Can you construct a triangle with sidelengths in the ratio \(1:3:5?\) Why or why not\(?\)
CBSE Class 8 Maths · Proportional Reasoning - 2
CBSE Class 8 Maths · Proportional Reasoning - 2
Imagine trying to build a triangle using three sticks of lengths 1, 3, and 5. The two shorter sticks must stretch far enough to touch each other when placed end-to-end against the longest stick. The short sticks measure 1 and 3, so together they reach only 4. But the longest stick is 5, which is even longer than 4! The two small sticks simply fall short and cannot meet, so no triangle can ever be formed with sides in the ratio \( 1 : 3 : 5 \).
Answer: No, a triangle with sides in the ratio \( 1 : 3 : 5 \) cannot be constructed, because \( 1 + 3 = 4 \) is less than \( 5 \), so the sum of the two smaller sides is not greater than the largest side and the Triangle Inequality is not satisfied.
To form a closed triangle, the three sides cannot be just any lengths. There is a rule called the Triangle Inequality: the sum of the lengths of any two sides of a triangle must be greater than the length of the third side. If even one pair of sides adds up to a value that is less than or equal to the third side, the two shorter sides cannot reach across to meet, so no triangle can be formed. Since we are given a ratio \( 1 : 3 : 5 \), we can take the actual sides as \( 1k, 3k \) and \( 5k \) for any positive number \( k \). The ratio behaves the same for every value of \( k \), so we can simply test the plain numbers \( 1, 3 \) and \( 5 \).
For sides a, b, c a triangle exists only if \( a + b > c \), \( b + c > a \) and \( c + a > b \) (each pair-sum greater than the third side).
No, a triangle with sides in the ratio \( 1 : 3 : 5 \) cannot be constructed, because \( 1 + 3 = 4 \) is less than \( 5 \), so the sum of the two smaller sides is not greater than the largest side and the Triangle Inequality is not satisfied.
A common mistake is checking only one pair, like \( 3 + 5 > 1 \), finding it true, and wrongly concluding a triangle is possible. You must specifically check the two SMALLEST sides against the largest side, since that is where the inequality is most likely to fail.
No, a triangle with sides in the ratio \( 1 : 3 : 5 \) cannot be constructed, because \( 1 + 3 = 4 \) is less than \( 5 \), so the sum of the two smaller sides is not greater than the largest side and the Triangle Inequality is not satisfied.
One common mistake: Students check only one or two of the three inequality conditions and declare a triangle possible without verifying the most critical one — the sum of the two smallest sides against the largest side.
Answer: No, a triangle with sides in the ratio \( 1 : 3 : 5 \) cannot be constructed, because \( 1 + 3 = 4 \) is less than \( 5 \), so the sum of the two smaller sides is not greater than the largest side and the Triangle Inequality is not satisfied.
Question: Can you construct a triangle whose sides are in the ratio 2 : 3 : 4? Give a reason.
Solution: Let the sides of the triangle be \( 2k \), \( 3k \), and \( 4k \) for some positive value \( k \). We check the three Triangle Inequality conditions: Condition 1: Sum of the two smaller sides must be greater than the largest side. \[ 2k + 3k > 4k \] \[ 5k > 4k \] This is TRUE. Condition 2: Sum of the smallest and largest sides must be greater than the middle side. \[ 2k + 4k > 3k \] \[ 6k > 3k \] This is TRUE. Condition 3: Sum of the two larger sides must be greater than the smallest side. \[ 3k + 4k > 2k \] \[ 7k > 2k \] This is TRUE. Since all three conditions are satisfied, the triangle CAN be constructed. For example, taking \( k = 1 \), the sides would be \( 2 \) cm, \( 3 \) cm, and \( 4 \) cm.
Answer: Yes, a triangle with sides in the ratio 2 : 3 : 4 can be constructed because all three Triangle Inequality conditions are satisfied.
Question: A student says that a triangle can be drawn with sides in the ratio 3 : 4 : 8. Is the student correct? Justify your answer.
Solution: Let the sides be \( 3k \), \( 4k \), and \( 8k \) for some positive value \( k \). We check the most critical Triangle Inequality condition first — the sum of the two smaller sides compared to the largest side. Condition 1: Sum of the two smaller sides vs. the largest side. \[ 3k + 4k > 8k \] \[ 7k > 8k \] This is FALSE, since \( 7k \) is NOT greater than \( 8k \). Because this condition fails, we do not need to check the other two conditions. The triangle inequality is violated. Therefore, the student is INCORRECT. A triangle with sides in the ratio 3 : 4 : 8 cannot be constructed.
Answer: No, the student is incorrect. A triangle with sides in the ratio 3 : 4 : 8 cannot be constructed because 3k + 4k = 7k, which is not greater than 8k, violating the Triangle Inequality.
Question: Can you construct a triangle whose sides are in the ratio \( 2 : 3 : 7 \)? Justify your answer.
Answer: No, a triangle with sides in the ratio \( 2 : 3 : 7 \) cannot be constructed, because \( 2 + 3 = 5 \) which is less than \( 7 \), so the sum of the two smaller sides is NOT greater than the largest side and the Triangle Inequality is violated.