. Pat and Sam also have the same count. Since Pat is the common friend, Alex and Sam must have equal marbles too! This is exactly what Euclid figured out long ago: if two things are each equal to a third thing, they must be equal to each other. Here, line segment \( PQ \) is like Pat — the common link that connects \( AB \) and \( XY \).
Answer: True. Since \( AB = PQ \) and \( PQ = XY \), by Euclid's first axiom (things equal to the same thing are equal to one another), we get \( AB = XY \).
This question is based on Euclid's axioms, which are self-evident truths accepted without proof. One of Euclid's most important axioms states: things which are equal to the same thing are equal to one another. In the figure we see three separate line segments, \( AB \), \( PQ \) and \( XY \). Even though they are drawn at different places and may look different in length, the given conditions tell us how their lengths are related. Here the segment \( PQ \) is the common thing to which both \( AB \) and \( XY \) are equal. So we can directly use Euclid's first axiom to compare \( AB \) and \( XY \).
Euclid's Axiom 1: If \( a = b \) and \( b = c \), then \( a = c \). (Things which are equal to the same thing are equal to one another.)
True. Since \( AB = PQ \) and \( PQ = XY \), by Euclid's first axiom (things equal to the same thing are equal to one another), we get \( AB = XY \).
A common mistake is to judge the answer by how the segments look in the figure (thinking they must be equal in the drawing) instead of using the given equalities and Euclid's axiom. The lengths in a rough figure need not be drawn to scale, so the reasoning must come from the axiom, not the picture.
True. Since \( AB = PQ \) and \( PQ = XY \), by Euclid's first axiom (things equal to the same thing are equal to one another), we get \( AB = XY \).
One common mistake: Students sometimes try to measure or compare the segments visually from the figure instead of using the given conditions logically. Euclid's axioms are applied to the stated equalities, not to the appearance of the diagram.
Answer: True. Since \( AB = PQ \) and \( PQ = XY \), by Euclid's first axiom (things equal to the same thing are equal to one another), we get \( AB = XY \).
Question: State whether the following statement is true or false and give a reason: If \( LM = RS \) and \( RS = TU \), then \( LM = TU \).
Solution: We are given two conditions. First condition: \( LM = RS \). Second condition: \( RS = TU \). We need to check whether \( LM = TU \) follows from these two conditions. By Euclid's first axiom, 'Things which are equal to the same thing are equal to one another.' Here, both \( LM \) and \( TU \) are equal to the same quantity \( RS \). Since \( LM = RS \) and \( RS = TU \), we can conclude: \[ LM = TU \] Therefore, the given statement is TRUE.
Answer: True. By Euclid's first axiom, since \( LM = RS \) and \( RS = TU \), it follows that \( LM = TU \).
Question: State whether the following statement is true or false and give a reason: Riya says that if the length of rope A equals the length of rope B, and the length of rope B equals the length of rope C, then rope A and rope C must have the same length. Is Riya correct?
Solution: Let the length of rope A be \( a \), the length of rope B be \( b \), and the length of rope C be \( c \). We are given: \[ a = b \] and \[ b = c \] We need to determine whether \( a = c \). According to Euclid's first axiom, 'Things which are equal to the same thing are equal to one another.' Both \( a \) and \( c \) are equal to the same quantity \( b \). Since \( a = b \) and \( b = c \), it directly follows that: \[ a = c \] So the length of rope A equals the length of rope C. Therefore, Riya is CORRECT, and the statement is TRUE.
Answer: True. Riya is correct. By Euclid's first axiom, since rope A = rope B and rope B = rope C, it follows that rope A = rope C.
Question: State whether the following statement is True or False. Give a reason for your answer. If \( LM = RS \) and \( RS = PQ \), then \( LM = PQ \). However, if it is also given that \( PQ = 2 \cdot XY \) and \( LM = 10 \) cm, find the length of \( XY \).
Answer: The statement is TRUE (by Euclid's first axiom). The length of \( XY \) is \( 5 \) cm.