SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Exercise 5.1 Q3

Consider two ‘postulates’ given below: (i) Given any two distinct points \(A\) and \(B,\) there exists a third point \(C\) which is in between \(A\) and \(B.\)
(ii) There exist at least three points that are not on the same line.
Do these postulates contain any undefined terms\(?\) Are these postulates consistent\(?\) Do they follow from Euclid’s postulates\(?\) Explain.

CBSE Class 9 Maths · Introduction To Euclids Geometry

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Some words in geometry, like 'point' and 'line', have no exact definition — we just know what they mean from experience. These are called undefined terms. Two rules can exist together peacefully if neither one fights the other. Imagine two class rules: 'always sit quietly' and 'raise your hand to speak' — both can be true at the same time. Our two postulates are like that. But Euclid never wrote them down himself, so they do not come directly from his original five rules.

Answer: Yes, the postulates contain undefined terms, namely 'point', 'line' and 'lies between'. Yes, the two postulates are consistent, because they can both be true at the same time without contradicting each other. However, they do not directly follow from Euclid's five postulates, since Euclid did not state these ideas as separate postulates.

📖 Analysing Two Given Postulates

Detailed Explanation

In geometry, some basic terms like point, line, and 'lies between' are undefined terms. We do not give exact definitions for them; instead we build an intuitive understanding and describe how they behave through axioms and postulates. A set of postulates is called consistent if it is possible for all of them to be true together, that is, no postulate contradicts another postulate or any deduction made from them. A postulate 'follows from' Euclid's postulates only if it can be logically derived from Euclid's own postulates. The two given statements are: (i) between any two distinct points there is a third point, and (ii) there exist at least three points that are not all on one line.

Formula Used

No numerical formula is used here. The key ideas are: undefined terms (point, line, between), consistency (no contradiction), and logical derivation from Euclid's postulates.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Look for undefined terms. In postulate (i) the words 'point' and 'in between' are used, and in postulate (ii) the words 'point' and 'line' are used. The terms point, line and 'lies between' are basic undefined terms in geometry, since they are never given a precise definition. So yes, these postulates do contain undefined terms.
  2. Step 2: Check consistency. Consider two distinct points \( A \) and \( B \). Postulate (i) says there is a point \( C \) between \( A \) and \( B \). Postulate (ii) says there are at least three points not lying on the same line. These two statements do not oppose each other in any way, because it is possible to have a point between two points and also have three non-collinear points at the same time.
  3. Step 3: Conclude about consistency. Since no statement contradicts the other, and both can be true together in the same figure, the two postulates are consistent. This means they can be assumed to hold together without any logical clash.
  4. Step 4: Check whether they follow from Euclid's postulates. Euclid's postulates deal mainly with drawing straight lines, extending line segments, drawing circles, right angles, and the parallel (fifth) postulate. They do not directly state that a point lies between two other points, nor do they directly state the existence of three non-collinear points as separate assumptions.
  5. Step 5: Interpret the result. The idea in postulate (i) is related to Euclid's understanding of a line segment, and the idea in postulate (ii) is used implicitly, but neither is one of Euclid's five stated postulates. So these two postulates do not directly follow from Euclid's postulates as separate logical consequences.

Final Answer

Yes, the postulates contain undefined terms, namely 'point', 'line' and 'lies between'. Yes, the two postulates are consistent, because they can both be true at the same time without contradicting each other. However, they do not directly follow from Euclid's five postulates, since Euclid did not state these ideas as separate postulates.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is thinking that 'consistent' means the postulates can be proved from Euclid's postulates. Consistency only means the postulates do not contradict each other; it is a different question from whether they can be derived from Euclid's postulates.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: State the two postulates clearly: The two postulates given are: (i) Between any two distinct points, there exists at least one more point. (ii) There are at least three points that do not all lie on the same line. — Reason: Clearly stating what is given helps us analyse each postulate systematically without confusion.
  2. Step 2: Identify undefined terms in postulate (i): Postulate (i) uses the words 'point' and 'lies between'. Neither of these is ever given a precise, formal definition in Euclidean geometry — we rely on an intuitive understanding of what a point is and what it means for one point to lie between two others. — Reason: Recognising undefined terms shows that even basic geometric statements rest on primitives that are accepted without definition.
  3. Step 3: Identify undefined terms in postulate (ii): Postulate (ii) uses the words 'point' and 'line'. Just like in Step 2, neither 'point' nor 'line' has a precise formal definition; they are primitive notions in geometry. — Reason: Checking every postulate for undefined terms gives a complete picture of which primitive ideas the entire system depends on.
  4. Step 4: Conclude on undefined terms: Across both postulates, the undefined terms are: 'point', 'line', and 'lies between'. So yes, the postulates do contain undefined terms. — Reason: Listing them together confirms that the answer to the first part of the question is affirmative.
  5. Step 5: Check whether the two postulates are consistent: Take two distinct points, say \( A \) and \( B \). Postulate (i) tells us there is a point \( C \) lying between \( A \) and \( B \). Now consider three points \( P \), \( Q \), and \( R \) not all on one line — postulate (ii) says such points exist. These two scenarios can both be true at the same time; accepting one does not force the other to be false. — Reason: Consistency requires only that it is possible for all postulates to hold simultaneously without any contradiction arising.
  6. Step 6: Conclude on consistency: Since postulates (i) and (ii) can both be true together without producing any contradiction, the two postulates are consistent. — Reason: A set of postulates is inconsistent only if accepting one forces another to be false; that does not happen here.
  7. Step 7: Check whether the postulates follow from Euclid's five postulates: Euclid's five postulates deal with drawing straight lines, extending lines, drawing circles, equality of right angles, and the parallel postulate. Neither the idea that 'a point exists between any two points' nor the idea that 'three non-collinear points exist' was stated or logically derived by Euclid as a separate postulate. These are independent geometric ideas that Euclid assumed implicitly but never listed among his five postulates. — Reason: A statement 'follows from' Euclid's postulates only if it is a logical consequence of those exact five postulates; here, neither postulate can be directly derived from them.
  8. Step 8: State the final conclusion: Combining all findings: the postulates contain undefined terms ('point', 'line', 'lies between'), they are mutually consistent, but they do not follow directly from Euclid's five postulates because Euclid never stated these ideas as explicit postulates. — Reason: Summarising all three aspects — undefined terms, consistency, and derivability — gives the complete answer to the question.

Final Answer

Yes, the postulates contain undefined terms, namely 'point', 'line' and 'lies between'. Yes, the two postulates are consistent, because they can both be true at the same time without contradicting each other. However, they do not directly follow from Euclid's five postulates, since Euclid did not state these ideas as separate postulates.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: Students often confuse 'consistency' with 'derivability' — a set of postulates can be perfectly consistent (no contradictions) without any one of them being logically derivable from Euclid's original five postulates. These are two separate properties and must be checked independently.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Identify undefined terms: Postulate (i) uses 'point' and 'lies between'; Postulate (ii) uses 'point' and 'line' — all three are undefined geometric primitives.
  2. Step 2: Check consistency: Take distinct points \( A \) and \( B \). Postulate (i) places a point \( C \) between them; Postulate (ii) asserts points not all collinear. Neither contradicts the other, so they are consistent.
  3. Step 3: Check derivability from Euclid's postulates: Euclid's five postulates do not state betweenness or non-collinearity explicitly, so these two postulates cannot be logically derived from them.

Answer: Yes, the postulates contain undefined terms, namely 'point', 'line' and 'lies between'. Yes, the two postulates are consistent, because they can both be true at the same time without contradicting each other. However, they do not directly follow from Euclid's five postulates, since Euclid did not state these ideas as separate postulates.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Consider the following two statements: (i) Given any line segment \ \( \overline{PQ} \), there exists at least one point \ \( R \) that lies on \ \( \overline{PQ} \) and is different from both \ \( P \) and \ \( Q \). (ii) There exist at least two distinct lines that pass through a given point \ \( X \). Do these statements contain any undefined terms? Are they consistent? Do they follow from Euclid's postulates? Explain.

Solution: Step 1 — Identify undefined terms. The terms 'point', 'line', 'line segment', and 'lies on' are used in both statements. These are primitive (undefined) terms in Euclid's geometry — they are accepted intuitively without a formal definition. So yes, both statements do contain undefined terms. Step 2 — Check for consistency. Statement (i) says: on every line segment \ \( \overline{PQ} \) there is at least one interior point \ \( R \) (different from \ \( P \) and \ \( Q \)). Statement (ii) says: through any given point \ \( X \), at least two distinct lines can be drawn. These two statements do not contradict each other. It is geometrically possible for both to hold simultaneously: a line segment can always have interior points, and through any point several lines can pass. Therefore, the statements are consistent. Step 3 — Check whether they follow from Euclid's postulates. Euclid's first postulate states that a straight line may be drawn from any one point to any other point. His postulates deal with drawing lines between two points, extending lines, drawing circles, and the behaviour of right angles — they do not explicitly state the existence of a point between two given points on a segment, nor do they state that multiple lines pass through a single point. In fact, Euclid's first postulate implies that through two distinct points exactly one line passes, which is consistent with (but more restrictive than) statement (ii). Consequently, statement (i) is not directly stated in Euclid's postulates (it relates more to his axioms about the infinite divisibility implied by extending lines, but is not explicitly a postulate). Statement (ii) is actually consistent with, but broader than, what Euclid's first postulate guarantees. Neither statement is a direct logical consequence of Euclid's five postulates alone; they are independent additional assumptions.

Answer: Both statements contain undefined terms ('point', 'line', 'line segment', 'lies on'). They are consistent with each other (no contradiction). Neither statement follows directly from Euclid's five postulates; they are independent assumptions.

Example 2

Question: Consider the following two statements: (i) Given any two distinct points \ \( M \) and \ \( N \), every point on the line through \ \( M \) and \ \( N \) is either between \ \( M \) and \ \( N \), or outside the segment \ \( \overline{MN} \) on either side. (ii) There exist at least four points such that no three of them are collinear (i.e., no three lie on the same line). Do these statements contain any undefined terms? Are they consistent? Do they follow from Euclid's postulates? Explain.

Solution: Step 1 — Identify undefined terms. The terms 'point', 'line', 'between', 'collinear', and 'on the same line' appear in these statements. In Euclid's system, 'point' and 'line' are undefined (primitive) terms taken as self-evident. The notion of 'between' is also a geometric primitive not formally defined by Euclid. So yes, both statements contain undefined terms. Step 2 — Check for consistency. Statement (i) describes the ordering of points on a line relative to a segment \ \( \overline{MN} \): any point on that line is either interior to \ \( \overline{MN} \) or exterior on one of the two sides. Statement (ii) asserts the existence of at least four points in general position (no three collinear). These two statements do not contradict each other. Statement (i) is about collinear points (on a fixed line), while statement (ii) is about the existence of non-collinear points. Both can hold simultaneously in ordinary (Euclidean) geometry — imagine any four vertices of a non-degenerate quadrilateral. Therefore, the two statements are consistent. Step 3 — Check whether they follow from Euclid's postulates. Euclid's postulates are: 1. A straight line may be drawn from any one point to any other point. 2. A terminated line (line segment) can be extended indefinitely. 3. A circle can be drawn with any centre and any radius. 4. All right angles are equal to each other. 5. (Parallel postulate) If a straight line falling on two straight lines makes the interior angles on the same side less than two right angles, those two lines, if produced indefinitely, meet on that side. Statement (i) is a statement about the linear ordering of points on a line. It is not explicitly stated in any of Euclid's five postulates; Euclid assumed such ordering intuitively but it was formalised much later (e.g., by Hilbert). So statement (i) does not directly follow from Euclid's postulates. Statement (ii) asserts the existence of four non-collinear points. Euclid's postulates do not explicitly guarantee the existence of points outside a given line (that is an existence axiom added later). Hence statement (ii) also does not follow directly from Euclid's five postulates. Both statements are independent additional assumptions beyond Euclid's original postulates.

Answer: Both statements contain undefined terms ('point', 'line', 'between', 'collinear'). They are consistent with each other (no contradiction). Neither follows directly from Euclid's five postulates; they are independent assumptions that go beyond what Euclid explicitly stated.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Consider the following two statements: (i) For every line \( l \) and every point \( P \) not on \( l \), there exists exactly one line passing through \( P \) that does not intersect \( l \). (ii) A line segment can be extended indefinitely in both directions. Do these statements contain any undefined terms? Are these two statements consistent with each other? Do they follow directly from Euclid's first four postulates? Explain.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Identify undefined terms: Examine both statements carefully for words that are used without a prior formal definition. In statement (i), the words 'line', 'point', and 'passes through' are used — none of these are given a formal definition within the statements themselves. In statement (ii), the words 'line segment' and 'extended' are similarly used without being defined within the statement. These are primitive (undefined) terms that are accepted intuitively, just as Euclid accepted 'point', 'line', and 'surface' as undefined. Therefore, yes, both statements contain undefined terms, namely 'point', 'line', 'line segment', and 'passes through'.
  2. Step 2: Check whether the two statements are consistent: Two postulates are consistent if it is possible for both of them to be true at the same time without leading to a logical contradiction. Statement (i) talks about a unique non-intersecting (parallel) line through a point outside a given line. Statement (ii) talks about the infinite extendability of a line segment. These two ideas deal with different geometric properties — parallelism and infinite extension — and there is no situation in which accepting both would lead to a contradiction. Hence, the two statements are consistent with each other.
  3. Step 3: Determine whether they follow from Euclid's first four postulates: Euclid's first four postulates are: (1) A straight line can be drawn from any one point to any other point. (2) A terminated line (line segment) can be extended indefinitely. (3) A circle can be drawn with any centre and any radius. (4) All right angles are equal to one another. Statement (ii) — that a line segment can be extended indefinitely in both directions — is essentially a restatement of Euclid's Second Postulate. So statement (ii) does follow directly from Euclid's postulates. However, statement (i) — that through a point not on a line there is exactly one line parallel to it — is precisely the content of Playfair's axiom, which is an equivalent version of Euclid's Fifth Postulate, not one of the first four. It does NOT follow from the first four postulates alone. In fact, geometries (such as hyperbolic geometry) exist in which the first four postulates hold but statement (i) does not.
  4. Step 4: Summarise the findings: To summarise: Both statements contain undefined terms ('point', 'line', 'line segment', 'passes through'). The two statements are consistent because they can both be true simultaneously without any contradiction. Statement (ii) does follow from Euclid's postulates (specifically the Second Postulate). Statement (i), however, does not follow from Euclid's first four postulates — it is equivalent to Euclid's Fifth Postulate (in the form of Playfair's axiom) and is independent of the first four.

Answer: Yes, both statements contain undefined terms, namely 'point', 'line', 'line segment', and 'passes through'. Yes, the two statements are consistent, as they can both be true simultaneously without contradiction. Statement (ii) does follow from Euclid's postulates (it is a restatement of the Second Postulate). However, statement (i) does NOT follow from Euclid's first four postulates — it is equivalent to Euclid's Fifth Postulate (Playfair's axiom) and is logically independent of the first four.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Introduction To Euclids Geometry