Construct a triangle with sidelengths in the ratio \(3:4:5.\) Will all the triangles drawn with this ratio of sidelengths be congruent to each other\(?\) Why or why not\(?\)
CBSE Class 8 Maths · Proportional Reasoning - 2
CBSE Class 8 Maths · Proportional Reasoning - 2
Imagine a recipe that says use sugar, flour, and butter in the ratio 3:4:5. You can make a tiny cake or a huge cake — both follow the same recipe! Similarly, a triangle with sides in the ratio \( 3:4:5 \) can be drawn in many different sizes. A small one might have sides \( 3 \) cm, \( 4 \) cm, and \( 5 \) cm, while a bigger one has \( 6 \) cm, \( 8 \) cm, and \( 10 \) cm. Same shape, different size — so they are similar, not congruent.
Answer: A triangle with sides \( 6 \) cm, \( 8 \) cm and \( 10 \) cm (ratio \( 3:4:5 \)) can be constructed as shown. However, NOT all triangles with sides in the ratio \( 3:4:5 \) are congruent. They all have the same shape (same angles), so they are similar, but different multipliers \( k \) give different sizes. Congruence needs equal size as well as equal shape, so only triangles drawn with the SAME multiplier are congruent.
A ratio like \( 3:4:5 \) only tells us how the sides compare to each other, not their actual lengths. To draw an actual triangle, we must first pick a common multiplier. For example, if we choose the multiplier \( 2 \) cm, the sides become \( 6 \) cm, \( 8 \) cm and \( 10 \) cm. Different people can choose different multipliers, so the triangles they draw will have different sizes. Congruent figures must have exactly the same shape AND the same size (all corresponding sides and angles equal). Triangles that only share the same ratio of sides have the same shape but not necessarily the same size, so they are similar, not congruent.
If the sides are in ratio \( 3:4:5 \), the actual sides are \( 3k, 4k, 5k \) for some chosen multiplier \( k \). To construct a triangle when all three sides are known, we use the SSS construction (using a ruler and compass).
A triangle with sides \( 6 \) cm, \( 8 \) cm and \( 10 \) cm (ratio \( 3:4:5 \)) can be constructed as shown. However, NOT all triangles with sides in the ratio \( 3:4:5 \) are congruent. They all have the same shape (same angles), so they are similar, but different multipliers \( k \) give different sizes. Congruence needs equal size as well as equal shape, so only triangles drawn with the SAME multiplier are congruent.
Students often think that having the same ratio of sides makes triangles congruent. In fact, equal ratios only guarantee the same shape (similarity). For congruence, the actual side lengths must be equal, not just proportional.
A triangle with sides \( 6 \) cm, \( 8 \) cm and \( 10 \) cm (ratio \( 3:4:5 \)) can be constructed as shown. However, NOT all triangles with sides in the ratio \( 3:4:5 \) are congruent. They all have the same shape (same angles), so they are similar, but different multipliers \( k \) give different sizes. Congruence needs equal size as well as equal shape, so only triangles drawn with the SAME multiplier are congruent.
One common mistake: students assume that because two triangles share the same side ratio they must be congruent — but congruence requires equal side lengths, not just equal ratios. Equal ratios guarantee similarity (same angles, same shape), not congruence (same size).
Answer: A triangle with sides \( 6 \) cm, \( 8 \) cm and \( 10 \) cm (ratio \( 3:4:5 \)) can be constructed as shown. However, NOT all triangles with sides in the ratio \( 3:4:5 \) are congruent. They all have the same shape (same angles), so they are similar, but different multipliers \( k \) give different sizes. Congruence needs equal size as well as equal shape, so only triangles drawn with the SAME multiplier are congruent.
Question: Construct a triangle whose sides are in the ratio 5 : 6 : 7. Will all triangles drawn with this ratio of side lengths be congruent to each other? Give a reason for your answer.
Solution: Step 1: Choose a scale factor to get actual side lengths. Let the common scale factor be \( k \). Then the three sides of the triangle are \( 5k \), \( 6k \), and \( 7k \). Step 2: Pick a value of \( k \) and draw the triangle. Choose \( k = 1 \) cm. The sides become 5 cm, 6 cm, and 7 cm. To construct: Draw a base of 6 cm. With a compass set to 5 cm, draw an arc from one end of the base. With a compass set to 7 cm, draw another arc from the other end. Mark the intersection as the third vertex and join. Step 3: Try a different value of \( k \). Choose \( k = 2 \) cm. The sides become 10 cm, 12 cm, and 14 cm. This is a different triangle with the same ratio \( 5 : 6 : 7 \) but different actual side lengths. Step 4: Check congruence. For two triangles to be congruent, all corresponding sides must be exactly equal. Here, Triangle 1 has sides 5 cm, 6 cm, 7 cm and Triangle 2 has sides 10 cm, 12 cm, 14 cm. Since \( 5 \ne 10 \), \( 6 \ne 12 \), and \( 7 \ne 14 \), the two triangles are NOT congruent. Step 5: Conclusion. All triangles with sides in the ratio \( 5 : 6 : 7 \) have the same shape (they are similar triangles) but their sizes differ depending on the scale factor \( k \). Therefore, they are NOT all congruent to each other.
Answer: No. All triangles with sides in the ratio 5 : 6 : 7 are similar to each other but not congruent, because the actual side lengths depend on the chosen scale factor and will generally be different.
Question: A student says: 'I drew two triangles, both with sides in the ratio 2 : 3 : 4. One triangle has its shortest side equal to 4 cm and the other has its shortest side equal to 6 cm. Are the two triangles congruent?' Find the actual side lengths of each triangle and answer the student's question with a reason.
Solution: Step 1: Find the side lengths of Triangle 1. The ratio of sides is \( 2 : 3 : 4 \). The shortest side corresponds to the part '2' in the ratio. If the shortest side is 4 cm, the scale factor \( k_1 \) satisfies: \[ 2 \times k_1 = 4 \] so \( k_1 = 2 \) cm. The three sides of Triangle 1 are: \[ 2 \times 2 = 4 \text{ cm}, \quad 3 \times 2 = 6 \text{ cm}, \quad 4 \times 2 = 8 \text{ cm} \] Step 2: Find the side lengths of Triangle 2. If the shortest side is 6 cm, the scale factor \( k_2 \) satisfies: \[ 2 \times k_2 = 6 \] so \( k_2 = 3 \) cm. The three sides of Triangle 2 are: \[ 2 \times 3 = 6 \text{ cm}, \quad 3 \times 3 = 9 \text{ cm}, \quad 4 \times 3 = 12 \text{ cm} \] Step 3: Compare the two triangles. Triangle 1 has sides 4 cm, 6 cm, 8 cm. Triangle 2 has sides 6 cm, 9 cm, 12 cm. The corresponding sides are not equal: \[ 4 \ne 6, \quad 6 \ne 9, \quad 8 \ne 12 \] Step 4: Check that both ratios are still \( 2 : 3 : 4 \). For Triangle 1: \( 4 : 6 : 8 = 2 : 3 : 4 \). Correct. For Triangle 2: \( 6 : 9 : 12 = 2 : 3 : 4 \). Correct. Both triangles have sides in the same ratio but different actual lengths, so they are similar but NOT congruent.
Answer: Triangle 1 has sides 4 cm, 6 cm, 8 cm and Triangle 2 has sides 6 cm, 9 cm, 12 cm. They are NOT congruent because their corresponding sides are unequal; they are only similar (same shape, different size).
Question: Construct a triangle whose sides are in the ratio \( 2 : 3 : 4 \). Will all triangles drawn with sides in this ratio be congruent to each other? Give a reason for your answer.
Answer: A triangle with sides in the ratio \( 2 : 3 : 4 \) can be constructed — for example, with sides 4 cm, 6 cm, and 8 cm (using \( k = 2 \) cm). However, NOT all triangles with sides in the ratio \( 2 : 3 : 4 \) are congruent to each other. Different values of the multiplier \( k \) produce triangles of different sizes. All such triangles are similar (same shape, same angles) but congruence also requires equal size. Only those drawn with the same multiplier \( k \) are congruent.