Detailed Explanation
In problems on profit, loss and discount, there are three important prices. The Cost Price (CP) is what the shopkeeper pays. The shopkeeper marks up (increases) this to fix a Selling Price with some profit margin — here \( 35\% \). But when sales are poor, he offers a discount ON that selling price. Discount always reduces the selling price. The key idea is that the discount is calculated on the already-increased price, not on the cost price. So we must first find the increased price, then reduce it by the discount, and finally compare the new price with the original cost price. If the new price is more than CP it is a profit, otherwise a loss. Since exact numbers are not given, we simply assume a convenient cost price like \( \text{CP} = 100 \) to make percentage calculations easy.
Formula Used
Selling Price with profit: \( \text{SP} = \text{CP} + \left( \frac{\text{Profit}\%}{100} \times \text{CP} \right) \). Price after discount: \( \text{Final Price} = \text{SP} - \left( \frac{\text{Discount}\%}{100} \times \text{SP} \right) \).
Solution
- Step 1: Assume a convenient cost price. Let \( \text{CP} = 100 \). Choosing 100 makes percentages easy to work with, and the final conclusion (profit or loss) does not depend on this choice.
- Step 2: Add the \( 35\% \) profit to fix the selling price. Profit \( = \frac{35}{100} \times 100 = 35 \). So the marked selling price is \[ \text{SP} = 100 + 35 = 135. \]
- Step 3: Apply the \( 30\% \) discount on this selling price (not on the cost price). Discount \( = \frac{30}{100} \times 135 = 40.5 \).
- Step 4: Find the final price the customer pays after the discount. \[ \text{Final Price} = 135 - 40.5 = 94.5. \]
- Step 5: Compare the final price with the cost price. Cost price was \( 100 \) and the final price is \( 94.5 \). Since \( 94.5 < 100 \), the shopkeeper gets back less than he paid, so there is a loss. Loss \( = 100 - 94.5 = 5.5 \), which gives \[ \text{Loss}\% = \frac{5.5}{100} \times 100 = 5.5\%. \]
Final Answer
The shopkeeper makes a loss. Taking \( \text{CP} = 100 \), the price becomes \( 135 \) after \( 35\% \) profit and then \( 94.5 \) after \( 30\% \) discount, which is less than \( 100 \). So he suffers a loss of \( 5.5\% \).
Common Mistake
A common mistake is to think that a \( 35\% \) profit followed by only a \( 30\% \) discount must still give a profit. Students forget that the \( 30\% \) discount is taken on the higher selling price \( 135 \), not on the cost price \( 100 \), so the discount amount is larger than the profit amount, leading to a loss.