In Question 4, point \(C\) is called a mid-point of line segment \(AB.\) Prove that every line segment has one and only one mid-point.
CBSE Class 9 Maths · Introduction To Euclids Geometry
CBSE Class 9 Maths · Introduction To Euclids Geometry
Imagine a chocolate bar with two ends. The middle point cuts it into two equal pieces. Now, what if someone says there are two different middle points? Each middle point must give two equal halves of the whole bar. Both halves from each point must be the same size. That forces the two middle points to sit at the exact same spot. So there can only ever be one midpoint on any line segment.
Answer: Since assuming two mid-points \( C \) and \( D \) forces \( AC = AD \), the two points coincide. Therefore every line segment has one and only one mid-point.
A point \( C \) is called the mid-point of a line segment \( \overline{AB} \) if it lies on \( AB \) and divides it into two equal parts, that is \( AC = CB \). The statement asks us to prove two things at once: (1) a mid-point exists, and (2) there is only ONE such point. To prove the 'only one' part, we use a standard mathematical technique called proof by contradiction: we assume there are two different mid-points, and then show this assumption leads to something impossible. The main tool we need is one of Euclid's axioms: 'Things which are halves of the same thing are equal to one another', together with the axiom that 'if equals are added to equals, the wholes are equal' and 'the whole is greater than the part'.
If \( C \) is the mid-point of \( \overline{AB} \), then \( AC = CB = \frac{1}{2}AB \). Euclid's Axiom used: things which are halves of the same thing are equal to one another.
Since assuming two mid-points \( C \) and \( D \) forces \( AC = AD \), the two points coincide. Therefore every line segment has one and only one mid-point.
A common mistake is to only show that the mid-point exists (that \( AC = CB \)) and forget to prove the 'only one' part. The uniqueness must be shown separately by assuming two mid-points and reaching a contradiction using Euclid's axiom about halves of the same thing being equal.
Since assuming two mid-points \( C \) and \( D \) forces \( AC = AD \), the two points coincide. Therefore every line segment has one and only one mid-point.
One common mistake: Students sometimes try to prove uniqueness by only showing that a midpoint exists (computing \( \frac{1}{2}AB \)) without carrying out the contradiction argument — this only proves existence, not that the midpoint is unique.
Answer: Since assuming two mid-points \( C \) and \( D \) forces \( AC = AD \), the two points coincide. Therefore every line segment has one and only one mid-point.
Question: Point M is said to be the mid-point of line segment PQ. Prove that a line segment PQ can have one and only one mid-point.
Solution: We are given that M is a mid-point of line segment \( \overline{PQ} \). We need to prove that \( \overline{PQ} \) cannot have more than one mid-point. Assume, for the sake of contradiction, that \( \overline{PQ} \) has two distinct mid-points, say M and N, where M and N are different points on \( \overline{PQ} \). Since M is a mid-point of \( \overline{PQ} \), we have: \[ PM = MQ \quad \text{...(1)} \] Adding \( PM \) to both sides of equation (1): \[ PM + PM = PM + MQ \] \[ 2 \cdot PM = PQ \quad \text{...(2)} \] Since N is also a mid-point of \( \overline{PQ} \), we have: \[ PN = NQ \quad \text{...(3)} \] Adding \( PN \) to both sides of equation (3): \[ PN + PN = PN + NQ \] \[ 2 \cdot PN = PQ \quad \text{...(4)} \] From equations (2) and (4), both equal \( PQ \). By Euclid's axiom — things which are equal to the same thing are equal to one another: \[ 2 \cdot PM = 2 \cdot PN \] Dividing both sides by 2 (using Euclid's axiom — if equals are divided by equals, the results are equal): \[ PM = PN \] This means M and N are the same point on \( \overline{PQ} \), which contradicts our assumption that M and N are two distinct mid-points. Hence, our assumption is wrong, and every line segment has one and only one mid-point.
Answer: Every line segment \( \overline{PQ} \) has one and only one mid-point. The assumption of two distinct mid-points leads to the contradiction \( PM = PN \), proving uniqueness.
Question: Suppose two points X and Y are each claimed to be the mid-point of line segment \( \overline{RS} \). Using Euclid's axioms, show that this leads to a contradiction, thereby proving that \( \overline{RS} \) can have only one mid-point.
Solution: We are given line segment \( \overline{RS} \). Suppose, for contradiction, that both X and Y are mid-points of \( \overline{RS} \), and that X and Y are distinct points. Since X is a mid-point of \( \overline{RS} \): \[ RX = XS \quad \text{...(1)} \] From (1), adding \( RX \) to both sides: \[ RX + RX = RX + XS \] \[ 2 \cdot RX = RS \quad \text{...(2)} \] Since Y is also a mid-point of \( \overline{RS} \): \[ RY = YS \quad \text{...(3)} \] From (3), adding \( RY \) to both sides: \[ RY + RY = RY + YS \] \[ 2 \cdot RY = RS \quad \text{...(4)} \] From equations (2) and (4), we have: \[ 2 \cdot RX = RS \quad \text{and} \quad 2 \cdot RY = RS \] By Euclid's axiom — things which are equal to the same thing are equal to one another: \[ 2 \cdot RX = 2 \cdot RY \] Applying Euclid's axiom — if equals are divided by equals, the results are equal — dividing both sides by 2: \[ RX = RY \] This means X and Y are at the same distance from R along the segment \( \overline{RS} \), so X and Y must be the same point. This is a contradiction to our assumption that X and Y are two distinct mid-points. Therefore, the assumption that \( \overline{RS} \) has two distinct mid-points is false. Hence, every line segment has one and only one mid-point.
Answer: The assumption of two distinct mid-points X and Y of \( \overline{RS} \) leads to \( RX = RY \), meaning X and Y coincide. Thus, \( \overline{RS} \) has one and only one mid-point.
Question: On a line segment \( \overline{PQ} \), a point \( M \) is said to be a mid-point of \( \overline{PQ} \) if \( PM = MQ \) and \( PM + MQ = PQ \). Using Euclid's axioms, prove by contradiction that a line segment \( \overline{PQ} \) cannot have two distinct mid-points.
Answer: Assuming two distinct mid-points \( M \) and \( N \) of \( \overline{PQ} \) leads to \( PM = PN \) by Euclid's Axiom 1, forcing \( M = N \). This contradiction proves that a line segment can have one and only one mid-point.