Tathagat has written several numbers that leave a remainder of \(2\) when divided by \(6.\) He claims, “If you add any three such numbers, the sum will always be a multiple of \(6.\)” Is Tathagat’s claim true\(?\)
CBSE Class 8 Maths · Number Play
CBSE Class 8 Maths · Number Play
Imagine numbers that always have a leftover of 2 when you share them into groups of 6. Numbers like 2, 8, 14, and 20 all behave this way. Now pick any three such numbers and add them up. The leftovers from each number add up to 6, which perfectly fills one more group. So the total has no leftover at all and fits neatly into groups of 6. That means the sum is always a multiple of 6, just as Tathagat claimed!
Answer: Yes, Tathagat's claim is true. The sum of any three numbers of the form \( 6k + 2 \) equals \( 6(a + b + c + 1) \), which is always a multiple of \( 6 \).
When a number leaves a remainder of \( 2 \) on division by \( 6 \), we can write it in a general form. Any such number is 'some multiple of 6, plus 2'. So it looks like \( 6k + 2 \), where \( k \) is a whole number \( (0, 1, 2, 3, \ldots) \). For example, \( 2, 8, 14, 20, \ldots \) are all of this form. To check Tathagat's claim, we add three such numbers in general form and see what remainder the sum leaves when divided by \( 6 \). A number is a multiple of \( 6 \) only if it leaves remainder \( 0 \).
A number leaving remainder 2 on division by 6 has the form \( 6k + 2 \), where \( k \) is a whole number.
Yes, Tathagat's claim is true. The sum of any three numbers of the form \( 6k + 2 \) equals \( 6(a + b + c + 1) \), which is always a multiple of \( 6 \).
A common mistake is forgetting to add the three remainders. The three 2's add up to \( 6 \), which itself is a multiple of \( 6 \); students sometimes think the leftover \( 2 + 2 + 2 = 6 \) spoils divisibility, when in fact it is exactly what makes the total a multiple of \( 6 \).
Yes, Tathagat's claim is true. The sum of any three numbers of the form \( 6k + 2 \) equals \( 6(a + b + c + 1) \), which is always a multiple of \( 6 \).
One common mistake: Using the same variable \( k \) for all three numbers (writing them all as \( 6k + 2 \)) — this incorrectly forces all three numbers to be equal, so the proof no longer covers the general case where the three numbers can be different.
Answer: Yes, Tathagat's claim is true. The sum of any three numbers of the form \( 6k + 2 \) equals \( 6(a + b + c + 1) \), which is always a multiple of \( 6 \).
Question: Meera has written several numbers that each leave a remainder of 3 when divided by 9. She claims, 'If you add any three such numbers, the sum will always be divisible by 9.' Is Meera's claim true? Justify your answer.
Solution: Every number that leaves a remainder of 3 when divided by 9 can be written in the form \( 9k + 3 \), where k is a whole number. Let three such numbers be \( 9a + 3 \), \( 9b + 3 \), and \( 9c + 3 \), where a, b, c are whole numbers. Their sum is: \[ (9a + 3) + (9b + 3) + (9c + 3) \] \[ = 9a + 9b + 9c + 9 \] \[ = 9(a + b + c + 1) \] Since \( a + b + c + 1 \) is always a whole number, the sum \( 9(a + b + c + 1) \) is always a multiple of 9. Verification with examples: Take 3, 12, and 21 (each leaves remainder 3 on division by 9). Their sum is \( 3 + 12 + 21 = 36 = 9 \times 4 \), which is divisible by 9. Take 3, 3, and 3: sum is \( 9 = 9 \times 1 \), also divisible by 9. Therefore, Meera's claim is TRUE.
Answer: Yes, Meera's claim is true. The sum of any three numbers, each leaving a remainder of 3 when divided by 9, is always a multiple of 9.
Question: Arjun writes down a list of numbers, each of which leaves a remainder of 4 when divided by 10. He says, 'Adding any two of these numbers will always give a multiple of 10.' Is Arjun correct? Give a reason and verify with an example.
Solution: Every number that leaves a remainder of 4 when divided by 10 can be written as \( 10k + 4 \), where k is a whole number. Let two such numbers be \( 10a + 4 \) and \( 10b + 4 \). Their sum is: \[ (10a + 4) + (10b + 4) \] \[ = 10a + 10b + 8 \] \[ = 10(a + b) + 8 \] The term \( 10(a + b) \) is a multiple of 10, but the leftover 8 is not zero. So the sum leaves a remainder of 8 when divided by 10, and is NOT a multiple of 10. Verification: Take 4 and 14 (both leave remainder 4 on division by 10). Their sum is \( 4 + 14 = 18 \). Dividing: \( 18 = 10 \times 1 + 8 \). The remainder is 8, not 0, so 18 is not a multiple of 10. Take 24 and 34: sum is \( 24 + 34 = 58 = 10 \times 5 + 8 \). Again, not a multiple of 10. Therefore, Arjun's claim is FALSE.
Answer: No, Arjun's claim is false. Adding any two numbers that each leave a remainder of 4 when divided by 10 gives a sum that leaves a remainder of 8, not a multiple of 10.
Question: Priya writes down several numbers, each of which leaves a remainder of \( 3 \) when divided by \( 9 \). She claims: 'If you pick any four such numbers and add them together, the sum will always be a multiple of \( 9 \).' Is Priya's claim true? Justify your answer.
Answer: No, Priya's claim is false. The sum of any four numbers of the form \( 9k + 3 \) equals \( 9(a + b + c + d) + 12 \), which leaves a remainder of \( 3 \) when divided by \( 9 \) and is therefore never a multiple of \( 9 \).