Determine whether the statements below are ‘Always True’, ‘Sometimes True’, or ‘Never True’. Explain your reasoning. \(8\ (7b-3)-4\ (11b+1)\) is a multiple of \(12.\)
CBSE Class 8 Maths · Number Play
CBSE Class 8 Maths · Number Play
Imagine you have bags of apples. You want to check if the total is always a perfect dozen (12 apples). We open the brackets and count everything carefully. After counting, we get \( 12b - 28 \). The part \( 12b \) is always a dozen's multiple, but 28 leftover apples never fit into exact groups of 12. So no matter how many bags you have, the total never comes out as a clean multiple of 12. The statement is never true.
Answer: The simplified expression is \( 12b - 28 \). Since \( 12b \) is a multiple of 12 but \( 28 \) is not, the expression can never be a multiple of 12. So the statement is Never True.
To test a statement like this, we first simplify the algebraic expression by removing the brackets using the distributive law, then combine like terms. Once we have the simplest form, we check whether it can always be written as 12 times some whole-number expression. If the whole simplified expression has 12 as a common factor of every term, it is always a multiple of 12. If only some values of the variable make it a multiple of 12, it is sometimes true. If it can never be divisible by 12, it is never true. Remember: the distributive law says \( a(b + c) = ab + ac \), and we must be careful with signs when a negative number multiplies a bracket.
\( a(b + c) = ab + ac \)
The simplified expression is \( 12b - 28 \). Since \( 12b \) is a multiple of 12 but \( 28 \) is not, the expression can never be a multiple of 12. So the statement is Never True.
A common mistake is forgetting that the minus sign in front of \( 4(11b + 1) \) applies to both terms, writing \( 56b - 24 - 44b + 4 \) instead of \( 56b - 24 - 44b - 4 \). This wrong sign gives \( 12b - 20 \) and leads to an incorrect conclusion.
The simplified expression is \( 12b - 28 \). Since \( 12b \) is a multiple of 12 but \( 28 \) is not, the expression can never be a multiple of 12. So the statement is Never True.
One common mistake: forgetting to flip the sign of every term inside the second bracket when subtracting — students often write \( 56b - 24 - 44b + 4 \) instead of \( 56b - 24 - 44b - 4 \), giving an incorrect constant of \( -20 \) instead of \( -28 \).
Answer: The simplified expression is \( 12b - 28 \). Since \( 12b \) is a multiple of 12 but \( 28 \) is not, the expression can never be a multiple of 12. So the statement is Never True.
Question: Determine whether the statement below is 'Always True', 'Sometimes True', or 'Never True'. Explain your reasoning. The expression \( 5(6x - 2) - 2(13x + 4) \) is a multiple of 18.
Solution: Step 1: Expand each bracket using the distributive law. \[ 5(6x - 2) = 30x - 10 \] \[ 2(13x + 4) = 26x + 8 \] Step 2: Subtract the second expanded expression from the first. \[ 5(6x - 2) - 2(13x + 4) = 30x - 10 - 26x - 8 \] Step 3: Collect like terms. Group the terms with \( x \) together and the constant terms together. \[ = (30x - 26x) + (-10 - 8) \] \[ = 4x - 18 \] Step 4: Check divisibility by 18. Factor the simplified expression. \[ 4x - 18 = 2(2x - 9) \] For this to be a multiple of 18, we need \( 4x - 18 = 18k \) for some integer \( k \), which gives \( 4x = 18k + 18 \), so \( x = \frac{18(k+1)}{4} = \frac{9(k+1)}{2} \). This holds for some values of \( x \) (e.g. when \( x = 9 \): \( 4(9) - 18 = 36 - 18 = 18 \), which is \( 18 \times 1 \)) but not all values (e.g. when \( x = 1 \): \( 4(1) - 18 = -14 \), which is not a multiple of 18). Since the simplified expression \( 4x - 18 \) depends on \( x \), it is a multiple of 18 only for specific values of \( x \), not for every value.
Answer: Sometimes True — the expression simplifies to \( 4x - 18 \), which is a multiple of 18 only for certain values of \( x \) (such as \( x = 9 \)), but not for all values.
Question: Determine whether the statement below is 'Always True', 'Sometimes True', or 'Never True'. Explain your reasoning. The expression \( 6(4y + 5) - 3(8y - 1) \) is a multiple of 9.
Solution: Step 1: Expand each bracket using the distributive law. \[ 6(4y + 5) = 24y + 30 \] \[ 3(8y - 1) = 24y - 3 \] Step 2: Subtract the second expanded expression from the first. \[ 6(4y + 5) - 3(8y - 1) = 24y + 30 - 24y + 3 \] Step 3: Collect like terms. \[ = (24y - 24y) + (30 + 3) \] \[ = 0 + 33 \] \[ = 33 \] Step 4: Check whether 33 is a multiple of 9. Divide 33 by 9. \[ 33 = 9 \times 3 + 6 \] The remainder is 6, not 0. So 33 is not divisible by 9. Since the expression simplifies to the constant 33 — regardless of the value of \( y \) — and 33 is never a multiple of 9, the expression can never be a multiple of 9, for any value of \( y \).
Answer: Never True — the expression always simplifies to the constant 33, and since \( 33 = 9 \times 3 + 6 \), it is never a multiple of 9.
Question: Determine whether the statement below is 'Always True', 'Sometimes True', or 'Never True'. Explain your reasoning. \[ 5(6m - 4) - 3(8m + 5) \] is a multiple of 15.
Answer: The simplified expression is \( 6m - 35 \). The constant term 35 is not a multiple of 15 (since \( 35 = 2 \times 15 + 5 \)), and no integer value of \( m \) can compensate for this remainder. Therefore, the statement is Never True.