Detailed Explanation
When a number leaves a certain remainder on division, we can write it in a general form. If a number leaves a remainder of \( 8 \) when divided by \( 12 \), it can be written as \( 12a + 8 \), where \( a \) is a whole number. A number that is \( 4 \) short of a multiple of \( 12 \) means it is \( 4 \) less than some multiple of \( 12 \), so it can be written as \( 12b - 4 \), where \( b \) is a whole number. To check Snehal's claim, we add these two general forms and see whether the result is always divisible by \( 8 \). A claim is only correct if it holds for EVERY allowed value; even one counterexample proves it wrong.
Formula Used
First number: \( 12a + 8 \). Second number: \( 12b - 4 \). Sum: \( (12a + 8) + (12b - 4) \).
Solution
- Step 1: Write the first number in general form. A number that leaves a remainder of \( 8 \) when divided by \( 12 \) is \( 12a + 8 \), where \( a \) is any whole number (\( 0, 1, 2, \dots \)).
- Step 2: Write the second number in general form. Being \( 4 \) short of a multiple of \( 12 \) means the number is \( 12b - 4 \), where \( b \) is any whole number.
- Step 3: Add the two numbers. \[ (12a + 8) + (12b - 4) = 12a + 12b + 4 \] So the sum is \( 12a + 12b + 4 \).
- Step 4: Test the claim with actual values. Take \( a = 0 \) and \( b = 1 \). First number \( = 12(0) + 8 = 8 \). Second number \( = 12(1) - 4 = 8 \). Sum \( = 8 + 8 = 16 \), which IS a multiple of \( 8 \). So far the claim seems to hold.
- Step 5: Try another pair to be sure. Take \( a = 1 \) and \( b = 1 \). First number \( = 12(1) + 8 = 20 \). Second number \( = 12(1) - 4 = 8 \). Sum \( = 20 + 8 = 28 \). Now check: \( 28 \div 8 = 3.5 \), which is NOT a whole number, so \( 28 \) is NOT a multiple of \( 8 \).
- Step 6: Conclude from the counterexample. Since the sum \( 12a + 12b + 4 \) gave \( 16 \) (a multiple of \( 8 \)) in one case but \( 28 \) (not a multiple of \( 8 \)) in another, the sum is NOT always a multiple of \( 8 \). One counterexample is enough to reject the claim.
Final Answer
Snehal's claim is FALSE. The sum equals \( 12a + 12b + 4 \), which is not always a multiple of \( 8 \). For example, \( 20 + 8 = 28 \) is not divisible by \( 8 \), so the sum is not always a multiple of \( 8 \).
Common Mistake
A common mistake is to test only one convenient pair (like \( 8 + 8 = 16 \)), see it works, and wrongly conclude the claim is always true. To prove a 'for all' claim you must show it works for every case; to disprove it, just one counterexample like \( 28 \) is enough.