Example 1
Question: For each statement below, determine whether it is always true, sometimes true, or never true. Explain your answer. Give examples and non-examples. Justify your claim using algebra. Statement: If two numbers are not divisible by 4, then their sum is not divisible by 4.
Solution: We check whether the statement is always true, sometimes true, or never true. Step 1: Try an example where the statement seems TRUE. Let the two numbers be 5 and 7. Neither is divisible by 4 (since 5 = 4 × 1 + 1 and 7 = 4 × 1 + 3). Their sum is 5 + 7 = 12, and 12 is NOT divisible by 4 (since 12 = 4 × 3, wait — 4 × 3 = 12, so 12 IS divisible by 4). Actually, 5 + 7 = 12, and \( 12 \div 4 = 3 \), so 12 IS divisible by 4. So here, two numbers not divisible by 4 gave a sum that IS divisible by 4. The statement is FALSE in this case. Step 2: Try another example where the statement is TRUE. Let the two numbers be 5 and 6. Neither 5 nor 6 is divisible by 4. Their sum is 5 + 6 = 11. Since \( 11 = 4 \times 2 + 3 \), 11 is NOT divisible by 4. So the statement is TRUE in this case. Step 3: Since the statement is true in some cases and false in others, it is SOMETIMES TRUE. Step 4: Algebraic justification. Any integer not divisible by 4 has remainder 1, 2, or 3 when divided by 4. Write the two numbers as \( 4a + r_1 \) and \( 4b + r_2 \), where \( r_1, r_2 \in \{1, 2, 3\} \). Their sum is: \[ (4a + r_1) + (4b + r_2) = 4(a + b) + (r_1 + r_2) \] The sum is divisible by 4 exactly when \( r_1 + r_2 \) is divisible by 4. Case A: \( r_1 = 1, r_2 = 3 \) gives \( r_1 + r_2 = 4 \), which IS divisible by 4. So the sum IS divisible by 4 — statement is FALSE. Example: 5 and 7 (remainders 1 and 3; sum = 12). Case B: \( r_1 = 2, r_2 = 2 \) gives \( r_1 + r_2 = 4 \), which IS divisible by 4. Example: 6 and 10 (both have remainder 2; sum = 16). Case C: \( r_1 = 1, r_2 = 2 \) gives \( r_1 + r_2 = 3 \), which is NOT divisible by 4. Example: 5 and 6 (sum = 11). Since there exist cases where the sum is divisible by 4 and cases where it is not, the statement is SOMETIMES TRUE.
Answer: Sometimes true. When the remainders of the two numbers (on division by 4) add up to 4 (e.g., remainders 1 and 3, or both 2), the sum IS divisible by 4, making the statement false. When the remainders add to a non-multiple of 4 (e.g., 1 and 2, giving sum 3), the sum is not divisible by 4, making the statement true.
Example 2
Question: For each statement below, determine whether it is always true, sometimes true, or never true. Explain your answer. Give examples and non-examples. Justify your claim using algebra. Statement: If two numbers are not divisible by 8, then their sum is not divisible by 8.
Solution: We check whether the statement is always true, sometimes true, or never true. Step 1: Try an example where the statement seems TRUE. Let the two numbers be 3 and 6. Neither 3 nor 6 is divisible by 8. Their sum is 3 + 6 = 9. Since \( 9 = 8 \times 1 + 1 \), the number 9 is NOT divisible by 8. The statement is TRUE for this pair. Step 2: Try to find a counterexample (where the statement is FALSE). Let the two numbers be 5 and 11. Check: \( 5 = 8 \times 0 + 5 \) (not divisible by 8) and \( 11 = 8 \times 1 + 3 \) (not divisible by 8). Their sum is 5 + 11 = 16. Since \( 16 = 8 \times 2 \), the sum IS divisible by 8. The statement is FALSE for this pair. Step 3: Since the statement is true in some cases (Step 1) and false in others (Step 2), it is SOMETIMES TRUE. Step 4: Algebraic justification. Any integer not divisible by 8 has a non-zero remainder when divided by 8. Write the two numbers as \( 8a + r_1 \) and \( 8b + r_2 \), where \( r_1, r_2 \in \{1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7\} \). Their sum is: \[ (8a + r_1) + (8b + r_2) = 8(a + b) + (r_1 + r_2) \] The sum is divisible by 8 exactly when \( r_1 + r_2 \) is a multiple of 8. Since each remainder is between 1 and 7, the possible values of \( r_1 + r_2 \) range from 2 to 14. The only multiple of 8 in this range is 8 itself. So the sum is divisible by 8 when \( r_1 + r_2 = 8 \). Example pairs of remainders: (1, 7), (2, 6), (3, 5), (4, 4). For 5 and 11: remainders are 5 and 3, so \( r_1 + r_2 = 5 + 3 = 8 \). The sum \( 5 + 11 = 16 = 8 \times 2 \) is divisible by 8. Statement is FALSE. For 3 and 6: remainders are 3 and 6, so \( r_1 + r_2 = 3 + 6 = 9 \), which is not a multiple of 8. The sum \( 3 + 6 = 9 \) is not divisible by 8. Statement is TRUE. Since the statement is true in some cases and false in others, the statement is SOMETIMES TRUE.
Answer: Sometimes true. When the remainders of the two numbers (on division by 8) add up to exactly 8 — for example, remainders 5 and 3 (numbers 5 and 11, sum = 16) — the sum IS divisible by 8, making the statement false. When remainders add to a non-multiple of 8, the sum is not divisible by 8, making the statement true.