SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 4 Q2

\(\text{“}\)I take a number that leaves a remainder of \(8\) when divided by \(12.\) I take another number which is \(4\) short of a multiple of \(12.\) Their sum will always be a multiple of \(\text{8”,}\) claims Snehal. Examine his claim and justify your conclusion.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Number Play

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Snehal says two special numbers always add up to a multiple of 8. One number gives remainder 8 when split into groups of 12. The other is 4 less than some multiple of 12. When you add them, you get something like 12 plus 12 plus a leftover 4. That leftover 4 causes trouble, because 28 is not in the 8-times table. So Snehal's guess is wrong.

Answer: Snehal's claim is FALSE. The sum equals \( 12a + 12b + 4 \), which is not always a multiple of \( 8 \). For example, \( 20 + 8 = 28 \) is not divisible by \( 8 \), so the sum is not always a multiple of \( 8 \).

📖 Examining Snehal's Claim About Divisibility

Detailed Explanation

When a number leaves a certain remainder on division, we can write it in a general form. If a number leaves a remainder of \( 8 \) when divided by \( 12 \), it can be written as \( 12a + 8 \), where \( a \) is a whole number. A number that is \( 4 \) short of a multiple of \( 12 \) means it is \( 4 \) less than some multiple of \( 12 \), so it can be written as \( 12b - 4 \), where \( b \) is a whole number. To check Snehal's claim, we add these two general forms and see whether the result is always divisible by \( 8 \). A claim is only correct if it holds for EVERY allowed value; even one counterexample proves it wrong.

Formula Used

First number: \( 12a + 8 \). Second number: \( 12b - 4 \). Sum: \( (12a + 8) + (12b - 4) \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Write the first number in general form. A number that leaves a remainder of \( 8 \) when divided by \( 12 \) is \( 12a + 8 \), where \( a \) is any whole number (\( 0, 1, 2, \dots \)).
  2. Step 2: Write the second number in general form. Being \( 4 \) short of a multiple of \( 12 \) means the number is \( 12b - 4 \), where \( b \) is any whole number.
  3. Step 3: Add the two numbers. \[ (12a + 8) + (12b - 4) = 12a + 12b + 4 \] So the sum is \( 12a + 12b + 4 \).
  4. Step 4: Test the claim with actual values. Take \( a = 0 \) and \( b = 1 \). First number \( = 12(0) + 8 = 8 \). Second number \( = 12(1) - 4 = 8 \). Sum \( = 8 + 8 = 16 \), which IS a multiple of \( 8 \). So far the claim seems to hold.
  5. Step 5: Try another pair to be sure. Take \( a = 1 \) and \( b = 1 \). First number \( = 12(1) + 8 = 20 \). Second number \( = 12(1) - 4 = 8 \). Sum \( = 20 + 8 = 28 \). Now check: \( 28 \div 8 = 3.5 \), which is NOT a whole number, so \( 28 \) is NOT a multiple of \( 8 \).
  6. Step 6: Conclude from the counterexample. Since the sum \( 12a + 12b + 4 \) gave \( 16 \) (a multiple of \( 8 \)) in one case but \( 28 \) (not a multiple of \( 8 \)) in another, the sum is NOT always a multiple of \( 8 \). One counterexample is enough to reject the claim.

Final Answer

Snehal's claim is FALSE. The sum equals \( 12a + 12b + 4 \), which is not always a multiple of \( 8 \). For example, \( 20 + 8 = 28 \) is not divisible by \( 8 \), so the sum is not always a multiple of \( 8 \).

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to test only one convenient pair (like \( 8 + 8 = 16 \)), see it works, and wrongly conclude the claim is always true. To prove a 'for all' claim you must show it works for every case; to disprove it, just one counterexample like \( 28 \) is enough.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Express the first number in general form. A number that leaves a remainder of \( 8 \) when divided by \( 12 \) is written as \( 12a + 8 \), where \( a \) is any whole number \( (0, 1, 2, \dots) \). — Reason: Using a general form lets us represent every possible number of this type at once, rather than checking one value at a time.
  2. Step 2: Express the second number in general form. A number that is \( 4 \) short of a multiple of \( 12 \) sits exactly \( 4 \) below some multiple of \( 12 \), so it is written as \( 12b - 4 \), where \( b \) is any whole number. — Reason: The phrase "4 short of a multiple of 12" directly translates to subtracting 4 from \( 12b \).
  3. Step 3: Add the two general forms together. \[ (12a + 8) + (12b - 4) = 12a + 12b + 4 \] — Reason: We combine like terms: the constants \( 8 \) and \( -4 \) give \( +4 \), and the multiples of 12 stay separate. The sum simplifies to \( 12a + 12b + 4 \).
  4. Step 4: Test with a first pair of values to see whether the claim seems plausible. Let \( a = 0 \) and \( b = 1 \). Then the first number is \( 12(0) + 8 = 8 \) and the second number is \( 12(1) - 4 = 8 \). Their sum is \( 8 + 8 = 16 \), which IS divisible by \( 8 \). — Reason: A single example that works does not prove the claim; we need to check more values or look at the general expression.
  5. Step 5: Test with a second pair of values to look for a counterexample. Let \( a = 1 \) and \( b = 1 \). Then the first number is \( 12(1) + 8 = 20 \) and the second number is \( 12(1) - 4 = 8 \). Their sum is \( 20 + 8 = 28 \). Now check: \( 28 \div 8 = 3 \) remainder \( 4 \), so \( 28 \) is NOT divisible by \( 8 \). — Reason: Finding even one case where the claim fails is enough to prove the claim is false.
  6. Step 6: Interpret the general expression \( 12a + 12b + 4 \) to understand why the sum is not always a multiple of \( 8 \). The term \( 12a + 12b \) is always a multiple of \( 4 \), but the extra \( +4 \) means the sum equals \( 4(3a + 3b + 1) \). For divisibility by \( 8 \), we would need \( 3a + 3b + 1 \) to be even, which is NOT guaranteed for all whole-number values of \( a \) and \( b \). — Reason: Analysing the algebraic form confirms that divisibility by \( 8 \) depends on \( a \) and \( b \), so it cannot hold universally.

Final Answer

Snehal's claim is FALSE. The sum equals \( 12a + 12b + 4 \), which is not always a multiple of \( 8 \). For example, \( 20 + 8 = 28 \) is not divisible by \( 8 \), so the sum is not always a multiple of \( 8 \).

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students assume that because the sum is divisible by 8 for one or two chosen values (like \( 8 + 8 = 16 \)), the claim must be true for all values. A claim about "always" requires checking the general algebraic expression, not just a few examples.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Sum: \[ (12a + 8) + (12b - 4) = 12a + 12b + 4 \]
  2. Step 2: Test \( a = 0,\ b = 1 \): first number \( = 8 \), second number \( = 8 \), sum \( = 16 \) — divisible by \( 8 \).
  3. Step 3: Test \( a = 1,\ b = 1 \): first number \( = 20 \), second number \( = 8 \), sum \( = 28 \) — NOT divisible by \( 8 \). Claim fails.

Answer: Snehal's claim is FALSE. The sum equals \( 12a + 12b + 4 \), which is not always a multiple of \( 8 \). For example, \( 20 + 8 = 28 \) is not divisible by \( 8 \), so the sum is not always a multiple of \( 8 \).

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Priya says: 'I take a number that leaves a remainder of 5 when divided by 9. I take another number which is 5 less than a multiple of 9. Their sum will always be a multiple of 9.' Examine Priya's claim and justify your conclusion.

Solution: Let the first number leave a remainder of 5 when divided by 9. We can write it in general form as: First number = \( 9k + 5 \), where k is a whole number. The second number is 5 less than a multiple of 9. We can write it as: Second number = \( 9m - 5 \), where m is a positive integer. Now let us add the two numbers: \[ (9k + 5) + (9m - 5) \] Simplifying: \[ = 9k + 5 + 9m - 5 \] \[ = 9k + 9m \] \[ = 9(k + m) \] Since \( k + m \) is always an integer, the sum \( 9(k + m) \) is always a multiple of 9. Let us verify with an example. Take \( k = 2 \) and \( m = 3 \). First number: \( 9 \times 2 + 5 = 23 \) Second number: \( 9 \times 3 - 5 = 22 \) Sum: \( 23 + 22 = 45 \) Checking: \( 45 \div 9 = 5 \), which confirms 45 is a multiple of 9. Therefore, Priya's claim is correct.

Answer: Priya's claim is correct. The sum of the two numbers is always \( 9(k + m) \), which is always a multiple of 9.

Example 2

Question: Rohan claims: 'I pick a number that is 7 more than a multiple of 10. I pick another number that is 3 less than a multiple of 10. The sum of these two numbers will always be a multiple of 10.' Is Rohan's claim true? Justify with algebra and a numerical check.

Solution: Let the first number be 7 more than a multiple of 10. We write it as: First number = \( 10a + 7 \), where a is a whole number. The second number is 3 less than a multiple of 10. We write it as: Second number = \( 10b - 3 \), where b is a positive integer. Adding the two numbers: \[ (10a + 7) + (10b - 3) \] Simplifying step by step: \[ = 10a + 7 + 10b - 3 \] \[ = 10a + 10b + 4 \] \[ = 10(a + b) + 4 \] The expression \( 10(a + b) + 4 \) has a remainder of 4 when divided by 10. It is NOT a multiple of 10. Let us verify with a numerical example. Take \( a = 1 \) and \( b = 2 \). First number: \( 10 \times 1 + 7 = 17 \) Second number: \( 10 \times 2 - 3 = 17 \) Sum: \( 17 + 17 = 34 \) Checking: \( 34 \div 10 = 3 \) remainder \( 4 \), so 34 is NOT a multiple of 10. Try another: \( a = 3 \), \( b = 1 \). First number: \( 10 \times 3 + 7 = 37 \) Second number: \( 10 \times 1 - 3 = 7 \) Sum: \( 37 + 7 = 44 \) Checking: 44 is not a multiple of 10 either. Therefore, Rohan's claim is INCORRECT. The sum always leaves a remainder of 4 when divided by 10, so it is never a multiple of 10.

Answer: Rohan's claim is incorrect. The sum equals \( 10(a + b) + 4 \), which always has a remainder of 4 when divided by 10, and is therefore never a multiple of 10.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Riya claims: 'I pick a number that leaves a remainder of 5 when divided by 9. I then pick another number that is 4 less than a multiple of 9. Their sum will always be a multiple of 6.' Examine Riya's claim and justify your conclusion with an algebraic argument and a counterexample (if needed).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Write the first number in general form: A number that leaves a remainder of 5 when divided by 9 can be written as \( 9a + 5 \), where \( a \) is a non-negative integer. For example, when \( a = 0 \): 5; when \( a = 1 \): 14; when \( a = 2 \): 23.
  2. Step 2: Write the second number in general form: A number that is 4 less than a multiple of 9 can be written as \( 9b - 4 \), where \( b \) is a positive integer. For example, when \( b = 1 \): 5; when \( b = 2 \): 14; when \( b = 3 \): 23.
  3. Step 3: Add the two numbers: Their sum is \( (9a + 5) + (9b - 4) \). Simplifying: \( 9a + 9b + 1 \), which equals \( 9(a + b) + 1 \).
  4. Step 4: Check whether the sum is always divisible by 6: The sum \( 9(a + b) + 1 \) is 1 more than a multiple of 9. For it to be divisible by 6, we need \( 9(a + b) + 1 \) to be divisible by 6. Since \( 9(a+b) \) is a multiple of 9 but not necessarily of 6, and adding 1 shifts the value further, there is no reason this expression must always be divisible by 6.
  5. Step 5: Provide a counterexample: Let \( a = 0 \) and \( b = 1 \). The first number is \( 9(0) + 5 = 5 \) and the second number is \( 9(1) - 4 = 5 \). Their sum is \( 5 + 5 = 10 \). Now check: \( 10 \div 6 \) gives remainder 4, so 10 is NOT divisible by 6. This counterexample disproves Riya's claim.
  6. Step 6: State the conclusion: Riya's claim is FALSE. The sum of the two numbers equals \( 9(a + b) + 1 \), which is not always a multiple of 6. The counterexample \( 5 + 5 = 10 \) confirms this, since 10 is not divisible by 6.

Answer: Riya's claim is FALSE. The sum equals \( 9(a + b) + 1 \), which is always 1 more than a multiple of 9, and is NOT always divisible by 6. For example, \( 5 + 5 = 10 \) is not divisible by 6.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Number Play