SOLVER7 Study. Nothing Else.
Figure It Out 4 Q11

Deepak claims, \(\text{“}\)There are some multiples of \(11\) which, when doubled, are still multiples of \(11.\) But other multiples of \(11\) don’t remain multiples of \(11\) when doubled\(\text{”.}\) Examine if his conjecture is true; explain your conclusion.

CBSE Class 8 Maths · Number Play

Solution

👶 Simple Explanation

Simple Explanation

Imagine you have a bag of 11 apples. That is one group of 11. Two bags give you 22 apples, still a perfect group of 11. Deepak thought doubling only sometimes keeps the group tidy. But every time you double any tidy group of 11, you always get another tidy group of 11. There are no exceptions, ever. So Deepak's guess was wrong — doubling a multiple of 11 always gives back a multiple of 11.

Answer: Deepak's conjecture is false. Every multiple of 11 can be written as \( 11k \), and doubling gives \( 22k = 11 \times (2k) \), which is again a multiple of 11. Therefore ALL multiples of 11 remain multiples of 11 when doubled, not just some.

📖 Do Doubled Multiples of 11 Stay Multiples of 11?

Detailed Explanation

A multiple of 11 is any number we get by multiplying 11 by a whole number. So the multiples of 11 are \( 11, 22, 33, 44, 55, \dots \), and in general any multiple of 11 can be written as \( 11k \), where \( k \) is a whole number like \( 1, 2, 3, \dots \). Deepak claims that doubling only sometimes keeps a number a multiple of 11. To check this, we do not need to test every number one by one. Instead, we use the general form of a multiple of 11 and see what happens when we double it. If the doubled number can always be written as 11 times a whole number, then it is always a multiple of 11.

Formula Used

A multiple of 11 has the general form \( 11k \), where \( k \) is a whole number. Doubling gives \( 2 \times 11k \).

Solution

  1. Step 1: Write any multiple of 11 in general form. Let the number be \( 11k \), where \( k \) is a whole number. For example, when \( k = 1 \) we get \( 11 \), when \( k = 2 \) we get \( 22 \), and so on.
  2. Step 2: Double this number. Doubling means multiplying by 2, so we get \[ 2 \times 11k = 22k. \]
  3. Step 3: Rewrite the result to check if it is a multiple of 11. Notice that \[ 22k = 11 \times (2k). \] Since \( k \) is a whole number, \( 2k \) is also a whole number. So the doubled number is 11 times a whole number, which means it is definitely a multiple of 11.
  4. Step 4: Test with actual numbers to confirm. Double \( 11 \) to get \( 22 = 11 \times 2 \). Double \( 33 \) to get \( 66 = 11 \times 6 \). Double \( 55 \) to get \( 110 = 11 \times 10 \). Every doubled value stays a multiple of 11, matching our general argument.
  5. Step 5: Conclude about the conjecture. Since \( 22k \) is always a multiple of 11 for every whole number \( k \), there is no multiple of 11 that loses this property when doubled. So the second part of Deepak's claim is false.

Final Answer

Deepak's conjecture is false. Every multiple of 11 can be written as \( 11k \), and doubling gives \( 22k = 11 \times (2k) \), which is again a multiple of 11. Therefore ALL multiples of 11 remain multiples of 11 when doubled, not just some.

Common Mistake

A common mistake is to test only two or three numbers and then guess, instead of using the general form \( 11k \). Checking a few examples can support an idea but cannot prove it for every case; writing the number as \( 11k \) settles it for all multiples at once.

🪜 Step-by-step Solution

Step-by-step Solution

  1. Step 1: Express any multiple of 11 using its general form. Any multiple of 11 can be written as \( 11k \), where \( k \) stands for a whole number (1, 2, 3, and so on). — Reason: Using a general form means we cover every possible multiple of 11 in one go, so we do not have to test each number separately.
  2. Step 2: Apply the doubling operation to this general form. Doubling \( 11k \) means multiplying by 2, giving us \[ 2 \times 11k = 22k. \] — Reason: This shows us what happens to every multiple of 11 when it is doubled, using algebra instead of guesswork.
  3. Step 3: Rewrite \( 22k \) to reveal whether it is a multiple of 11. We can factor 22 as \( 11 \times 2 \), so \[ 22k = 11 \times (2k). \] Since \( k \) is a whole number, \( 2k \) is also a whole number. — Reason: A number is a multiple of 11 exactly when it equals 11 times some whole number; rewriting in this form confirms that test is satisfied.
  4. Step 4: Verify with concrete examples to build confidence. Double \( 11 \) to get \( 22 = 11 \times 2 \). Double \( 33 \) to get \( 66 = 11 \times 6 \). Double \( 55 \) to get \( 110 = 11 \times 10 \). — Reason: Numerical checks confirm what the algebra already proved, and help us see the pattern clearly.
  5. Step 5: Evaluate Deepak's conjecture in light of the result. Deepak claimed that only some multiples of 11 stay multiples of 11 when doubled. However, the algebraic argument in Steps 2 and 3 applies to every value of \( k \) without exception, meaning the result holds for ALL multiples of 11, not just some. — Reason: Because the general form \( 11k \) represents every multiple of 11, the conclusion drawn from it is universal, which directly contradicts Deepak's claim.

Final Answer

Deepak's conjecture is false. Every multiple of 11 can be written as \( 11k \), and doubling gives \( 22k = 11 \times (2k) \), which is again a multiple of 11. Therefore ALL multiples of 11 remain multiples of 11 when doubled, not just some.

Common Mistake

One common mistake: students test only a few specific multiples of 11 (like 11, 22, 33) and conclude the conjecture is true for those, mistakenly thinking that checking a handful of cases is enough to prove a statement about all multiples — always use the general form \( 11k \) to reason about every case at once.

✍️ Exam-ready Answer

Exam-ready Answer

  1. Step 1: Let any multiple of 11 be \( 11k \). Doubling: \[ 2 \times 11k = 22k \]
  2. Step 2: Rewrite: \[ 22k = 11 \times (2k) \] Since \( 2k \) is a whole number, \( 22k \) is a multiple of 11.
  3. Step 3: Verification: \( 2 \times 11 = 22 = 11 \times 2 \), \( 2 \times 33 = 66 = 11 \times 6 \), \( 2 \times 55 = 110 = 11 \times 10 \). All are multiples of 11.

Answer: Deepak's conjecture is false. Every multiple of 11 can be written as \( 11k \), and doubling gives \( 22k = 11 \times (2k) \), which is again a multiple of 11. Therefore ALL multiples of 11 remain multiples of 11 when doubled, not just some.

➕ More Examples

More Examples

Example 1

Question: Riya claims: 'Every multiple of 7, when tripled, gives a result that is still a multiple of 7.' Examine whether her conjecture is always true, sometimes true, or always false. Explain your conclusion with examples.

Solution: We start by understanding what it means to be a multiple of 7. A multiple of 7 can be written as \( 7 \times m \) for some positive integer \( m \). Now, tripling this multiple gives: \[ 3 \times (7 \times m) = 7 \times (3m) \] Since \( 3m \) is still an integer, the result \( 7 \times (3m) \) is always a multiple of 7. Let us verify with specific examples. Example 1: Take \( 7 \times 1 = 7 \). Tripling: \( 3 \times 7 = 21 = 7 \times 3 \). This is a multiple of 7. Confirmed. Example 2: Take \( 7 \times 4 = 28 \). Tripling: \( 3 \times 28 = 84 = 7 \times 12 \). This is a multiple of 7. Confirmed. Example 3: Take \( 7 \times 9 = 63 \). Tripling: \( 3 \times 63 = 189 = 7 \times 27 \). This is a multiple of 7. Confirmed. The reason this always works is that multiplying any multiple of 7 by 3 introduces an extra factor of 3, but the factor of 7 is never removed. Since divisibility by 7 depends only on whether 7 is a factor, and it remains a factor after tripling, the result is always a multiple of 7. Therefore, Riya's conjecture is ALWAYS TRUE. Every multiple of 7, when tripled, is still a multiple of 7.

Answer: Riya's conjecture is always true. Tripling any multiple of 7 always gives another multiple of 7, because multiplying by 3 cannot remove the factor of 7.

Example 2

Question: Arjun says: 'Some multiples of 9, when you add 9 to them, remain multiples of 9. But other multiples of 9 do NOT remain multiples of 9 when you add 9.' Is Arjun's conjecture correct? Investigate and explain.

Solution: We need to check: if we take any multiple of 9 and add 9 to it, is the result always, sometimes, or never a multiple of 9? A general multiple of 9 can be written as \( 9 \times m \) for some positive integer \( m \). Adding 9 to this gives: \[ 9 \times m + 9 = 9 \times (m + 1) \] Since \( m + 1 \) is an integer, \( 9 \times (m + 1) \) is always a multiple of 9. Let us verify with specific examples. Example 1: Take the multiple \( 9 \times 2 = 18 \). Adding 9: \( 18 + 9 = 27 = 9 \times 3 \). This is a multiple of 9. Confirmed. Example 2: Take the multiple \( 9 \times 5 = 45 \). Adding 9: \( 45 + 9 = 54 = 9 \times 6 \). This is a multiple of 9. Confirmed. Example 3: Take the multiple \( 9 \times 10 = 90 \). Adding 9: \( 90 + 9 = 99 = 9 \times 11 \). This is a multiple of 9. Confirmed. In every case, adding 9 to a multiple of 9 gives the next multiple of 9. This always works because 9 itself is a multiple of 9, and the sum of two multiples of 9 is always a multiple of 9: \[ 9m + 9 \times 1 = 9(m + 1) \] Therefore, Arjun's conjecture is FALSE. It is not the case that only 'some' multiples of 9 stay as multiples of 9 when 9 is added. In fact, EVERY multiple of 9, when increased by 9, always gives a multiple of 9.

Answer: Arjun's conjecture is false. Adding 9 to any multiple of 9 ALWAYS gives another multiple of 9, without any exceptions.

🎯 Try a Similar Question

Try a Similar Question

Question: Priya claims: 'When you triple (multiply by 3) a multiple of 7, the result is sometimes a multiple of 7 and sometimes not — it depends on which multiple of 7 you choose.' Examine whether Priya's claim is true or false. Verify with at least two examples and give a general algebraic explanation.

Solution

  1. Step 1: Understand the claim: Priya says that tripling a multiple of 7 does not always stay a multiple of 7. Let us check this with specific examples first.
  2. Step 2: Test with the first example: Take the multiple of 7: \( 14 \). Tripling it gives \( 3 \times 14 = 42 \). Now check: \( 42 \div 7 = 6 \). Since 6 is a whole number, 42 is a multiple of 7.
  3. Step 3: Test with the second example: Take the multiple of 7: \( 35 \). Tripling it gives \( 3 \times 35 = 105 \). Now check: \( 105 \div 7 = 15 \). Since 15 is a whole number, 105 is a multiple of 7.
  4. Step 4: Test with one more example: Take the multiple of 7: \( 49 \). Tripling it gives \( 3 \times 49 = 147 \). Now check: \( 147 \div 7 = 21 \). Since 21 is a whole number, 147 is a multiple of 7.
  5. Step 5: General algebraic explanation: Any multiple of 7 can be written as \( 7k \), where \( k \) is a positive integer. Tripling this multiple gives \[ 3 \times 7k = 7 \times (3k). \] Since \( 3k \) is an integer, the result \( 7 \times (3k) \) is always a multiple of 7, no matter which value of \( k \) we choose.
  6. Step 6: Conclusion: Priya's claim is FALSE. Tripling ANY multiple of 7 always produces a multiple of 7 — there are no exceptions. The result follows directly from the algebraic form \( 3 \times 7k = 7 \times (3k) \).

Answer: Priya's claim is FALSE. Every multiple of 7 can be written as \( 7k \), and tripling it gives \( 3 \times 7k = 7 \times (3k) \), which is always a multiple of 7. Therefore ALL multiples of 7 remain multiples of 7 when tripled — not just some.

Everything you get with Solver7

More questions in Number Play