SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 1 Q3(ii)

For each statement below, determine whether it is always true, sometimes true, or never true. Explain your answer. Mention examples and non-examples as appropriate. Justify your claim using algebra. If a number is not divisible by \(18,\) then it is also not divisible by \(9.\)

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Number Play

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Think of 18 as a club that only lets in numbers divisible by BOTH 2 and 9. The number 9 is divisible by 9 but it is odd, so 18's club turns it away. Now the statement says: kicked out of the 18-club means also not in the 9-club. That is not always true! The number 9 is proof — it got kicked out of the 18-club but it still belongs to the 9-club. Some numbers make the statement true, some break it, so the statement is only sometimes true.

Answer: The statement is SOMETIMES TRUE. It holds for numbers like 7 (not divisible by 18 and not by 9), but it fails for numbers like 9, 27 and 45, which are not divisible by 18 yet ARE divisible by 9. In general, any odd multiple of 9, written as \( 9(2k+1) = 18k + 9 \), is a non-example, so the claim cannot be always true.

📖 Is the Statement Always, Sometimes, or Never True?

Detailed Explanation

We are testing the statement: If a number is not divisible by 18, then it is also not divisible by 9. To judge such a claim we look at how divisibility by 18 and by 9 are related. A number is divisible by 18 only if it is divisible by BOTH 2 and 9, because \( 18 = 2 \times 9 \). This means every multiple of 18 is a multiple of 9, but the reverse is not guaranteed. A number can be a multiple of 9 (divisible by 9) while being odd, so it is NOT a multiple of 18. Such a number is 'not divisible by 18' yet still 'divisible by 9', which directly breaks the statement. Since we can find at least one number that satisfies the 'if' part but fails the 'then' part, the statement is NOT always true. We must also check whether it can ever hold, to decide between 'sometimes true' and 'never true'.

Formula Used

\( 18 = 2 \times 9 \), so a number is divisible by 18 exactly when it is divisible by both 2 and 9.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand the relationship between 18 and 9. Since \( 18 = 2 \times 9 \), any number divisible by 18 is automatically divisible by 9. But divisibility by 9 alone does not force divisibility by 18, because we still need the factor 2 as well.
  2. Step 2: Look for a counter-example (a non-example that breaks the statement). Try \( 9 \). It is divisible by 9, so \( 9 \div 9 = 1 \). Is it divisible by 18? \( 9 \div 18 \) is not a whole number, so 9 is NOT divisible by 18. Here the number is 'not divisible by 18' but it IS divisible by 9.
  3. Step 3: More such examples exist: \( 27 = 9 \times 3 \) and \( 45 = 9 \times 5 \) are both divisible by 9 but are odd, so they are not divisible by 18. Each one contradicts the claim that 'not divisible by 18 means not divisible by 9'.
  4. Step 4: Justify with algebra. Write an odd multiple of 9 in general form. Take \( n = 9(2k + 1) \) for a whole number \( k \). This is clearly divisible by 9. But \( 9(2k+1) = 18k + 9 \), which leaves a remainder of 9 when divided by 18, so it is never divisible by 18. So for every such \( k \) we get a number that is not divisible by 18 yet is divisible by 9.
  5. Step 5: Check when the statement DOES hold, to classify it correctly. Take a number like \( 7 \). It is not divisible by 18, and it is also not divisible by 9. So here the statement is true. This shows the statement is true for some numbers and false for others.

Final Answer

The statement is SOMETIMES TRUE. It holds for numbers like 7 (not divisible by 18 and not by 9), but it fails for numbers like 9, 27 and 45, which are not divisible by 18 yet ARE divisible by 9. In general, any odd multiple of 9, written as \( 9(2k+1) = 18k + 9 \), is a non-example, so the claim cannot be always true.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is thinking that because \( 18 = 2 \times 9 \), 'not divisible by 18' must mean 'not divisible by 9'. This confuses the direction: divisibility by 18 forces divisibility by 9, but NOT the other way round, so a number can miss the factor 2 (stay odd) and still be a multiple of 9.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Write out exactly what the statement claims: if a number is NOT divisible by 18, then it is also NOT divisible by 9. — Reason: Pinning down the claim precisely tells us what the 'if' condition is and what the 'then' conclusion must be, so we know exactly what would break it.
  2. Step 2: Recall how 18 and 9 are related: \[ 18 = 2 \times 9 \] This means that to be divisible by 18, a number must have both 2 and 9 as factors. — Reason: Understanding this relationship tells us that every multiple of 18 is automatically a multiple of 9, but a multiple of 9 need NOT be a multiple of 18 (it might be odd).
  3. Step 3: Test the number 9 against the 'if' condition. Check divisibility by 18: \[ 9 \div 18 = 0.5 \] Since 0.5 is not a whole number, 9 is NOT divisible by 18, so the 'if' condition is satisfied. — Reason: We need a number that meets the starting condition so we can then check whether the conclusion holds.
  4. Step 4: Now check whether 9 is divisible by 9: \[ 9 \div 9 = 1 \] It IS divisible by 9. — Reason: This directly contradicts the 'then' part of the statement, which claimed the number should NOT be divisible by 9. So 9 is a counter-example that breaks the statement.
  5. Step 5: Confirm with two more counter-examples. For 27: \[ 27 \div 18 = 1.5 \text{ (not a whole number, so not divisible by 18)} \] and \[ 27 \div 9 = 3 \text{ (whole number, so divisible by 9)} \] For 45: \[ 45 \div 18 = 2.5 \text{ (not divisible by 18)} \] and \[ 45 \div 9 = 5 \text{ (divisible by 9)} \] — Reason: Multiple counter-examples make the pattern clear: any odd multiple of 9 will fail the statement.
  6. Step 6: Write the general form of all such counter-examples. Any odd multiple of 9 can be written as \( 9(2k+1) \) for a whole number \( k \), which equals \( 18k + 9 \). This is never divisible by 18 (it leaves a remainder of 9), yet it is always divisible by 9. — Reason: A general formula shows there are infinitely many counter-examples, confirming the statement is not always true.
  7. Step 7: Check whether the statement can ever be true to decide between 'sometimes true' and 'never true'. Take the number 7: \[ 7 \div 18 \text{ is not a whole number (not divisible by 18)} \] and \[ 7 \div 9 \text{ is not a whole number (not divisible by 9 either)} \] So the statement holds for 7. — Reason: Because there exist numbers where the statement holds AND numbers where it fails, the verdict is SOMETIMES TRUE, not NEVER TRUE.

Final Answer

The statement is SOMETIMES TRUE. It holds for numbers like 7 (not divisible by 18 and not by 9), but it fails for numbers like 9, 27 and 45, which are not divisible by 18 yet ARE divisible by 9. In general, any odd multiple of 9, written as \( 9(2k+1) = 18k + 9 \), is a non-example, so the claim cannot be always true.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students assume that because 9 is a factor of 18, 'not divisible by 18' automatically means 'not divisible by 9' — they forget that an odd multiple of 9 (like 9, 27, or 45) is divisible by 9 but never by 18, since 18 requires the extra factor of 2.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Since \( 18 = 2 \times 9 \), divisibility by 18 requires divisibility by both 2 and 9.
  2. Step 2: Counter-example: \( 9 \div 9 = 1 \) (divisible by 9), but \( 9 \div 18 \) is not a whole number (not divisible by 18).
  3. Step 3: Further counter-examples: 27 and 45 are each divisible by 9 but not by 18.
  4. Step 4: General form of counter-examples: \( 9(2k+1) = 18k + 9 \) for any non-negative integer \( k \), giving odd multiples of 9 that are never divisible by 18.

Answer: The statement is SOMETIMES TRUE. It holds for numbers like 7 (not divisible by 18 and not by 9), but it fails for numbers like 9, 27 and 45, which are not divisible by 18 yet ARE divisible by 9. In general, any odd multiple of 9, written as \( 9(2k+1) = 18k + 9 \), is a non-example, so the claim cannot be always true.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: For the statement below, determine whether it is always true, sometimes true, or never true. Explain your answer. Give examples and non-examples. Justify using algebra. Statement: If a number is not divisible by 12, then it is also not divisible by 4.

Solution: We need to check whether every number that is NOT divisible by 12 is also NOT divisible by 4. Step 1: Understand the relationship between 12 and 4. \[12 = 4 \times 3\] So 12 is a multiple of 4. This means every number divisible by 12 is also divisible by 4. But the converse need not be true. Step 2: Try to find a non-example (a number not divisible by 12, but divisible by 4). Consider the number 20. Is 20 divisible by 12? We check: \[20 \div 12 = 1 \text{ remainder } 8\] So 20 is NOT divisible by 12. Is 20 divisible by 4? We check: \[20 \div 4 = 5\] So 20 IS divisible by 4. This is a non-example that breaks the statement. Step 3: Find another case where the statement is true. Consider the number 10. \[10 \div 12: \text{ not divisible}\] \[10 \div 4: \text{ not divisible (since } 10 = 4 \times 2 + 2\text{)}\] Here, 10 is not divisible by 12 AND also not divisible by 4. So the statement holds for 10. Step 4: Algebraic justification. Suppose a number n is NOT divisible by 12. This means there is no integer k such that \[n = 12k\] However, n could still equal \[n = 4m\] for some integer m (as long as m is not a multiple of 3). For example, when \( m = 5 \), \( n = 20 \), which is divisible by 4 but not by 12. Conclusion: The statement is SOMETIMES TRUE. It is true for numbers like 10 (not divisible by 4 either), but false for numbers like 20 (not divisible by 12, yet divisible by 4).

Answer: Sometimes true. Example where true: 10 (not divisible by 12, and also not by 4). Non-example: 20 (not divisible by 12, but IS divisible by 4).

Example 2

Question: For the statement below, determine whether it is always true, sometimes true, or never true. Explain your answer. Give examples and non-examples. Justify using algebra. Statement: If a number is divisible by 6, then it is also divisible by 24.

Solution: We need to check whether every number divisible by 6 is also divisible by 24. Step 1: Understand the relationship between 6 and 24. \[24 = 6 \times 4\] So 24 is a multiple of 6, not the other way around. Being divisible by 6 is a weaker condition than being divisible by 24. Step 2: Try a non-example (a number divisible by 6, but NOT by 24). Consider 18. Is 18 divisible by 6? \[18 \div 6 = 3\] Yes, 18 is divisible by 6. Is 18 divisible by 24? \[18 \div 24 = 0 \text{ remainder } 18\] No, 18 is NOT divisible by 24. So the statement is FALSE for 18. This is a non-example. Step 3: Try another number divisible by 6. Consider 48. Is 48 divisible by 6? \[48 \div 6 = 8\] Yes. Is 48 divisible by 24? \[48 \div 24 = 2\] Yes. So the statement holds for 48. Step 4: Algebraic justification. If n is divisible by 6, then \[n = 6k\] for some integer k. For n to also be divisible by 24, we need \[n = 24m\] which means \[6k = 24m\] which gives \[k = 4m\] This is only true when k is a multiple of 4. For example, \( k = 1 \) gives \( n = 6 \), which is not divisible by 24. But \( k = 4 \) gives \( n = 24 \), which is divisible by 24. Conclusion: The statement is SOMETIMES TRUE. It holds when the number is a multiple of both 6 and 24 (i.e., a multiple of 24), but fails for multiples of 6 that are not multiples of 24, such as 6, 12, 18, 30, etc.

Answer: Sometimes true. Example where true: 48 (divisible by both 6 and 24). Non-example: 18 (divisible by 6, but NOT by 24).

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: For the statement below, determine whether it is always true, sometimes true, or never true. Explain your answer with examples and non-examples, and justify your claim using algebra. Statement: 'If a number is not divisible by 24, then it is also not divisible by 8.'

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand the relationship between 24 and 8: First, note that 24 = 8 \times 3, so 8 is a factor of 24. This means every multiple of 24 is also a multiple of 8. However, the converse need not be true: a multiple of 8 may or may not be a multiple of 24.
  2. Step 2: Test an example where the statement seems to hold: Take the number 10. It is not divisible by 24 (since 24 does not divide 10), and it is also not divisible by 8 (since 8 does not divide 10). So for 10, the statement holds: not divisible by 24, and also not divisible by 8.
  3. Step 3: Test a non-example (counter-example) that breaks the statement: Take the number 8. It is not divisible by 24 (since \( 24 \div 8 = 3 \) but \( 8 \div 24 \) is not a whole number). However, 8 IS divisible by 8 (since \( 8 \div 8 = 1 \)). So for 8, the statement fails. Similarly, 16 is not divisible by 24 but is divisible by 8. And 32 is not divisible by 24 but is divisible by 8.
  4. Step 4: Algebraic justification: Every multiple of 8 can be written as \( 8k \) for some positive integer k. It becomes a multiple of 24 exactly when k is a multiple of 3, i.e. when \( k = 3m \), giving \( 8 \times 3m = 24m \). When k is NOT a multiple of 3 (for example, \( k = 1, 2, 4, 5, \ldots \)), the number \( 8k \) is divisible by 8 but NOT by 24. These are precisely the counter-examples to the statement.
  5. Step 5: Conclude: Since there exist numbers (like 7 or 10) that are neither divisible by 24 nor by 8 (statement holds), AND numbers (like 8, 16, 32) that are not divisible by 24 but ARE divisible by 8 (statement fails), the statement is SOMETIMES TRUE — not always true and not never true.

Answer: The statement is ALWAYS FALSE (Never True). Wait — re-examining: the statement is SOMETIMES TRUE. It holds for numbers like 10 or 7 (not divisible by 24 and also not divisible by 8), but it fails for numbers like 8, 16, and 32, which are NOT divisible by 24 yet ARE divisible by 8. Algebraically, any multiple of 8 of the form \( 8k \) where k is not a multiple of 3 (written as \( k = 3m + 1 \) or \( k = 3m + 2 \)) is not divisible by 24 but IS divisible by 8, providing infinitely many counter-examples. Therefore the statement is SOMETIMES TRUE — it cannot be always true.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Number Play